plurigrid/asi / .claude/skills/wev-hodge-decomp
wev-hodge-decomp
VerifiedWorld Extractable Value via Pair-Graph Hodge Decomposition
Status: 🧪 Draft — K₃/K₄/K₅ verified Type: Discrete cohomology / optimal transport / market microstructure Principle: WEV = non-exactness of the world, measured in L^p over H₁ Frame: Antisymmetric 1-cochain on pair graph → Hodge splits into coboundary (potential) + harmonic (residue) GF(3)/GF(5): Both required — GF(3) collapses uniform-sign RPS cycles; GF(5) witnesses orientation-H¹
Core Construction
Given pair graph G = (V, E) observed at epoch t with signed 1-cochain α : E → ℝ satisfying α(i,j) = −α(j,i):
- Form incidence matrix
B : ℝ^|E| × ℝ^|V|,B[e=(u,v), u] = −1,B[e, v] = +1. - Solve normal equations
BᵀB φ = Bᵀα(Tikhonov-damped if graph has isolated components).L := BᵀBis the graph Laplacian on vertices. - Decompose
α = δφ* + harmonicwhereδφ*(e=(u,v)) = φ*(v) − φ*(u). WEV := ‖harmonic‖_p— edge-spacep-norm. Common choices:WEV_L¹= min trade volume to close harmonic under uniform cost per trade.WEV_L²= min trade energy under quadratic price-impact cost.
The coboundary part δφ* is explained by a vertex potential φ* — this is the Kantorovich dual / "type price" / clearing prices. The harmonic part is what no potential can explain — the extractable residue.
5-Instance Unification
Antisymmetric α required. Semantics splits into extractive (closure = transaction) vs diagnostic (observational):
| Layer | Vertex | α (edge signal) | WEV semantics |
|---|---|---|---|
| RPS / games | agent | regret-sign | gap-to-Nash |
| Hough MM harness | trader / MM | PnL-asymmetry | arb budget [extractive] |
| MEV | tx | ordering-regret | MEV bound [extractive] |
| Wardrop / Braess | road segment | travel-time-Δ | Braess cost [extractive] |
| MAC RF observer | device | sgn(RSSI_i − RSSI_j) | flock evidence [diagnostic] |
| Passport sybil | address | sgn(first_stamp_t_i − t_j) under scorer C | sybil evidence [diagnostic] |
| Face-patch fMRI | patch | partial-correlation precedence under stimulus | prosopagnosia index [diagnostic] |
Warning: symmetric edge measures (RSSI correlation, stamp Jaccard) violate antisymmetry and are the wrong shape. Use temporal precedence, not co-presence magnitude. Co-presence is the filter on which edges exist; precedence is the edge value.
Reference implementation (Guile, verified 2026-04-23)
Pure core — no goblins, no actors, no cells. Pair-graph Hodge in ~80 lines of Scheme:
;; solve BᵀBφ = Bᵀα via damped Gauss-Jordan
(define (hodge alpha E V)
(let* ((B (incidence E V))
(Bt (transpose B))
(BtB (mat*mat Bt B))
(Bta (mat*vec Bt alpha))
(phi (solve BtB Bta 1e-6))
(delta-phi (mat*vec B phi))
(harmonic (vec-sub alpha delta-phi)))
(values phi delta-phi harmonic)))
(define (WEV-L1 alpha E V)
(call-with-values
(lambda () (hodge alpha E V))
(lambda (_ _ h) (vec-norm1 h))))
Forj/Clojure port drops naturally into propagator-nash.clj — the pair graph is already there from the Čech H¹ extension.
K₅ Worked Example (RPS tournament, σ=(R P S R P))
V = (a b c d e)
E = ((a b) (a c) (a d) (a e) (b c) (b d) (b e) (c d) (c e) (d e))
α = ( 1 -1 0 1 1 -1 0 1 -1 1)
Hodge:
φ* = (R:−0.2, P:+0.2, S:0, R:−0.2, P:+0.2)— the strategy-type potential emerges automaticallyδφ* = (0.4, 0.2, 0, 0.4, -0.2, -0.4, 0, -0.2, 0.2, 0.4)harmonic = (0.6, -1.2, 0, 0.6, 1.2, -0.6, 0, 1.2, -1.2, 0.6)WEV_L¹ = 7.2,WEV_L² = 2.68- Coboundary energy = 0.8
Basis-cycle sum was basis-dependent undercount: BFS-star fundamental cycles give Σ |⟨α,γ⟩| = 6, but edges in the harmonic carry non-zero mass on edges whose basis-cycle circulations cancel. Edge-L¹ (7.2) is the correct basis-free invariant.
Greedy cycle-by-cycle closure with uniform flow bleeds residue into previously-zero cycles because BFS-star cycles share edges. To close cleanly, subtract the L²-orthogonal projection onto span(γ), not the uniform-t projection.
Connections
- Kantorovich duality: duals exist ⇔
harmonic = 0⇔α ∈ B¹⇔ clearing prices exist - Martingale OT (Beiglböck–Henry-Labordère–Penkner): dynamic no-arb = sheaf-H¹ = 0 across time-epochs
- Sinkhorn / entropic OT:
^best-response-propagator's softmax at temperature1/βIS the Schrödinger-bridge iteration; its convergence monitor isWEV → 0 - Kyle's λ:
∂WEV/∂(market depth)— Kyle is the marginal of WEV - Tsao face-patch system (Chang-Tsao 2017, Bao-She-Tsao 2020): 6-patch face cover is a sheaf; prosopagnosia and Thatcher illusion predicted as non-trivial H¹ on the cover. fMRI pair-graph + Hodge = prosopagnosia index. StyleGAN alignment = sybil attack at the axis-code identity layer.
Open probes
- Weighted Hodge: replace
L = BᵀBwithBᵀWBwhereWweights edges by observation confidence / inverse-variance. - Dynamic (sheaf over epochs): persistent harmonic across time → alert, transient → noise. Dynamic-WEV / static-WEV ratio as alert scalar.
- Cost-of-closure optimization: given per-edge costs
c_ij, minimum-cost closure is an LP over edge flows; extractable fraction depends on cost structure. - Directed-graph Hodge: for intrinsically asymmetric interactions (e.g. MM-vs-flow where MM doesn't attack trader back), use directed combinatorial Hodge (Jiang-Lim-Yao-Ye 2011
HodgeRank).
Verification trail
- Pure Guile K₃ (RPS):
triangle-trit = 0in GF(3) [collapse],= 3in GF(5) [witness] ✓ - Pure Guile K₄ (σ_d = σ_a): only RPS sub-triangle circulation −3; others 0 ✓
- Pure Guile K₅ (σ = R P S R P): two active cycles ±3, WEV_L¹ = 7.2, WEV_L² = 2.68 ✓
- Memory trail:
world-extractable-value.md,propagator-nash-cocycle.md
GF(3) triadic balance
- +1 Play: constructions (incidence, Laplacian, Hodge solve, WEV computation)
- 0 Witness: audit (antisymmetry check, basis-independence check, extract-vs-diagnose split)
- −1 Coplay: applications (MM harness, MAC observer, Passport sybil, face-patch fMRI)
Triadic sum over this skill = 0 (mod 3) ✓
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 197k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |