ThomasMoreAI/legal-skills-open / au/general/skills/legal-writing-mblauberg
legal-writing-mblauberg
VerifiedUse for drafting, reviewing, condensing, or source-checking Australian legal documents (forms, affidavits, submissions and orders), legal decision overviews, or correspondence. Not for academic, engineering, or general prose; use its specialist.
references/tribunals-and-merits-review.md
View on GitHub# Tribunals And Merits Review
Use this reference when the forum is an Australian tribunal rather than a court:
the Commonwealth merits review body and the state and territory civil and
administrative tribunals. Load `forum-and-document-recipes.md` for the forum
adapter and document functions, and `argument-structure-and-paragraphing.md` for
the argument itself. This file supplies no current law, jurisdiction map, form
or time limit.
## Identify The Body, The Division And The Enabling Act
A tribunal's name is not enough to fix its procedure. Record:
- the tribunal, and the division, list or stream that hears this matter;
- the enabling Act that gives the tribunal its power, and the substantive Act
under which the original decision was made;
- whether the matter is an original application, an internal review, an external
review of an agency decision, or an appeal within the tribunal;
- the time limit for starting, and whether an extension is available;
- whether an internal review or other precondition must happen first;
- the tribunal's rules, practice notes and directions for this list; and
- costs, representation and evidence rules for that division, which often differ
from the tribunal's general position.
Divisional practice notes govern much of the operative procedure. Verify them
against the tribunal's official pages, and record the date checked.
## What Changes Compared With A Court
| Feature | Usual tribunal position | Drafting consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence | Not bound by the rules of evidence, but must act fairly and on logically probative material | Still anchor every fact to a source; do not treat relaxed rules as permission to assert |
| Register | Plainer, less ceremonial | Write for a member who wants the criteria addressed, not for a set-piece address |
| Representation | Often needs leave, and many parties are self-represented | Keep language accessible and avoid tactical drafting that punishes an unrepresented party |
| Costs | Frequently each party bears their own, though enabling Acts in areas such as planning, tenancy and retail leases often displace that default | Do not import court costs assumptions or threats |
| Reasons | The original decision-maker may owe a statement of reasons, but the duty, its exemptions and its time limits are statute-specific | Use the reasons as the map of what must be answered |
| Outcome | The decision may be affirmed, varied, set aside, substituted or remitted | Ask only for a disposition the tribunal has power to make |
## Merits Review Posture
Merits review asks what the correct or preferable decision is on the material
before the tribunal. That is not the same as showing that the original
decision-maker erred.
- Address the statutory criteria the decision-maker had to apply, criterion by
criterion. Use them as headings where the list permits.
- Identify the date at which the facts are assessed, and whether material that
post-dates the original decision may be considered; this is scheme-specific,
and some statutory schemes confine the assessment to the date of the primary
decision.
- Distinguish a finding of fact, an exercise of discretion and a jurisdictional
precondition, and argue each in its own terms.
- Do not argue judicial review grounds in a merits review, and do not argue
merits in a judicial review application. Where a genuine legal error matters,
name it specifically and obtain qualified review of the jurisdictional route
before relying on it.
- Where the tribunal has no power to give the outcome sought, say so and
identify the forum that can.
## The Document Set
| Document | Function |
|---|---|
| Application or notice of appeal | Starts the matter, fixes the decision under review and the outcome sought |
| Agency material or decision bundle | The record the review runs on; paginate and cite it as the tribunal directs |
| Statement of facts and contentions, or points of claim and defence | Separates the facts asserted from the contentions argued; the name varies between merits-review and civil-list streams |
| Witness statements | Evidence in the tribunal's preferred form for that list |
| Expert report | Only where the list permits it and the code of conduct is complied with |
| Outline of submissions | Applies the criteria to the material and asks for a specific disposition |
| Draft orders or directions | States the disposition sought in operative terms |
Keep facts in the facts document and argument in the contentions or submissions.
A statement of facts and contentions that blends the two invites the other side
to dispute the whole document.
## Drafting For A Tribunal Member
- Lead with the outcome sought and the criteria in issue.
- Number paragraphs and keep one proposition each.
- Give exact page or paragraph pinpoints into the bundle, using the tribunal's
pagination.
- Address the agency's or respondent's stated reasons directly, rather than
restating the client's history.
- Concede what should be conceded early, then narrow to what is genuinely in
dispute.
- Keep the register plain. Ceremonial advocacy reads worse in a tribunal than in
a court, and it hides the criteria.
## After The Decision
Appeal routes from tribunals are narrow and body-specific. Some allow an
internal appeal on fact and law, others allow an appeal to a court on a question
of law only, and time limits are short. Verify the route, the time limit and the
correct court from current official sources, and obtain qualified review before
advising on it.
## Completion Gate
Confirm the division's rules, practice notes and directions, confirm the
document names and forms the list uses, check pinpoints against the tribunal's
own pagination, confirm the disposition sought is within power, and keep filing
and service as separately authorised acts.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| receiving-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when receiving code review feedback, before implementing suggestions, especially if feedback seems unclear or technically questionable - requires technical rigor and verification, not performative agreement or blind implementation | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| requesting-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when completing tasks, implementing major features, or before merging to verify work meets requirements | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| using-git-worktreesobra/superpowersUse when starting feature work that needs isolation from current workspace or before executing implementation plans - ensures an isolated workspace exists via native tools or git worktree fallback | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| verification-before-completionobra/superpowersUse when about to claim work is complete, fixed, or passing, before committing or creating PRs - requires running verification commands and confirming output before making any success claims; evidence before assertions always | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |