Skip to content

rse/ase / plugin/skills/ase-meta-diaboli

ase-meta-diaboli

Verified

Challenge a thesis by playing "Devil's Advocate" (Latin: "Advocatus Diaboli"). Use when the user wants a thesis or statement relentlessly challenged or criticised.

FileKindSize
SKILL.mdskill md7.8 KB
help.mdmarkdown4.1 KB

##  NAME

`ase-meta-diaboli` - Play "Devil's Advocate" (Latin: "Advocatus Diaboli")

##  SYNOPSIS

`ase-meta-diaboli`
    [`--help`|`-h`]
    [`--count`|`-c` *count*]
    [`--ground`|`-G`]
    *thesis*

##  DESCRIPTION

The `ase-meta-diaboli` skill plays *Devil's Advocate* (Latin:
*Advocatus Diaboli*) by relentlessly challenging or criticising a
supplied *thesis*. It applies a disciplined set of critical-thinking
tenets - steelmanning, stress-testing fundamentals, surfacing implicit
assumptions, demanding proportional evidence, seeking disconfirming
cases, *Reductio Ad Absurdum*, exposing hidden costs, and pre-mortem
thinking - while targeting the claim rather than its proponent and
yielding where the argument genuinely holds.

The skill iterates until it has found at least *count* anti-theses
(counter-arguments) each ranked at least 7 on a 0 (weak) to 10
(strong) Likert scale (or until it has checked *count* x 5 candidates,
then surfacing the highest-ranked ones regardless), reports the top
*count* sorted from strongest to weakest, and finally applies *Hegelian dialectics* (*Thesis* +
*Antithesis* → *Synthesis*) to derive a single-sentence *SYNTHESIS*
that preserves what is true in both the thesis and its antitheses
while discarding what is false.

The `--count`/`-c` *count* option sets the minimum number of strong
anti-theses to surface (default *10*), raising or lowering the floor of
counter-arguments hunted for, sorted, and reported in the single
challenge pass. A `0`, negative, or non-numeric value falls back to the
default *10*.

By default, the anti-theses are derived from model knowledge only. With
the `--ground`/`-G` option, the skill first gathers facts on the
*thesis* from the project artifacts and the Internet/Web, prefers
anti-theses backed by them, and tags every anti-thesis with its
evidence or as unverified.

The intent is constructive: stress-testing the thesis in good faith to
arrive at a better final decision, not obstructing or merely being
contrarian.

##  OPTIONS

-   `--count`|`-c` *count*:
    Surface at least *count* strong anti-theses (default *10*) before
    sorting and reporting the top *count* and deriving the *SYNTHESIS*. An
    invalid or non-positive *count* reverts to the default *10*.

-   `--ground`|`-G`:
    Ground the challenge in facts instead of the world knowledge of the
    model alone: once before the challenge, the requirements and the
    realization of the project (its specification, documentation, code,
    and infrastructure files) are scanned for the facts relevant to the
    *thesis*, and the Internet/Web is searched for them. Anti-theses
    backed by these facts are preferred, contradicted ones are
    discarded, and every anti-thesis is tagged with its evidence (file
    path or source URL) or as `[unverified]`. If no usable facts are
    found, a warning is shown and the challenge falls back to model
    knowledge.

##  ARGUMENTS

-   *thesis*:
    The statement, claim, or position to be relentlessly challenged.
    It may be technical, factual, or opinion-based; the skill attacks
    its strongest ("steelman") interpretation.

##  SCENARIOS

-   You want a thesis relentlessly challenged with counter-arguments
-   You want a decision stress-tested before you commit to it
-   You want the strongest anti-theses ranked plus a synthesis
-   You want a devil's advocate against a claim or plan
-   You want counter-arguments backed by evidence from the project and the Web

##  EXAMPLES

Challenge a technology-choice claim:

```text
❯ /ase-meta-diaboli HAPI is the best REST framework
```

Stress-test a design decision:

```text
❯ /ase-meta-diaboli We should rewrite the service in Rust.
```

Surface at least fifteen anti-theses:

```text
❯ /ase-meta-diaboli --count 15 We should rewrite the service in Rust.
```

Challenge a claim with evidence from the project artifacts and the
Internet/Web:

```text
❯ /ase-meta-diaboli --ground Our task store scales to thousands of tasks.
```

##  SEE ALSO

[`ase-meta-why`](../ase-meta-why/help.md), [`ase-meta-evaluate`](../ase-meta-evaluate/help.md), [`ase-meta-quorum`](../ase-meta-quorum/help.md),
[`ase-meta-steelman`](../ase-meta-steelman/help.md).

slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack."Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall