majiayu000/spellbook / skills/product-discovery
product-discovery
VerifiedProduct discovery and market research expert. Use when validating product ideas, conducting market research, user interviews, competitive analysis, or opportunity assessment. Covers JTBD, Kano model, and Value Proposition Canvas.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 13.0 KB |
| reference/competitive-analysis.md | markdown | 19.0 KB |
| reference/extended.md | markdown | 3.4 KB |
| reference/market-research.md | markdown | 15.2 KB |
| reference/opportunity-frameworks.md | markdown | 26.2 KB |
| reference/user-research.md | markdown | 23.2 KB |
| templates/discovery-template.md | markdown | 11.8 KB |
reference/competitive-analysis.md
View on GitHub# Competitive Analysis
## Competitive Analysis Frameworks
### Types of Competitors
```markdown
## Direct Competitors
Same solution, same market, same customers
Example: Slack vs Microsoft Teams vs Discord (for work)
## Indirect Competitors
Different solution, same problem
Example: Email vs project management tools (both for team communication)
## Substitute Products
Solves problem in fundamentally different way
Example: Uber vs public transit vs bike sharing
## Potential Entrants
Not competing today, but could enter your market
Example: Apple entering search (potential threat to Google)
```
---
## Porter's Five Forces
Comprehensive framework for analyzing industry competition. See [market-research.md](market-research.md) for full details.
```
THREAT OF NEW ENTRANTS
↓
SUPPLIER POWER ← INDUSTRY → BUYER POWER
RIVALRY
↑
THREAT OF SUBSTITUTES
```
**Use when:** Assessing industry attractiveness, strategic planning, investment decisions
---
## Competitive Positioning Matrix
### 2x2 Matrix Framework
```markdown
## Purpose
Visualize competitive landscape on two key dimensions
## Common Dimension Pairs
- Price (Low ← → High) × Features (Few ← → Many)
- Ease of Use (Simple ← → Complex) × Power (Basic ← → Advanced)
- Market Focus (SMB ← → Enterprise) × Specialization (General ← → Niche)
## Example: Project Management Tools
Many Features
↑
[Jira]
|
Simple ← [Trello] [Asana] [Monday.com] → Complex
|
[ClickUp]
↓
Few Features
## Insights
- Where are competitors clustered? (crowded space)
- Where are white spaces? (opportunity)
- How are we differentiated?
- Where should we move strategically?
```
---
## Feature Comparison Matrix
### Detailed Feature Analysis
```markdown
## Purpose
Compare specific capabilities across competitors
## Template
| Feature / Capability | Us | Competitor A | Competitor B | Competitor C |
|---------------------|-----|--------------|--------------|--------------|
| **Pricing** |
| Free tier | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ |
| Paid tiers | $10, $20, $50 | $15, $30 | $25 | $12, $25 |
| **Core Features** |
| Real-time collaboration | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Mobile apps | ✓ (iOS, Android) | ✓ (iOS only) | ✓ | ✗ |
| Integrations | 50+ | 100+ | 20 | 10 |
| API access | ✓ | ✓ (Enterprise only) | ✓ | ✗ |
| **Advanced** |
| AI features | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Custom workflows | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ |
| White-labeling | ✗ | ✓ (Enterprise) | ✗ | ✗ |
| **Support** |
| Email support | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Chat support | ✓ | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ |
| Dedicated CSM | ✓ (Enterprise) | ✓ (Enterprise) | ✗ | ✗ |
| **Non-functional** |
| Uptime SLA | 99.9% | 99.95% | 99.5% | No SLA |
| SOC 2 certified | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ |
| GDPR compliant | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
## Color Coding
✓ Green = We win
✗ Red = We lose
≈ Yellow = Parity
## Analysis Questions
- Where do we lead?
- Where do we lag?
- Which features matter most to customers?
- What's our unique differentiation?
```
---
## Competitive Intelligence Gathering
### What to Track
```markdown
## Product
- Features and functionality
- User experience and design
- Technical architecture
- Performance and reliability
- Mobile apps and platforms
- Integrations and ecosystem
## Pricing
- Price points and tiers
- Discounting strategy
- Free trial length and limitations
- Annual vs monthly pricing
- Enterprise pricing model
## Marketing & Positioning
- Messaging and value proposition
- Target audience and personas
- Brand identity and voice
- Content strategy (blog, videos, podcasts)
- SEO keywords and rankings
- Ad spend and channels
## Sales & GTM
- Sales process (self-serve vs sales-led)
- Sales team size (LinkedIn employees)
- Channel partnerships
- Customer acquisition strategy
- Geographic expansion
## Customers
- Customer count and growth
- Key customer logos
- Customer reviews (G2, Capterra, TrustRadius)
- Case studies and testimonials
- Churn signals (LinkedIn "ex-employees")
## Funding & Business
- Funding rounds and amounts
- Valuation
- Revenue (if public or disclosed)
- Team size and growth
- Key hires (executives, senior engineers)
## Product Roadmap
- Job postings (what they're building)
- Beta features and announcements
- Conference talks and blog posts
- Changelog and release notes
```
### Intelligence Sources
```markdown
## Primary Sources (Direct Observation)
### Product Analysis
- Sign up for competitor products (free trials)
- Use as customer would
- Document UX, features, performance
- Take screenshots and notes
### Customer Reviews
- G2, Capterra, TrustRadius
- App Store reviews (iOS, Android)
- Reddit, Product Hunt comments
- Twitter/social media sentiment
Look for:
- What customers love (strengths to match)
- What customers hate (weaknesses to exploit)
- Feature requests (unmet needs)
- Migration stories (why they switched)
### Customer Interviews
- Ask: "What else did you evaluate?"
- Why did they choose you over competitor?
- What almost made them choose competitor?
- What do they wish you had from competitor?
## Secondary Sources (Published Information)
### Company Information
- Company website (products, pricing, about)
- Investor presentations and earnings calls (public companies)
- SEC filings (10-K, 10-Q for public companies)
- Crunchbase (funding, valuation, employees)
- LinkedIn (team size, roles, employee backgrounds)
### Media & Content
- Press releases and news articles
- Blog posts and changelogs
- Conference presentations (YouTube)
- Podcasts with founders/executives
- Job postings (skills = technology, volume = priorities)
### Market Research
- Industry analyst reports (Gartner, Forrester)
- Market research firms (IDC, Statista)
- Trade publications
- Academic papers
## Monitoring Tools (2025)
### Competitive Intelligence Platforms
- **Crayon** — Tracks competitor websites, pricing, content, job postings
- Real-time alerts when competitors make changes
- Battlecards for sales team
- $$$
- **Klue** — Competitive enablement platform
- Aggregates competitive intel
- Distributes to sales teams
- $$-$$$
- **Kompyte** — Automated competitive tracking
- Monitors websites, ads, social media
- AI-powered insights
- $$
### DIY Monitoring
- **Google Alerts** — Free email alerts for keywords
- **BuiltWith** — Technology stack analysis
- **SimilarWeb** — Traffic estimates and sources
- **Ahrefs/SEMrush** — SEO, keywords, backlinks
- **Wayback Machine** — Historical website snapshots
- **RSS feeds** — Subscribe to competitor blogs/changelogs
### Social Listening
- **Mention** — Brand monitoring across web/social
- **Brand24** — Social media monitoring
- **Reddit search** — r/[industry] communities
- **Twitter/X** — Follow competitors, search mentions
```
---
## SWOT Analysis
### Framework
```markdown
SWOT = Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats
## Strengths (Internal, Positive)
What do we do well?
- Unique capabilities
- Competitive advantages
- Strong resources
- Market position
## Weaknesses (Internal, Negative)
What do we do poorly?
- Gaps in capabilities
- Resource constraints
- Negative customer feedback
- Areas competitors beat us
## Opportunities (External, Positive)
What external factors could we exploit?
- Market trends favoring us
- Competitor mistakes
- Regulatory changes
- Emerging technologies
## Threats (External, Negative)
What external factors could harm us?
- New competitors
- Market shifts
- Economic downturn
- Technology disruption
```
### SWOT Template
```markdown
# SWOT Analysis: [Product/Company]
**Date:** 2025-12-18
**Analyst:** [Name]
## Strengths
- ✓ Best-in-class AI features (unique differentiator)
- ✓ Strong enterprise customer base (40% of revenue)
- ✓ 99.99% uptime (better than competitors)
- ✓ Intuitive UX (4.8/5 on G2 vs 4.2 industry avg)
- ✓ Team has deep domain expertise (avg 10 years)
## Weaknesses
- ✗ Limited integrations (20 vs 100+ for competitors)
- ✗ No mobile app (major customer request)
- ✗ Pricing higher than competitors ($50/mo vs $30/mo)
- ✗ Weak brand awareness outside our niche
- ✗ Small sales team (5 AEs vs 50+ at competitor)
## Opportunities
- ⬆ AI adoption accelerating (plays to our strength)
- ⬆ New regulation requiring our type of solution
- ⬆ Competitor A raised prices (opening for us)
- ⬆ International expansion (Europe, APAC)
- ⬆ Partnership with complementary product
## Threats
- ⬇ Major competitor launched similar AI features
- ⬇ Open-source alternative gaining traction
- ⬇ Economic downturn reducing budgets
- ⬇ Apple/Google could enter our space
- ⬇ Customer acquisition costs rising (ads more expensive)
## Strategic Implications
### Leverage Strengths
- Double down on AI (our differentiator)
- Use enterprise customers for case studies/testimonials
- Emphasize reliability in marketing
### Address Weaknesses
- Prioritize mobile app (top request)
- Build top 10 integrations
- Introduce lower-priced tier for SMBs
- Invest in content marketing for awareness
### Pursue Opportunities
- Expand to Europe (GDPR compliance = strength)
- Partner with [Complementary Product]
- Create sales battlecard vs Competitor A pricing
### Mitigate Threats
- Accelerate AI roadmap (stay ahead)
- Highlight advantages vs open-source (support, security)
- Focus on retention to weather downturn
- Build moats (network effects, switching costs)
```
---
## Competitive Strategy Framework
### Differentiation Strategies
```markdown
## Cost Leadership
Be the cheapest option
Examples: Walmart, Ryanair, Canva
Pros:
✓ Clear value proposition
✓ Attracts price-sensitive customers
✓ Economies of scale
Cons:
✗ Race to the bottom
✗ Hard to sustain as company grows
✗ Vulnerable to even cheaper competitors
## Differentiation
Offer unique value that justifies premium price
Examples: Apple, Tesla, Superhuman
Differentiation types:
- Features (most powerful)
- UX (easiest to use)
- Support (best customer service)
- Brand (prestige, community)
- Performance (fastest, most reliable)
Pros:
✓ Higher margins
✓ Loyal customers
✓ Defensible position
Cons:
✗ Must continuously innovate
✗ Smaller addressable market
✗ Requires investment in R&D
## Focus/Niche
Specialize in specific segment
Examples: Shopify (e-commerce), Salesforce (CRM), Figma (design)
Pros:
✓ Deep domain expertise
✓ Less competition
✓ Loyal, engaged community
✓ Can charge premium
Cons:
✗ Limited market size
✗ Vulnerable to broader platforms entering niche
✗ Harder to scale
```
### Blue Ocean Strategy
```markdown
## Concept
Instead of competing in existing markets (red oceans),
create new market space (blue oceans)
## Framework: Value Innovation
Simultaneously pursue differentiation AND low cost
## Four Actions Framework
### Eliminate
What factors the industry takes for granted should be eliminated?
Example: Cirque du Soleil eliminated animals (expensive, controversial)
### Reduce
What factors should be reduced well below industry standard?
Example: Southwest eliminated seat selection, meals
### Raise
What factors should be raised well above industry standard?
Example: Cirque raised artistic production value
### Create
What factors should be created that industry never offered?
Example: Cirque created theme-based shows (vs traditional circus)
## Application to Product
### Example: Video Conferencing (Zoom)
Eliminate:
- Complex setup and configuration
- Need for IT support
- Expensive hardware
Reduce:
- Meeting room requirements
- Training time
Raise:
- Video quality
- Reliability (fewer dropped calls)
- Participant capacity
Create:
- Virtual backgrounds
- Waiting rooms
- One-click join
Result: Massive market expansion beyond enterprise to consumers
```
---
## Win/Loss Analysis
### Purpose
```markdown
Understand WHY you win and lose deals to competitors
Insights reveal:
- Your true differentiators (not what you think)
- Competitor strengths to address
- Product gaps to fill
- Pricing/packaging issues
```
### Process
```markdown
## Step 1: Identify Opportunities
Track every deal where you competed against someone
Data to capture:
- Deal size
- Industry/segment
- Competitors evaluated
- Win or loss?
- Close reason
## Step 2: Interview Decision-Makers
Within 30 days of decision (while fresh)
Questions to ask:
- "What were your top priorities in a solution?"
- "What impressed you most about [our product]?"
- "What concerned you about [our product]?"
- "How did [competitor] compare?"
- "What was the deciding factor?"
- "What almost made you choose differently?"
For losses, ESPECIALLY important to interview!
## Step 3: Categorize Reasons
### Why We Win
- Better features/functionality
- Superior UX/ease of use
- Better pricing/value
- Stronger support/services
- Trust/brand
- Faster implementation
### Why We Lose
- Missing key features
- Higher price
- Poor UX
- Integration gaps
- Weak brand
- Sales experience
## Step 4: Quantify and Trend
Track over time:
- Win rate overall
- Win rate by competitor
- Win rate by segment
- Top 3 win reasons
- Top 3 loss reasons
Example metrics:
- Overall win rate: 35%
- Win rate vs Competitor A: 45%
- Win rate vs Competitor B: 25%
- Top loss reason: "Missing mobile app" (40% of losses)
## Step 5: Take Action
- Update roadmap (address top loss reasons)
- Update sales battlecards (emphasize win reasons)
- Adjust positioning (lean into differentiators)
- Consider pricing changes
```
### Win/Loss Template
```markdown
# Win/Loss Interview: [Company Name]
**Date:** 2025-12-16
**Interviewee:** Jane Smith, VP Marketing
**Company Size:** 200 employees
**Industry:** B2B SaaS
**Deal Size:** $50,000/year
**Result:** ❌ LOSS (chose Competitor A)
**Competitors Evaluated:** Us, Competitor A, Competitor B
## Selection Criteria (Ranked)
1. Integration with Salesforce (Must-have)
2. AI-powered analytics
3. Ease of use
4. Price
5. Customer support
## What They Liked About Us
- "Your AI features were the most advanced"
- "Loved the UX, very intuitive"
- "Pricing was competitive"
## What Concerned Them
- "No native Salesforce integration (deal-breaker)"
- "Smaller company, worried about longevity"
- "Fewer customer references in our industry"
## Why They Chose Competitor A
- "Native Salesforce integration (our #1 requirement)"
- "Established brand, felt safer"
- "Had customers in our industry we could talk to"
## How Close Were We?
"If you had Salesforce integration, you would have won.
We preferred your product otherwise."
## Takeaways
- LOSS REASON: Missing Salesforce integration (must-have)
- DIFFERENTIATION: AI features, UX (we lead here)
- ACTION: Prioritize Salesforce integration on roadmap
- ACTION: Build more case studies in this industry
```
---
## Battlecards for Sales
### Purpose
```markdown
Equip sales team to compete effectively
Battlecards provide:
- Quick reference on competitor
- Our advantages vs theirs
- How to position against them
- Objection handling
```
### Battlecard Template
```markdown
# Battlecard: Competitor A
## Overview
**What they do:** Project management for teams
**Target market:** SMB to mid-market
**Pricing:** $15/user/month
**Strengths:** Easy to use, many integrations, strong brand
**Weaknesses:** Lacks advanced features, limited customization
---
## Our Advantages
### 1. AI-Powered Insights ✓
**Us:** Built-in AI suggests priorities, predicts delays
**Them:** No AI capabilities
**Message:** "We help you work smarter, not just organize tasks"
### 2. Advanced Customization ✓
**Us:** Custom fields, workflows, automations
**Them:** Limited to pre-built templates
**Message:** "Adapt the tool to your process, not vice versa"
### 3. Superior Reporting ✓
**Us:** Real-time dashboards, custom reports, exports
**Them:** Basic reports only
**Message:** "Visibility for stakeholders, not just task tracking"
---
## Their Advantages (How to Counter)
### 1. More Integrations (100+ vs our 20)
**Counter:** "We focus on deep integrations that matter (Slack, Salesforce, GitHub).
Our API lets you build any integration you need.
What integrations are must-haves for you?"
### 2. Lower Price ($15/user vs our $25/user)
**Counter:** "Our AI saves managers 5+ hours/week. At $50/hour salary, that's $250/week saved.
ROI pays for itself in days."
### 3. Bigger Brand
**Counter:** "True, they're well-known. But ask their users about [AI features, customization].
We're newer, which means we're building with modern tech and your needs in mind."
---
## Common Objections
### "We're already using Competitor A"
**Response:**
"That's great — they're a solid tool. What prompted you to look at alternatives?"
[Listen for pain points]
"We hear that a lot from customers who switched. The top reasons they moved to us were:
1) AI saves hours per week, 2) Advanced reporting for stakeholders, 3) Better ROI despite higher price.
Can I show you how [specific feature] would work for [their use case]?"
### "Competitor A has more integrations"
**Response:**
"Good point. Which integrations are critical for you?"
[Focus on integrations you HAVE]
"We support those! We prioritize deep, reliable integrations over long lists.
Plus, our API is robust — [Customer X] built their custom integration in a day."
---
## When to Position Against Them
- Deals with >50 users (our sweet spot)
- Teams that need customization
- Companies with technical resources (API integration)
## When NOT to Position
- Tiny teams (<10 users) → They'll choose cheaper option
- Non-technical users → Simplicity wins
- Companies with no budget → Not worth discount battle
```
---
## 2025 Competitive Intelligence Trends
### AI-Powered Competitive Tracking
```markdown
## New Capabilities
- **Real-time monitoring:** AI alerts within minutes of competitor changes
- **Automated analysis:** AI synthesizes competitor moves into insights
- **Predictive:** AI predicts competitor roadmap from job postings, traffic patterns
- **Sentiment analysis:** AI tracks social media, review sentiment trends
## Tools
- Crayon (AI battlecard generation)
- Klue (AI competitive insights)
- Kompyte (automated tracking)
- ChatGPT (analyze public data, SEC filings)
## Best Practices
✓ Automate data collection, humanize analysis
✓ Focus on strategic insights, not just data
✓ Share insights cross-functionally (not just competitive intel silo)
```
### Continuous Competitive Monitoring
```markdown
## Weekly
- Review competitor changelog/release notes
- Check review sites for new feedback trends
- Monitor social media mentions
- Track website changes (Crayon alerts)
## Monthly
- Update competitive feature matrix
- Review win/loss data
- Update sales battlecards
- Share competitive newsletter with team
## Quarterly
- Deep-dive competitive analysis
- SWOT update
- Porter's Five Forces refresh
- Strategic positioning review
```
---
## See Also
- [market-research.md](market-research.md) — Porter's Five Forces, TAM/SAM/SOM
- [user-research.md](user-research.md) — Customer interviews, surveys
- [opportunity-frameworks.md](opportunity-frameworks.md) — JTBD, Value Proposition Canvas
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| add-product-e2e-evalpaperclipai/paperclipAdd or extend a Paperclip full-stack runner E2E workflow, fixture, matcher, or report evidence path for local or Daytona execution. | Stars: 115k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| add-runner-evalpaperclipai/paperclipAdd or extend a Paperclip Runner protocol evaluation definition, roster, assertion, or report fixture with provenance and narrow validation. | Stars: 115k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| diagnose-why-work-stoppedpaperclipai/paperclipCompatibility entry point for failed, stalled, looping, or over-recovered Paperclip work. Use fix-failed-paperclip-run for the full diagnosis, regression, repair, real verification, and green-PR workflow; honor an explicitly requested diagnosis-only scope. | Stars: 115k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| fix-failed-paperclip-runpaperclipai/paperclipDiagnose and fix failed, stuck, slow, or incorrectly blocked Paperclip tasks and runs. Use with a task/run URL or failure report to trace the root cause, prove a regression red then green, check second-order effects, verify the real workflow, and deliver a PR with passing checks. | Stars: 115k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |