Skip to content

samuelcastro/startup-skills / fundraising

fundraising

Verified

Guide founders through the complete fundraising journey from pitch deck to close. Use when a founder says "help me raise", "build a pitch deck", "find investors", "financial projections", "how much to raise", "investor outreach", or asks about valuations, term sheets, or VC meetings. Covers pre-seed through Series A with stage-appropriate frameworks.

references/vc-insights.md

View on GitHub
# How VCs Actually Make Decisions

## Source
This reference is based on "How Do Venture Capitalists Make Decisions?" (Gompers, Gornall, Kaplan, Strebulaev - NBER Working Paper 22587), a comprehensive survey of 885 institutional VCs at 681 firms, plus additional industry research.

---

## The VC Deal Funnel

### By the Numbers
- **200** companies screened per year per VC
- **4** investments made per year per VC
- That's a **2% conversion rate**

### How Deals Are Sourced
| Source | % of Deals |
|--------|------------|
| Professional network referrals | 30% |
| Portfolio company referrals | 20% |
| Other VC referrals | 8% |
| Cold inbound | 10% |
| Self-generated (proactive) | 30% |

**Key Insight:** 60% of deals come through warm referrals. Cold inbound only accounts for 10% of funded deals.

### Due Diligence Process
- Average **118 days** from first contact to term sheet
- **20 hours** of due diligence on average
- Ranges from a few hours to 250+ hours

---

## What VCs Actually Value

### Factor Importance Rankings

| Factor | % Important | % Most Important |
|--------|-------------|------------------|
| **Team** | 95% | 47% |
| Business Model | 83% | 10% |
| Product | 74% | 6% |
| Market | 68% | 7% |
| Industry | 31% | - |
| Valuation | - | 2% |
| Ability to add value | - | 2% |
| Fit with fund | - | 2% |

### Team Factors (Ranked)
1. **Management team ability** - cited as critical
2. **Industry/domain experience** - want founders who know the space
3. **Entrepreneurial passion/commitment** - determination matters
4. **Prior entrepreneurial track record** - success begets success
5. **Educational background** - matters but less than experience

### Why Team Dominates
"I'd rather have an A team with a B idea than a B team with an A idea."

VCs believe:
- Ideas can pivot; teams can't easily change
- Execution matters more than concept
- Strong founders find product-market fit
- Reference checks on founders are crucial

---

## How VCs Evaluate Businesses

### What They Actually Analyze

**Business Assessment:**
1. Business model strength
2. Product differentiation
3. Market size and timing
4. Competitive dynamics
5. Customer acquisition strategy

**Financial Analysis:**
- **9%** use no financial metrics at all
- **20%** don't forecast cash flows
- Only **20%** use DCF/NPV
- **63%** use cash-on-cash multiples
- **42%** use IRR

**Key Insight:** VCs are not doing complex financial modeling. They're pattern-matching and assessing whether a business can reach venture-scale returns.

### Investment Criteria by Stage

| Stage | Primary Focus |
|-------|---------------|
| Seed | Team, vision, early validation |
| Series A | Traction, unit economics, market |
| Series B+ | Growth rate, path to profitability |

---

## Valuation Insights

### How VCs Set Valuations

Primary methods:
1. **Comparable company analysis** - what similar companies raised at
2. **Revenue multiples** - industry-specific rules of thumb
3. **Stage-based norms** - pre-seed $2-5M, seed $5-15M, etc.
4. **Negotiation/market** - what the market will bear

### Seed Stage Valuations
From the survey:
- **$2-10M** range for typical seed deals
- Pre-money, before the round

### What Affects Valuation
- Traction and growth rate
- Team pedigree
- Market size
- Competitive dynamics
- Investor demand/competition for deal
- Current market conditions

---

## Value-Add Rankings

### Where VCs Believe They Add Value

| Activity | % of VCs Ranking #1 |
|----------|---------------------|
| Strategic guidance | 87% |
| Connecting customers/partners | 72% |
| Connecting to investors | 69% |
| Operational guidance | 65% |
| Hiring board members | 58% |
| Hiring management team | 46% |

### Key Value-Add Activities
1. **Board participation** - governance and strategic guidance
2. **Network access** - customers, partners, talent
3. **Follow-on fundraising** - introductions to other VCs
4. **Credibility signal** - brand association

---

## What Drives VC Returns

### The Attribution Debate

When asked what drives fund returns:
| Factor | VCs Ranking #1 |
|--------|----------------|
| Deal selection | 49% |
| Post-investment value-add | 27% |
| Deal flow | 23% |

**Interpretation:** VCs believe picking winners matters more than helping them win, but both matter.

### Portfolio Construction
- Average VC makes **4 investments per year** per partner
- Portfolio typically **10-20 companies** per fund
- Following the "power law"—one big winner makes the fund

---

## VC Decision-Making Process

### Stages of Evaluation

1. **Initial Screen** (minutes)
   - Does this fit our thesis?
   - Is the team credible?
   - Quick pass/proceed decision

2. **Deep Dive** (hours)
   - Partner takes a meeting
   - Reviews materials
   - Does basic due diligence

3. **Partner Discussion** (days)
   - Presents to partnership
   - Discusses risks and potential
   - Decision to proceed or pass

4. **Due Diligence** (weeks)
   - Reference checks
   - Market research
   - Financial analysis
   - Legal review

5. **Investment Committee** (days)
   - Final approval
   - Term sheet issued

### Time Breakdown
- **Initial screen to first meeting:** Days to weeks
- **First meeting to partner meeting:** 1-2 weeks
- **Partner meeting to term sheet:** 2-4 weeks
- **Term sheet to close:** 4-6 weeks

**Total:** 2-4 months typical for seed, 3-6 months for Series A

---

## Reference Checks

### What VCs Ask

**About the Founders:**
- What's their biggest strength?
- What's their biggest weakness?
- Would you work with them again?
- How do they handle adversity?
- How do they treat employees?

**Who They Call:**
- Former co-workers and employers
- Previous investors
- Current/former customers
- Industry experts
- Other portfolio founders

**Key Insight:** Reference checks can kill deals. Ensure your references are prepared and positive.

---

## Why VCs Pass

### Common Rejection Reasons

| Reason | Frequency |
|--------|-----------|
| Team concerns | Most common |
| Market size too small | Very common |
| Not in our thesis/focus | Very common |
| Competitive concerns | Common |
| Valuation too high | Common |
| Business model concerns | Common |
| Traction insufficient | Common |
| Timing wrong (for us) | Sometimes |

### What "Not Right Now" Usually Means
- "We need to see more traction" = need proof points
- "Come back when you're further along" = didn't believe in current stage
- "Not in our current focus" = doesn't fit thesis
- "We have a conflict" = portfolio company overlap

---

## VC Firm Dynamics

### Decision-Making Structures

| Structure | % of Firms |
|-----------|------------|
| Consensus (all partners agree) | 44% |
| Supermajority (most partners agree) | 32% |
| Single partner can decide | 24% |

**Implication:** Even if one partner loves you, they often need to convince others.

### What This Means for Founders
- Build relationships with multiple partners if possible
- Understand the firm's decision process
- Give your champion the tools to advocate internally
- Be patient during partner meeting weeks

---

## Practical Implications

### For Fundraising Strategy

1. **Prioritize warm intros**
   - 60% of deals come through referrals
   - Cold outreach has low conversion

2. **Focus on team narrative**
   - It's the #1 factor by far
   - Prepare your "why us" story
   - Ensure references are aligned

3. **Don't over-index on financials**
   - VCs aren't doing DCF analysis
   - Focus on showing you understand unit economics
   - Growth story matters more than perfect projections

4. **Expect 2% conversion**
   - Plan to contact 50-100 investors
   - Budget 3-6 months
   - Don't get discouraged by rejection

5. **Give champions ammunition**
   - Clear, memorable pitch
   - One-pager for internal sharing
   - Metrics they can defend

6. **Understand value-add**
   - Ask VCs how they help portfolio companies
   - Check with their founders
   - Value-add varies widely by firm and partner

---

## Red Flags VCs Watch For

### Team Red Flags
🚩 Founder conflict or dysfunction
🚩 Unwillingness to adapt/pivot
🚩 Overconfidence without self-awareness
🚩 Negative references
🚩 Lack of relevant experience

### Business Red Flags
🚩 Can't clearly articulate value proposition
🚩 Market too small for venture returns
🚩 No credible path to customer acquisition
🚩 Unclear competitive differentiation
🚩 Unsustainable unit economics

### Process Red Flags
🚩 Inconsistent information across meetings
🚩 Defensiveness about weaknesses
🚩 Unrealistic expectations
🚩 Poor preparation
🚩 Lack of urgency/drive
slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack."Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall