nWave-ai/nWave / nWave/skills/nw-dr-review-criteria
nw-dr-review-criteria
VerifiedCritique dimensions, severity framework, verdict decision matrix, and review output format for documentation assessment reviews
Documentation Review Criteria
Critique Dimensions
1. Classification Accuracy
Verify type assignment against DIVIO decision tree.
Questions: Do cited signals support assigned type? | Contradicting signals ignored? | Confidence appropriate? | Decision tree leads to same classification?
Verification: 1) Run decision tree independently 2) Check positive signals present 3) Check for red flags 4) Verify confidence matches signal strength
Severity: if wrong classification leads to wrong verdict = blocking.
2. Validation Completeness
Verify all type-specific criteria checked. Questions: All items checked? | Pass/fail correct? | Issues properly located? | Any criteria missed?
Tutorial (required): completable without external refs | steps numbered/sequential | verifiable outcomes | no assumed knowledge | builds confidence
How-to (required): clear goal | assumes fundamentals | single task | completion indicator | no basics teaching
Reference (required): all params documented | return values | error conditions | examples | no narrative
Explanation (required): addresses "why" | context/reasoning | alternatives considered | no task steps | conceptual model
3. Collapse Detection Correctness
Verify all five anti-patterns checked with accurate findings.
- Tutorial creep: explanation >20% | How-to bloat: teaching basics | Reference narrative: prose in entries
- Explanation task drift: steps in explanation | Hybrid horror: 3+ quadrants
Verification: independently scan, count lines per quadrant, compare to documentarist's findings, flag discrepancies.
4. Recommendation Quality
Criteria: Specific (exact what/where) | Actionable (author knows next step) | Prioritized (important first) | Justified (why it matters) | Root cause (underlying issue)
Bad: "Improve the documentation", "Make it clearer" Good: "Move explanation in section 3.2 (lines 45-60) to separate doc", "Add return value docs for login()"
5. Quality Score Accuracy
Verify six characteristics: Accuracy (factual claims verified?) | Completeness (gap analysis thorough?) | Clarity (Flesch 70-80?) | Consistency (style 95%+?) | Correctness (errors counted?) | Usability (structural assessment?)
Note: Documentarist cannot fully measure accuracy (needs expert) or usability (needs user testing). Verify limitations properly scoped.
6. Verdict Appropriateness
Verify verdict matches findings per decision matrix below.
Severity Framework
| Level | Definition | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Blocking | Wrong classification/verdict, missed collapse making doc unusable | Must fix |
| High | Multiple criteria missed, collapse missed but usable | Should fix; may block |
| Medium | Single criterion missed, miscalibrated confidence, false positive | Recommended |
| Low | Format inconsistency, wording clarity | Optional |
Reject: any blocking | 3+ high | classification wrong | verdict contradicts findings Conditionally approve: 1-2 high not affecting verdict | multiple medium but core correct Approve: no blocking/high | medium noted but not blocking
Verdict Decision Matrix
- Approved: all checks pass or low-only failures | no collapse | quality gates met (Flesch 70-80, purity 80%+)
- Needs Revision: medium/low failures only | no collapse | fixable without restructuring
- Restructure Required: collapse detected | purity <80% | multiple user needs | requires splitting
Verification Algorithm
- Count issues by severity 2. Check collapse_detection.clean 3. Check quality gates 4. Apply matrix 5. Compare to documentarist verdict 6. Flag discrepancy
Review Output Format
documentation_assessment_review:
review_id: "doc_rev_{timestamp}"
reviewer: "nw-documentarist-reviewer (Quill)"
assessment_reviewed: "{path}"
original_document: "{path}"
classification_review:
accurate: [boolean]
confidence_appropriate: [boolean]
independent_classification: "[your type]"
match: [boolean]
issues: [{issue, evidence, severity, recommendation}]
validation_review:
complete: [boolean]
criteria_checked: "[X/Y required + Z/W additional]"
missed_criteria: [list]
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
collapse_detection_review:
accurate: [boolean]
independent_findings: "[anti-patterns found]"
false_positives: [count]
missed_patterns: [list]
issues: [{issue, severity, recommendation}]
recommendation_review:
quality: [high|medium|low]
actionable: [boolean]
properly_prioritized: [boolean]
issues: [{issue, severity, improvement}]
quality_score_review:
accurate: [boolean]
issues: [{score, issue, correction}]
verdict_review:
appropriate: [boolean]
documentarist_verdict: "[their verdict]"
recommended_verdict: "[your verdict]"
verdict_match: [boolean]
rationale: "{justification}"
overall_assessment:
assessment_quality: [high|medium|low]
approval_status: [approved|rejected_pending_revisions|conditionally_approved|escalate_to_human]
issue_summary: {blocking: N, high: N, medium: N, low: N}
blocking_issues: [list]
recommendations: [{priority, action}]
Review Iteration Limits
Maximum 2 revision cycles. After cycle 2: escalate to human, return approval_status: escalate_to_human with rationale.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| rea-changelog-updatemorluto/reaPrepare or rewrite REA release changelogs and GitHub release notes from pinned Git history, with verified contributor thanks and Release Please synchronization. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| academy-guideanthropics/skillsStop and check this skill before finishing any reply to a question about how to use Claude or a Claude product — it recommends matching courses, tutorials, and use cases from Claude Academy (academy.claude.com), Anthropic's learning hub. Trigger on: "how do I", "how can I", "getting started with", "what can Claude do", "teach me", "learn to use"; questions about artifacts, projects, skills, plugins, connectors, MCP; requests about rolling Claude out to a team, class, or organization; and any ask for training materials, onboarding content, or learning resources. Use it when the user is learning how to use a feature or product — not when they are mid-task and just want the task done. This skill composes with other skills: after consulting product documentation to answer how a Claude feature works, also check here for a matching course or tutorial — a docs-grounded answer and an Academy recommendation belong together. Only recommend on a strong match; never invent Academy content. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| claude-apianthropics/skillsReference for the Claude API / Anthropic SDK — model ids, pricing, params, streaming, tool use, MCP, agents, caching, token counting, model migration. TRIGGER — read BEFORE opening the target file; don't skip because it "looks like a one-liner" — whenever: the prompt names Claude/Anthropic in any form (Claude, Anthropic, Fable, Opus, Sonnet, Haiku, `anthropic`, `@anthropic-ai`, `claude-*`, `us.anthropic.*`, `[1m]`); the user asks about an LLM (pricing/model choice/limits/caching) — never answer from memory; OR the task is LLM-shaped with provider unstated (agent/MCP/tool-definition/multi-agent/RAG/LLM-judge/computer-use; generate/summarize/extract/classify/rewrite/converse over NL; debugging refusals/cutoffs/streaming/tool-calls/tokens). SKIP only when another provider is being worked on (overrides all triggers): OpenAI/GPT/Gemini/Llama/Mistral/Cohere/Ollama named in the query; OR `grep -rE 'openai|langchain_openai|google.generativeai|genai|mistralai|cohere|ollama'` over the project hits (run this grep FIRST if no provider named — don't Read the file). | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Unverified | Install |
| doc-coauthoringanthropics/skillsGuide users through a structured workflow for co-authoring documentation. Use when user wants to write documentation, proposals, technical specs, decision docs, or similar structured content. This workflow helps users efficiently transfer context, refine content through iteration, and verify the doc works for readers. Trigger when user mentions writing docs, creating proposals, drafting specs, or similar documentation tasks. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |