Skip to content

mbfinotti/advertising-skills / skills/ad-platform-selection

ad-platform-selection

Verified

Decide which paid channel families fit a business's economics, audience, funnel stage, and budget at campaign setup - paid search, paid social, short-form video, connected TV, native/discovery, retail media, programmatic display, podcast/audio, paid review listings, B2B professional networks - including whether each is affordable against allowable CAC and payback. Use whenever the user asks where to spend a new ad budget, which platform to advertise on, how to build a paid channel mix, whether a channel is worth trying, or compares two ad channels - even if they never say 'channel selection'. Covers B2B and B2C. Do NOT use to split an ongoing budget across existing campaigns - use mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-allocation instead.

references/channel-family-profiles.md

View on GitHub
# Channel family profiles

Directional profiles for the affordability gate (step 1), ranking (step 4), and funding floor check (step 5). Named platforms below appear only as the source of a specific figure or policy, not as the operating vocabulary.

All figures are 2025-2026 reporting-period numbers from vendor-published datasets and practitioner guidance; vendors have a commercial interest in more spend, and medians hide very wide variance (published search CPCs in the legal vertical alone span roughly $1.50 to $50+). Use as ranges, never targets; reverify against current platform documentation before spend commits.

Both the table and the sections below run in SKILL.md step 4's default efficiency order - highest value returned per unit of effort first. That order is a default, not a law: re-rank it against the business's own advantages, in-house skills and owned assets, and against the interview's deadline, one-off-versus-compounding and effort-ceiling answers, before using it.

## Table of Contents

- [Summary table](#summary-table)
- [Paid search](#paid-search)
- [Retail media](#retail-media)
- [Paid social](#paid-social)
- [B2B professional networks](#b2b-professional-networks)
- [Short-form video](#short-form-video)
- [Podcast / audio](#podcast-audio)
- [Connected TV](#connected-tv)
- [Native / discovery - price-discovery bucket](#native-discovery-price-discovery-bucket)
- [Programmatic display - price-discovery bucket](#programmatic-display-price-discovery-bucket)
- [Paid review listings - price-discovery bucket](#paid-review-listings-price-discovery-bucket)

## Summary table

Effort is what the team spends, not what the media costs: setup hours, assets produced per month, coordination with third parties, and how reversible the commitment is.

| Family                         | Demand state                     | Value ceiling                                                                  | Effort load                                                                                  | Practical monthly minimum                                                  | Signal threshold                                                                             |
| ------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Paid search                    | Capture                          | Bounded by existing search volume; the highest-yield revenue inside that bound | A day or two of setup, near-zero ongoing (text + landing page)                               | Budget for ~10 clicks/day; daily budget 3-5x target CPA                    | ≥1 conversion/day on paper                                                                   |
| Automated cross-surface search | Capture + creation blend         | Same demand pool, wider surfaces, less control                                 | A day or two of setup, near-zero ongoing; opaque to diagnose                                 | ~$2,000-$10,000 (practitioner-cited)                                       | ~30 conversions/month; ~50/month for stability                                               |
| Retail media                   | Capture                          | Modest, bounded by the host marketplace's shelf traffic                        | A week (listing setup plus marketplace terms), low ongoing                                   | $2,000-$3,000 (sponsored listings); $100/day on the second-largest network | No technical minimum on sponsored listings                                                   |
| Paid social prospecting        | Creation (+ retargeting capture) | Highest of any family - unbounded by existing demand                           | A standing job: 8-15+ variants per ad set, refresh on frequency                              | ~$1,000/week per ad set at a $20 CPA                                       | ~50 optimization events per ad set per 7 days                                                |
| B2B professional networks      | Capture/creation hybrid          | High value per lead, capped by a small addressable audience                    | A few days per asset cycle (~4-6 week asset life); a quarter of commitment before a verdict  | $3,000-$5,000; ~$5,000 (North America) for sales outcomes                  | Audience 300 technical floor; ~5,000-50,000 working range; 15-25 conversions/month realistic |
| Short-form video               | Creation                         | High ceiling on broad consumer categories                                      | A standing job, heavier than paid social: 10-20 variants, fatigue in days                    | Similar per-campaign logic to paid social                                  | 10-20 creative variations per campaign                                                       |
| Podcast / audio                | Creation                         | Strong endorsement effect, hard to read                                        | A quarter: show booking lead times, multi-episode flights, a measurement build before launch | ~$15,000+ across 3+ shows to be measurable                                 | Multi-episode flights; shows with 300-1,000+ downloads/episode                               |
| Connected TV                   | Creation                         | Broad reach, structurally weak click-level read                                | A quarter: video production plus an incrementality build, both due before the first result   | $500 self-serve; $5,000+ programmatic DSP; $50,000+ direct                 | ~$165/day self-serve guidance; run ≥1 month                                                  |

Retargeting is a mode, not a family - it runs on the paid social and programmatic display surfaces. It sits second on step 4's efficiency ordering because it reuses creative and audience already paid for, so its effort is near-zero. Its value ceiling is capped by whatever traffic feeds it, which is why it is never the primary.

### What this order starves

Podcast/audio and connected TV sit last because a ratio demotes anything high on value and high on effort, and the affordability gate and the funding floor push the same two families down again. Promote one to primary against its rank only when the buyer is demonstrably on that surface, no capture family reaches them, the budget clears that family's floor by concentrating rather than spreading, and the deadline sits at least a quarter out - the full condition is in SKILL.md step 4. Short-form video is the same case one row up wherever video production is already in-house.

A family the affordability gate, the disqualifier pass or the funding floor rules out is deleted from the account's candidate set and named as deleted - it does not come back into this table as a low-scoring row.

### Price-discovery bucket - deliberately unranked

Native/discovery, programmatic display and paid review listings sit outside the ordering above. Ranking them against benchmarked families would be invented precision because cost and value vary widely. Gate each with the step 7 price-discovery test and treat them as second-channel candidates once that test returns a real number - never as the funded primary on a first plan.

## Paid search

- Capture. Fits any category buyers actively search, at any price point where CPC clears the math. Low creative burden (text + landing page).
- 2026 US benchmark (13,474 campaigns across two search networks, Apr 2025-Mar 2026): all-industry average CPC $5.42, average CPL $66.69 - the first CPL decline in five years. Cheapest verticals ~$1.63-$2.05 CPC; most expensive (legal) $9.87 average, with the underlying range ~$1.50-$50+.
- Floor logic: fund ~10 clicks/day and a daily budget of 3-5x target CPA; if the budget cannot deliver at least one conversion/day on paper, it cannot produce signal.
- Automated cross-surface search products: the only official floor is "3x CPA daily budget"; ~30 conversions/month minimum and ~$2,000-$10,000/month are practitioner extrapolations sometimes wrongly attributed to the platform.
- Effort: a day or two to build the account, then near-zero ongoing - no creative treadmill, and the whole thing pauses in minutes. That combination, not its media price, is why it leads the default ordering wherever the category has search volume.
- Disqualified by: no category search volume; restricted categories requiring certification.

## Retail media

- Capture at the shelf: shoppers already in a buying session. Fits products actually sold on the host marketplaces; disqualified outright if you don't sell there.
- Heavily US-concentrated: the largest network holds ~79.7% of US retail media (2025), and the top two take ~88-89% of US incremental retail media spend.
- Entry: $2,000-$3,000/month working floor for sponsored product listings on the largest network (no technical minimum); the second-largest runs self-serve from $100/day (~$3,000/month test), cut bid floors to $0.50 in late 2025, and shows ~55% lower CPCs on matched CPG terms. Managed DSP tiers start around $50,000.
- Effort: a week to set up listings and clear marketplace terms; near-zero creative burn afterwards. Value is capped by the host's own traffic, which is what keeps it below the creation families on value while staying above them on efficiency.

## Paid social

- Creation, plus the highest-volume retargeting surface. B2C default; also carries B2B creation.
- The most-cited learning threshold in paid media: ~50 optimization events per ad set per 7-day window (largest platform's official guidance) - at a $20 cost per conversion that implies roughly $1,000/week per ad set. Below it the ad set never exits learning; consolidate ad sets or optimize to a higher-frequency proxy event.
- 2025 ecommerce dataset (~35,000 brands): median CPM ~$13.48-$15.06, median CPA ~$38.19-$38.99, median ROAS 1.86-1.93x, median CTR 2.19%. CPM rose ~20% YoY; CPA held nearly flat because conversion rates rose 8.3%. Highest-CPM vertical: health & wellness at ~$20.70-$21.80.
- Small-budget practitioner tiers: "small" is under ~$3,000/month, "tiny" under ~$600/month; at those tiers a 2-3x ROAS is the reasonable goal, not 10x, and a low-volume account (~5 purchases/week) can take about a month to exit learning.
- Small-budget tactics:
  - One offer.
  - Skip awareness objectives.
  - Lean on the platform's automated campaign type.
  - Avoid edits that reset learning.
- Profitability check: at the median 1.86x ROAS, paid social is profitable only above roughly a 50% contribution margin.
- Creative burden: high. This is a standing job, not a setup task, and it is the reason the family's top-of-table value ceiling still lands mid-table on efficiency.
  - 8-15+ meaningfully different variations per ad set.
  - Refresh when frequency reaches ~2.5-3.
  - Refresh cadence tightens to every 3-5 days above ~$1,000/day.
- Its retargeting mode is the exception: reusing existing creative against an existing audience is near-zero effort, which is why retargeting outranks prospecting on efficiency while ranking last on value.
- Disqualified/weakened by: special-ad-category regimes for credit, employment, housing, and financial products (see disqualifier checklist); static-only creative capacity at scale.

## B2B professional networks

- Hybrid: precise firmographic reach to buyers in a work mindset. The defining B2B creation-and-capture family.
- Practitioner gate (LinkedIn-focused agency guidance, published 2024-2026):
  - Don't run it for pipeline below ~$5,000/month (North America); ~$500/month only proves engagement signal, not sales.
  - Require LTV of roughly $10,000-$15,000 minimum to recoup the front-end premium.
  - Require a clearly defined title/seniority/industry/company-size audience.
  - Commit to a ~3-month test.

  "Users aren't ready to buy your $10K – $100K products or services after seeing one ad."

- Costs:
  - North America CPC ~$8-$16 (3-5x the ~$3-$5 typical of cheaper social).
  - CPL ~$110 typical, with qualified leads at $20-$60 in favorable cases.
  - Cost per sales-qualified lead often runs less than half that of cheaper social despite the higher CPC.
- Minimum daily budget per campaign ~$25-$50; the platform can spend up to 1.5x the daily campaign budget on a given day.
- Signal: audience floor of 300 is technical only - the working range is ~5,000-50,000; 15-25 conversions/month is realistic, so the 50-event learning bar of paid social rarely applies here.
- Creative burden: low volume, long life (~4-6 weeks per asset) - a few days of work per asset cycle, well inside most teams' ceilings. The binding effort cost is the quarter of committed spend before a verdict, not the assets.
- Disqualified by: LTV below the floor; ICP not expressible in firmographic terms.

## Short-form video

- Creation. Fits broad B2C, younger-skewing audiences, and brands with real video capacity.
- Creative volume is the bottleneck, not media budget:
  - 10-20 creative variations per campaign.
  - Fatigue is algorithmic and can begin within 3-5 days at scale, before frequency reaches 2.
  - The fastest brands produce 200+ assets/month.
- Production anchor: user-generated-style video runs ~$150-$300 per asset; growth-stage brands typically invest ~$1,500-$5,000/month in creative.
- Effort: the heaviest standing creative job of any family here. A team that already shoots video in-house has an unfair advantage that moves this family several rows up the default ordering; a team that does not should read its position as generous.
- Disqualified by: static-only or low-volume creative capacity - this gate fails more plans than media cost does.

## Podcast / audio

- Creation via endorsement. US podcast ad revenue $2.862B in 2025 (+17.6% YoY).
- Measurability floor: ~$15,000+ spread across 3+ shows in multi-episode flights; pick shows above roughly 300-1,000 downloads/episode.
- CPM: host-read mid-roll $25-$50, pre-roll $15-$30, programmatic ~$15.
- Measurement runs on promo codes, vanity URLs, and self-reported attribution - plan them before booking.
- Effort: a quarter, most of it before any impression - show research, booking lead times, host-read script and claim review, and a measurement scheme that has to exist at launch. Booked flights are hard to pull back mid-run, so this family also carries the least reversibility.

## Connected TV

- Creation / brand. US-centric maturity: ~117M US connected-TV households in 2025; thin in many other markets.
- Entry:
  - $500/month self-serve tiers exist.
  - $5,000+ via programmatic DSPs.
  - $50,000+ for direct deals.

  One self-serve vendor recommends ~$165/day; run at least one month.

- CPM $20-$40 managed (settling near $25); ad-supported streaming tiers $15-$30.
- Production on top of media: $1,500-$5,000 to repurpose existing video; $15,000+ for a new 30-second spot.
- Measurement is structurally weak at the click level - plan incrementality/geo-lift from day one.
- Effort: a quarter, and uniquely front-loaded - the video production and the incrementality build both come due before the first readable result, which is why this family sits last in the default ordering despite a broad reach ceiling. An already-owned finished spot removes most of that and moves it up.
- Disqualified by: low-contribution products (the CPM plus production math rarely clears a sub-$50 contribution); non-US target markets with thin CTV penetration.

## Native / discovery - price-discovery bucket

- Creation, mid-funnel: paid placement inside content feeds and recommendation surfaces.
- Taboola sets no hard floor: its own budget guidance recommends 10x the target CPA or at least $50/day, enough for the algorithm to gather signal, and separately frames $300/day as the threshold to exit the learning phase and scale.
- Outbrain enforces a hard minimum of $20/day and recommends $100-150/day to gather enough data to optimize.
- Neither platform publishes an official CPC rate card. Third-party CPC estimates for both span roughly $0.03-$2.00+ and disagree substantially across sources - treat any cited CPC figure as directional only, not as a benchmark.
- Gate with the step 7 price-discovery test and the general test-duration guidance (display-class: 4-8 weeks) before committing real budget beyond the platform-published minimums above.

## Programmatic display - price-discovery bucket

- Creation and retargeting at low CPMs across open-web inventory.
- Amazon DSP is the only major platform with a published minimum: $50,000/month for managed service, with no published minimum for self-service since Amazon removed its self-service floor in late 2025.
- The Trade Desk and Google DV360 publish no minimum spend on their own sites. Practitioner-reported practical floors run $50,000-$1,000,000+/month depending on account structure and buying model - unverified against platform documentation, treat as directional only.
- CPM ranges commonly cited in industry sources: $1-$4 open exchange/broad targeting, $4-$12 private marketplace/targeted, $10-$25 for B2B firmographic targeting - all third-party aggregated, not platform rate cards.
- Post-tracking-changes reality: multi-touch attribution coverage industry-wide fell from 90%+ to ~30-60%, and display is among the hardest-hit - plan measurement accordingly.
- Judge over 4-8 week tests; avoid folklore numbers and run price discovery to establish real costs for this category and your ICP.

## Paid review listings - price-discovery bucket

- Capture, B2B software: sponsored placement on software review and comparison directories, reaching buyers mid-evaluation. "Often skipped, high intent" per B2B practitioner playbooks.
- G2's published entry tier: Starter at $299/month, or $2,999 for the first year rising to $5,999/year from year two. Professional and Enterprise tiers are quote-only.
- Capterra publishes a pay-per-click floor directly in its PPC service terms: $2/click minimum bid against a $500/month budget floor, second-price auction, bids move in $0.25 increments.
- TrustRadius lists its vendor "Customer Voice" package starting at $30,000/year - the widest spread of the three sites, and a sign that category and tier drive cost far more than any single benchmark can capture.
- Fits: B2B SaaS in categories buyers actively compare. Disqualified by: categories with no active review-site traffic.
reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness.Stars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependenciesStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is availableStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall