Skip to content

mattgierhart/PRD-driven-context-engineering / .claude/skills/prd-v03-pricing-model

prd-v03-pricing-model

Verified

Select and validate pricing model for PRD v0.3 Commercial Model. Triggers on requests to set pricing, choose monetization model, design pricing tiers, validate willingness to pay, or when user asks "how much should we charge?", "what pricing model?", "freemium vs paid?", "how to structure tiers?", "price point?". Consumes Competitive Landscape (CFD-) and Product Type (BR-) from v0.2. Outputs BR- entries for pricing rules, tier boundaries, and competitive positioning.

FileKindSize
SKILL.mdskill md11.7 KB
assets/br-pricing.mdmarkdown5.9 KB
references/examples.mdmarkdown6.9 KB

references/examples.md

View on GitHub
# Pricing Model Examples

## Good Examples

### 1. Digital Signage — Flat Rate Undercut

**Context**: Digital signage SaaS targeting SMBs (cafes, restaurants, agencies)

**Model Chosen**:
- $5/screen/month flat
- No per-seat fees (unlike competitors at $20-40/screen)
- White-label tier at $100/mo base + $5/screen for agencies

**Competitive Input**:
- ScreenCloud: $20-40/screen/mo
- Yodeck: $8-15/screen/mo
- Most competitors also add per-user fees

**Why It Worked**:
- Clear price leadership (50-75% savings)
- Removed "SMB penalty" (unlimited users included)
- White-label created B2B2C distribution (agencies buy at $5, sell at $15-30)

**Transferable Pattern**:
> When targeting SMBs against enterprise competitors, flat pricing removes complexity and creates dramatic savings headlines.

**BR- Entry Example**:
```
BR-PRC-001: Per-Screen Flat Rate
Rule: $5/screen/month, no per-user fees at any tier
Rationale: 50%+ savings vs ScreenCloud creates price leadership
Evidence: CFD-XXX (competitor pricing matrix)
```

---

### 2. Asset Management — Location-Based vs Per-User

**Context**: Physical asset tracking for cafes, restaurants, trade contractors

**Model Chosen**:
- $9-15/location/month flat
- No per-seat pricing
- Offline mode included (not paywalled)

**Competitive Input**:
| Competitor | Model | 5-User Annual Cost |
|------------|-------|-------------------|
| UpKeep | $45/user/mo | $2,700/year |
| MaintainX | $21/user/mo | $1,260/year |
| Xenia | $99/mo (15 users) | $1,188/year |

**Why It Worked**:
- Calculated SMB penalty: $2,700/year vs $99/year = 96% savings
- Location-based makes sense for asset tracking (value per site, not per person)
- Avoided crippled free tier trap (MaintainX limits to 2 work orders)

**Transferable Pattern**:
> Calculate the "5-user annual cost" for per-seat competitors. If you can offer 70%+ savings with flat pricing, lead with price.

**BR- Entry Example**:
```
BR-CMP-001: Per-User Undercut Positioning
Rule: Marketing must lead with "$99/year vs $2,700/year" comparison
Rationale: 96% savings is the core value proposition
Evidence: CFD-XXX (UpKeep pricing page)
```

---

### 3. Freemium SaaS — Usage-Capped Free Tier

**Context**: Consumer product (HomeFalcon — home product management)

**Model Chosen**:
- Free: 5 products, 3 issues/month, basic features
- Pro ($19/mo): Unlimited products, all features
- Pro+ ($29/mo): Includes medical bills, insurance guidance
- Add-ons: $10/mo modules

**Why It Worked**:
- Free tier demonstrates value (hook) but has clear limit (5 products)
- Upgrade trigger is usage-based (run out of products), not artificial
- Add-on revenue creates expansion without tier complexity

**Transferable Pattern**:
> Free tier caps should hit naturally as user gets value. "You've added 5 products and HomeFalcon saved you $200 — upgrade for unlimited" is better than "Feature X is Pro only."

**BR- Entry Example**:
```
BR-PKG-001: Free Tier Product Limit
Rule: Free tier capped at 5 products, show upgrade prompt at product 4
Rationale: Enough to demonstrate value, triggers upgrade at success moment
Evidence: Competitor analysis — Notion does similar with blocks
```

---

## Bad Examples

### 1. Generic Clone Without Differentiation

**Context**: Review management tool copying BirdEye

**Model Chosen**: Matched BirdEye's feature set and pricing tiers

**Failure Mode**:
- Tried to match feature-for-feature (massive build scope)
- No price differentiation
- Competing against well-funded incumbent on their terms
- No niche focus (just "SMBs")

**What Should Have Happened**:
- Pick specific segment (restaurants only, not all SMBs)
- Cut features aggressively (not match them)
- Lead with price ($49/mo vs $299+/mo)

**Anti-Pattern**:
> Clone without differentiation = death. Must have execution edge OR become Undercut with niche focus.

---

### 2. Innovation Pricing on Fast Follow Product

**Context**: Physical therapy documentation tool

**Model Chosen**: Initially classified as Innovation (new market creation)

**Failure Mode**:
- Priced for "new category" when EMR tools already existed
- Required market education that wasn't funded
- Didn't anchor to existing budget lines

**What Should Have Happened**:
- Classify as Undercut (documentation tools exist)
- Position as "like [EMR] but built for PT at 60% lower cost"
- Use competitor pricing as anchor, not greenfield

**Anti-Pattern**:
> Don't use Innovation pricing (premium, value-based) when you're actually Fast Follow or Undercut. Customers won't pay "new category" prices for problems with existing solutions.

---

### 3. Consumer Innovation Without Budget Evidence

**Context**: Consumer advocate platform (new category)

**Model Chosen**: Freemium with $9.99/month premium

**Failure Mode**:
- No existing budget line for this category
- Required significant market education
- B2C innovation is extremely capital-intensive
- Unclear who the buyer was (consumers? businesses?)

**What Should Have Happened**:
- Validate budget exists before building
- Find proxy budget (what do consumers pay for similar outcomes?)
- Consider if B2B might fund B2C (white-label to insurance companies?)

**Anti-Pattern**:
> Innovation type requires very high confidence (85%+) and clear budget evidence. If you can't find existing spend in adjacent categories, the market may not exist.

---

## WTP Validation Examples

### Strong Validation (Tier 1-2)

**Landing Page Test**:
- 500 visitors from targeted ads
- 12% clicked "Start Free Trial" with $49/mo price displayed
- 3% entered payment info (even though trial was free)
- **Result**: Strong signal at $49 price point

**Pre-Order Test**:
- 200 email subscribers from content marketing
- Offered 50% discount for annual prepay
- 23 prepaid ($500 in validated revenue)
- **Result**: Tier 1 evidence — actual payment

### Weak Validation (Tier 4-5)

**Survey Only**:
- "Would you pay $49/month for this?" — 60% said yes
- But: Only 5% converted when landing page went live
- **Lesson**: Stated preference ≠ buying behavior

**Gut Feel**:
- "Competitors charge $99, so $49 should work"
- No testing of actual conversion
- **Lesson**: Competitor pricing doesn't validate YOUR WTP

---

## Pricing Pattern Library

### Pattern: The "Annual Upsell"

```
Monthly: $X
Annual: $X × 10 (17% savings)
Founding: $X × 8 (33% savings, limited time)
```

Rationale: Annual improves cash flow and reduces churn; founding creates urgency.

### Pattern: The "Usage Ceiling"

```
Free: 100 [units]/month
Pro: 1,000 [units]/month
Business: Unlimited
```

Rationale: Caps create natural upgrade moments tied to success.

### Pattern: The "Good-Better-Best"

```
Basic ($X): Core functionality only
Pro ($2X): Core + productivity features
Enterprise ($4X): Core + Pro + compliance/security
```

Rationale: Clear value steps, anchor effect makes Pro seem reasonable.

### Pattern: The "Flat Rate Undercut"

```
Competitor: $Y/user/month
Us: $Z flat (no per-user)
```

Headline: "Same features, [X]% less for teams of 5+"
brainstormingobra/superpowersYou MUST use this before any creative work - creating features, building components, adding functionality, modifying behavior, or planning anything new, in software or out of it (a talk, a business, a renovation).Stars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
brand-guidelinesanthropics/skillsApplies Anthropic's official brand colors and typography to any sort of artifact that may benefit from having Anthropic's look-and-feel. Use it when brand colors or style guidelines, visual formatting, or company design standards apply.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
frontend-designanthropics/skillsGuidance for distinctive, intentional visual design when building new UI or reshaping an existing one. Helps with aesthetic direction, typography, and making choices that don't read as templated defaults.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
mcp-builderanthropics/skillsGuide for creating high-quality MCP (Model Context Protocol) servers that enable LLMs to interact with external services through well-designed tools. Use when building MCP servers to integrate external APIs or services, whether in Python (FastMCP) or Node/TypeScript (MCP SDK).Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall