by-carlos/plan-staged-rollout / skills/staged-rollout
staged-rollout
UnverifiedRun a large build as many small, resumable sessions by decomposing it into a `.plan/` folder of dependency-ordered stages with an evidence ledger, then executing one stage per fresh session. Use when the user says "this is too big for one session", "plan a staged rollout", or describes a multi-day build that needs cross-session progress tracking.
SKILL.md
View on GitHub---
name: staged-rollout
description: Run a large build as many small, resumable sessions by decomposing it into a `.plan/` folder of dependency-ordered stages with an evidence ledger, then executing one stage per fresh session. Use when the user says "this is too big for one session", "plan a staged rollout", or describes a multi-day build that needs cross-session progress tracking.
---
# Staged rollout
Run a large build as **many small sessions, not one huge one.** Decompose the
work once into dependency-ordered stages in a `.plan/` folder, then execute one
stage per fresh session. Context can't accumulate across stages because sessions
don't share it; the plan can't drift because every decision lives in exactly one
place; progress is a glanceable ledger, not a transcript.
The file formats are in `references/templates/` (`PLAN.md`, `LEDGER.md`,
`stage-N.md`, `stage-f-review.md`, `README.md`, `RUNNER.md`, `BRIEF.md`) — copy those
verbatim for structure, then fill every `<placeholder>` when scaffolding.
`RUNNER.md` is the stage-runner contract scaffolded into each plan so any
session — cloud included, where this plugin does not load — can run a stage
cold from a one-line instruction pointing at `.plan/RUNNER.md`. This file is the
*method*: when to use it, how to decompose, how to set flags. Don't restate
the templates here.
## When to use it
All of these true: the work spans multiple sessions (hours/days, roughly four+
sessions of work); it decomposes into ordered units with dependencies; you want
to stop and resume freely; you care about keeping per-session token cost flat;
and the design is settle-able (there are decisions worth freezing).
## When NOT to use it
- **Work that fits in one to three sessions.** The scaffold has a floor cost;
below ~four sessions, just do the work.
- **Exploratory work with no settle-able design.** If every session would
legitimately rewrite the frozen decisions, there's nothing to freeze yet.
- **Work that can't be decomposed.** One giant inseparable step gains nothing
from a ledger around it.
Two honest limits even when it fits: decomposition quality gates everything (bad
stage boundaries cause cross-stage churn no protocol fixes — the final review
stage catches what leaks, but it can't un-tangle a bad split); and fresh
sessions only know what was written down (note discipline replaces the tacit
context a long session would carry).
## Core principles
1. **Single source of truth, referenced not copied.** All durable decisions live
in `PLAN.md` as *frozen decisions*. Stage files and prompts point at it; they
never restate it. Copies are what drift — a decision that exists in one place
cannot diverge.
2. **Session-per-stage = free context control.** The primary token-control
mechanism isn't subagents or clever prompting — it's that each stage is small
and runs in its own fresh session. Cost per stage is flat
(`O(PLAN.md + stage file + ledger table)`), no matter how many stages came
before. No compaction spiral.
3. **The ledger is the resume point *and* the memory.** `LEDGER.md` holds
per-stage status plus as-built notes, so "where were we?" is a 10-line table,
and a later stage can catch a regression an earlier one introduced because the
earlier stage's assumptions were written down.
4. **Verify before done.** A stage is done when its acceptance check *ran* and
the real output is pasted into the ledger — not when the model claims success.
Evidence, not assertion.
## Requirements and decisions, before decomposing
Bootstrap settles *what* before *how*, and the plan is checked before any
stage runs. All of it happens inside `/plan-stages`, before the scaffold
commit — there is no extra stage.
- **Requirements step.** Capture the requirements first, before any decision:
outcome, day to day, constraints ranked, out of scope, and done as checks
(`PLAN.md` › Requirements). Play them back to the user in plain language and
get a confirmation before going on. The same step looks for an existing ADR
folder or current-decisions document and records the path as a decision, so
a plan adopts what the repo already has instead of starting a parallel list.
- **Decision triage.** Every decision the plan needs goes into one of three
groups: **Decided** (reversible and low impact — settled with its reason),
**Needs you** (taste, irreversible, cost, security or anything external) or
**Default for now** (a working default, flagged to revisit). Only **Needs
you** reaches the user, in **one batch**, each question with a recommended
answer. A **Needs you** decision still pending blocks only the stages that
name it, not the plan.
- **The brief.** After decomposition, generate `.plan/BRIEF.md` from
`PLAN.md` — a one-page view to check the plan against, never a second
source. Feedback on it is applied to `PLAN.md` and the brief regenerated.
Shape and stamp: [`templates/BRIEF.md`](references/templates/BRIEF.md).
- **Plan review.** Lens subagents read the uncommitted scaffold; their
findings are applied, and only then is the scaffold committed, so the plan
is reviewed before stage 1 by construction. Lenses, triggers and outcomes:
[`plan-review.md`](references/plan-review.md).
**Depth by size.** No new size metric: the line is the one *When NOT to use
it* already draws. Work that warrants a plan (about four or more sessions) is
big and gets all of the above. Work handled as a single issue is small — its
acceptance criteria are the spec, with no brief and no plan review; tiny work
has no ticket at all. Within a plan, depth scales by what the plan touches —
the review lenses' triggers — never by how many stages it has.
## Decomposing the work
- **Smallest sensible stage.** If a unit has two genuinely different mechanisms,
or a design-heavy part plus mechanical parts, split it.
- **Size a stage by time, not context.** Measured over 46 past stage sessions
(no compaction in any of them), the more a stage ran, the more the person had
to step in; how full the context got made no difference. A stage is **too big
when a run of it needs more than 4 interventions (messages from you after the
one that launched it) or more than 1 hour of active time** (gaps over 10
minutes dropped); about one stage session in five did either. Aim for a stage
that fits in about 0.4 hours, and split it into smaller stages rather than
adding checkpoints inside one. The ticked-checkbox resume stays for a stage
that cannot be split. The count includes approvals the protocol asks for, so
it slightly overstates size.
- **Group by effort, not just by feature.** Several near-identical mechanical
units can be one stage; a single design-heavy unit deserves its own.
- **Keystone as S0.** Identify the piece with no prerequisites that everything
else needs, make it S0, and gate the rest behind it.
- **`depends` is a graph, not a queue.** An edge means "cannot safely start
until", not "written after". Serialising by habit — writing
`S0 → S1 → S2 → S3` where the truth is `S0 → {S1, S2, S3}` — is the most
expensive decomposition mistake available here, because the index still
reads as correct while the plan takes three rounds instead of two. For every
edge, name the artifact the dependent stage consumes; if you can't name one,
drop the edge.
- **Every stage changes something or feeds a stage that does.** A stage whose
only output is a finding, a verification or documentation — "confirm X",
"investigate Y", "record Z" — earns its place only when a later stage lists
it in `depends` and names what it consumes from it. No consumer: fold the
investigation into the stage that would act on it, or drop it. A finding
that nothing downstream uses spends a session and changes nothing. The
standing review stage is the one exception, because its outcomes are
themselves actions.
- **Group by gate.** Alongside "group by effort": put the stages that need
a person — `gate: human` (frozen decisions get settled or amended, or
acceptance needs a person) and `gate: live` (the stage changes a running
system) — at the **front** or the **end** of the dependency graph, as far as
the dependencies allow, with the review stage last; keep the middle
mechanical, `gate: auto` and (when the plan opts in) `merge: auto`. Never
interleave a human or live gate between two auto stages unless a dependency
edge genuinely forces it: an unattended runner stops at every `human` and
`live` stage, so one in the middle of an auto run cuts the run in two for no
reason. Decisions that only
surface mid-build still go through `blocked` (see *Statuses and human-gated
stages*) — the rule shapes the graph, it doesn't forbid surprises.
- **Number in running order, with plain IDs.** Stages are `S0`, `S1`, … plus
`SF`, numbered in the order they run: stages that can run side by side get
consecutive numbers, and no stage is numbered below anything it `depends`
on. A suffixed ID (`S12b`) is rejected at scaffold time and when a stage is
inserted — renumber instead; an existing one is still read.
- **A wait measured in days is not a stage.** A soak period or a vendor's
reply would hold a session, a branch and a worktree open for nothing. Leave
it out of the index and record it as a dated follow-up (the date, the exact
check, the pass condition and what to do if it fails); the review stage lists
it and files it after the user's yes. A wait of hours stays in its stage.
- **Several independent outcomes make a programme, not one long plan.** When
the requirements hold two or more outcomes that can each merge into `main`
on their own, bootstrap proposes a **programme**: one plan per outcome, each
closing into `main` through its own final PR, tied together by a root
`PROGRAMME.md` ([format](references/programme-format.md)). The trigger is a
count of outcomes, never of stages.
- **Standing final review stage.** Always append `SF: plan review` as the last
stage (see below), scaffolded from `stage-f-review.md`. Bootstrap adds it;
it's not optional.
## Flag heuristics
Each stage declares `depends` / `mode` / `exec` / `model` / `effort` / `gate`
/ `estimate` in the **PLAN.md stage index** — the single authoritative home
for these flags, read by `/stage-run`'s weight check and the runnable-set
logic both commands share. `estimate` is a range in hours, judged at
bootstrap and measured against at finish; the method, including how later
plans calibrate from earlier actuals, is
[`references/estimates.md`](references/estimates.md). The plan as
a whole declares two more, `merge` and `plan-dir`, on the **plan flags** line
directly under that index — those two are the plan's *declared defaults*, the
answers an unattended session applies where an interactive one would ask (see
*Unattended mode*). Stage files never restate any of them. The **process**
defaults are deliberately cheap — escalate `mode`, `exec` and `gate` only
where a stage genuinely warrants it. `model`/`effort` are not among them:
those are sized to finish the stage, not to be minimised (see below).
**Linking a stage to its issue.** A stage file may carry one optional
`Issue:` line directly under its title, naming the issue the stage came from:
`#123`, `owner/repo#123` or an issue URL. It is a pointer, not a flag — it
changes nothing about how the stage's work runs, which is why it lives in the
stage file and not in the stage index. Commands read it as follows: the first line
of the stage file that starts with `Issue:`, above the first `##` heading,
whose value is one of those three forms. No such line, a blank value or an
unfilled template placeholder all read as "no linked issue", silently, so a
plan without the field behaves exactly as before. A Jira issue is linked by
its URL (`https://<site>/browse/KEY-123`), which carries the site.
It has two effects, a status sync and a closing line.
**Status sync while the stage runs.** When the ticket template resolved for
the issue's tracker sets `[work].status` (the same keys `work-issue` uses),
`/stage-run` moves the ticket to `on_start` when the stage starts fresh and
to `on_pr` when its pull request opens, each with one short comment naming
the stage and the plan (the second also links the pull request). It reuses
`work-issue`'s adapter calls and their read-back: Jira `transition` and
`comment`, GitHub `set-fields` and `comment`. `tickets/scripts/work_core.py
stage-status` decides what to do, so the rules below hold in every run. A
ticket is **never moved to a done status**: a done name, or a Jira status in
the done category, is refused and reported. A result that is not
`VERIFIED` is one line and the stage carries on; a status write never stops
a stage. The template declaring the status is the authority for the write
and its fixed-text comment, so an `--unattended` run makes them too; a
write that would need a question (a GitHub board number for an unrouted
repo) is skipped and reported instead. A template with no `[work].status`,
or no linked issue, means no write, no comment and no output. A cloud
session following `RUNNER.md` never touches issues, so it does not sync.
**The closing line at closeout.** `/plan-close` writes a `Closes <ref>`
line for each linked GitHub issue into the final PR body, so the issue
closes when a person merges that PR (`Refs` instead when the plan only
partly delivers it; `/plan-close` step 3 has the rule). A Jira issue always
gets `Refs <url>`, because only GitHub closes an issue from a pull request:
a person moves the Jira ticket to done.
- `mode: direct` by default (state a one-line plan, implement). Use `brainstorm`
only where the stage has real open design choices. A full brainstorm on a
mechanical one-liner is pure ceremony.
- `exec: inline` by default. Session-per-stage already isolates context, so
reserve `subagent(<model>)` for churn-heavy stages (lots of iteration, config,
debugging) where dispatching keeps the churn out of the orchestrator's context.
- `model`/`effort` are **launch hints**, not switches the agent can flip
mid-session. Both are verifiable: the model from the session itself, and the
effort level from `CLAUDE_EFFORT` in the environment — so state what is
actually set rather than restating the flag as a reminder. When that variable
is absent, say the effort could not be read instead of assuming it matched.
Pick the tier that would
carry the stage to its **exit criteria without the session having to
escalate** — not the cheapest tier that could plausibly start it. A stage
that stalls and gets re-run costs more than the tier it saved, and because
the re-run happens in a fresh session the plan never records that it
happened. **Where two tiers are arguable, take the higher one.** Reserve the
top model for the keystone and the one or two design-heavy stages; much
staged work still lands at `low`/`med` effort, but that is an observation
about past plans, not a target this one should hit.
- `gate: auto` by default. `gate` says whether a stage may be **launched
unattended** — by an orchestrator session that fires stages back-to-back
with nobody watching them run (see `references/remote-driver.md`); this flag
is the contract it reads. A `gate: human`, `gate: local` or `gate: live`
stage is never launched unattended: the orchestrator stops in front of it
and reports rather than firing, and a session
that finds itself running one unattended (see *Statuses and human-gated
stages*) reports and stops rather than starting it. A runner fires a stage
only when its `gate` is `auto` or absent; any other value, unknown ones
included, is refused and named. Mark `human` where a
person must be present for the stage to get anywhere: every
`mode: brainstorm` stage (a design pass is a conversation), and any stage
whose acceptance needs a human's eyes or hands (a visual check, a GUI-only
action, a credential). Mark `local` where the stage needs a resource only
the local machine has, known at authoring time — local hardware, a
LAN-only host, a secret not committed anywhere reachable, or a
locally-installed toolchain. Mark `live` where the stage deploys or changes
a running system — a service, a host, a database, anything outside the
repository that people or other systems depend on; every stage that is not
`live` is a build stage that touches only its `## Artifacts` files. The
three gates are independent: the driver refuses any of them exactly the same
way, but for a different reason — `human` because nobody is watching,
`local` because the driver could be running anywhere but the machine the
stage needs, `live` because a person chooses when a running system changes.
A stage that only discovers this
mid-run, with nothing declared up front, uses the `needs-local` blocked
reason instead (*Statuses and human-gated stages*, below). **Why `auto` is
the default and not `human`:** the flag changes nothing until something
runs stages unattended — today, and for any plan that never adopts a
driver, `merge: manual` already stops at every merge whatever `gate` says,
so an `auto` default costs existing plans nothing and keeps a fresh plan
closest to today's fully-manual experience. The conservative alternative
(`human` by default, opt stages *into* unattended) would make bootstrap
upgrade every mechanical stage by hand instead of downgrading the few that
need a person; it was considered and is the right call only if unattended
runs turn out to misfire on stages that looked mechanical at decomposition.
An **absent** `gate` column reads as `auto` — plans written before the flag
existed need no edit.
- `merge: manual` by default — **plan-level, not per-stage.** `merge` says
what happens to a stage PR once it is open: under `manual` the session
offers the merge and waits for your OK (today's behaviour, unchanged);
under `auto` it merges the stage PR into the plan branch itself — still a
squash, still only after the sibling re-sync check, and only once every
required check is green — then carries straight on to the `done` write and
teardown. `auto` is opt-in because any other default would silently change
the merge behaviour of every plan that predates the flag, and it governs
**stage PRs only**: the plan→main PR is manual in every mode, with no
override (see *Git model*). An **absent** plan-flags line reads as
`merge: manual`.
- `plan-dir: delete` by default — **plan-level, and read only at closeout.**
`plan-dir` says what happens to `.plan/` when the plan is closed: under
`delete` it goes as the last commit on the plan branch (nothing is lost —
the full plan history stays in git, and the final PR shows the removal);
under `keep` it stays, for a project where the plan doubles as its
documentation. This is the answer `/plan-close` already calls its default,
written down in advance so an unattended closeout has it — an interactive
closeout still asks, with this value as the recommendation. An **absent**
`plan-dir` entry reads as `delete`, so nothing changes for a plan that
predates the flag.
## Model weight tiers
Every weight check (bootstrap's gate, a stage's `model` comparison) needs a
mechanical rule for "is this session heavy enough" — not the model's own guess
about itself. Maintain this tier list as model families evolve, and place a new
family by its capability and price, not by where its name sorts:
- **Top tier ("Opus-class"):** the Opus generation (e.g. `claude-opus-*`), plus
any frontier family positioned at or above it (e.g. `claude-fable-*`).
- **Mid tier ("Sonnet-class"):** the Sonnet generation (e.g. `claude-sonnet-*`).
- **Light tier ("Haiku-class"):** the Haiku generation (e.g. `claude-haiku-*`).
**Fail-safe:** if the session's disclosed model ID or name doesn't recognizably
match a tier above — an unfamiliar family, a third-party model, a future rename —
do not guess which tier it belongs to. State the exact model ID/name from the
system prompt and ask the user which tier applies, rather than silently passing
or failing the gate.
## Parallel stages
`depends` is a real dependency graph, so more than one stage is often runnable
at once. Three rules keep that an advantage rather than a source of confusion
(and one limit: no two `gate: live` stages ever run at once, however the
graph looks — `/stage-run` preflight refuses the second at start):
- **Derive, never store.** The runnable set, the waves, and the critical path
are *views* of the `depends` column, computed on demand — by bootstrap's
post-decomposition summary and by every stage's end announcement. Do **not**
add a `wave` or `parallel-group` column to the stage index: that would be a
second copy of the graph, and principle 1 exists precisely because copies
drift. Stage IDs are plain numbers in running order, so stages that can run
side by side carry consecutive numbers; a suffixed ID is read but never
created.
- **Report the set; don't launch it.** The deliverable is telling the operator
what *can* overlap — every `todo` stage whose `depends` are all `done` or
`skipped`, each
with its command, recommended model/effort and `gate`. Starting them is the
operator's action, one session per stage — or an orchestrator's, firing
cloud stages and honouring `gate`. In the desktop app a stage can *offer*
each one as a suggestion chip, but the click is still the operator's: the
chip cannot pick its launch mode and can set model and effort only downward
(if at all, depending on which chip tool the session has), and it exists nowhere
else (not on a phone, not in a terminal), so the printed command stays the
handoff every surface can use.
- **Separate working trees are what make it physical.** The semantics below
make concurrent sessions *safe*; worktree-per-stage (see *Git model*) makes
them *possible*. Two sessions sharing one working tree fight over `HEAD`
whatever the merge rules say.
Four semantics are what make concurrent sessions safe rather than merely
possible. They are specified in full in the template `PLAN.md`, which owns the
operating protocol; the reasoning behind them is the method:
- **The plan branch is the serialization point.** Parallel stage PRs merge one
at a time, first come first served. The second merger syncs the plan branch
*into* its stage branch and re-runs the acceptance check — "mergeable" means
no textual conflict, not that the stage still passes. Squash merge makes
that free (the merge commit is discarded), which is why a stage branch is
never rebased or force-pushed.
- **A sibling's stage branch is not drift.** Preflight classifies by *whose*
stage a mismatch belongs to instead of halting on any `todo` row with a
committed branch — otherwise every parallel session stops the moment a
second one starts. Real drift on the stage you are running still stops you,
and a genuinely crashed stage stays visible in every later preflight report
and in closeout's gate.
- **Shared write territory is a `depends` edge, not a new field.** Two stages
that write the same files are not independent, whatever the feature graph
says, and `depends` is the only place that can say so. A dedicated
"territory" field would be a second record of one constraint — a second
thing to drift.
- **The `done` ledger write races.** It is a direct commit on the plan branch,
so two sessions finishing together collide there: replay the commit on
rejection, keep both rows on conflict, never force-push the plan branch.
**Is `exec: subagent(<model>)` fan-out an alternative to parallel sessions?**
Only *inside* a stage — never as a substitute for them. Dispatching a whole
wave from one orchestrator does sidestep git concurrency, but it collapses N
stages into one: a single branch, PR, ledger row, and acceptance check
covering work the decomposition deliberately kept separate (git semantics 1
and 3) — and the orchestrator accumulates every subagent's return, so
per-session cost stops being flat and principle 2, the mechanism the whole
method rests on, goes with it. For a wave of cheap mechanical stages the
honest options are therefore: run them as N sessions (the supported answer),
or decide at **decomposition** time that they were really one stage, merge
them, and let `exec: subagent(<model>)` absorb the churn within it. That is a
decomposition decision, not an execution one — "group by effort, not just by
feature" already points at it.
## Statuses and human-gated stages
Statuses are `todo → doing → done`, plus `blocked` and `skipped` (full lifecycle
and the checkbox resume mechanism are in the templates). Two are worth calling
out as method, not just vocabulary:
- **`blocked`** is a first-class state, not a failure. A stage that hits a gate
only a human or an external system can clear (a GUI-only action, a credential,
an approval) is best written as a **runbook**: produce exact step-by-step
instructions plus the verification check, mark the stage `blocked`/`doing`, and
let the human complete it. Never fake progress past a gate. **Where that
record is committed** is settled once, in the template `PLAN.md`'s operating
protocol under *Recording a block* — on the plan branch directly when the
block predates the stage branch, and on the stage branch plus a
`.plan/BLOCKED.md` section on the plan branch once it exists. That is the
single source of truth for the rule. Neither this skill nor `/stage-run`
restates it — they only name which side of it a given decision point falls
on. **`needs-local`** is the reason value for one specific case: a stage
that discovers *mid-run* — nothing declared as `gate: local` up front —
that it needs a resource only the local machine has. Same `blocked` state,
same commit rule, but the one-line reason is the literal token
`needs-local` rather than free text, so an orchestrator's report can
say "re-run this stage locally" instead of a generic failure (`PLAN.md`,
*Recording a block*, "The discovered case").
- **Unattended, a stage question that has no declared default becomes
`blocked`.** A `gate: human`, `gate: local` or `gate: live` stage found
running unattended is the plainest case: it is not started. Mark the stage `blocked` with a runbook stating the question
and what would unblock it, commit that where *Recording a block* says, and
stop. This is the existing
state and the existing mechanism, not new machinery; the only rule
unattended mode adds is that waiting on an answer is not an option, because
there is nobody to give one. The human answers later by amending the frozen
decisions or the ledger and relaunching the stage. Which questions have a
declared default and which are hard stops is the table in *Unattended
mode*, below.
- **`skipped`** records a one-line reason for work decided against, so the gap is
a decision, not a silent hole. It satisfies a dependent's `depends` exactly
like `done` — the runnable set never deadlocks on a stage that was
deliberately dropped. If the skipped stage owned acceptance or verification
work (a check nothing else covers), say so in the same note: that coverage
is now unowned, and the final review stage (`SF`) is where it gets
reassigned or explicitly accepted as a gap — never silently lost.
Track known gaps and latent hazards explicitly in the ledger notes (things not
under version control, footguns, "this script would delete X if run") — writing
them down is what stops them becoming surprises, and it's what lets the final
review stage catch them.
## Unattended mode
**One mode, one rule, honoured at every decision point.** A session is
unattended when nobody can answer it: a command was told so explicitly with its
`--unattended` argument, or its opening prompt says so in plain words. That
last path is how a **cloud** session enters this mode: plugins do not load in
cloud containers, so there is no command and no argument to carry the flag —
the orchestrator that fired the stage (see `references/remote-driver.md`)
states it in the prompt instead. However a session
learns it, the contract below is identical. That argument is a single switch selecting **declared
default over ask** — never "proceed anyway". Interactive sessions keep asking
exactly as they always have, and one body of skill text serves both modes. A
fork into interactive and unattended copies is the anti-pattern this contract
exists to prevent: two bodies means every protocol change made twice, and the
seams between the modes are subtle enough that the second copy would be the
one that rots.
Every question the protocol can put to a person is classified once, as one of
two kinds:
- **Declared default.** The answer is fixed ahead of the run — written on
`PLAN.md`'s **plan flags** line (`merge`, `plan-dir`), or a mechanical rule
that needs no answer at all. An unattended session applies it and carries
on; an interactive one still asks, with the declared value as the
recommendation.
- **Hard stop.** There is no defensible default, so an unattended session
does not invent one. It records the question where the next session will
find it — the stage row marked `blocked` with a runbook, committed where
*Recording a block* says so it is readable without waiting for a merge, or,
where no stage row owns the question, a report naming the exact state and the
command that clears it — and ends. Nothing is faked past a gate and nothing
is retried.
| Decision point | Interactive | Unattended |
|---|---|---|
| A `gate: human` stage | announced — the person at the keyboard *is* the gate | **hard stop**, never started |
| A `gate: local` stage | announced — running it here means this session already has what it needs | **hard stop**, never started — except by `/plan-run-local`, whose driver runs on this machine |
| A `gate: live` stage | announced — the person at the keyboard chooses when the running system changes | **hard stop**, never started |
| A `gate` value that is not `auto`, `human`, `local` or `live` | refused and named | **hard stop**, never started |
| Weight check: lighter model than recommended, or a readable effort that differs from the flag | **hard stop** — relaunch named, nothing written | **hard stop** — `blocked` + runbook |
| Weight check: an unrecognised tier | asked which tier applies | **hard stop** — `blocked` + runbook |
| A mid-stage question the frozen decisions don't settle | asked | **hard stop** — `blocked` + runbook |
| Redo of a `done` stage | confirmed first | **hard stop** — `blocked` + runbook |
| A stage PR's merge | `merge` flag — `auto` merges it, `manual` offers it | `merge` flag — `auto` merges it, `manual` is a **hard stop** |
| Checking out the plan branch to reach `.plan/` | offered | default: check it out when exactly one plan branch matches; two or more is a **hard stop** |
| A stage worktree still present at closeout | offered for removal when its branch is merged and nothing is unpushed | removed on that same condition; anything else is a **hard stop** |
| The final review stage's kept-decisions list | asked in one batch | the stage applies its own proposals, and merging the plan→main PR approves them; an ambiguous decisions target is a **hard stop** for that step only |
| Deleting `.plan/` at closeout | asked | `plan-dir` flag |
| Merging the plan→main PR | the PR is proposed; you merge it | the PR is opened; you merge it — **no session merges it in any mode**, no flag, no override |
Every **`blocked` + runbook** cell above means the record *Recording a block*
defines. The weight-check and redo hard stops fire before the stage branch
exists, so they commit straight onto the plan branch; a mid-stage question
fires after it does, so it lands on the stage branch and is announced on the
plan branch through `.plan/BLOCKED.md`. The distinction matters more unattended
than anywhere else: a runbook left on an unmerged branch with nothing on the
plan branch pointing at it is one the next pass never reads.
**What no mode loosens.** The plan→main PR is opened by closeout and merged
by a person, always. A `gate: human` stage is never launched unattended, and
neither is a `gate: live` one, nor a `gate: local` one by any runner but
`/plan-run-local` — same refusal, different reason. A
worktree holding real uncommitted or unpushed work is never removed, and never
with `--force`. A merge the platform refuses is never forced or retried.
**Bootstrap has no unattended mode, deliberately.** `/plan-stages` is design
work — decomposition, frozen decisions, the `merge` question — and those have
no defensible defaults to declare. A plan decomposed badly costs far more than
the session it would have saved. Where a plan genuinely needs to be bootstrapped
headless, a fully-specified brief that says to make every decision and ask
nothing does the job as an ordinary prompt; that route needs no contract behind
it.
## Git model
**Branch-per-stage in a worktree-per-stage is the only supported model** —
it's the model this plugin was built with, and there is no alternative to
choose at bootstrap:
```
main
└── plan-<slug> ← plan branch; .plan/ lives here
├── plan-<slug>-s0 → PR → plan-<slug> (squash merge)
├── plan-<slug>-s1 → PR → plan-<slug> (squash merge)
└── ...
plan-<slug> → final PR → main ← at closeout (normal merge)
```
**`.plan/` must be tracked, and the plan branch must have an upstream.** Both
are load-bearing invariants, not tidiness. An untracked (or `.gitignore`d)
`.plan/` breaks the model in two ways at once: a stage whose only artifacts are
decisions or documentation produces nothing to commit, so it can never open the
PR that semantics 3–4 below require, and every stage depending on it deadlocks
on an unsatisfiable gate; and the whole decision record lives only in a working
directory that a `git clean` or a deleted worktree takes with it. A local-only
plan branch is the quieter version of the same failure — the preflight's fetch
and fast-forward both succeed and do nothing, forever. Bootstrap refuses to
scaffold into an ignored path and pushes the plan branch with an upstream;
every stage preflight re-checks both.
Seven frozen semantics:
1. **One branch per stage**, cut from the plan branch (`plan-<slug>`) — no
exceptions. Uniformity keeps each unit reviewable in isolation and contains
the classic failure where "one small commit" quietly becomes twenty commits
of fixes bleeding into shared history.
2. **Commits are compulsory and incremental** — commit at logical units as the
stage progresses, not a single commit at stage end. Every stage has
something to commit: the ledger evidence and any frozen-decision amendment
are tracked files, so even a decision-only stage lands a real commit and a
real PR.
3. **A stage PR into the plan branch is compulsory** — the finish protocol
creates it; it is never "offered" as optional.
4. **A stage cannot be closed (marked `done`) until its PR is merged** into
the plan branch.
5. **After the merge, return to the clone and fast-forward** the plan branch
before the session ends — the clone is already on it, so there is no
checkout — and record the stage `done` in the ledger there: the `done`
edit is committed on the plan branch after the merge, never on the stage
branch, so a `done` row is always visible from a synced plan branch.
6. **Merge type is fixed by position:** each stage PR is **squash-merged** into
the plan branch (one clean commit per stage, no intra-stage churn on the plan
branch); the final PR from the plan branch into `main` is a **normal
(non-squash) merge**, so every stage lands on `main` as its own distinct
commit and the as-built history survives. **This is the one rule the plan
cannot enforce**, because it is the one merge no session performs: the
person merging gets the repo's default merge button, and a default of
"Squash and merge" collapses every stage into one commit on `main` while
still looking like a clean, successful merge. Set the repo's default to
"Create a merge commit" when the plan is set up — that is the only real
control; closeout naming the merge type in the PR body is a reminder.
7. **One worktree per stage, and the clone never leaves the plan branch.** A
stage branch is checked out only in its own sibling worktree
(`../<repo>-s<N>`); the main clone stays parked on `plan-<slug>` for the
life of the plan. See *Worktree-per-stage* below.
Also: **flat branch names** (`plan-<slug>-s3`, not `plan/<slug>/s3`) — git
refs can't nest a branch under an existing branch name. And **push freely,
offer merges**: stage and plan branches are feature branches — the agent
creates and **pushes** them without asking, and **opens** the stage PR into
the plan branch as part of the compulsory finish protocol, but **offers** the
merge for your OK — it never merges without your OK, never pushes to `main`,
and the final PR to `main` is always yours to merge.
**The one carve-out: `merge: auto`.** A plan that sets `merge: auto` on its
plan-flags line (see *Flag heuristics*) has given that OK **in advance, for
stage PRs only** — so under `auto` the session squash-merges its own stage PR
into the plan branch once the sibling re-sync check has run and every required
check is green, and continues to the `done` write and teardown without
stopping. Nothing else loosens: the merge is still a squash, the re-sync rule
still applies, and a merge that GitHub refuses (a red or missing check, a
branch-protection rule the plan branch carries) is **not** retried or forced —
the session leaves the row `doing`, reports the refusal and why, and ends; the
next preflight completes the bookkeeping once a person merges it, exactly as
when a merge is declined today. **The plan→main PR is manual in every mode.**
`merge` is never read at closeout, and no value of it — nor any future flag —
creates a path that merges into `main` without a person's explicit OK. That is
the one human gate that survives even a fully unattended plan.
### Worktree-per-stage
**The clone holds the plan; worktrees hold the work.** The main clone is
permanently parked on `plan-<slug>` — that is the only branch ever checked out
there. Every stage branch lives in its own sibling worktree, created from the
plan branch tip:
```
~/src/
hive/ ← main clone, always on plan-<slug>, holds .plan/
hive-s1/ ← worktree, branch plan-<slug>-s1
hive-s3/ ← worktree, branch plan-<slug>-s3 (concurrent)
```
This is fixed, not a choice — the same register as branch-per-stage. Three
things follow from it, and they are why it is worth a frozen semantic rather
than a suggestion:
- **The ledger is always readable and always writable.** Because the clone
never moves off the plan branch, `.plan/` there is the synced plan-branch
copy at every moment. The `done` write (finish step 5) is a commit in the
clone that needs no checkout and cannot disturb an in-flight stage.
- **Concurrency stops contending for `HEAD`.** *Parallel stages* above makes
concurrent sessions semantically safe; separate working trees are what make
them physically possible. Two sessions in one directory fight over the
checkout no matter how correct the merge rules are.
- **Provisioning prefers the harness, falls back to git.** Use the harness's
native worktree mechanism when there is one (Claude Code's `EnterWorktree`,
or `superpowers:using-git-worktrees` when installed) — but only when it
honors the exact branch and path names above (the template `PLAN.md` owns
the full rule); otherwise `git worktree add`. What it must **never** do is
degrade to checking the
stage branch out in the clone — if the harness refuses to work outside its
original directory, the honest move is to stop and hand the operator the
path to relaunch in.
Two honest costs, named where they bite rather than discovered later. A fresh
worktree contains only tracked files, so untracked local setup a stage needs
(`.env`, local config, build caches, `node_modules`) is not there — copy what
the stage needs and note it in the ledger. And a worktree is a real directory
that outlives a crashed session, so teardown is part of the protocol: after
the merge, a clean and fully-pushed worktree is removed along with its merged
branch, while anything uncommitted, unpushed, or stashed is left alone and
reported. Preflight reports orphans; closeout gates on any that survive —
removing the ones that are merged and fully pushed, and refusing to close
while one holds work git cannot recover (see *Closeout*).
**Preflight & sync — verify git state before trusting the ledger.** The
ledger is canonical, but only after it's proven fresh: every stage session
and the closeout start with a preflight block, defined once in the template
`PLAN.md`'s operating protocol — confirm `.plan/` is tracked and the plan
branch has an upstream, fetch, fast-forward the plan branch (holds
under both squash-merge and merge-commit remotes), require a clean tree in
both the clone and this worktree, apply the **two-tree rule** to HEAD (the
clone on the plan branch, the stage on its own worktree), and reconcile the
ledger rows against actual branch, PR, and worktree state. One state is
self-healing (a `doing` row whose PR merged remotely gets its `done`
recorded); one is expected under concurrency (another
stage's in-flight branch — reported, not fatal, see *Parallel stages*);
everything else is drift, and the preflight **reports and stops** — it never
auto-stashes, resets, or deletes branches.
**Decisions in force.** At the start of each stage the session is shown the
decisions-document entries whose `Paths:` overlap the stage file's
`## Artifacts`, and `BRIEF.md`'s stamp is checked against `PLAN.md`; the
template `PLAN.md`'s protocol defines both.
## Drift — the scope referee
Plans drift, and some drift is the plan doing its job: a stage finds work
nobody could have planned. What hurts is a plan that becomes a different
plan one reasonable step at a time — a review that starts implementing, a
proof of concept that turns into the production build, a direction change
carried on under the old Outcome. The check is about **kind, not amount**:
there is no threshold and no count.
It fires at one moment only: **when a stage is added** after the scaffold
commit, by anyone. A fresh-context subagent — the **scope referee** — sees the
plan's Outcome and Out of scope, the new stage with its reason, and the
earlier additions, and nothing of the session that wants the stage, so it has
no stake in the work so far. Its verdicts: **grows** (add it, silently),
**losing shape** (add it, one line to the user suggesting a re-plan), or
**different plan** (stop and offer: carry on, re-plan, or close this plan as
a milestone and start a new one). The user always decides; a session running
unattended never adds a stage at all. The template `PLAN.md`'s *Adding a
stage* defines the inputs, the record line in the ledger and each verdict's
handling, and the session-start hook points every session of a plan that
carries that section at it.
**Inside a running stage** the referee sees nothing, because a stage that
keeps going adds no stage — the proof of concept that becomes the production
build. Two things cover it. A stage's **Acceptance is its stop line**: once
its checks pass, more of the same work is a new stage, through the referee
like any other, and every stage file has the session read the Outcome and
Out of scope before it starts. After the fact, the finish protocol records an
**`Artifacts check:` line** — `scripts/artifacts_check.py` compares the files
the stage changed with the paths its `## Artifacts` names — and the final
review judges each `outside` line. It is a record, never a gate: touching an
unlisted file is routine, and a proof of concept can become production inside
its declared files. Both live in the templates, so a plan scaffolded before
them carries neither.
The cheapest drift is the one prevented at bootstrap: an idea too vague to
state its Done checks, whose checks name nothing observable, or whose
Outcome has no edge ("exhaustive", "etc." with no list of what is in) is
scaffolded as a **discovery plan** by default — its Outcome a decision, its
Out of scope `Building <subject> — that is the next plan.`, so the referee
has a written boundary to judge by. A build plan from such requirements is
never refused, but it needs the user's reason, recorded as a frozen
decision with the drift risk (`/plan-stages`, step 2).
## The final review stage
`SF` is the one stage exempt from the read-scope rule: on its first pass it
reads the *entire* ledger — every note, gotcha, shortcut, and known gap — and
`PLAN.md` › Requirements › Out of scope, and sweeps for stragglers. A redo
after a fix reads only the plan file, the first pass's loose-end list with
outcomes, the notes of the `Fix:` stages added since, and any stage whose notes
are missing from the first pass's coverage record or changed since the commit
it records (`git diff` of the ledger against it). Crucially, **it
catalogs; it never implements, and it never adds a stage** — bar one capped
exception below. Each finding becomes exactly one outcome:
- **An issue** — work that belongs in its own ticket. A wait measured in days
(never a stage) is a **dated follow-up**, also an issue: its body states the
date, the exact check, the pass condition (with the basis for its threshold)
and the action on failure. Nothing is scheduled. Attended, `SF` files it
through `create-issue` after the user's yes. Unattended it files nothing: it
records the item under a `closeout will list` heading in its ledger notes, and
`/plan-close` copies it into the final PR body.
- **A later plan** — work for a later plan of the programme (the programme index
`PROGRAMME.md` names it). Unattended, recorded under the same `closeout will
list` heading.
- **An explicit "accepted, won't fix"** — with a one-line reason, so the gap is a
decision instead of a surprise.
- **Exception — a fix.** Never a feature: a fix names the requirement, failing
Done check or regression it repairs, and needs the user present and saying
yes, with its own verification. Fix stages are titled `Fix: …`, and `SF`'s
ledger notes keep a `#### Fixes` list, the durable count. At most 3 per plan;
a fourth fix is a hard stop in every mode. How it runs: `SF`'s PR lands what it
found — the `Fix:` stage's index row placed before `SF` (via
`scripts/renumber_stages.py`, so `SF` stays last), `SF`'s `depends` extended to
it, and `SF`'s row set back to `todo` — so the catalogue of loose ends is
kept. The fix runs as an ordinary stage, then `SF` re-runs from the top as a
redo. Unattended, `SF` stops and asks: it records a block through *Recording a
block* instead of adding the fix.
Its acceptance check: every loose end in the notes has exactly one of these
outcomes.
**It also owns what outlives `.plan/`.** Closeout deletes the plan, so `SF`
decides what survives it:
- **Decision triage at close.** For every frozen decision, propose one
outcome — drop it, a `DECISIONS.md` entry, or an ADR — and write the
approved ones, into the repo's existing decisions document or ADR folder
when it has one. The keep rule, entry shape and ADR shape are in
[`decisions-format.md`](references/decisions-format.md). Attended, the
whole list is approved in one batch. Unattended, `SF` applies its own
proposals and `/plan-close` lists them in the plan→main PR body, so merging
that PR is the approval.
- **Docs and pointer.** Update the README (or the changed module's own doc)
and add the repo's `CLAUDE.md` pointer line to the decisions file.
- **Cold-reader check.** Read the updated docs as someone who never saw the
plan, and fix what they could not follow.
All three are written **only on a clean pass**: a run that adds a fix writes none
of them, and the redo does. These are documentation writes, not product code, so
"catalogs, never implements" still holds. `SF` stays `gate: auto` by default,
though an unattended run stops and asks when it finds a fix.
## Closeout
Closeout refuses to run until every ledger row is `done` or `skipped` (including
stages the review spawned) **and** no stage PR into the plan branch remains
open or unmerged — a `done` row alone is not enough; the preflight's
reconcile runs first and treats that mismatch as a gate failure. Then it: distills `PLAN.md` + the ledger into the
final PR body so the *why* and the as-built story survive on `main`; deletes
`.plan/` as the last commit on the plan branch (nothing is lost — the full plan
history remains in git; keeping `.plan/` is the `plan-dir: keep` option, for a
plan that doubles as documentation); and proposes the PR from `plan-<slug>` to
`main` for the human to review and merge.
When the plan belongs to a programme, closeout also removes the plan's own line
from `PROGRAMME.md` (the last plan removes the file), so the final PR carries
it and the next plan is always the first line left; it then offers to plan that
next plan, to be bootstrapped from `main` after the merge.
### Lessons at close
A retro written as a record is read by nobody. Closeout's lessons exist to
change the **next** plan, so they are short, blunt, and fed forward.
- **What.** Three to six one-line lessons in two groups, in this fixed
layout, printed in the chat and copied as a `## Lessons` section into the
final PR body:
```markdown
### Lessons from this plan
🧭 **For you, next time**
- <what happened, with its number> — <what to do differently>
🔧 **For the plugin**
- <what the plugin got wrong or lacked> — <what it should do>
```
A group with nothing actionable reads `- nothing this time`.
- **Evidence only.** Each line comes from the plan's own record: the
scaffold's `PLAN.md` against the final one (stages, requirements, frozen
decisions), the `Added by` lines and their referee verdicts, skipped stages
and their reasons, blocks and what they waited on, rows not verified,
`SF`'s fixes, and closeout's usage report — estimates against actuals: a
stage that ran far outside its range, or a plan total far off its
estimate, is a lesson about sizing ("S3 took 6h against 1–2h — split a
stage whose Steps name two components"). A plan with no estimates has no
such line. A lesson with no evidence behind it is not written.
- **Tone rule.** Blunt, whatever register the user's assistant normally uses:
no praise, no pleasantries, no "went well" lines, no softening. Each line
names what happened and what to do differently; a line that is not an
action is dropped. A flattering retro teaches nothing.
- **Fed forward.** The next `/plan-stages` in the same repository reads the
last merged plan's `## Lessons` and checks the new requirements against the
*For you* lines during the playback — that is where a lesson can still
change something. Each *For the plugin* line is offered, attended and after
the user's yes, as an issue in the plugin's repository, scrubbed of
project detail. Lessons are for plans only: work done as a single ticket
gets none.
**Stage worktrees are part of closeout's gate, under one rule in both modes.**
A surviving worktree whose branch matches `plan-<slug>-s*` means some stage
never finished its teardown. If that worktree's branch is merged into the plan
branch and it holds nothing unpushed, it is finished work and removal is safe:
interactive closeout offers to remove it, unattended closeout removes it.
Anything else — unpushed commits, an unmerged branch, work that is not
recoverable from git — stops closeout in both modes, with the path and what it
holds reported. An operator's unrelated worktree (any other branch) is none of
the plan's business and never blocks.
**Closeout runs unattended too** (`/plan-close --unattended`), and an
orchestrator can fire it once every stage is `done` or `skipped`, so a plan can go from
bootstrap to an open plan→main PR with exactly two human gates: a `gate: human`
stage, and the final merge. See *Unattended mode*.
## Anti-patterns this exists to prevent
- Restating decisions in prompts or stage files — copies drift; point at
`PLAN.md`.
- One giant stage — blows context, can't resume; split it.
- Brainstorming everything — design ceremony on mechanical work; `direct` is the
default.
- Subagents everywhere — session-per-stage already isolates context; reserve them
for churn.
- Claiming done without evidence — the acceptance output must actually land in
the ledger.
- Silent scope creep — "while I'm here…"; note it, spin a stage, move on.
- Editing decisions in two places — frozen decisions change in `PLAN.md` only.
- Skipping the dependency gate — building on an unbuilt prerequisite.
- Checking a stage branch out in the main clone — the clone is the plan's
window; moving it hides the ledger and breaks every concurrent session.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |