mbfinotti/advertising-skills / skills/ad-spend-allocation
ad-spend-allocation
VerifiedSplit a fixed total paid-media budget across campaigns, platforms, funnel stages, and audiences based on expected marginal return - the monthly or quarterly reallocation decision, for B2B and B2C. Use whenever the user asks how to split an ad budget, which channel or campaign should get more money, how to reallocate spend, how much to put behind prospecting vs retargeting, or mentions a portfolio split, marginal return, or diminishing returns - even if they never say 'allocation'. Do NOT use to raise the total budget on a proven campaign (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@paid-media-scaling), to track daily spend against a set budget (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-budget-pacing), or to pick channels at setup (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-platform-selection).
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 27.6 KB |
| evals/evals.json | config | 34.3 KB |
| references/heuristics-and-figure-grading.md | markdown | 18.4 KB |
| references/worked-allocation-examples.md | markdown | 8.3 KB |
references/heuristics-and-figure-grading.md
View on GitHub# Named split heuristics and figure grading
Every fixed-percentage split circulating in the field, with its source and an honest evidence label. Treat each as a starting posture to be corrected by marginal evidence - never as authorization. The sharpest counter-stance in the field: fixed ratios, fixed CPA multiples, and fixed percentage scaling are "optional heuristics, never universal authorization"; any ratio you adopt is operator policy, recorded with its rationale.
Evidence labels:
- **sourced** - traced to a named original source.
- **convention** - widely repeated, traceable to nobody in particular.
- **folklore** - traced, but to something that does not support the media-budget claim made of it.
Figures circulating in this space that are fabricated or secondhand, never repeat them as fact:
- "McKinsey research shows 70/20/10 companies achieve 2.7x higher shareholder returns" - no such named report exists; treat as fabricated.
- "budgets waste 20-30% of spend on saturated channels" - secondhand vendor citation.
- "71% of CFOs rejected a budget request over revenue-tied metrics" - secondhand vendor citation.
The retargeting ≤10% cap and the ~20% step-size rule are consensus heuristics, not proven constants. The one durable quantified figure: McKinsey's review of 400+ client engagements over eight years found integrated analytics frees **15-20% of marketing spend**.
## Portfolio-level splits
Ranked for adoption. Reading and applying any of these costs about the same - an hour - so effort is flat across the table and efficiency follows evidence strength alone: `60/40 brand-activation > phase-adjusted 70/20/10 > 20% fresh-creative reserve > highest-confidence-first recipe > flat 70/20/10 > marketing-category split`. Take the highest row whose scope actually matches the decision in front of you; a lower row is a starting posture, never a number to defend.
The rule of 7 sits outside the ranking entirely - folklore, contradicted by the research it is usually credited to, and never a budget input. ESOV, 95-5 and zero-based budgeting are not splits at all: they are diagnostics and discipline that tell you when a split is wrong, so they compete with nothing here.
| Heuristic | Split | Source | Evidence |
| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 70/20/10 current / next / experimental | 70% what works now, 20% the deliberate next bet (becomes "current" in 2-4 quarters), 10% exploratory | Eric Schmidt's "70 Percent Solution" (Business 2.0, Dec 2005), verbatim in _How Google Works_ (2014); applied to content by Coca-Cola "Content 2020" (Mildenhall, Cannes 2011); numbers borrowed from the 70:20:10 learning-and-development model | **Folklore for media budgets** - the origin is a corporate resource-allocation rule, and no controlled study establishes it as optimal for paid media. Useful only as a portfolio-discipline device |
| Phase-adjusted 70/20/10 | No channel proven yet → ~40/30/30; proven growth engine → ~80/15/5 | Same playbook family | Convention - but the most reusable rule in the set: the split is a function of portfolio maturity, not a constant |
| Fresh-creative reserve | "20% of spend always went into fresh ads to prevent fatigue" | Prash Brooks & Justin Setzer, Demand Curve growth newsletter #318 (applied case, $62K → $493K in 90 days) | Sourced - the only directly sourced 70/20/10-family figure |
| Highest-confidence-first recipe | 60-70% to the highest-confidence channel; 15-20% testing; 10-15% contingency; shift monthly | Knowledge-work campaign-planning playbook, flagged by its own author as "adjust based on goals and historical data" | Convention |
| Marketing-category split | Paid acquisition 30-40% / content 20-30% / events 10-20% / tools 10-15% / testing 5-10% | Same playbook | Convention - org-budget level, not a media split |
| Brand vs performance 60/40 | ~60% long-term brand building / 40% short-term activation; later refined to ~62/38. **B2B optimum ~46/54**, tilted toward activation (LinkedIn B2B Institute, 2019) | Les Binet & Peter Field, _The Long and the Short of It_ (IPA, 2013), from the IPA Databank - 996 campaigns, ~700 brands, 83 sectors, 30+ years | **Sourced - the strongest evidence base of any split**, but a dataset average maximising across categories, not a per-brand law. The right ratio moves with brand maturity, purchase frequency and competitive context. Never present it to finance as a proven optimum |
| ESOV (excess share of voice) | Every 10 points of positive ESOV ≈ 0.5 pp annual market-share growth (B2C), ~0.7 pp (B2B) | John Philip Jones, "Ad Spending: Maintaining Market Share," HBR 1990; quantified by Binet & Field on the IPA Databank | Sourced - reasonably robust correlational finding. Some retellings invert the B2C/B2B figures; cite the B2B Institute report directly |
| 95-5 rule | Only ~5% of B2B buyers are in-market in a given quarter; ~20% in a given year | Prof. John Dawes, Ehrenberg-Bass Institute / LinkedIn B2B Institute, 2021 | Sourced - robust as a heuristic, though the 5% is category-dependent. This is the structural reason short-window ROAS reallocation is invalid in B2B |
| Zero-based budgeting | Every line re-justifies its budget from zero each cycle | Peter Pyhrr, HBR 1970; revived by McKinsey/3G Capital ~2015 | Sourced - a real cost-discipline tool (10-25% documented SG&A savings) but **not an allocation optimiser**. Use it annually to kill legacy lines, not to choose the split |
| "Seven touches" / rule of 7 | Buyers need ~7 exposures before converting | Attributed to 1930s cinema; modern claimant Jeffrey Lant (1989) | **Folklore** - no studies support it, and Krugman's "three exposures" (1972) contradicts it. Never size a frequency budget on this |
## Within-platform splits
Deliberately unranked. Prospecting-vs-retargeting has two defaults (60/40 and 70/30) circulating with no criterion separating them, and the two testing-phase splits govern different objects (account phase versus campaign structure), so an efficiency ordering here would be false precision. What carries is the direction, not the ratio: over ~40% on retargeting is the signal to expand prospecting.
| Heuristic | Split | Source | Evidence |
| ------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Testing-phase split | First 2-4 weeks: 70% proven / 30% testing new audiences and creative | Open-source ads playbook | Convention |
| Scaling + testing campaign structure | ~80% scaling campaign holding only graduated ads; ~20% testing campaign with protected budget - "inside one CBO, proven ads always starve new ones" | Same playbook family (Meta decision system) | Convention, with a stated mechanism |
| Prospecting vs retargeting | 60/40 and 70/30 both circulate as _the_ default, unreconciled; broader practitioner range 60-90% prospecting; spending over ~40% on retargeting is a signal to expand prospecting | Multiple open-source skills and agencies (Hawke Media, Top Growth Marketing) | Convention - no criterion for choosing between the two defaults. The important part is the objection: over-funding retargeting inflates blended ROAS while starving the prospecting that refills the retargeting pool |
## Concentration and eligibility rules
| Heuristic | Rule | Source | Evidence |
| -------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Concentration-first | Master one channel at 80% of budget/effort for 90 days before adding a complementary one for 60 days | One-page-marketing playbook; echoed independently ("2-4 complementary motions, start with strongest") | Convention, independently converged |
| Budget-tier channel gating | <$1K/month: one search channel only; $1K-5K: + one social; $5K-20K: search + two social/video; $20K-100K: + new-channel testing; $100K+: all channels + programmatic/influencer | Mobile-UA playbook, structurally general | Convention - the only rule here where total budget decides _which_ channels are eligible at all |
| LinkedIn penetration bands | 30-day penetration <25% → room to raise; 25-35% → hold; 35%+ → scale horizontally into new audiences. "Doubling budget grows penetration ~50-70%, not 100%" | B2B LinkedIn playbook | Convention - but the best-evidenced "how much more can this channel absorb" signal available, and one of only two quantified diminishing-returns statements in circulation |
## Upstream budget sizing (input to allocation, not allocation)
| Heuristic | Rule | Source | Evidence |
| --------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------------ |
| Revenue-based posture | 5% of ARR conservative / 15-25% standard growth / up to 40% aggressive | Budget-planning playbook | Convention |
| Goal-based formula | Budget = [(New ARR ÷ (ARPC × 12)) × CAC] ÷ annual retention, + 10-20% experimental buffer; CAC fully loaded, never paid-spend-only | Same playbook | Convention, with a worked derivation |
## What no heuristic gives you
Three decisions the named heuristics above do not make for you - do not pretend one fills them:
- **Cross-platform allocation under a single budget cap.** The named systems stop at "compare platforms"; splitting one cap across them is a judgment the workflow makes, not a ratio to look up.
- **Marginal-return curves are asserted here, never modeled - a real modeling methodology exists but sits outside this skill's scope.** Marketing Mix Modeling (MMM) fits nonlinear saturation curves (Hill/S-curve, power, or logarithmic functions) to weekly spend and outcome data, and named open-source and commercial tools do this in practice (Meta's Robyn, Recast, Mutinex). It requires a dedicated modeling exercise on the org's own multi-channel spend history, not something derivable from platform exports in a single allocation pass - which is why, within this skill's scope, the LinkedIn 50-70% line and search impression-share saturation remain the only quantified diminishing-returns statements available. Point a user with the budget and data for a proper MMM engagement there rather than asserting this skill can compute the same curve from exports alone.
- **Channel sunset criteria.** Ad-level kill rules are everywhere; a rule for retiring an entire channel from the mix is not. Build one from the same gates: a channel exits when it fails payback at its marginal (not average) efficiency across two consecutive quarterly reviews with creative and tracking ruled out.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness. | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependencies | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is available | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |