Skip to content

ericrisco/rsc-harness / skills/viral-score

viral-score

Verified

Use to judge whether a short-form clip is worth publishing — scores a reel, short or podcast excerpt 0-100 on ten weighted criteria with automatic penalties, then ranks a batch and says where the cut-off falls. Run it on transcript candidates before rendering. NOT writing the hook or caption (that is `shortform-packaging`), NOT inventing the idea (that is `shortform-ideation`), NOT executing the edit (that is `shortform-editing`).

viral-score — is this clip worth publishing?

A fixed rubric for scoring a vertical clip's chance of travelling. Its value is that it is fixed: the same clip scores the same on Monday and Friday, and two clips are comparable because they were measured with the same instrument.

So do not substitute your own judgment for the rubric and do not adjust the weights. If a clip has a quality the rubric does not capture, say so in the reasons — but score it with this.

Score candidates before rendering whenever you can. Judging a transcript excerpt costs seconds; editing a clip that gets discarded costs an afternoon.

The ten criteria

Each is scored 0-10.

#CriterionWeightWhat earns the points
1Opening hook20 %Do the first 3 seconds stop the scroll? Curiosity, surprise, emotion, a strong claim, a striking open
2Expected retention20 %Is there a reason to reach the end? Sustained curiosity, pace, resolution, no dead air
3Emotional impact15 %Intensity: inspiration, awe, fear, anger, joy, nostalgia, humour, surprise. Indifference scores very low
4Shareability10 %Would someone send this to a friend?
5Comment-worthiness10 %Does it invite debate or a reply?
6Message clarity5 %Does the idea fit in one sentence?
7Value density5 %Does every second earn its place?
8Originality5 %Is it different or unexpected?
9Context independence5 %Does it land without having heard the rest of the episode?
10Storytelling5 %Is there a story, a lesson, or a transformation?

The calculation

Viral Score = ( Hook×0.20 + Retention×0.20 + Emotion×0.15 + Shareability×0.10
              + Comments×0.10 + Clarity×0.05 + Density×0.05
              + Originality×0.05 + Context×0.05 + Storytelling×0.05 ) × 10

Automatic penalties

Subtracted after the formula, and they stack.

PenaltyPoints
Weak hook−10
Slow intro−8
Needs too much context−10
Long pauses−5
Idea too generic−8
Provokes no emotion−10
Unsatisfying ending−5

Clamp the final result to [0, 100].

Reading the score

RangeVerdict
95-100Exceptional. Publish immediately
90-94Very likely to perform
80-89Good candidate. Worth editing and publishing
70-79Acceptable, but there are better clips
60-69Weak. Publish only if there is no alternative
0-59Discard

Required output, per clip

  • Start and end timestamp
  • Viral Score (0-100)
  • A table with all ten criterion scores
  • Reasons behind the scoring
  • Main strengths
  • Main weaknesses
  • Verdict: Publish / Review / Discard

Scoring several clips adds two things: a ranking from highest to lowest, and where the cut-off falls — the point below which publishing stops being worth it.

Applying it well

Score the clip, not the topic. A fascinating episode routinely yields a clip that scores 45.

Judge the hook on the actual first three seconds, not on the idea in the abstract. A clip that opens with a filler word or halfway through a sentence has a weak hook: −10. That is also why the excerpt should start on a sentence boundary — where you cut decides the hook.

Be strict about context independence. If the viewer needs to know who the guest is, or what the previous question was, that is −10.

Do not inflate the mean. If twenty clips all come out above 80, the rubric is not being applied. A healthy batch spreads widely, with few above 85.

Justify every low score with what happens in the clip, at a timestamp — not with a generality.

Anti-patterns

Anti-patternDo instead
Scoring how interesting the subject isScore this clip's execution; the topic is not the artifact
Grading the hook from the full ideaRead only the first three seconds as the viewer receives them
Compressing a batch into 78-85Use the range; a flat distribution means the instrument is not being used
"Weak hook" with no evidenceQuote the opening words and the timestamp
Adjusting weights for a clip you likeThe weights are the instrument. Argue in the reasons, score with the rubric
Rendering first, scoring afterScore transcript candidates, then edit only what survives
Skipping the penalties because the total looks lowThey are automatic and they stack; a 72 with three penalties is a 49

See Also

  • ../shortform-packaging/SKILL.md — the hook line, caption, hashtags and cover for a clip that passed this bar.
  • ../shortform-ideation/SKILL.md — inventing the angle, upstream of anything scoreable.
  • ../shortform-editing/SKILL.md — executing the edit once a clip is chosen.
  • ../shortform-strategy/SKILL.md — what the channel should publish over time, which this feeds with per-clip evidence.
slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack."Stars: 197kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall