mbfinotti/advertising-skills / skills/ad-creative-fatigue
ad-creative-fatigue
VerifiedDecide whether a running ad creative is genuinely wearing out, or whether a confounder - budget change, learning-phase reset, audience saturation, auction CPM inflation, seasonality, tracking breakage - explains the decline, and return a verdict with confidence plus the highest-return remedy per unit of effort. Use whenever the user mentions creative or ad fatigue, wear-out, climbing frequency, dropping CTR, a rising CPA on an older ad, when to refresh creative, or whether to kill an ad - even if they never say 'fatigue'. Covers B2B and B2C across search, social, video, and native. Ends at the verdict: replacement creative belongs to mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-copy-variants and mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ugc-ad-scripts.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 31.4 KB |
| evals/evals.json | config | 38.7 KB |
| references/confounders.md | markdown | 9.8 KB |
| references/examples.md | markdown | 11.4 KB |
| references/signal-reference.md | markdown | 11.8 KB |
evals/evals.json
View on GitHub{
"skill_name": "ad-creative-fatigue",
"evals": [
{
"id": 1,
"prompt": "I run paid social for Lumo Home, a DTC home-fitness brand. Our hero static 'before-after-hero-v2' has been our best Meta ad for five weeks. Eleven days ago we raised the ad set budget from $600/day to $1,050/day in one step. Since then: link CTR 1.19% vs 1.38% before, CPA $44 vs $33, frequency 2.6 vs 1.8. The two other creatives in the ad set dropped the same way. Our growth lead says the hero ad is fatigued and wants me to brief two replacement UGC videos today. Can you confirm the fatigue read and help me plan the refresh?",
"expected_output": "A confounded verdict attributing the decline to the +75% budget step and its learning-phase reset, refusing the creative refresh and re-baselining at the new spend level.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Runs a confounder screen before issuing any fatigue verdict",
"Marks the budget/bid change confounder as failing, tying the decline onset to the budget step from $600/day to $1,050/day eleven days ago",
"Identifies the budget step as a significant edit that reset the platform learning phase",
"Cites all three creatives in the ad set declining together as evidence against fatigue, because fatigue is creative-specific",
"Issues a verdict of confounded, not fatigued",
"Refuses to brief or commission the two replacement UGC videos",
"Recommends re-baselining the creative at the new spend level after delivery stabilises, rather than judging it against the pre-increase peak",
"States that some efficiency loss at higher spend is the normal cost of scale, not decay",
"Treats the frequency rise from 1.8 to 2.6 as a lagging, confirming signal that cannot carry the call",
"Flags that the current comparison window overlaps post-edit volatility and requires a clean window after stabilisation before any future fatigue read",
"Delivers a structured verdict block containing at least verdict, confidence, action, and re-check fields",
"Sets a re-check date one full comparison window after delivery stabilises",
"Applies no universal frequency or CTR-drop threshold as justification for a verdict"
]
},
{
"id": 2,
"prompt": "Brightfern here, we sell skincare DTC. Our Meta cold-prospecting video hit frequency 3.4 this week and every guide I have read says to kill creatives at 3.0. Link CTR is 1.24% this week vs 1.21% for the trailing month, CVR is 3.1% vs 3.2%, CPA is up about 4%. I have a replacement video edited and ready to go. Should I pause the current one tomorrow morning and swap in the new one?",
"expected_output": "A healthy verdict that rejects the universal frequency-3.0 kill rule, explains frequency's structural flaws as a signal, and leaves the ad running.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Declines to call the creative fatigued",
"Rejects the universal 3.0 frequency kill threshold and states triggers derive from the creative's own trailing baseline and the account's own history",
"States frequency is a lagging, confirming signal that never carries the fatigue call by itself",
"Notes reported frequency is measured at ad or ad-set level while fatigue happens at creative level",
"Notes reported frequency is a period average, not the marginal effect of the next impression",
"Applies the two-signal rule requiring at least two signals, at least one leading, across two or more consecutive periods, and finds no decayed signal here",
"Reads the stable link CTR (1.24% vs 1.21%) and stable CVR as evidence the creative is healthy",
"Issues a healthy verdict and recommends leaving the ad alone",
"Distinguishes cold from warm exposure tolerance before reading the frequency number, citing the higher warm tolerance as an attributed practitioner heuristic rather than a rule",
"Advises against pausing or swapping the creative tomorrow; the ready replacement may enter as an additional test at most, not a substitution",
"Delivers a verdict block including a next scheduled review or re-check date",
"Does not present the frequency-3.0 rule as a platform rule or research finding"
]
},
{
"id": 3,
"prompt": "Peakform sells sports supplements. Our top Meta ad's numbers fell apart in the last ten days: CVR went from 3.2% to 1.1% while link CTR is steady around 1.4% and hook rate has not moved. The ad is seven weeks old so I assume it has just worn out. We also shipped a new checkout flow on the 2nd, and our 20%-off launch code expired around then, but the dev team says the release was minor. I need a fresh creative angle - can you help me figure out what the new ad should say?",
"expected_output": "A confounded verdict identifying a downstream funnel/offer problem (healthy CTR, collapsed CVR), with funnel checks instead of a new creative angle.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Identifies healthy CTR with collapsing CVR as the inverse of the fatigue signature, pointing at landing page, offer, or tracking",
"Issues a confounded verdict, not fatigued",
"Refuses to develop the requested new creative angle",
"Ties the decline onset to the checkout deploy and/or the expired 20%-off code dates",
"Recommends comparing conversion rate for other traffic sources hitting the same page",
"Recommends reconciling platform-reported conversions against the order system, checking for a stable ratio between the two rather than equality",
"Reports the confounder screen before reaching any fatigue conclusion",
"States that no creative refresh can fix a problem downstream of the ad",
"Recommends handing the structural or tracking root cause to an account-level diagnostic follow-up",
"States the fatigue signature for contrast: costs rise while conversion rate holds",
"Delivers a verdict block with confidence and re-check fields",
"Frames expected recovery as tied to fixing the funnel or offer, not to any new creative"
]
},
{
"id": 4,
"prompt": "Small B2B account here - Kindler & Co, we sell compliance training. Our Meta webinar-signup ad's link CTR was 0.95% over the last two days, about 8,000 impressions total, against 1.1% for the trailing two weeks. We got 3 signups this week vs 5 last week. Spend is about $70/day. My manager wants the creative killed and replaced by Monday because the data says it's done. Is he right?",
"expected_output": "An insufficient-data verdict backed by the sampling-noise band, refusing the kill and stating what extra data would clear the gate.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Applies the sampling-noise band p plus-or-minus 2 times sqrt(p(1-p)/n) to the baseline rate",
"Concludes the 0.95% read sits inside the noise band around 1.1% at roughly 8,000 impressions (band approximately 0.87%-1.33%), so the observed decline is noise",
"Notes two days of data fails the requirement of movement across two or more consecutive periods",
"Issues an insufficient data verdict",
"Refuses to recommend killing or replacing the creative by Monday",
"States the additional days, impressions, or spend needed before the noise band becomes narrower than the observed delta",
"Notes that 3-5 weekly conversions cannot clear the conversion floor for any CPA- or CVR-based claim",
"Recommends gating this low-conversion account on leading engagement signals and saying so in the verdict's confidence line",
"Warns that retiring a healthy creative on an underpowered read is the expensive false positive to avoid",
"Uses a moving-average comparison against the creative's own trailing baseline instead of comparing single days",
"Delivers a verdict block with confidence marked low and the gate math given as its basis",
"Sets a re-check date after enough data accumulates"
]
},
{
"id": 5,
"prompt": "Ledgerline - fintech, ABM motion on LinkedIn. Our matched account list renders about 38,000 members. We have run five sponsored-content ads for ten weeks. All five are decaying together - even the one we launched fresh three weeks ago, which fell to the pack's numbers within two weeks. CTR 0.29% vs 0.43% earlier, reach has been flat for a month while impressions keep climbing, frequency 7.8, demo requests down from about 6 a week to 2-3, and click-to-demo rate slid too. Leadership already approved budget for a full new creative batch from our agency. How many new ads should we brief and what angles?",
"expected_output": "A saturating verdict: the 38k pool is depleting, the fresh-creative test already failed on the same audience, so the remedy is audience expansion, not the approved creative batch.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Issues a saturating verdict, not fatigued",
"Cites all five creatives decaying together, including the fresh one, as pointing at the pool rather than the assets",
"Reads the fresh creative's failure to recover performance on the same audience as the discriminating test resolving toward saturation",
"Reads flat reach with climbing impressions as the platform recycling the same pool",
"Reads conversion rate degrading alongside engagement as the saturation signature, contrasting it with fatigue where CVR typically holds",
"Recommends audience expansion, list refresh, or exclusions as the remedy instead of new creative",
"Explicitly advises against briefing the approved new creative batch, stating creative work is wasted effort under saturation",
"Notes ABM and list-based audiences saturate by design, so B2B should expect saturating verdicts more often than fatigued",
"Gates confidence on leading engagement signals because single-digit weekly conversions cannot clear the conversion floor, and says so in the confidence line",
"Promotes audience expansion to the first action under the saturating verdict",
"Uses new-member reach or first-time-exposure trend as a leading saturation signal",
"Delivers a verdict block including the confounder screen results",
"Sets a re-check one full comparison window after the audience expansion"
]
},
{
"id": 6,
"prompt": "Trailnut, snack brand. Our Meta UGC video 'trail-taste-test' has run nine weeks and is still our volume driver. Over the last three weekly reads: hook rate 24% then 19% then 16%; hold rate at 15 seconds basically flat (9.1% vs 9.4% baseline); link CTR down about 20%; CVR stable at 2.8%. Hide/report rate has tripled vs our account norm. No budget, audience, or landing-page changes, and the deltas are way outside noise on about 150k weekly impressions. We have an in-house editor with spare capacity this week. My plan is to start over: brief an entirely new concept with our agency, about six weeks out. Sound right?",
"expected_output": "A fatigued verdict localised to the hook, prescribing a hook swap shipped as a new ad ID (because negative feedback is elevated) instead of the six-week new concept.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Confirms a fatigued verdict from two or more signals moving together across consecutive periods with the gate cleared",
"Localises the decay to the hook: hook rate falling while hold rate and CVR stay stable means the opening is tired, not the whole ad",
"Attributes the hook-fatigue framing to Ben Heath or labels it as a practitioner heuristic",
"Recommends a hook/thumbnail swap on the same body as the first action, ahead of any new concept",
"States the six-week new concept over-serves the evidence, being the highest-effort remedy reserved for an exhausted concept",
"Because negative feedback is elevated, requires the swap to ship as a new ad/asset ID, since the algorithmic penalty rides the asset ID and a hook swap on the same ID does not clear it",
"Instructs never to edit the live ad because edits reset learning and destroy the baseline; the swap launches alongside",
"Keeps the current ad running while the swap ramps, never pausing a producer with nothing staged",
"Assigns the hook swap to the in-house editor, matching its effort profile",
"States expected recovery as hook rate and link CTR back toward baseline on the same audience, which also confirms fatigue over saturation",
"Sets a re-check one full comparison window after the swap launches",
"Delivers a verdict block including the confounder screen and a confidence line",
"Positions iterating the winner, not the new concept, as the fallback if the hook swap fails"
]
},
{
"id": 7,
"prompt": "Norvane is a B2B SaaS running Google Ads. Our main RSA's Ad Strength dropped from 'Good' to 'Average' last week and our new account manager says that means the ad is fatiguing and we must rewrite all the assets this sprint. CTR and conversion rate have been flat for two months. The asset report shows nine assets at 'Good' or 'Best' and one headline stuck at 'Low' for five weeks. Do we rewrite everything?",
"expected_output": "Rejects Ad Strength as a fatigue signal, reads the flat CTR/CVR as healthy, and recommends replacing only the persistent Low headline based on asset performance labels.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Rejects Ad Strength as a fatigue or performance signal",
"States Ad Strength measures asset diversity and completeness, not performance",
"Cites Optmyzr's analysis finding 'Average'-strength ads with the best CPA/CVR as evidence",
"Points to the asset performance labels (Learning/Low/Good/Best) as the performance-based signal on RSAs",
"Recommends replacing only the headline stuck at 'Low' for five weeks, not a full rewrite",
"Labels any replacement cadence such as 2-4 weeks as practitioner advice, not a Google rule",
"Reads two months of flat CTR and conversion rate as no decay, yielding a healthy verdict for the ad overall",
"Refuses the account manager's full asset rewrite",
"Bases any future fatigue read on the ad's own trailing performance baseline, not on platform score movement",
"Delivers a verdict block with confidence and re-check fields",
"Does not recommend pausing or restructuring the RSA"
]
},
{
"id": 8,
"prompt": "Aurelia Waters is a premium bottled-water brand. We run a 60-second brand film on YouTube and Meta with a brand-awareness objective - we optimize for lift and view metrics, not conversions. Eight weeks in, view rate and our aided-recall survey numbers keep improving while frequency crept to 4.1. Our agency's policy is mandatory creative rotation every four weeks because all ads wear out, and they say we are overdue and risking burnout. Should we force the rotation?",
"expected_output": "A wear-in verdict valid because the objective is brand: leave the ad alone, refuse rotation on a frequency number or calendar policy, keep monitoring.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Identifies performance improving under repeated exposure as wear-in",
"Notes wear-in is a plausible verdict for brand objectives, attributed to Les Binet",
"Notes Meta's 2023 research found no wear-in for direct-response objectives, so the verdict is available only because this objective is brand",
"Issues a wear-in verdict and recommends leaving the ad alone",
"Refuses to rotate the creative on a frequency number",
"Rejects the agency's universal four-week rotation policy as not derived from this creative's own data",
"Verifies the improvement holds across multiple consecutive periods against the creative's own baseline",
"Still screens confounders such as seasonality, auction, or mix shift before accepting the improving trend",
"States the same improving read would be treated with suspicion if the objective were direct response",
"Delivers a verdict block with confidence and a re-check or monitoring date",
"Continues scheduled monitoring rather than declaring the creative permanently immune to wear-out"
]
},
{
"id": 9,
"prompt": "Fernwald Outfitters, outdoor apparel. Our Meta Advantage+ shopping campaign's CPA is up 22% over three weeks. We have 28 live ads that boil down to six concepts. Our head of growth wants a full creative refresh - all 28 replaced next month - because the campaign is fatigued. Our exports can go per-creative per-day. What should the refresh roadmap look like?",
"expected_output": "Rejects the campaign-average diagnosis, moves the analysis to per-creative and per-concept level with asset breakdowns under Advantage+, and refuses the blanket 28-ad refresh.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Rejects the campaign-level average as the unit of analysis",
"Requires analysis at creative and concept level, grouping the 28 ads under their six concepts",
"States that one or a few fatigued ads can drag the campaign average while most creatives stay healthy",
"Notes Advantage+ automated rotation silently shifts budget away from fatigued assets, masking per-asset decay, so asset-level breakdowns must be read",
"Flags a creative silently losing budget share with no manual change as itself a decay signal to check per creative",
"Adopts the offered per-creative per-day export as the working data granularity",
"Refuses the blanket refresh of all 28 ads",
"Builds each creative's own trailing baseline before judging any of them",
"Runs the confounder screen on the CPA rise before attributing anything to fatigue",
"Defers any fatigue verdict until the per-creative read is complete, or issues insufficient data at campaign grain",
"Treats CPA as a lagging signal and requires leading signals per creative before any call",
"Scopes the output to identifying which creatives, if any, need action rather than scheduling a wholesale refresh"
]
},
{
"id": 10,
"prompt": "Bexley Books, DTC bookseller. Our analyst's weekly deck shows our evergreen carousel fatiguing: every Monday we compare the last seven days against the prior seven, CPA is always up around 25%, and then the gap shrinks by the next pull. Mid-month we also moved the dashboard from 7-day click to 1-day click attribution to be conservative. CTR (all) is stable so engagement seems fine. Marketing wants a refresh plan for the carousel. What's the plan?",
"expected_output": "Identifies the decline as an attribution-lag artefact compounded by the attribution-setting switch and the all-clicks CTR read; no refresh, fix the measurement instead.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Identifies trailing-window attribution lag: the most recent days of any trailing window under-report conversions by construction",
"States every trailing window ends in an apparent decline, consistent with the gap shrinking on the next pull as conversions backfill",
"Requires both comparison windows to be lag-mature before any delta is read",
"Flags the mid-month switch from 7-day click to 1-day click as manufacturing an artificial decline and requires the same attribution setting on both windows",
"Rejects CTR (all) and requires link/outbound CTR, because all-clicks counts reactions, comments, and expands and can flatter a dying ad",
"Issues a confounded or insufficient-data verdict rather than fatigued",
"Refuses to produce the requested refresh plan",
"Recommends re-pulling the same windows after the attribution window closes to confirm the backfill",
"Runs the remaining confounder screen before any verdict",
"Requires the two-signal rule with at least one leading signal before any future fatigue call",
"Delivers a verdict block with confidence and re-check fields",
"Names fixing the measurement method - matched, mature windows on one consistent attribution setting - as the action"
]
},
{
"id": 11,
"prompt": "Glintwork sells jewelry. It is mid-November and our nine-week-old Meta prospecting video suddenly got expensive: CPA up 28% and CPM up 24% over three weeks. Link CTR is 1.35% vs 1.33% baseline and CVR is flat. The whole team is convinced the ad wore out right before Black Friday and wants an emergency two-week creative sprint. Green-light it?",
"expected_output": "A confounded verdict: CPM up with CTR flat is Q4 auction inflation, not wear-out; no emergency sprint.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Reads CPM rising while CTR holds flat as auction-side inflation, not creative wear-out",
"States CPM is diagnostic for fatigue only when paired with falling CTR",
"Attributes the cost rise to seasonal Q4/Black Friday auction pressure raising the price of every impression",
"Recommends comparing the creative's CPM trend against the account's other ad sets, and category benchmarks where available, over the same weeks",
"Notes stable CTR and CVR mean the audience responds exactly as before and each response simply costs more",
"Issues a confounded verdict",
"Refuses to green-light the emergency creative sprint",
"Notes auction inflation typically shows account-wide and industry-wide, not on one creative",
"Checks comparison-window composition for promo days and day-of-week match given the season",
"Delivers a verdict block with confidence and re-check fields",
"Treats any fixed CPM-inflation percentage threshold as unsourced folklore rather than a decision rule"
]
},
{
"id": 12,
"prompt": "Mapleworks, B2B HR software. Our main Meta lead-gen video looks genuinely done: link CTR down 27% and hook rate down 24% vs its own 30-day baseline across four consecutive weekly reads, about 180k impressions in the window so the deltas are far outside noise, CVR steady, and its spend share keeps falling with no manual change. Change history is clean - no edits since June, budget flat - the landing page is untouched, CPM is in line with our other ad sets, first-time impression ratio sits at 71%, and tracking reconciles with our CRM. Constraints: our board demo is in four days and the CEO wants the CPL bleeding stopped before it; our only other live ad is a static that performs fine; our video editor left last month; agency lead time is five weeks minimum; and legal is out this month so no new audience-list upload can be signed off. What do we do?",
"expected_output": "A fatigued verdict whose action ladder is pruned by the stated constraints: budget shift to the healthy static now, every deleted rung named with its deleting constraint, production staged for after the deadline.",
"files": [],
"expectations": [
"Issues a fatigued verdict from the supplied evidence: two leading signals across four consecutive periods, confounders passing, gate cleared",
"Deletes the rungs the constraints rule out rather than merely demoting them to the bottom of the list",
"Rules out the hook swap, naming the departed video editor as the deleting constraint",
"Rules out iterating and the new concept, naming the five-week agency lead time against the four-day deadline",
"Rules out audience expansion, naming the unavailable legal/lawful-basis sign-off",
"Treats rotation as limited to the single healthy static or rules it out for lack of a challenger bench",
"Selects a same-day surviving action - shifting budget toward the healthy static, optionally with a frequency-cap check - as the highest-ranked remaining rung",
"Keeps the still-profitable fatigued video running rather than pausing a producer with nothing staged",
"States the same-day action buys time and CPA protection, not a fix",
"Names every deleted rung with its deleting constraint on the verdict's ruled-out line",
"Does not recommend editing the live video",
"Recommends starting replacement production for after the deadline so the deleted rungs return as funded scope rather than silently disappearing",
"Delivers a verdict block with a re-check one full comparison window after the action"
]
}
],
"trigger_queries": [
{ "query": "Is my Facebook ad fatigued? CTR dropped 20% over the last two weeks", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our best meta ad is dying, do we need new creative?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "frequency on our prospecting campaign hit 4.2, should I rotate the ads?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "how do I know when an ad creative is worn out?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "CPA on our 8-week-old video ad keeps climbing, is the creative done?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "creative wear-out check on our TikTok campaign please", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "when should we refresh our ad creatives?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "Meta is showing 'creative fatigue' status on two ads, what now?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "this ad crushed it for two months and now it doesn't - why?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "same ad, same audience, same budget, worse results every week. what's going on?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "should I kill this ad or let it ride?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "the video that carried our account all summer suddenly costs twice as much per sale", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "hook rate on our top UGC ad went from 25% to 17%, is it tired?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "do I really need to refresh creatives every 2 weeks like my agency says?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our LinkedIn ads have been running 8 weeks and engagement keeps sliding", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "ad fatigue analysis for our holiday campaign", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "is rising frequency a reason to swap creative?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "CTR decay on a long-running search ad - fatigue or something else?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "my winning ad stopped winning, help me figure out if it's worn out", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "how long can one ad creative keep performing before it burns out?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our retargeting ads feel stale - people must be sick of seeing them", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "results tanked on an ad we haven't touched in 6 weeks", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "is it time to retire our hero ad?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "has our audience seen this ad too many times? how do I tell?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "ROAS on our oldest creative keeps drifting down month over month", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "diagnose whether this creative decline is real or just noise", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "my boss says the ad is burned out because frequency is 3.5 - true?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "when does ad wear-out actually start on Meta cold audiences?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "should we refresh creative before Black Friday or hold what's running?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "the same TikTok spark ad has run 3 weeks and delivery is trending down", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "CPL on our lead ad rose 30% but nothing changed in the account - is the ad spent?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our ad's thumbstop rate keeps dropping week over week", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "people are hiding our ad more than usual and results are dipping - worn out?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "how do I tell ad fatigue apart from audience saturation?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "is this creative decline just seasonality or actual fatigue?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "first-time impression ratio fell below 50%, do we have a fatigue problem?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "my Google RSA has run for 6 months - does search creative fatigue exist?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "which metrics actually prove an ad is wearing out?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "give me a keep, refresh, or kill verdict on this long-running ad", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our YouTube ad's view rate has slid three weeks straight", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "old ad is still profitable but declining - when do I pull the plug?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "conversion costs creeping up on an ad that's been live since March", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "I think our audience is tired of this ad but my cofounder disagrees - settle it", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "what's the right refresh cadence for our Meta creatives?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "here are weekly CTRs for our main ad: 1.4, 1.3, 1.1, 0.9 - creative fatigue?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "ad performance decay - how do I confirm it's actually the creative?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our agency wants to rebuild all creatives because performance dipped last week - overkill?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "why is my ad getting more expensive the longer it runs?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "ad ran great for 6 weeks, now CTR is down and CPM is up - worn out?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "should a still-working ad be rotated out preventively?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "how many weeks does a UGC ad usually last before it wears out?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "spend share of our best ad keeps shrinking even though we changed nothing", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "everyone's seen our ad already, right? reach flatlined", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "my ad is on a slow decline - is it the creative or the auction?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "is my ad wearing in or wearing out? numbers actually improved with frequency", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "getting worse results from the same creative in month 3 - is that normal?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "check if our top 3 ads are fatiguing", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "when a proven ad slips, how long should I wait before replacing it?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "the creative that used to print money is bleeding now - diagnosis?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "help me decide between refreshing the hook or making a whole new ad for a declining video", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our ad's cost per result doubled and Meta flagged it creative limited", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "banner has been in rotation 10 weeks on native placements - past its shelf life?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "customers keep seeing the same ad and I'm worried about burnout - what would the data need to show?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "one creative in the ad set fell off a cliff while the others are fine", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "prospecting video slowing down: fatigue call or budget issue?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "how do I baseline an ad so I can spot wear-out early?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "is a 25% CTR decline over 3 weeks enough to declare fatigue?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "ad performance dropped, nothing changed, audience is small - fatigue or saturation?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "our carousel's engagement halved since last month and it's run since spring", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "declining hook rate but stable hold rate on our main video - what does that mean?", "should_trigger": true },
{ "query": "score these five hook options before we launch the campaign", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "which of these three video openings deserves test budget?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "write 10 headline variants for our spring sale ads", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "turn this value prop into distinct ad copy angles", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "write a UGC script for our skincare brand's new serum", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "draft the replacement UGC video script for the ad we're retiring", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "put together a creative brief our designer can execute", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "brief for a short-form video shoot targeting gym owners", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "design an A/B test to compare our two new ad concepts", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "how much budget does a clean creative split test need?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our entire ad account's ROAS dropped across every campaign this month - find the root cause", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "audit my ad account, everything underperforms since the iOS update", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "are we pacing to spend our $60k monthly ad budget?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "we're underspending against the Q4 budget - fix the pacing", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our campaign is crushing it - how fast can I scale the budget?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "what's a safe weekly budget ramp for a winning ad set?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "what frequency caps should each stage of my retargeting sequence get?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "design a cart-abandonment retargeting funnel with exclusions", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "build a cold prospecting targeting plan for our SaaS", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "which interest and lookalike segments should we layer for launch?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "which customers should seed our lookalike audience?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "is 800 matched users enough for a value-based lookalike?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "Meta says 240 purchases, Shopify says 180 - reconcile the gap", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "why does the ad platform report more revenue than our CRM?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "verify our pixel isn't double-firing before we launch Monday", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "check conversion event dedup between browser and CAPI", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "is a $95 CAC acceptable for a $40/month subscription?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "benchmark our ROAS - healthy or not?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "ads get clicks but the landing page doesn't convert - audit the page", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "review my landing page for message match with the ad", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "carousel or video for a cold awareness campaign?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "which ad formats fit a lead-gen objective on LinkedIn?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "organize these competitor ads into a swipe file", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "catalog what competitors are running in the ad library right now", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "should we move from cost cap to bid cap on this campaign?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "pick a target ROAS bidding setup for our new campaign", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "we have 40 campaigns doing the same thing - plan a consolidation", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "merge these ad sets without resetting learning", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "split $50k monthly between Google, Meta and TikTok", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "how much of the budget should prospecting vs retargeting get?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "set a maximum allowable CAC policy for the company", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "define kill-switch spend thresholds for our paid program", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "mine our search terms report for negative keywords", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our search campaign matches junk queries - build exclusion lists", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "which paid channels fit a $3k/month budget for a B2B tool?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "is connected TV worth it for our audience?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "promote our CEO's viral LinkedIn post as a thought leader ad", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "plan a founder-fronted ads program from his organic posts", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "write copy for an ad slot inside an AI assistant's answer", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "map the buying committee for our six-figure ERP deal", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "how do I break into media buying as a career?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "review my performance marketing portfolio for job applications", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "write a job description for a senior media buyer", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "which PPC newsletters and podcasts should I follow?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "where do I start with paid ads for my startup?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "my email open rates have been declining for months", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "newsletter subject line fatigue - subscribers stopped opening", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our organic Instagram reach keeps dropping", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "SEO traffic to our blog has decayed since the core update", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "I'm creatively burned out as a designer, how do I recover?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "act as a creative director and set the visual direction for our rebrand", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our sales team is fatigued by the new CRM workflow", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our app store screenshots need a refresh - what converts best?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "website hero image has been the same for a year, should we change it?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our billboard has been up for 6 months - is OOH wear-out measurable?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "we made two new ads - which one should we launch first?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "estimate the sample size for testing a new hook against the control", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "how often should I post new organic TikToks to avoid follower fatigue?", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "set up automated rules to pause ads when CPA exceeds target", "should_trigger": false },
{ "query": "our push notification opt-outs are climbing - are we messaging too often?", "should_trigger": false }
]
}
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness. | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependencies | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is available | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |