Skip to content

rse/ase / plugin/skills/ase-meta-steelman

ase-meta-steelman

Verified

Build the strongest possible case for a thesis by playing "Steelman" (Latin spirit: "Advocatus Dei"). Use when the user wants a thesis or statement charitably strengthened and defended.

@${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../../meta/ase-control.md @${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../../meta/ase-skill.md @${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR}/../../meta/ase-getopt.md

$ARGUMENTS

Determine the number of rounds to perform: set to ; if is non-numeric or less than or equal to 0, use the default 1 instead.

Determine the minimum number of pro-theses to surface: set to ; if is non-numeric or less than or equal to 0, use the default 10 instead.

  1. Begin a round of fortification and consolidating reasoning. On the first visit, set 1 (set round counter to one); on each subsequent visit (via the jump back in the last step), has already been incremented.

    Output the thesis with the following :

  2. Reason on the thesis in by playing Steelman (Latin spirit: "Advocatus Dei") - building the strongest possible case for it - by charitably strengthening and defending it with the help of the following tenets:

    • Charitable Interpretation: Defend the strongest ("steelman") interpretation of the , not the weakest ("strawman"), because the most generous reading is the one worth defending and the one a fair critic must ultimately confront.

    • Strengthen the Fundamentals: Identify the soundest fundamental ideas behind the thesis and make them explicit, because a position rests on the strength of its foundation and a solid foundation carries everything built on top of it.

    • Credit Claims, Not Person: Support the thesis, the assumption, the evidence - never appeal to the proponent's authority or reputation, because a case that leans on who said it instead of what was said is no stronger than its weakest argument.

    • Make the Enabling Assumptions Explicit: Surface the reasonable assumptions the thesis depends on and show they hold, because most strong arguments gain their force from premises that are sound once stated out loud.

    • Supply Evidence Proportional to Claim: Ask "How do we know this?" and "What best supports it?", and marshal that support, because a claim defended with its strongest available evidence is the one hardest to dismiss.

    • Seek the Confirming Case: Actively hunt for the supporting example, the favorable scenario, the precedent where the position succeeds, because one solid confirming case anchors the argument in reality.

    • Merit Identification: Focus on the genuine strengths of the thesis with the highest potential value only, because marginal merits are not worth the explicit discussion.

    • Push the Logic to its Best Conclusion: Ask "If we accept this, then what follows?" and apply "Reduction to the Good" (Latin: "Reductio Ad Bonum"), because this strengthens the thesis by showing that accepting it leads to coherent, beneficial, and reinforcing conclusions.

    • Surface the Upside and Leverage: Name the opportunity gained, the compounding benefit, the problem dissolved, because every choice in the thesis unlocks possibilities that a fair appraisal must count.

    • Stay Falsifiable and Concrete: Frame each supporting point so it can be checked and confirmed with facts, because vague enthusiasm ("I just like it") adds no strength to the case.

    • Argue in Good Faith: Make clear you are building the best honest case, not overselling, because the goal is a better final decision, not a sales pitch.

    • Concede the Real Weaknesses: Acknowledging where the thesis genuinely falls short is what makes the defense credible, because a Steelman who can never admit a flaw is just an apologist.

    • Pre-Parade Thinking: Imagine success scenarios of the thesis, because envisioning how it wins clarifies the conditions worth securing in advance.

    For each Pro-Thesis or Supporting-Argument, rank it on a Likert scale of 0 (weak) to 10 (strong). Repeat the process of finding more Pro-Theses or Supporting-Arguments until you EITHER have found at least Pro-Theses or Supporting-Arguments with at least a rank of 7 OR you have already checked a total of x 5 Pro-Theses or Supporting-Arguments. If the second condition is reached first and fewer than Pro-Theses or Supporting-Arguments reached a rank of at least 7, nevertheless surface the highest-ranked ones found so far, because is the minimum number of Pro-Theses to surface.

    Then, for the top- highest-ranked Pro-Theses or Supporting-Arguments, sort them by their rank from highest to lowest, store each in with the format **<aspect-N/>** (rank: <rank-N/>/10): <statement-N/> (where is a short 1-3 word summary of , is the determined rank on the Likert scale, and is a single-sentence statement of not more than 40 words), and then output the following :

  3. Following the consolidation of...

    *Thesis* + *Pro-Theses* → *Fortification*
    

    ...with...

    • Thesis: the initial statement, claim, or position. It is asserted as true, but on its own it is under-developed: it captures part of the truth while leaving its own strongest support implicit, unstated, or unproven.

    • Pro-Theses: the reinforcing forces. They are the corroboration, evidence, or supporting positions that the thesis invites - precisely the role a Steelman played. The pro-theses make explicit what the thesis assumed or left unsaid.

    • Fortification: the consolidation. Not an uncritical "cheerleading" of the thesis, and not a mere restatement of it, but a stronger position that consolidates everything that genuinely strengthens it while honestly bounding where it holds. The fortification reinforces the position by sharpening it.

    ...then derive a strong single-sentence (not more than 40 words) fortification of the and all found - the strongest defensible form of the thesis - store it in , and then finally output the following :

    Finally, decide whether to perform a further round:

slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack."Stars: 197kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall