Skip to content

thatrebeccarae/claude-marketing / skills/account-structure-review

account-structure-review

Verified

Google and Meta paid media account structure evaluation. Audits campaign/ad set architecture against conversion volume minimums, budget thresholds, and targeting overlap. Identifies over-segmentation, under-segmentation, budget fragmentation, and structural anti-patterns blocking algorithmic learning. Provides consolidation roadmaps with migration plans. Use when inheriting accounts, quarterly health checks, or before scaling budgets.

FileKindSize
EXAMPLES.mdmarkdown35.8 KB
LICENSEother1.0 KB
REFERENCE.mdmarkdown24.9 KB
SKILL.mdskill md23.4 KB

EXAMPLES.md

View on GitHub
# Account Structure Review — Examples

Six realistic examples demonstrating how to use the account structure review skill across different scenarios, budgets, and platforms.

---

## Example 1: Mid-Market DTC Account Audit ($30K/mo)

### User Request

"I just inherited a DTC skincare account spending $30K/month across Google and Meta. The previous agency had 40+ campaigns running. Performance has been declining for 3 months — CPAs are up 35% and ROAS is down. Audit the structure and give me a consolidation plan."

### Analysis Steps

1. **Inventory all campaigns** — List every campaign across both platforms with type, objective, bid strategy, daily budget, and last-30-day conversions.
2. **Run conversion volume audit** — Compare each campaign's conversions against minimum thresholds for its bid strategy (Google) or optimization goal (Meta). Flag under-volume campaigns.
3. **Run budget fragmentation audit** — Check daily budgets against minimums. Identify campaigns exhausting budget before 3 PM.
4. **Run targeting overlap audit** — Pull Google Search Terms Report to find cross-campaign cannibalization. Run Meta Audience Overlap tool on all prospecting audiences.
5. **Build consolidation plan** — Group campaigns by merge candidates, pause candidates, and restructure candidates. Design migration roadmap.

### Sample Output

```markdown
# Account Structure Review — [Skincare DTC Brand] — 2026-03-11

## Executive Summary
- **Total monthly spend**: $30,000 ($15K Google, $15K Meta)
- **Total campaigns**: 42 (Google: 28, Meta: 14)
- **Campaigns flagged**: 34 (81% of total)
- **Primary issues**: (1) Severe over-segmentation on Google Search — 28 campaigns averaging $18/day each; (2) 10 Meta prospecting campaigns with 35-60% audience overlap; (3) PMax + Standard Shopping running simultaneously
- **Recommended consolidation**: 42 campaigns → 11 campaigns
- **Expected impact**: CPA reduction of 20-30% within 30 days as campaigns exit learning phase

## Structural Health Score: 28/100
- Conversion volume: 6/30 (only 8 of 42 campaigns meet minimum thresholds)
- Budget allocation: 5/25 (26 campaigns below minimum daily budget)
- Targeting efficiency: 8/25 (critical overlap on both platforms)
- Objective alignment: 9/20 (3 Google campaigns on Maximize Clicks with conversion tracking active)

## Google Ads Findings

### Campaign Inventory
| Campaign Name | Type | Bid Strategy | Daily Budget | Monthly Conv. | Flag |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand - Exact | Search | tCPA | $40 | 85 | OK |
| Brand - Broad | Search | tCPA | $25 | 42 | OK |
| Category - Moisturizer | Search | tCPA | $18 | 12 | Under-Volume |
| Category - Serum | Search | tCPA | $18 | 8 | Under-Volume |
| Category - Cleanser | Search | tCPA | $15 | 6 | Under-Volume, Under-Budget |
| Category - SPF | Search | tCPA | $12 | 4 | Under-Volume, Under-Budget |
| Category - Toner | Search | tCPA | $10 | 2 | Under-Volume, Under-Budget |
| Product - Vitamin C Serum | Search | MaxClicks | $15 | 3 | Objective Mismatch |
| Product - Retinol Cream | Search | MaxClicks | $12 | 2 | Objective Mismatch |
| Product - HA Moisturizer | Search | MaxClicks | $10 | 1 | Objective Mismatch |
| ... (18 more product-level campaigns) | Search | Various | $5-15 | 0-3 | Under-Volume, Under-Budget |
| PMax - All Products | PMax | MaxConv | $80 | 35 | OK |
| Standard Shopping | Shopping | ManualCPC | $30 | 4 | Cannibalized by PMax |
| Display - Retargeting | Display | MaxConv | $25 | 8 | Under-Budget |

### Issues Identified
1. **Over-Segmentation (Search)** — 28 Search campaigns averaging $18/day and 8 conversions/month. 22 campaigns are below the 30/month minimum for tCPA optimization. Campaigns perpetually re-enter learning, driving CPAs up 35%.
   - **Impact**: Algorithm never stabilizes. Each bid change or ad rotation resets learning on campaigns that were never out of learning to begin with.
   - **Recommendation**: Merge 28 Search campaigns into 6: Brand, Competitor, Category (Skincare), Category (SPF/Sun), Generic (Skin Concerns), Product (Top 5 SKUs).

2. **Budget Fragmentation** — 15 campaigns have daily budgets under $20. These exhaust by 10 AM, missing afternoon and evening shoppers entirely.
   - **Impact**: Missing 60% of daily shopping window. Algorithm front-loads impressions into early morning when competition is highest.
   - **Recommendation**: Consolidation fixes this automatically — 6 campaigns at $60-100/day each.

3. **PMax Cannibalization** — Standard Shopping campaign getting <5% of eligible impressions. PMax is capturing all Shopping traffic. Standard Shopping generated 4 conversions vs PMax's 35.
   - **Impact**: $30/day ($900/month) wasted on a campaign that can't compete for impressions.
   - **Recommendation**: Pause Standard Shopping immediately. Increase PMax budget from $80/day to $120/day.

4. **Objective Mismatch** — 3 product-level campaigns using Maximize Clicks despite active conversion tracking.
   - **Impact**: Paying for clicks instead of optimizing for purchases. These campaigns have the worst CPA in the account ($85 vs $22 average).
   - **Recommendation**: Merge into consolidated Category campaigns with tCPA bidding.

### Google Consolidation Plan
- **Merge**: 28 Search campaigns → 6 campaigns (Brand $65/day, Competitor $50/day, Category Skincare $100/day, Category SPF $60/day, Generic $60/day, Product Top SKUs $45/day)
- **Pause**: Standard Shopping (cannibalized by PMax)
- **Restructure**: PMax — increase budget from $80/day to $120/day, add brand negatives
- **Resulting structure**: 6 Search + 1 PMax + 1 Display Retargeting = 8 campaigns

## Meta Findings

### Campaign Inventory
| Campaign Name | Objective | Budget Type | Daily Budget | Weekly Conv. | Overlap % | Flag |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prospecting - LAL 1% | Sales | ABO | $50 | 18 | 65% (w/ LAL 2-3%) | Overlap |
| Prospecting - LAL 2-3% | Sales | ABO | $50 | 12 | 65% (w/ LAL 1%) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - Interest Skincare | Sales | ABO | $40 | 8 | 45% (w/ LAL 1%) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - Interest Beauty | Sales | ABO | $35 | 6 | 52% (w/ Skincare) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - Interest Anti-Aging | Sales | ABO | $30 | 4 | 38% (w/ Skincare) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - Broad | Sales | ABO | $25 | 3 | N/A | Under-Volume, Under-Budget |
| Prospecting - LAL Purchasers | Sales | ABO | $30 | 5 | 70% (w/ LAL 1%) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - LAL ATC | Sales | ABO | $25 | 3 | 55% (w/ LAL 1%) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - LAL Email | Sales | ABO | $20 | 2 | 48% (w/ LAL 1%) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Prospecting - Cold Video | Sales | ABO | $15 | 1 | N/A | Under-Volume, Under-Budget |
| Retargeting - Website 30d | Sales | ABO | $80 | 25 | N/A | OK |
| Retargeting - Cart Abandon | Sales | ABO | $40 | 15 | N/A | OK |
| Retargeting - DPA | Sales | ABO | $30 | 10 | N/A | Under-Volume |
| Retargeting - Email List | Sales | ABO | $30 | 8 | N/A | Under-Volume |

### Issues Identified
1. **Targeting Overlap (Critical)** — 10 prospecting campaigns with 35-70% audience overlap. Lookalike 1% and Lookalike Purchasers have 70% overlap — effectively the same audience in two campaigns.
   - **Impact**: Bidding against yourself in 35-70% of auctions. Inflated CPMs, fragmented data, no campaign has enough volume to optimize.
   - **Recommendation**: Consolidate 10 prospecting campaigns into 1 Advantage+ Shopping campaign.

2. **Under-Volume** — 8 of 10 prospecting campaigns have <50 purchases/week. None can exit learning phase.
   - **Impact**: All 8 are in "learning limited" status. CPAs 40% above the 2 campaigns that have sufficient volume.
   - **Recommendation**: Consolidation into Advantage+ solves this — projected 60+ purchases/week from combined budget.

### Meta Consolidation Plan
- **Merge**: 10 prospecting campaigns → 1 Advantage+ Shopping campaign ($320/day)
- **Merge**: 4 retargeting campaigns → 1 Retargeting CBO campaign ($180/day, 3 ad sets: Website 7-30d, Cart Abandoners 7d, Engaged Users 30d)
- **Resulting structure**: 2 campaigns total (Advantage+, Retargeting CBO)

## Migration Roadmap

### Phase 1 (Week 1-2): Immediate Actions
- **Launch**: 6 consolidated Google Search campaigns at 25% budget ($95/day total)
- **Launch**: 1 Advantage+ Shopping campaign at $160/day (50% of prospecting budget)
- **Launch**: 1 Retargeting CBO campaign at $90/day (50% of retargeting budget)
- **Reduce**: Old Google Search campaigns to 75% budget
- **Reduce**: Old Meta prospecting campaigns to 50% budget
- **Pause**: Standard Shopping campaign immediately

### Phase 2 (Week 3-4): Performance Validation
- **Monitor**: New campaigns for learning phase completion (expect by day 10-14)
- **Compare**: New vs old CPA at 50/50 budget split
- **If new campaigns within 15% of old CPA**: Shift to 75% new / 25% old

### Phase 3 (Week 5-6): Full Migration
- **Shift**: 100% budget to new structure
- **Pause**: All old campaigns (do NOT delete)
- **Archive**: Export 12 months of historical data from old campaigns
- **Final structure**: 8 Google campaigns + 2 Meta campaigns = 10 total (down from 42)

## Expected Outcomes
- **Learning phase stability**: All 10 campaigns will have sufficient volume to exit and stay out of learning
- **Budget efficiency**: Every campaign will sustain full-day delivery with budgets above platform minimums
- **CPA improvement**: Projected 20-30% CPA reduction within 30 days
- **Reporting clarity**: 10 campaigns instead of 42 makes weekly performance reviews actionable

## Risks & Mitigations
| Risk | Likelihood | Impact | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance dip during learning phase | High | Medium | Gradual 50/50 migration over 4 weeks |
| Advantage+ underperforms manual prospecting | Low | High | Keep $50/day manual prospecting campaign as hedge for 30 days |
| Loss of audience-level insights | Medium | Low | Use Meta breakdown dimensions (age, gender, placement) for insights |
```

---

## Example 2: Startup Account Structure Design ($5K/mo)

### User Request

"We're launching paid media for a B2B SaaS startup. Budget is $5K/month total across Google and Meta. We need a structure that maximizes learning with minimal budget. What campaigns should we set up and how should we allocate budget?"

### Analysis Steps

1. **Determine platform split** — Assess whether Google or Meta (or both) is appropriate for B2B SaaS at $5K/month.
2. **Apply minimum viable structure** — Use the $5K/month tier guidelines, adjusted for B2B SaaS (leads, not purchases).
3. **Calculate conversion volume feasibility** — At $5K/month, estimate CPL and check if campaigns can hit minimum thresholds.
4. **Design campaign architecture** — Specify campaigns, ad groups/ad sets, targeting, and budget allocation.

### Sample Output

```markdown
# Account Structure Design — [B2B SaaS Startup] — 2026-03-11

## Executive Summary
- **Total monthly budget**: $5,000 ($3,000 Google, $2,000 Meta)
- **Recommended structure**: 5 campaigns total (Google: 3, Meta: 2)
- **Primary constraint**: At $167/day total, every campaign must justify its existence. Zero room for experimentation campaigns or audience testing — that comes at $10K+/month.
- **Expected monthly leads**: 50-80 (assuming $65-100 CPL for B2B SaaS)

## Structural Health Score: N/A (new account — baseline)

## Google Ads Structure ($3,000/month, $100/day)

### Recommended Campaigns
| Campaign | Type | Bid Strategy | Daily Budget | Expected Monthly Conv. | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand Search | Search | Maximize Conversions | $20/day | 15-20 | Protect branded terms, lowest CPL. Even at launch, competitors may bid on your brand. |
| Category Search | Search | Maximize Conversions | $60/day | 20-30 | Core demand capture. 2-3 ad groups by problem/solution theme, 8-12 keywords each, phrase + broad match. |
| Display Retargeting | Display | Maximize Conversions | $20/day | 5-10 | Website visitors only. Don't run Display Prospecting at this budget — CPLs are too high. |

### Why NOT PMax at $5K/month
PMax minimum viable budget is $100/day. At $20/day (what's left after Search and Retargeting), PMax can't test across its 6 channels. It will default to Display and Gmail — the lowest-quality placements. Use Search for demand capture, skip PMax until budget hits $10K+/month.

### Why NOT Competitor Search
At $5K/month, Competitor Search CPCs ($15-30 for B2B SaaS) will consume budget without enough volume to optimize. Defer until budget doubles.

## Meta Ads Structure ($2,000/month, $67/day)

### Recommended Campaigns
| Campaign | Objective | Budget Type | Daily Budget | Expected Weekly Conv. | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prospecting | Leads | CBO | $47/day | 5-8 | 2 ad sets: Advantage+ Audience with job title signals, Lookalike 1% of email list. Lead form or landing page. |
| Retargeting | Leads | ABO | $20/day | 3-5 | 1 ad set: Website visitors 180d + LinkedIn profile visitors (if using CAPI partner). |

### Critical Constraints
- At $47/day CBO with Leads optimization, you need 10+ leads/week per ad set to exit learning. If you're getting 5-8 across 2 ad sets, one will starve. Start with 1 ad set and add the second when you hit 15+ leads/week.
- Do NOT optimize for Purchase or ATC — you're B2B SaaS, optimize for Lead (form fill, demo request, or trial signup).
- Advantage+ Shopping is not appropriate for B2B lead gen.

## Migration Roadmap

### Week 1-2: Launch
- Launch Brand Search + Category Search on Google
- Launch Prospecting (1 ad set only) + Retargeting on Meta
- Install conversion tracking: Google Ads tag + Meta pixel + CAPI for lead events

### Week 3-4: Optimize
- Review Search Terms Report — add negatives aggressively
- If Meta prospecting hits 10+ leads/week: add second ad set
- If any campaign has zero conversions by day 14: pause and reallocate budget

### Month 2+: Scale Decisions
- If CPL <$80 and lead quality is good: increase budget to $7.5K/month, add second Category Search campaign
- If CPL >$120: narrow targeting, improve landing page, or reduce to Google-only

## Expected Outcomes
- **Month 1**: 30-50 leads at $100-170 CPL (learning phase, expect higher costs)
- **Month 2**: 50-80 leads at $65-100 CPL (campaigns exit learning, costs stabilize)
- **Month 3+**: Optimize toward 80-120 leads at $40-65 CPL as algorithms learn
```

---

## Example 3: Budget Scaling Assessment ($20K to $50K/mo)

### User Request

"We're scaling our DTC brand from $20K/month to $50K/month on Google and Meta. Current structure is 5 Google campaigns and 3 Meta campaigns. Is our structure ready for 2.5x budget, or do we need to restructure before scaling?"

### Analysis Steps

1. **Audit current structure at $20K** — Verify campaigns meet volume and budget thresholds at current spend.
2. **Model structure at $50K** — Project conversion volumes and daily budgets at 2.5x. Identify campaigns that will benefit vs campaigns that will waste incremental budget.
3. **Identify structural gaps** — Determine what new campaigns are needed at $50K that aren't needed at $20K.
4. **Build scaling plan** — Sequence the budget increase with structural changes.

### Sample Output

```markdown
# Budget Scaling Assessment — [DTC Brand] — 2026-03-11

## Executive Summary
- **Current spend**: $20,000/month (Google: $12K, Meta: $8K)
- **Target spend**: $50,000/month (Google: $25K, Meta: $25K)
- **Current structure**: 8 campaigns (Google: 5, Meta: 3) — structurally sound at $20K
- **Scaling readiness**: PARTIAL — Google structure can absorb 2x, but Meta needs 2 additional campaigns before scaling past $30K
- **Recommended pre-scale changes**: Add 1 Advantage+ Shopping campaign (Meta), add 1 YouTube Prospecting campaign (Google), split Category Search into 2 campaigns by product line

## Structural Health Score: 72/100 (at current $20K spend)
- Conversion volume: 24/30 (all but 1 campaign meet thresholds)
- Budget allocation: 20/25 (Display Retargeting slightly under minimum)
- Targeting efficiency: 16/25 (moderate overlap between prospecting audiences on Meta)
- Objective alignment: 12/20 (1 campaign misaligned — Maximize Clicks on Competitor Search)

## Scaling Readiness by Campaign

### Google Ads — Current Structure
| Campaign | Daily Budget Now | Conv/Month Now | Daily Budget at $50K | Projected Conv/Month | Scaling Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand Search | $100 | 120 | $150 | 160 | LOW — Brand has ceiling, diminishing returns past $150/day |
| Competitor Search | $100 | 25 | $150 | 35 | MEDIUM — Switch from MaxClicks to tCPA before scaling |
| Category Search | $150 | 45 | $300 | 80 | MEDIUM — Split into 2 campaigns at $150/day each for better ad group control |
| PMax | $200 | 55 | $400 | 100 | LOW — PMax scales well, more budget = more asset group testing |
| Display Retargeting | $50 | 15 | $100 | 25 | LOW — Retargeting pool grows with prospecting spend |

### Meta Ads — Current Structure
| Campaign | Daily Budget Now | Conv/Week Now | Daily Budget at $50K | Projected Conv/Week | Scaling Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prospecting CBO | $400 | 55 | $500 | 65 | HIGH — Adding $100/day to existing audiences hits diminishing returns. Need Advantage+ to absorb incremental. |
| Retargeting CBO | $150 | 35 | $200 | 45 | LOW — Retargeting pool grows naturally with more prospecting spend |
| Creative Testing | $117 | 15 | $150 | 20 | LOW — Testing budget should scale proportionally |

### Structural Changes Needed Before Scaling

1. **Add Advantage+ Shopping campaign (Meta)** — At $50K, Meta gets $25K/month ($833/day). Current Prospecting CBO can't absorb $500+/day efficiently — audience frequency will spike. Launch Advantage+ at $400/day to absorb incremental budget. Requires 50+ purchases/week (currently at 55, so threshold is met).

2. **Add YouTube Prospecting (Google)** — At $25K/month Google, there's room for upper-funnel investment. YouTube Prospecting at $100/day builds awareness and feeds Search/PMax retargeting pools.

3. **Split Category Search** — At $300/day, one Category Search campaign with 5 ad groups becomes unwieldy. Split into Category A ($150/day, 3 ad groups) and Category B ($150/day, 2 ad groups) for better budget control.

4. **Fix Competitor Search bid strategy** — Switch from Maximize Clicks to tCPA before scaling. At $150/day with MaxClicks, you're paying for traffic without optimizing for conversions.

## Scaling Roadmap

### Week 1-2: Pre-Scale Restructure (stay at $20K)
- Split Category Search into 2 campaigns
- Switch Competitor Search to tCPA
- Launch Advantage+ Shopping at $100/day (funded by reducing Prospecting CBO to $300/day)
- Let new campaigns exit learning phase

### Week 3-4: Scale to $35K
- Increase Google to $18K/month: PMax +$100/day, YouTube Prospecting launch at $100/day, remaining across Search
- Increase Meta to $17K/month: Advantage+ to $250/day, Prospecting CBO to $350/day, Retargeting to $167/day

### Week 5-8: Scale to $50K
- Increase Google to $25K/month: distribute evenly across campaigns
- Increase Meta to $25K/month: Advantage+ to $400/day, Prospecting CBO to $200/day, Retargeting to $200/day, Testing to $150/day
- Final structure: 8 Google campaigns + 4 Meta campaigns = 12 total

## Expected Outcomes
- **At $50K**: 250-350 monthly conversions (up from 120-150 at $20K)
- **Blended CPA**: $145-200 (vs $130-170 currently — expect 10-15% CPA increase at higher scale due to broader audience reach)
- **Efficiency ratio**: 2.5x budget should yield 1.7-2.3x conversions (diminishing returns are normal at scale)
```

---

## Example 4: Google PMax Cannibalization Review

### User Request

"We're running PMax, Standard Shopping, and Brand Search simultaneously. Our Brand Search CPA has doubled in the last 60 days and Shopping impressions dropped 80%. Is PMax cannibalizing everything? Should we kill it or restructure?"

### Analysis Steps

1. **Pull impression share data** — Compare Brand Search and Shopping impression share before and after PMax launch.
2. **Analyze PMax search terms** — Check Insights tab for branded queries appearing in PMax.
3. **Compare CPA trends** — Plot Brand Search CPA, Shopping CPA, and PMax CPA on the same timeline.
4. **Model scenarios** — What happens if you pause PMax, add brand negatives to PMax, or pause Shopping.

### Sample Output

```markdown
# PMax Cannibalization Review — [Brand] — 2026-03-11

## Executive Summary
- **Diagnosis**: PMax is cannibalizing both Brand Search and Standard Shopping. 65% of PMax conversions are from branded queries (Insights tab). Standard Shopping impression share dropped from 45% to 8% since PMax launch.
- **Root cause**: No brand negatives in PMax. PMax prioritizes easy wins (branded queries) to hit its Maximize Conversions target.
- **Recommended action**: Add brand term negatives to PMax + pause Standard Shopping. This is not optional — it's the only path to clean data.

## Structural Health Score: 45/100
- Conversion volume: 20/30 (all campaigns have volume, but it's the wrong volume)
- Budget allocation: 18/25 (budgets are adequate)
- Targeting efficiency: 2/25 (critical cannibalization across all 3 campaigns)
- Objective alignment: 5/20 (PMax is optimizing for branded conversions it's stealing from Brand Search)

## Cannibalization Evidence

### Impression Share Timeline
| Campaign | 90 Days Ago | 60 Days Ago | 30 Days Ago | Today |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand Search IS | 92% | 78% | 61% | 55% |
| Standard Shopping IS | 45% | 28% | 12% | 8% |
| PMax (estimated) | 15% | 35% | 52% | 68% |

### CPA Trend
| Campaign | 90 Days Ago | Today | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand Search | $8 | $16 | +100% |
| Standard Shopping | $22 | $45 | +105% |
| PMax | $18 | $15 | -17% |
| Blended | $14 | $18 | +29% |

PMax CPA looks great in isolation — but it's artificially low because 65% of its conversions are branded queries that Brand Search was capturing at $8 CPA. PMax is claiming credit for conversions that would have happened anyway.

### PMax Search Terms Breakdown (from Insights)
- Branded queries: 65% of PMax conversions
- Category queries: 20% of PMax conversions
- Product queries: 10% of PMax conversions
- Discovery/Display: 5% of PMax conversions

## Consolidation Plan

### Immediate Actions (This Week)
1. **Add brand negatives to PMax** — Submit all brand terms, brand misspellings, and brand + product combinations as account-level negatives for PMax (requires Google rep or API access as of 2026).
2. **Pause Standard Shopping** — PMax has fully absorbed Shopping traffic. Standard Shopping at 8% impression share is a reporting artifact, not a real campaign.
3. **Monitor Brand Search** — After brand negatives are applied to PMax, Brand Search impression share should recover to 85-90% within 7-10 days.

### Expected Post-Fix Performance
| Campaign | Projected CPA | Projected Monthly Conv. |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Search | $9-10 (recovery from $16) | 150 (recovery from 90) |
| PMax (non-brand only) | $28-35 (true non-brand CPA) | 60-80 |
| Blended | $15-18 (improvement from $18) | 210-230 |

### Key Insight
PMax's "true" non-brand CPA is $28-35, not the $15 it's reporting. Once you strip out branded conversions, evaluate PMax on its non-brand performance only. If $28-35 CPA is acceptable for non-brand acquisition, keep PMax. If not, consider replacing with manual Shopping + Display Prospecting.

## Risks & Mitigations
| Risk | Mitigation |
|---|---|
| PMax performance drops after brand negatives | Expected — the $15 CPA was inflated by brand. True non-brand CPA of $28-35 is the real benchmark. |
| Brand Search doesn't recover impression share | Check that brand negatives are actually applied in PMax. Also check if competitors are now bidding on your brand. |
| Losing Shopping traffic after pausing Standard | PMax covers Shopping placements. If PMax Shopping performance is poor, launch a new Standard Shopping campaign without PMax running. |
```

---

## Example 5: Meta Audience Overlap Diagnosis

### User Request

"We have 10 prospecting campaigns on Meta, all optimizing for purchases. CPMs have been climbing for 3 months and CPAs are up 45%. I think we're bidding against ourselves. Can you diagnose the overlap and give me a consolidation plan?"

### Analysis Steps

1. **Map all audiences** — List every prospecting campaign with its audience targeting.
2. **Identify overlap pairs** — Determine which audiences are functionally similar.
3. **Quantify the damage** — Calculate estimated CPM inflation from self-competition.
4. **Design consolidated structure** — Reduce to 1-2 prospecting campaigns.

### Sample Output

```markdown
# Meta Audience Overlap Diagnosis — [Brand] — 2026-03-11

## Executive Summary
- **Active prospecting campaigns**: 10, all Sales objective, ABO, optimizing for Purchase
- **Total prospecting budget**: $500/day ($15,000/month)
- **Average audience overlap**: 47% across all campaign pairs (range: 22-78%)
- **Estimated CPM inflation**: 25-35% above market rate due to self-competition
- **Recommended consolidation**: 10 campaigns → 2 campaigns (Advantage+ Shopping + 1 Broad Prospecting)
- **Projected savings**: $3,750-5,250/month in wasted CPM inflation

## Structural Health Score: 32/100
- Conversion volume: 8/30 (8 of 10 campaigns under 50 purchases/week)
- Budget allocation: 10/25 (budgets individually adequate but collectively fragmented)
- Targeting efficiency: 4/25 (critical overlap across all campaigns)
- Objective alignment: 10/20 (correct objective, wrong structure)

## Audience Overlap Matrix

| Campaign | Audience | Budget | Purch/Wk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prospecting 1 | LAL 1% - Purchasers | $60/day | 22 |
| Prospecting 2 | LAL 2-3% - Purchasers | $55/day | 15 |
| Prospecting 3 | LAL 1% - ATC | $50/day | 12 |
| Prospecting 4 | LAL 1% - Email List | $50/day | 10 |
| Prospecting 5 | Interest: Fitness | $50/day | 8 |
| Prospecting 6 | Interest: Wellness | $45/day | 6 |
| Prospecting 7 | Interest: Yoga | $40/day | 5 |
| Prospecting 8 | Interest: Running | $40/day | 4 |
| Prospecting 9 | Broad (no targeting) | $60/day | 18 |
| Prospecting 10 | LAL 5% - Purchasers | $50/day | 3 |

### Critical Overlap Pairs
| Campaign A | Campaign B | Overlap % | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| LAL 1% Purchasers | LAL 2-3% Purchasers | 78% | These are nearly identical audiences. Campaign B is a slightly wider version of Campaign A. |
| LAL 1% Purchasers | LAL 1% ATC | 72% | Purchasers are a subset of ATC users. Seed audiences overlap heavily. |
| LAL 1% Purchasers | LAL 1% Email | 65% | Email list and purchaser list overlap significantly. |
| Interest: Fitness | Interest: Wellness | 58% | Broad interest overlap — Meta's interest graph connects these heavily. |
| Interest: Fitness | Interest: Running | 52% | Running is a subset of Fitness in Meta's taxonomy. |
| Interest: Wellness | Interest: Yoga | 48% | Similar overlap pattern. |
| LAL 1% Purchasers | Broad | 55% | Broad targeting includes your LAL audiences by definition. |
| LAL 5% Purchasers | Broad | 70% | 5% LAL is effectively Broad with a seed signal. Highly redundant. |

### The Math on Self-Competition
- 10 campaigns entering the same auctions means your bid competes against your own bid in ~47% of impressions
- Meta's auction deduplicates (only charges you once), but your effective CPM rises because you're signaling high demand for the same users
- Average CPM across campaigns: $18.50. Estimated market CPM without overlap: $12-14
- **$4-6.50 CPM premium = $3,750-5,250/month in waste** at current spend levels

## Consolidation Plan

### Target Structure: 2 Prospecting Campaigns

**Campaign 1: Advantage+ Shopping ($350/day)**
- Let Advantage+ handle all audience finding
- Feed it your best 8-12 creative assets
- Advantage+ will naturally find the audiences your LAL and interest campaigns were targeting — but without the overlap penalty
- Projected: 65-85 purchases/week (vs 103 combined currently, but at 30% lower CPA)

**Campaign 2: Broad Prospecting ($100/day)**
- 1 ad set, no targeting constraints (Advantage+ Audience with age/gender only)
- Purpose: creative testing and incremental reach beyond Advantage+
- 3-4 ads per ad set, rotate new creative weekly
- Projected: 15-25 purchases/week

**Retargeting stays as-is** — not part of this diagnosis.

### Migration Plan
- **Week 1**: Launch Advantage+ at $175/day (50% of target). Keep all 10 old campaigns at 50% budget.
- **Week 2**: If Advantage+ CPA is within 20% of old blended CPA, increase to $250/day. Pause 5 lowest-performing old campaigns.
- **Week 3**: Increase Advantage+ to $350/day. Pause remaining 5 old campaigns. Launch Broad Prospecting at $100/day.
- **Week 4**: Full new structure. Monitor for learning phase completion.

## Expected Outcomes
- **CPM reduction**: $18.50 → $12-14 (25-35% decrease from eliminating self-competition)
- **CPA improvement**: $55 → $38-42 (25-30% improvement from lower CPMs + better algorithmic learning)
- **Weekly purchases**: 80-110 (vs 103 currently) at significantly lower cost
- **Monthly savings**: $3,750-5,250 in reduced CPM waste
- **Management time**: 2 campaigns to monitor instead of 10
```

---

## Example 6: Quarterly Health Check

### User Request

"Run a quarterly health check on our paid media accounts. We're spending $45K/month across Google ($25K) and Meta ($20K). I want a structural health score, trend analysis vs last quarter, and any action items."

### Analysis Steps

1. **Score current structure** — Apply the 100-point health score methodology across all four dimensions.
2. **Compare to previous quarter** — Identify improvements and regressions.
3. **Flag new issues** — Any structural problems that emerged since last review.
4. **Prioritize action items** — Rank by impact and urgency.
5. **Set targets for next quarter** — Define what "good" looks like in 90 days.

### Sample Output

```markdown
# Quarterly Health Check — [Brand] — Q1 2026

## Executive Summary
- **Total monthly spend**: $45,000 (Google: $25,000, Meta: $20,000)
- **Total campaigns**: 14 (Google: 8, Meta: 6)
- **Structural Health Score**: 71/100 (up from 58 last quarter)
- **Key improvement**: Google Search consolidation from 15 campaigns to 6 (+18 points)
- **Key regression**: Meta prospecting overlap crept back to 32% as new audiences were added (-4 points)
- **Action items**: 3 (1 urgent, 2 scheduled)

## Structural Health Score: 71/100

### Score Breakdown
| Dimension | This Quarter | Last Quarter | Change | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion Volume | 22/30 | 14/30 | +8 | Search consolidation pushed 4 campaigns above threshold |
| Budget Allocation | 20/25 | 16/25 | +4 | Eliminated shared budgets, all campaigns above minimums |
| Targeting Efficiency | 15/25 | 18/25 | -3 | New Meta prospecting audiences introduced 32% overlap |
| Objective Alignment | 14/20 | 10/20 | +4 | Migrated Competitor Search from MaxClicks to tCPA |
| **Total** | **71/100** | **58/100** | **+13** | |

### Trend Analysis
- **Q3 2025**: 42/100 (critical — 35+ campaigns, severe fragmentation)
- **Q4 2025**: 58/100 (improving — Google consolidation Phase 1 complete)
- **Q1 2026**: 71/100 (good — on track for 80+ by Q2 if Meta overlap is resolved)

## Google Ads Health (Score: 42/45)

### Campaign Inventory
| Campaign | Type | Daily Budget | Monthly Conv. | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand Search | Search | $120 | 145 | Healthy |
| Competitor Search | Search | $80 | 32 | Healthy (recently migrated to tCPA) |
| Category - Skincare | Search | $120 | 48 | Healthy |
| Category - Wellness | Search | $100 | 35 | Healthy |
| Generic - Problems | Search | $80 | 22 | Marginal (below 30 ideal for tCPA) |
| PMax | PMax | $250 | 85 | Healthy |
| Display Retargeting | Display | $50 | 18 | Healthy |
| YouTube Prospecting | YouTube | $80 | 12 | Marginal (but awareness goal, volume less critical) |

### Issues
1. **Generic Search volume** — 22 conversions/month is below tCPA ideal of 30. Not urgent — monitor for one more month. If still under 30, consider merging into Category - Skincare.
2. **YouTube Prospecting measurement** — 12 conversions/month is low, but YouTube's role is awareness/consideration. Validate with view-through conversion data and Search lift studies if available.

### No Action Required — Google structure is sound.

## Meta Ads Health (Score: 29/55)

### Campaign Inventory
| Campaign | Objective | Budget Type | Daily Budget | Weekly Conv. | Overlap % | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advantage+ Shopping | Sales | CBO | $300 | 72 | N/A | Healthy |
| Prospecting - LAL | Sales | CBO | $150 | 28 | 32% (w/ Interest) | Overlap |
| Prospecting - Interest | Sales | CBO | $100 | 15 | 32% (w/ LAL) | Overlap, Under-Volume |
| Retargeting - Website | Sales | CBO | $80 | 22 | N/A | Healthy |
| Retargeting - Engaged | Sales | ABO | $30 | 8 | N/A | Under-Volume |
| Creative Testing | Sales | ABO | $40 | 6 | N/A | Testing (expected low volume) |

### Issues
1. **URGENT — Prospecting overlap returned** — LAL and Interest campaigns have 32% overlap. Interest campaign was added in February without checking overlap with existing LAL audience. Interest campaign has only 15 purchases/week (below 50 minimum).
   - **Action**: Merge Interest campaign into LAL campaign as a second ad set, OR pause Interest and increase LAL budget by $100/day.
   - **Timeline**: This week.

2. **Retargeting - Engaged under-volume** — 8 purchases/week from engaged users. This ad set has been under 10 for 3 consecutive months.
   - **Action**: Merge into Retargeting - Website campaign as a second ad set. Combined budget of $110/day with CBO.
   - **Timeline**: Next 2 weeks.

## Action Items (Priority Order)

| # | Action | Platform | Priority | Timeline | Expected Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Merge or pause Interest prospecting campaign | Meta | Urgent | This week | Eliminate 32% audience overlap, reduce CPM by 10-15% |
| 2 | Merge Retargeting - Engaged into Retargeting - Website | Meta | Scheduled | Next 2 weeks | Consolidate under-volume ad set, improve learning |
| 3 | Monitor Generic Search campaign volume | Google | Watch | End of Q2 | If still <30 conv/month, merge into Category |

## Q2 2026 Targets
- **Health Score target**: 80+/100
- **Conversion volume**: 26+/30 (all campaigns above minimum thresholds)
- **Budget allocation**: 22+/25 (maintain current)
- **Targeting efficiency**: 20+/25 (resolve Meta overlap, maintain Google clean)
- **Objective alignment**: 14+/20 (maintain current)

## Next Review: June 2026
```

---

## Common Analysis Patterns

### Pattern 1: "Inherited Account" Audit
```
I just took over [account/client] spending $[X]/month on [Google/Meta/both].
Here's a summary of the current structure:
[Paste campaign list with budgets and recent performance]

Audit the structure and give me:
1. Structural health score
2. Top 3 issues
3. Consolidation plan with migration roadmap
```

### Pattern 2: "Should I Consolidate?" Assessment
```
I have [X] campaigns on [platform] spending $[X]/month total.
[X] campaigns have fewer than [X] conversions per [month/week].
Daily budgets range from $[X] to $[X].

Should I consolidate? If so, what's the target structure and migration plan?
```

### Pattern 3: "Pre-Scale" Structure Check
```
I'm scaling from $[X]/month to $[X]/month on [platform].
Current structure: [list campaigns with budgets]

Is my structure ready for [X]x budget? What needs to change before I scale?
```

---

## Pro Tips

1. **Instead of**: "How many campaigns should I have?"
   **Ask**: "Given $30K/month budget, 200 monthly conversions, and 3 product categories on Google + Meta, what's the right campaign structure?"

2. **Instead of**: "Should I use PMax?"
   **Ask**: "I'm running Brand Search ($100/day, 80 conv/month) and Standard Shopping ($150/day, 45 conv/month). Should I add PMax, and if so, what happens to Shopping?"

3. **Instead of**: "My CPAs are too high"
   **Ask**: "My tCPA campaigns are running at $45 CPA against a $30 target. 4 of 6 campaigns have <20 conversions/month. Is the structure causing this?"

4. **Instead of**: "Audit my account"
   **Ask**: "Audit my account structure against conversion volume minimums, budget fragmentation thresholds, and targeting overlap. Score it and give me a prioritized consolidation plan."

5. **Instead of**: "Should I use CBO or ABO?"
   **Ask**: "I have $200/day for Meta prospecting with 3 audiences averaging 15 purchases/week each. CBO or ABO, and should I consolidate into fewer ad sets?"
rea-analysis-optimizationmorluto/reaOptimize REA providers and shared analysis workflows for agent context, latency, CPU, and memory while preserving correctness and Evidence. Use for analysis bottlenecks and cache or query design; CI/test-suite optimization belongs to rea-ci-tests-audit.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
rea-ci-tests-auditmorluto/reaAudit REA CI and test suites for correctness, fixture drift, false passes, and measured performance; use for suite or workflow investigations and efficiency changes, rather than ordinary feature testing or a single test failure.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
rea-tool-designmorluto/reaAudit, investigate, design, or change REA investigation tools, CLI/MCP contracts, provider capabilities, and Evidence semantics.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-auditDietrichGebert/ponytailQuality audit of the whole repo: bugs, security, real load, missing tests, speed, and what to delete. Most important first.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall