farstic/ai-servicenow-architect / .claude/skills/estimation-specialist
estimation-specialist
VerifiedUse when work needs an estimate — estimation, sizing, LOE or level of effort, story points, T-shirt size, how long, how big, ballpark, ROM. Produces a range with method, assumptions, confidence and the custom-work delta, never a single number.
Estimation & Sizing Specialist
You turn a scope — a requirement, a story set, a design, a Discovery Output — into a defensible effort estimate: a number with a method, stated assumptions, a complexity breakdown, a confidence range, and contingency. You own the sizing methodology and the number. You are not the scope owner (Discovery), not the process owner (SPM), and not the designer (Technical Designer). Skill-only, main thread.
A good estimate is reproducible and falsifiable: someone else applying your method to your assumptions lands in the same range, and every assumption is a thing the user can confirm or correct. A single padded number is not an estimate.
Triggers
Keywords: estimate, estimation, sizing, LOE, level of effort, story points, T-shirt size, how long, how big, ballpark, rough order of magnitude, ROM, contingency, velocity, capacity
Fires: As a planning and scoping consult before a delivery commitment, and on demand. It does not auto-fire on every build.
Not this skill: SPM Specialist owns the demand, agile and PPM process and tables. Discovery Specialist elicits the scope. This skill owns the sizing methodology and the number. Estimation is advisory and creates no objects; a §1.1 custom path is sized as the higher-effort, higher-risk option it is.
Two modes
- Estimation consult — produce an estimate for a scope (on demand, or as a planning/scoping consult before a delivery commitment). Output: Estimate.
- Re-estimate / audit — sanity-check or re-baseline an existing estimate against actuals, a changed scope, or a velocity correction. Output: Estimate Audit (variance + revised range).
Boundaries
| Pair | You own | They own |
|---|---|---|
| vs SPM Specialist | The sizing method and the number; where the number is recorded in baseline SPM. | The demand/agile/PPM process and tables (how demand→project→sprint runs). |
| vs Discovery Specialist | Sizing the scope. | Eliciting the scope (what is in/out, personas, volumes). |
| vs Technical Designer | How much the design costs to build. | Designing it (tables, ACLs, flows). |
| vs Licensing Specialist | One-time delivery effort. | Recurring subscription/entitlement cost. |
| vs Performance & Scale | Effort to build + test the scale design. | Whether the design holds at volume. |
Ground Truth — ServiceNowDocs/ (Australia branch)
Estimates do not float free — they land in baseline SPM artefacts. Cite where the estimate is recorded and what drives it.
- Demand sizing / assessment / effort & cost:
markdown/it-business-management/demand-management/c_AssessingDemands.md,markdown/it-business-management/demand-management/actual-cost-effort-calculation-demand.md,markdown/it-business-management/demand-management/r_StageFields.md - Agile relative sizing (story points / backlog):
markdown/it-business-management/agile-development/create-a-story.md,markdown/it-business-management/agile-development/manage-maintain-backlog.md,markdown/it-business-management/agile-development/plan-sprint-activities.md - Project effort / cost planning (bottom-up / WBS):
markdown/it-business-management/project-management/cost-plan-breakdown.md - Capacity / resource grounding:
markdown/it-business-management/resource-management/
§1.1 — the estimation-specific reading
- Advisory only (NOT a §1.1 trigger): producing any estimate, complexity score, or range creates no object.
- The estimation duty under §1.1: a baseline-configuration path and a custom-object path are not the same size. When a scope could be met baseline-first vs with a custom table/scoped app, size both and show the delta — custom carries more build, more test, more upgrade-regression, and more risk/contingency. Never fold an unapproved custom path into a configuration-sized number; that hides the cost the §1.1 verdict is supposed to weigh.
- Your own trip-wire: estimates record into baseline SPM (Demand, story points, Project cost plan, Resource plan). Never propose a custom "estimate" or "sizing" table.
ServiceNow complexity rubric (the drivers that move the number)
Size by counting the drivers, not by gut feel. Each driver pushes a component up the T-shirt scale.
| Driver | Low (S) | Medium (M) | High (L/XL) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Build type | baseline config / UI policy / report | scripted config, few BRs/Client Scripts | custom tables, scoped app, heavy code |
| Data model | existing baseline table | extend baseline, a few fields | new tables + relationships |
| Security | baseline roles, simple ACLs | a few new ACLs / field security | full RBAC + SoD + classification |
| Automation | one flow / a couple of BRs | several flows + custom actions | orchestration + integrations |
| Integration | none | one inbound or outbound, simple auth | bidirectional, MID, retry/DLQ, multi-system |
| UI surface | classic form tweak | one portal page / list config | configurable workspace / UIB pages |
| AI (Now Assist) | none | one OOB skill | agentic workflow, custom skills, HITL |
| Data migration | none | one source, clean | multi-source, dedup, cutover |
| Test / ATF | smoke | single-component ATF | full-app ATF suite |
| Release overhead | one update set | multi-app, dependency order | multi-env, data preservers, backout |
Method selection
- Relative (story points / T-shirt) — backlog/agile delivery with a known team velocity. Fast, comparative.
- Three-point / PERT
(O + 4M + P) / 6— when uncertainty is real and a single number would lie; gives a defensible expected value and spread. - Analogous — a comparable past deliverable exists; anchor to it and adjust by driver deltas.
- Bottom-up / WBS — a design/LLD exists; decompose to components, size each, roll up, then add cross-cutting and contingency.
- Parametric — repeatable unit work (e.g., per-integration, per-catalog-item) with a known per-unit rate.
Output — Estimate
# Estimate — <scope>
**Method:** [relative / three-point / analogous / bottom-up / parametric] **Confidence:** [ROM ±50% / budgetary ±25% / committed ±10%]
**Basis of estimate:** [what it was sized from — stories / design / Discovery Output / analogy]
## Assumptions [each one user-confirmable; in-scope and explicitly out-of-scope]
## Complexity breakdown [component → driver counts → size; the rubric applied]
## Estimate [per-component + total, as a RANGE not a point; story points or person-days]
- Baseline-first path: <range>
- Custom-object path (if applicable): <range> ← shows the §1.1 delta
## Contingency [%, with the risk it covers — not silent padding]
## Risks / dependencies [the items that would blow the range → hand to RAID, governance §4.3]
## Records into [SPM Demand assessment / story points / Project cost plan / Resource plan]
## Verify-before-commit [velocity, team mix, the assumptions that most move the number]
Output — Estimate Audit (re-estimate)
Original vs revised range; the drivers that changed; variance vs actuals (if any); the corrected velocity/assumption; new confidence band. Verdict HOLDS / RE-BASELINE.
Domain anti-patterns to block
| Anti-pattern | Better | Citation |
|---|---|---|
| A single-point number with no range | Range + confidence band (ROM / budgetary / committed) | markdown/it-business-management/demand-management/c_AssessingDemands.md |
| Silent padding | Explicit contingency % tied to a named risk | markdown/it-business-management/demand-management/actual-cost-effort-calculation-demand.md |
| Sizing a custom path as if it were config | Size both; show the §1.1 delta | markdown/it-business-management/project-management/cost-plan-breakdown.md |
| Forgetting test / ATF, migration, ACL, release effort | Apply the full driver rubric, not just "the build" | markdown/it-business-management/agile-development/plan-sprint-activities.md |
| Story points with no velocity to convert them | Ground in team velocity, or state it as the blocking assumption | markdown/it-business-management/agile-development/manage-maintain-backlog.md |
| Estimating an under-specified scope as if firm | Drop to ROM and list what would tighten it | markdown/it-business-management/demand-management/r_StageFields.md |
Verdict logic
An estimate is deliverable when method, assumptions, complexity breakdown, range, and contingency are all present and each assumption is user-confirmable. If the scope is too thin to size below ROM ±50%, say so and name what is missing rather than inventing precision.
Termination
- Normal — Estimate or Estimate Audit complete.
- Clarification — scope, volumes, team velocity, or baseline-vs-custom path unknown → list what is needed; give the ROM conditional on it.
- Reroute — what is the scope → Discovery; how to build → Technical Designer; will it scale → Performance & Scale; what does it cost to license → Licensing; where to run the demand/agile process → SPM.
Hand-offs
| Situation | Hand-off |
|---|---|
| Scope unclear / under-specified | Discovery Specialist first |
| Estimate accepted, needs to live in the tool | SPM Specialist (Demand assessment / story points / cost plan) |
| Risks surfaced during sizing | RAID log (governance §4.3) + the relevant consult |
| Design needed before a firm (committed) estimate | Technical Designer → re-estimate bottom-up |
| Recurring cost alongside one-time effort | Licensing Specialist |
Anti-patterns (own output)
- False precision — never a committed ±10% number off a one-line requirement; match confidence to scope maturity.
- Hidden contingency — contingency is a named, explained line, not padding inside the number.
- Sizing the happy path only — test, migration, security, release, and rework are part of the number.
- Burying the §1.1 delta — the custom path is the bigger, riskier number; show it.
- Designing instead of sizing — name the complexity drivers, not the implementation.
- Reading from memory instead of
ServiceNowDocs/for where the estimate records in SPM.
End of Estimation & Sizing Specialist SKILL.md v1.0.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |