Skip to content

DavidCho1999/archaiflow-skills / bundles/construction-admin/skills/constructability-review

constructability-review

Verified

This skill should be used when the user shares construction documents (DD set, 50%/100% CD, GMP set) and wants them reviewed through a constructor's lens — sequencing, tolerance stack-ups, MEP coordination, install access, lay-down logistics, temporary works, long-lead procurement, and phased operations. Trigger on 'constructability review', 'CM review', 'sequencing check', 'install access', 'crane reach', 'lay-down', 'long-lead', 'MEP coordination clearance', 'site logistics', or pasted CD context with build-feasibility intent. Generates a structured review markdown in `docs/constructability/` and appends to the project constructability index.

references/constructability_axes.md

View on GitHub
# Constructability Review — Eight Axes

Detailed framework for auditing construction documents through a CM / preconstruction / owner's-rep lens. Each axis carries sub-criteria, common failure modes, and example findings phrased the way they should appear in the review file.

Severity tagging: **High** (will cause a CO or schedule slip if not addressed before CD), **Medium** (likely to surface as RFI in CA), **Low** (worth noting, resolvable without redesign).

The 8-axis structure is an internal synthesis informed by AGC of America preconstruction publications, CMAA *Construction Management Standards of Practice* (preconstruction services chapter), and the published tolerance / clearance / safety standards cited per axis below (AISC 303-22, ACI 117, SMACNA, NEC 2023, NFPA 241-22, IBC 2024, OSHA 1926, ASHRAE 170-2021, FGI 2022). **Note:** AGC and CMAA do not publish a numbered constructability rubric with this exact axis decomposition — see `_provenance.md` for the framework disclaimer and the verification list of practice references.

---

## 1. Trade sequencing & critical path

**Sub-criteria:**

- Implied sequence physically possible — predecessors completed before successors require them.
- Out-of-sequence work flagged (e.g., framing before MEP rough-in inside a tight cavity).
- Concurrent work in the same volume — physical conflicts during install.
- Hand-off cleanliness — when Trade A leaves and Trade B starts, what condition is the surface in?
- Protection requirements during follow-on work.

**Common failure modes:**

- Spec calls for sealed concrete floor to receive resilient flooring, but the floor is the staging area for steel deck topping — protection cost not in scope.
- Curtain-wall install requires the slab to be cured 28 days; schedule shows install at day 21.
- Drywall before MEP rough-in tested — coordination meetings the only place this surfaces, and not always.

**Example finding:**

> [High] Detail 5/A8.04 shows acoustic ceiling tile installed before final MEP testing. Light fixtures on the AV signal path require de-mount and re-mount for fixture-by-fixture testing. Recommend revising Section 09 51 13 sequencing language to require ACT install after MEP commissioning, or accept the de-mount cost in CA contingency. Estimated CO if surfaced in CA: $35-50K.

---

## 2. Tolerance stack-up

**Sub-criteria:**

- Cumulative tolerance from structure to finish vs. detail accommodation.
- Steel ±¼" (AISC 303), CIP concrete ±¼" to ±¾" (ACI 117), masonry ±¼" plumb 10 ft, sheet metal ±⅛" (SMACNA), glazing manufacturer's installation tolerance.
- Detail "reveals" and "shadow gaps" sized to absorb tolerance — typical 3/8"+ reveal absorbs 3/8" of variance.
- Adjustability of attached assembly (shimming range, slotted holes, gasketed joints).

**Common failure modes:**

- Steel + deck + topping + acoustic substrate stack adds to ¾" of variance; detail shows 1/8" reveal.
- Curtain-wall manufacturer's installation tolerance is ±1/4" but the wall returns into a punched opening with 1/16" reveal callout.
- Granite cladding pinned to steel with no adjustability — survey deviation forces shop-rework.

**Example finding:**

> [High] Detail 7/A8.21 storefront-to-slab transition: 1/8" reveal callout at slab edge. Stack: AISC 303 steel ±¼" + topping ±⅛" + storefront install ±¼" = ±5/8" cumulative. Detail accommodates ±1/8". Either widen reveal to 3/8"+ or specify shimming range and slotted attachment in Section 08 41 13. Estimated CO if surfaced as RFI in CA: $25-45K plus 2-3 weeks of redesign.

---

## 3. MEP coordination & rack space

**Sub-criteria:**

- Above-ceiling clear height accommodates duct + sprinkler + cable tray + lighting in real coordination, not just BIM-clashed.
- Riser stack alignment story-to-story.
- Shaft enclosure penetrations within rated-assembly limits per IBC.
- Equipment-room dimensions accommodate install AND future replacement.
- Service clearance for code (NEC 110.26 for electrical), maintenance, and removal route.

**Common failure modes:**

- 8'-0" finish ceiling with 24" round duct + 8" sprinkler + 8" tray + 8" lighting requires 14'-0" structure-to-ceiling. Not provided.
- AHU room sized for install but no removal path through corridor doors.
- Riser shaft sized for risers but no maintenance access door at each floor.

**Example finding:**

> [High] AHU-3 mechanical room (Sheet M2.04) door is 36 in wide. AHU-3 specified is 38 in wide. Removal route blocked. Either widen door, change AHU type, or accept AHU is not removable without wall demo. Same condition at AHU-5 and AHU-7. Recommend coordinated revision before 100% CD.

---

## 4. Install access & rigging

**Sub-criteria:**

- Crane / boom-truck reach for steel and pre-cast erection.
- Hoisting paths through future façade openings (or via exterior crane).
- Equipment-room dimensions for AHU / chiller / switchgear installation.
- Future-replacement removal route (the "30-year question" — when this AHU dies, can the next one come in).
- Site access for delivery vehicles (turning radius, vertical clearance, weight capacity of overhead structure).

**Common failure modes:**

- Crane swing radius required but neighbor airspace not yet negotiated.
- Switchgear room access through a stair hall that turns — gear cannot make the turn.
- Roof-mounted chiller scheduled for placement after parapet is built.

**Example finding:**

> [High] Roof chiller delivery: schedule shows chiller hoisting on day 145 (per CPM); parapet wall placement is day 130. After parapet is in, chiller hoisting requires either (a) lift over the parapet (additional crane mobilization $40K), or (b) leaving a parapet panel out, hoisting, then closing. Recommend revising sequence to hoist chiller before parapet completion — saves $40K.

---

## 5. Lay-down & site logistics

**Sub-criteria:**

- Material storage area on-site or off-site lease cost.
- Truck deliveries: frequency, time-of-day restrictions, restricted streets.
- Crane swing radius respects neighbor airspace; airspace easements negotiated where required.
- Pedestrian protection per IBC, OSHA 1926 Subpart M, local DOB / DSA / agency requirements.
- Construction parking, worker access, lunch break logistics.
- Neighbor noise / vibration limits per local ordinance and AHJ.

**Common failure modes:**

- Urban infill site has zero lay-down — every delivery is just-in-time, weather-dependent, escalates GC.
- Crane swing over neighbor parcel without airspace easement — neighbor blocks operation.
- Loading dock adjacent to a daycare with noise restrictions during specific hours.

**Example finding:**

> [Medium] Zero on-site lay-down; existing parking and adjacent vacant lot (off-site lease pending owner negotiation). Without lay-down lease secured before NTP, deliveries become just-in-time and labor productivity reduces ~10-15%. Estimated cost increase if lay-down not secured: $200-400K over 18-month build. Recommend adding lay-down lease to the owner pre-construction commitments.

---

## 6. Temporary works

**Sub-criteria:**

- Shoring for excavation per OSHA 1926 Subpart P, local DOB / DSA / agency requirements.
- Dewatering capacity vs. groundwater rate.
- Weather enclosure for winter concrete or interior finishes.
- Life-safety path during construction — egress paths, sprinkler activation phasing, fire watch per NFPA 241.
- Temporary heating, lighting, and power.
- Snow removal and ice management on the site.

**Common failure modes:**

- Excavation shown in February in a freezing climate with no winter-concrete provisions in the spec.
- Dewatering requires a discharge permit that has 4-month lead time; not flagged.
- Sprinkler activation deferred until 90% completion; OSHA 1926 / NFPA 241 require operational system or fire watch from materials-installation start.

**Example finding:**

> [High] Schedule shows concrete pour from December through February in Climate Zone 5A. Section 03 30 00 contains no winter-concrete provisions (heated enclosure, blanket cure, accelerator, hot mix). Either add winter-concrete spec language or shift the pour window to March-November. Estimated cost of winter provisions if retained: $80-150K.

---

## 7. Materials procurement & lead times

Reference: `long_lead_items_2026.md` for the methodology of building a project-specific long-lead register from current, dated, named-source quotes. That file is **not** a lookup table — it is a sourcing methodology. Lead-time values used in a finding must cite manufacturer + quote source + quote date, never a recalled or bundled number.

**Sub-criteria:**

- Long-lead items identified and their decision-freeze dates set in the schedule.
- Procurement releases at NTP for items that need it (not waiting for 100% submittal cycle).
- Backup vendors identified for single-source long-leads.
- Substitution risk if primary vendor slips.

**Common 2026 long-lead categories** (no specific lead-time numbers are listed here on purpose — see methodology note below):

- Electrical switchgear (LV and MV), MCCs, generators, transformers, ATS.
- AHUs (custom > catalog), chillers, cooling towers, boilers, VRF systems, large pumps.
- Custom unitized curtain wall, oversized IGUs, custom skylights, decorative metal panels.
- Elevators (new and modernization).
- Structural steel (mill + fab), mass timber (CLT / glulam), pre-cast concrete.
- Owner-furnished medical / lab equipment (linacs, MRI, fume hoods, biosafety cabinets).

**Methodology note — do not bake lead-time numbers into a finding from recall:** values listed in any reference document are illustrative only. Pull current, dated, named-source quotes per the methodology in `long_lead_items_2026.md`. Each lead-time number used in a constructability finding must cite the manufacturer + quote source + quote date — never a recalled or table-baked figure. Verify with the manufacturer (or fabricator, for steel and mass timber) at review time.

**Common failure modes:**

- Switchgear submittal scheduled at 100% CD; project NTP is 6 months later — switchgear arrives 6 months after needed.
- Custom curtain wall design coordinated with shop drawings during CA — fabrication doesn't start until shop approval, install slips.

**Example finding:**

> [High] Electrical switchgear: contract documents are at 75% CD. Per Eaton customer lead-time letter dated 2026-04-12 (entered into the project lead-time register), current lead time for the specified low-voltage switchgear is 48 weeks. Schedule places switchgear energization at month 16 from NTP. To make this work, the gear must be ordered no later than month 16 - 48 weeks ≈ month 4. Currently the schedule shows order release after submittal approval at month 9. Either accelerate switchgear procurement (release at month 4 against 75% CD with explicit redesign risk allocation) or reschedule energization to month 21+. Estimated cost of acceleration vs. reschedule: $0 vs. ~$300K (5 months of GC overhead). Re-confirm the Eaton number at order release — the 2026-04-12 letter will be ~120 days old by month 4. (Source-quote methodology: see `long_lead_items_2026.md`.)

---

## 8. Phased operations & owner occupancy

**Sub-criteria:**

- Owner-occupied phasing — temporary-condition floor plans coordinated.
- Means of egress maintained during all construction phases.
- Mechanical of patient/student transitions (MOP) documented.
- Infection-control risk assessment (ICRA) for healthcare per ASHRAE 170 / FGI Guidelines.
- Security boundaries between construction and occupied areas.
- Neighbor noise / vibration limits during operating hours.
- AHJ approval for temporary conditions (NYC DOB occupied-building protocols, CA HCAI for healthcare, school-district summer-only windows, GSA tenant-occupied protocols).

**Common failure modes:**

- Schedule assumes 24/7 site access; owner is a school with summer-only construction window.
- Healthcare project with no ICRA dust-control specification.
- Phased plan blocks one of the two required exit paths during the phase.

**Example finding:**

> [High] Phase 2 (Sheet G2.04): East corridor closed for renovation; remaining egress is West corridor only. Travel distance from Room 312 (Level 3) to West corridor exit is 232 ft per re-measurement. IBC 2021 Table 1017.2 sprinklered B limit is 250 ft, marginally compliant — but the West corridor also serves Phase 2 staging area, narrowing to 36 in clear width per the staging plan. Recalculate occupant load served and confirm ≥0.2 in/occupant capacity in the temporary condition. Recommend a phased life-safety plan reviewed by the AHJ before NTP.
rea-changelog-updatemorluto/reaPrepare or rewrite REA release changelogs and GitHub release notes from pinned Git history, with verified contributor thanks and Release Please synchronization.Stars: 471kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
academy-guideanthropics/skillsStop and check this skill before finishing any reply to a question about how to use Claude or a Claude product — it recommends matching courses, tutorials, and use cases from Claude Academy (academy.claude.com), Anthropic's learning hub. Trigger on: "how do I", "how can I", "getting started with", "what can Claude do", "teach me", "learn to use"; questions about artifacts, projects, skills, plugins, connectors, MCP; requests about rolling Claude out to a team, class, or organization; and any ask for training materials, onboarding content, or learning resources. Use it when the user is learning how to use a feature or product — not when they are mid-task and just want the task done. This skill composes with other skills: after consulting product documentation to answer how a Claude feature works, also check here for a matching course or tutorial — a docs-grounded answer and an Academy recommendation belong together. Only recommend on a strong match; never invent Academy content.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
claude-apianthropics/skillsReference for the Claude API / Anthropic SDK — model ids, pricing, params, streaming, tool use, MCP, agents, caching, token counting, model migration. TRIGGER — read BEFORE opening the target file; don't skip because it "looks like a one-liner" — whenever: the prompt names Claude/Anthropic in any form (Claude, Anthropic, Fable, Opus, Sonnet, Haiku, `anthropic`, `@anthropic-ai`, `claude-*`, `us.anthropic.*`, `[1m]`); the user asks about an LLM (pricing/model choice/limits/caching) — never answer from memory; OR the task is LLM-shaped with provider unstated (agent/MCP/tool-definition/multi-agent/RAG/LLM-judge/computer-use; generate/summarize/extract/classify/rewrite/converse over NL; debugging refusals/cutoffs/streaming/tool-calls/tokens). SKIP only when another provider is being worked on (overrides all triggers): OpenAI/GPT/Gemini/Llama/Mistral/Cohere/Ollama named in the query; OR `grep -rE 'openai|langchain_openai|google.generativeai|genai|mistralai|cohere|ollama'` over the project hits (run this grep FIRST if no provider named — don't Read the file).Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexUnverifiedInstall
doc-coauthoringanthropics/skillsGuide users through a structured workflow for co-authoring documentation. Use when user wants to write documentation, proposals, technical specs, decision docs, or similar structured content. This workflow helps users efficiently transfer context, refine content through iteration, and verify the doc works for readers. Trigger when user mentions writing docs, creating proposals, drafting specs, or similar documentation tasks.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall