Skip to content

samuelcastro/startup-skills / legal-compliance

legal-compliance

Verified

Guide founders through startup legal foundations and compliance. Use when a founder says "Should I incorporate as C-corp or LLC?", "Where should I incorporate?", "Help me create founder agreement", "What vesting schedule?", "Help with employee equity", "Generate terms of service", "Help with SAFE/convertible notes", "Help with cap table", or asks about incorporation, founder agreements, ESOP setup, legal documents, fundraising instruments, or cap table management.

references/fundraising-instruments.md

View on GitHub
# Fundraising Instruments Guide

## Overview

Early-stage startups typically raise capital through convertible instruments before priced equity rounds. The two main instruments are:

1. **SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity)**: YC-created, no interest, no maturity
2. **Convertible Notes**: Debt instrument that converts to equity

## SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity)

### Key Terms

**Valuation Cap**
- Maximum valuation at which SAFE converts to equity
- Protects investor if company raises at higher valuation
- Example: $10M cap means investor converts at $10M even if Series A is at $20M

**Discount**
- Percentage discount to next round's price
- Typically 10-25%
- Rewards early investors for risk
- Can combine with cap (investor gets better of the two)

**Post-Money vs Pre-Money SAFE**
- **Pre-money** (legacy): Cap doesn't include SAFE itself in calculation
- **Post-money** (current standard): Cap includes SAFE and option pool
- Post-money provides clearer ownership math

### SAFE Types (YC Standard)

| Type | Cap | Discount | Use Case |
|------|-----|----------|----------|
| Cap, no discount | Yes | No | Most common |
| Discount, no cap | No | Yes | When valuation unclear |
| Cap and discount | Yes | Yes | Investor-friendly |
| MFN, no cap, no discount | No | No | Very early/small checks |

### Conversion Mechanics (Post-Money SAFE)

**At Qualifying Financing:**
1. SAFE converts to same type of stock as new investors
2. Conversion price = Valuation Cap ÷ Company Capitalization
3. Company Capitalization = all shares + promised options (post-money)

**Example:**
- SAFE: $500K at $5M post-money cap
- Investor ownership at conversion: 10% ($500K ÷ $5M)
- This ownership is fixed regardless of Series A valuation

### Pro-Rata Rights

- Right to invest in future rounds to maintain ownership percentage
- Standard in YC SAFE for investments ≥$250K
- Important for investors; minor dilution concern for founders

### When SAFEs Convert

- **Equity Financing**: Converts to preferred stock
- **Liquidity Event**: Converts or receives 1x investment back
- **Dissolution**: Receive invested amount back (if available)

## Convertible Notes

### Key Terms

**Principal**: Amount invested
**Interest Rate**: Typically 2-8% annually (accrues, doesn't pay out)
**Maturity Date**: When note comes due (usually 18-24 months)
**Valuation Cap**: Same as SAFE
**Discount**: Same as SAFE

### Note vs SAFE Comparison

| Feature | SAFE | Convertible Note |
|---------|------|------------------|
| Interest | No | Yes (2-8%) |
| Maturity date | No | Yes (18-24 months) |
| Complexity | Simple | Moderate |
| Debt on books | No | Yes |
| Legal cost | Low (~$2-5K) | Moderate (~$5-15K) |
| Investor preference | Varies | Some prefer debt rights |

### Maturity Date Considerations

**What happens at maturity?**
- Most notes simply extend by mutual agreement
- Note could technically become due (rarely enforced)
- May trigger default provisions

**Typical approaches:**
- Automatic extension provisions
- Conversion to equity at cap
- Negotiated resolution

### Interest Calculation

Interest typically accrues and adds to principal at conversion:

```
Conversion Amount = Principal × (1 + Interest Rate × Time)

Example:
$100K principal
5% annual interest
2 years to Series A
Conversion Amount = $100K × (1 + 0.05 × 2) = $110K
```

## SAFE vs Convertible Note: Decision Framework

**Choose SAFE when:**
- Speed is important
- Minimizing legal costs
- No complex terms needed
- Investors are comfortable with SAFEs
- YC or SV ecosystem

**Choose Convertible Note when:**
- Investors require debt structure
- Outside Silicon Valley norms
- Need maturity date pressure to raise
- Institutional angels require it

## Cap Table Impact

### SAFE Stack Example

| Investor | Amount | Cap (Post-Money) | Implied Ownership |
|----------|--------|------------------|-------------------|
| Angel 1 | $100K | $4M | 2.5% |
| Angel 2 | $200K | $5M | 4.0% |
| Angel 3 | $200K | $6M | 3.3% |
| **Total** | **$500K** | - | **9.8%** |

### Conversion at Series A

Series A: $3M at $12M pre-money valuation

Each SAFE converts at its cap (all caps below Series A price):
- Angel 1: Converts at $4M cap → Gets 2.5% of $15M post = $375K value
- Angel 2: Converts at $5M cap → Gets 4.0% of $15M post = $600K value
- Angel 3: Converts at $6M cap → Gets 3.3% of $15M post = $500K value

### Shadow Securities in Cap Table

Until conversion, SAFEs should be tracked as "shadow securities":
- Not actual shares yet
- Model potential conversion scenarios
- Important for understanding true dilution
- See cap table template for implementation

## Common Terms to Negotiate

### Investor-Favorable
- Lower valuation cap
- Higher discount
- Both cap AND discount
- Pro-rata rights
- Information rights
- Board observer rights

### Founder-Favorable
- Higher valuation cap
- No discount (cap only)
- Cap on pro-rata rights
- No information/board rights at this stage
- Post-money SAFE (clearer ownership)

## Multiple Instrument Scenarios

### Same Round, Different Caps
- Can create complexity
- Each SAFE converts at its own cap
- Track separately in cap table

### Stacked Rounds
- Seed SAFEs + Series A SAFEs
- All convert at Series A pricing
- Order of operations matters for dilution

### Conversion Waterfalls
At priced round:
1. Option pool created/expanded
2. Convertible notes convert (with interest)
3. SAFEs convert
4. New money invested
5. Resulting cap table established

## Red Flags and Issues

**For Founders:**
- Personal guarantees (never accept)
- Security interests
- Aggressive maturity terms
- Excessive pro-rata rights
- Unusual governance rights

**For Investors:**
- No valuation cap (unlimited downside protection)
- Very high caps relative to stage
- Multiple SAFE layers creating excessive dilution
- Unclear conversion mechanics

## Templates and Resources

**YC SAFE Documents:**
- [YC SAFE Documents](https://www.ycombinator.com/documents) - Current standard
- Post-money SAFEs recommended
- Free to use, well-documented

**500 Startups KISS:**
- Alternative convertible instrument
- Similar to SAFE with some variations

**Legal Review:**
- While SAFEs are standard, have lawyer review non-standard terms
- Ensure consistency across multiple investors
- Verify conversion mechanics match expectations
slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack."Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read.Stars: 196kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report.Stars: 196kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt.Stars: 196kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall