Skip to content

mbfinotti/advertising-skills / skills/ad-spend-allocation

ad-spend-allocation

Verified

Split a fixed total paid-media budget across campaigns, platforms, funnel stages, and audiences based on expected marginal return - the monthly or quarterly reallocation decision, for B2B and B2C. Use whenever the user asks how to split an ad budget, which channel or campaign should get more money, how to reallocate spend, how much to put behind prospecting vs retargeting, or mentions a portfolio split, marginal return, or diminishing returns - even if they never say 'allocation'. Do NOT use to raise the total budget on a proven campaign (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@paid-media-scaling), to track daily spend against a set budget (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-budget-pacing), or to pick channels at setup (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-platform-selection).

references/worked-allocation-examples.md

View on GitHub
# Worked allocation examples

Illustrative numbers - recalibrate every figure against the account's own data. What matters is the shape of the reasoning, not the amounts.

## Worked example 1 - B2C e-commerce, $60K/month, monthly reweight

Context from interview: 55% contribution margin → break-even ROAS ≈ 1.82. Measurement maturity 9/15 (no incrementality tests - all marginal estimates are directional proxies, plan says so). Approver: head of growth, max one-cycle movement 20% of total.

Gates: all five current lines clear payback; Google brand search flagged at the data-basis gate - its 11x is platform-reported, and brand search is the canonical incrementality offender, so it is capped pending a holdout test rather than trusted.

| Line              | Current     | Proposed    | Rationale (marginal evidence)                                                                                    | Expected effect                                         | Uncertainty                      | Rollback threshold                 | Verify |
| ----------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------ |
| Meta prospecting  | $24,000     | $28,000     | Penetration 18% → headroom; last +15% step held CPA within 8% of target                                          | +55-70 orders/mo                                        | Medium - stepped-increment proxy | Blended MER < 2.6 for 2 wks        | Day 30 |
| Meta retargeting  | $12,000     | $9,500      | 34% of Meta spend on retargeting inflates blended ROAS; pool refill depends on prospecting                       | Blended ROAS dips, total orders flat-to-up              | Medium                           | New-customer orders -10%           | Day 30 |
| Google non-brand  | $10,000     | $12,500     | Lost impression share (budget) 41% → budget-responsive headroom                                                  | +18-25 orders/mo                                        | Low-medium                       | CPA > 1.3x target                  | Day 30 |
| Google brand      | $8,000      | $5,000      | Platform 11x untrusted (data-basis gate); holdout test commissioned this cycle                                   | Revenue impact expected minimal if near-non-incremental | High - that is why the test      | Tracked branded-search revenue -8% | Day 45 |
| TikTok experiment | $6,000      | $5,000      | Bounded test, cycle 2 of 3: hypothesis "CPA within 1.5x Meta's marginal CPA"; decision date day 60; stop if > 2x | Learning, not volume                                    | High, bounded                    | Spend cap only                     | Day 60 |
| **Total**         | **$60,000** | **$60,000** | Fixed total - sums exactly                                                                                       |                                                         |                                  |                                    |        |

Sequence check:

- Commitments reserved: none.
- Proven marginal contributors protected: Meta prospecting, Google non-brand.
- Experiment bounded: TikTok.
- No idle contingency.
- Defunded lines are the weakest _marginal_ opportunities (saturating retargeting, unverified brand search), not the worst average performers.

Largest single move is 37% of the brand line but 5% of the total; step sizes on growing lines held to 15-25%.

## Worked example 2 - B2B SaaS, $150K/quarter, quarterly resplit

Context: $28K ACV, sales cycle ~100 days → this quarter's reallocation reads leading indicators (cost per SQL, pipeline created, penetration), never last quarter's closed-won. Break-even CPL = $28,000 × 12% lead-to-close ≈ $3,360; target CPL set at $1,800 by the profitability policy owner.

Signal driving the resplit: demand capture (search + review sites) produces 62% of pipeline on 40% of budget - pipeline share exceeds budget share and search lost-IS (budget) is 35%, so capture is under-funded at the margin. LinkedIn demand creation sits at 31% 30-day penetration of a 42,000-person audience → hold band; more budget there buys the same people again.

| Line (stage)                       | Current      | Proposed     | Rationale                                                                                                                         | Rollback threshold                 | Verify |
| ---------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ------ |
| Demand capture - search            | $45,000      | $58,000      | Pipeline share > budget share; lost-IS(budget) 35%                                                                                | Cost/SQL > 1.4x baseline           | Day 45 |
| Demand capture - review sites      | $15,000      | $18,000      | Same signal; category floor still cleared                                                                                         | Cost/SQL > 1.5x baseline           | Day 45 |
| Demand creation - LinkedIn         | $60,000      | $50,000      | 31% penetration = hold band; creative supply caps absorbable budget at ~$50K (10 proven ads × $5K)                                | Pipeline created -20% over 60 days | Day 60 |
| Accelerate (retargeting open opps) | $12,000      | $12,000      | Small audience, saturated; protected as proven                                                                                    | -                                  | -      |
| Revive (closed-lost) experiment    | $18,000      | $12,000      | Cycle 1 read weak: cost/SQL 2.1x baseline, but sample below 3x target CPL of spend → reduced, not killed; decision date at day 75 | Stop if > 2.5x at decision date    | Day 75 |
| **Total**                          | **$150,000** | **$150,000** |                                                                                                                                   |                                    |        |

Note what did _not_ happen: LinkedIn was not cut for having the worst average cost per SQL - its penetration band and creative-supply ceiling set the cut, and the money followed the strongest marginal signal (capture), not the biggest pipeline stage in absolute terms.

## Negative example - annotated

The tempting plan that fails review. Same B2C account as example 1:

> "Google brand is our best performer at 11x ROAS, so we're doubling it to $16K. Meta prospecting is only 2.1x, so we're cutting it to $12K and moving the rest into retargeting (4.8x). TikTok never beat Meta, so it's dead. New split effective Monday."

Line by line:

- **"Best performer at 11x"** - average, platform-reported, and brand search: three flags at once. Platform reporting overstates 1.75-2.97x, and brand search is the classic near-non-incremental line (19x → 5.7x under one published test). No incrementality evidence was even requested.
- **"Doubling it"** - a 100% step. Default increments are 15-20%; nothing here derives a larger step from account history or blast radius.
- **"Only 2.1x, so cut"** - defunds on _average_ ROAS. Prospecting at 18% penetration is plausibly the account's best _marginal_ line; the plan never asks.
- **"Moving the rest into retargeting (4.8x)"** - retargeting's high average is partly credit for demand prospecting created. Over-funding it inflates blended ROAS now and starves the pool; total conversions drop weeks later, after this plan is declared a success.
- **"TikTok never beat Meta, so it's dead"** - compared the experiment to Meta's _average_ efficiency. The right comparison is Meta's marginal efficiency - the last dollars this plan is (correctly or not) moving around. It also kills a bounded test before its decision date on a below-evidence-floor sample.
- **"Effective Monday"** - no owner, no expected effect, no uncertainty, no verification date, no rollback threshold. Not a change packet; unauditable and irreversible by design.
- Structural: the amounts are also not shown to sum to the fixed total, and no gate (payback, measurement maturity, floors, data basis) ran at all.
reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness.Stars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependenciesStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is availableStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall