Yuan1z0825/nature-skills / skills/nature-academic-search
nature-academic-search
FlaggedSearch literature across sources, verify or manage citations, and build MeSH strategies or citation-impact audits. Use for 文献检索、引文核对、参考文献管理、严格他引 and evidence-backed citer profiles; not for translating a paper or drafting manuscript prose.
references/workflows/wf6-strict-other-citation-impact-audit.md
View on GitHub# Workflow 6: Strict Other-Citation Impact Audit
## Contents
- [Definitions](#definitions)
- [Procedure](#procedure)
- [Article Summary Table Mode](#article-summary-table-mode)
- [Output Format](#output-format)
- [Red Lines](#red-lines)
**Purpose:** Audit who cites a target paper, distinguish strict independent
other-citations from self/team citations, build article-level citation metric
tables, identify high-profile independent citers, and extract how those citers
discuss the target paper.
**Use when the user asks:** `严格他引`, `他引判定`, `排除自引`,
`谁引用了我的文章`, `引用我的文章的人有没有大牛`, `院士引用`,
`杰青引用`, `长江学者引用`, `Fellow citation`, `influential citer`,
`citation context`, `文章引用表`, `指定文章引用数`, `严格他引数`,
`整理成表格`, or similar citation-impact questions.
**Uses:**
- [Search Strategy](../search-strategy.md) — construct title/DOI/cited-by queries.
- [Dedup Engine](../dedup-engine.md) — deduplicate citing records across sources.
- [Source Tiers](../source-tiers.md) — report source coverage and confidence limits.
## Definitions
Use conservative labels. Do not upgrade a citation to strict independent status
unless the evidence supports it.
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| `confirmed_strict_other_citation` | The citing paper cites the target paper; no target-paper author overlap; no obvious same lab/team/institution conflict; no discoverable recent coauthorship tie with target authors in the checked sources. |
| `probable_external_citation` | No author overlap is visible, but affiliation, ORCID, coauthor-network, or full metadata is incomplete. |
| `self_or_team_citation` | At least one target-paper author appears on the citing paper, or the citing authors are clearly from the same lab/team/project group. |
| `collaborator_or_affiliation_overlap` | No direct author overlap, but there is a same-institution, same-center, advisor/student, project, or recent coauthorship tie strong enough to make strict independence doubtful. |
| `unknown_metadata` | Metadata is insufficient to classify independence. |
For `严格他引`, the default bar is stricter than a simple non-self-citation:
exclude direct self-citations, same-team citations, and obvious close
collaboration-network citations. If the user wants a looser bibliometric
definition, state the changed rule explicitly.
## Procedure
1. **Identify the target paper.**
- Resolve title, DOI, PMID/arXiv ID if any, publication year, journal, author
list, corresponding authors, affiliations, and author identifiers
(ORCID/Scopus Author ID/Semantic Scholar author ID when available).
- If the target is ambiguous, list the candidate records and ask for the DOI
or exact title before auditing.
2. **Retrieve citing papers with source coverage stated.**
- Prefer citation-graph sources when available: Scopus, Web of Science,
Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, CrossRef cited-by, publisher cited-by pages.
- Use multiple sources when possible, then deduplicate with
[Dedup Engine](../dedup-engine.md).
- Report which sources were checked and which were unavailable. Do not imply
an exhaustive citation count when only partial sources were available.
3. **Classify strict other-citation status.**
- Compare citing-paper authors against target-paper authors by normalized
name plus ORCID/author IDs when available.
- Check affiliations, lab/center names, corresponding-author groups, and
recent coauthorship ties when source metadata allows.
- Classify each citing paper using the labels above. Include the specific
evidence for exclusions, such as shared author, shared lab, shared center,
or missing metadata.
4. **Extract citation context.**
- Prefer full text: PubMed Central JATS, ScienceDirect metadata/full text,
publisher HTML, or legally available PDF text.
- If publisher HTML needs JavaScript or the text is in a PDF, see
[Publisher pages and PDF text](../../static/core/routing-and-ops.md#publisher-pages-and-pdf-text-optional).
- Locate the target reference in the bibliography, map it to in-text citation
markers (numeric or author-year), then extract the citing sentence plus one
adjacent sentence before/after when available.
- If only abstract/metadata is available, set `citation_context:
unavailable` and do not infer wording from title similarity.
- Preserve exact citation-context snippets only when short; otherwise
paraphrase and identify where the citation appeared.
5. **Identify high-profile independent citers.**
- Run this step only on `confirmed_strict_other_citation` and
`probable_external_citation` papers unless the user asks for all citing
papers.
- Check identity evidence in this order:
1. official university, academy, government, funding-agency, or learned
society pages;
2. official fellow/member lists, talent-program lists, editorial-board
pages, or institutional appointment announcements;
3. stable researcher profiles such as ORCID, Scopus, Semantic Scholar, or
Google Scholar;
4. news, personal pages, or third-party biographies only as secondary
support.
- Recognized profile signals include academy member / 院士, university
president or vice president, dean or department chair, national talent
awards such as 杰青 / 长江学者 / 优青, society fellow status such as IEEE
Fellow / AAAS Fellow / RSC Fellow / ASCE Fellow, highly cited researcher
status, major editor roles, or clearly field-leading citation/profile
evidence.
- Disambiguate names using affiliation, field, ORCID/author IDs, coauthors,
and publication topics. If the evidence does not identify the same person,
mark the profile `unverified`.
6. **Assess how the target paper was cited.**
- Classify citation function as one or more of:
`background_support`, `method_used`, `data_or_code_used`,
`benchmark_or_comparison`, `direct_extension`, `replication_or_validation`,
`limitation_or_critique`, `review_summary`, or `incidental_mention`.
- Classify stance as `positive`, `neutral`, `critical`, `mixed`, or
`not_assessable`.
- Explain the classification from the citation context. Do not infer praise
merely from the fact that the paper was cited.
7. **Generate the audit report.**
- Start with coverage and limitations.
- Separate high-profile independent citers from ordinary citing papers.
- Keep every identity claim tied to evidence. Unsupported "大牛" labels are
not allowed.
## Article Summary Table Mode
Use this compact mode when the user asks to organize one or more specified
papers into a table, especially when they ask for fields such as article title,
publication date, authors, affiliations, citation count, strict other-citation
count, and DOI.
### Required fields
For each specified paper, return a table with these columns unless the user asks
for a different schema:
| Column | Required handling |
|---|---|
| `Article title` | Use the resolved title from DOI/PMID/arXiv/publisher metadata. If multiple records match, ask for confirmation before counting citations. |
| `Publication date` | Prefer full date (`YYYY-MM-DD`); otherwise use year/month or year and mark the precision. |
| `Authors` | List all authors when the list is short; for long author lists, list first 6 + `et al.` and state that the full author list is available. |
| `Author affiliations` | Preserve author-affiliation mapping when metadata provides it. If only institution-level metadata is available, summarize distinct affiliations and mark mapping precision. |
| `Citation count` | Use the best available citation-count source and name it in an evidence note. Do not merge counts from different databases as if they are identical. |
| `Strict other-citation count` | Count only records classified as `confirmed_strict_other_citation`. Optionally report `probable_external_citation` separately in a note, not inside the strict count. |
| `DOI` | Normalize DOI casing/prefix; use `not_found` only after checking title and ID-based lookup routes. |
### Counting rules
1. Resolve the target paper first; do not count citations against an ambiguous
title match.
2. Retrieve citing records as in the main procedure, deduplicate them, then
classify strict other-citation status.
3. Set `Citation count` to one source-specific count, preferably Scopus, Web of
Science, Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, or publisher/CrossRef in that order when
available. If multiple counts are available, include them in `Evidence /
notes` instead of collapsing them.
4. Set `Strict other-citation count` to the number of deduplicated citing papers
with label `confirmed_strict_other_citation`.
5. If the audit cannot inspect enough metadata to classify strict independence,
use `not_assessable` for the strict count and state the missing sources.
6. For batches, keep one row per target paper and put source limitations in a
short notes column or a separate evidence section.
### Table format
```markdown
| Article title | Publication date | Authors | Author affiliations | Citation count | Strict other-citation count | DOI | Evidence / notes |
|---|---|---|---|---:|---:|---|---|
| | | | | | | | |
```
For Chinese outputs, use this header:
```markdown
| 文章名 | 发表时间 | 作者名 | 作者机构 | 引用数 | 严格他引数 | DOI | 证据 / 备注 |
|---|---|---|---|---:|---:|---|---|
| | | | | | | | |
```
Always include a short source note after the table:
```text
计数来源:
- 引用数来源:
- 严格他引判定来源:
- 未覆盖或无法访问的来源:
```
## Output Format
```text
Strict other-citation impact audit
Target paper
- Title:
- DOI / PMID / arXiv:
- Year / venue:
- Target authors checked:
Coverage
- Citation sources checked:
- Full-text sources checked:
- Identity sources checked:
- Known limitations:
Citation classification summary
- total citing records retrieved:
- deduplicated citing papers:
- confirmed strict other-citations:
- probable external citations:
- self/team citations:
- collaborator or affiliation-overlap citations:
- unknown metadata:
High-profile independent citers
1. [Name]
- Citing paper:
- Strict other-citation status:
- Profile signals:
- Identity evidence:
- Citation context:
- How they used the target paper:
- Stance:
- Confidence:
All citing-paper classifications
| Citing paper | Year | Citer(s) flagged | Strict-status label | Citation context available | Citation function | Notes |
|---|---:|---|---|---|---|---|
Evidence gaps / next checks
- [missing source, paywalled full text, ambiguous author identity, incomplete affiliation metadata]
```
## Red Lines
- Do not call someone an academy member, fellow, dean, president, 杰青, 长江学者,
or similar without evidence for the same person.
- Do not treat same-name matches as identity matches without affiliation or
author-ID support.
- Do not treat citation count or h-index alone as proof that the citer is a
"大牛"; present it as bibliometric context only.
- Do not infer citation context from abstracts, titles, or reference-list
presence when full text is unavailable.
- Do not hide source coverage limits. If Scopus/WoS/Semantic Scholar/OpenAlex
are unavailable or incomplete, say so before reporting counts.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| rea-analysis-optimizationmorluto/reaOptimize REA providers and shared analysis workflows for agent context, latency, CPU, and memory while preserving correctness and Evidence. Use for analysis bottlenecks and cache or query design; CI/test-suite optimization belongs to rea-ci-tests-audit. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| rea-ci-tests-auditmorluto/reaAudit REA CI and test suites for correctness, fixture drift, false passes, and measured performance; use for suite or workflow investigations and efficiency changes, rather than ordinary feature testing or a single test failure. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| rea-tool-designmorluto/reaAudit, investigate, design, or change REA investigation tools, CLI/MCP contracts, provider capabilities, and Evidence semantics. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-auditDietrichGebert/ponytailQuality audit of the whole repo: bugs, security, real load, missing tests, speed, and what to delete. Most important first. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |