Skip to content

m3taz-ahmed/aizee / skills/bmad-advanced-elicitation

bmad-advanced-elicitation

Verified

Pushes a draft off its first answer with critique methods and proposes one revision. Use when the user or another skill names bmad-advanced-elicitation, or the user says "advanced elicitation". Not for a critique or a named method such as pre-mortem without that name.

FileKindSize
SKILL.mdskill md8.1 KB
assets/methods.csvother8.9 KB
bmod.tomlconfig122 B
customize.tomlconfig3.4 KB
evals/cases.jsonconfig6.1 KB
evals/files/pantry-pal.mdmarkdown1.2 KB
evals/files/prd-notifications.mdmarkdown3.2 KB
evals/files/rollout-plan.mdmarkdown1.3 KB
evals/triggers.jsonconfig3.1 KB
scripts/pick_methods.pyscript16.1 KB
scripts/tests/test_pick_methods.pyscript14.5 KB

assets/methods.csv

View on GitHub
num,direction,method_name,description,form,tier,aliases
1,wrong,Critique and Refine,Find the strengths to keep and the weaknesses to fix,"Strengths in two lines, then each weakness with its fix beside it",more,
2,wrong,Edge Case Sweep,"Try the extremes: empty, zero, maximum, malformed, the inputs happy-path thinking skips","A table of boundary inputs and what the draft does with each, failures marked",core,Boundary & Edge Case Sweep
3,wrong,Failure Mode Analysis,"For each part, how it fails and what that takes down","One line per component: failure, effect, how it is detected, how it is prevented",core,
4,wrong,Consistency Check,Restate the draft's claims and find where it contradicts itself or its own numbers,"Pairs of claims that conflict, with the one to keep and why",core,
5,missing,Stakeholder Lens,Each person the draft affects says what it owes them,"One stakeholder speaking in their own voice for a few lines, then what the draft owes them, located in the draft",core,Stakeholder Round Table; Stakeholder Lens Rotation
6,missing,Second-Order Thinking,Follow each consequence to the consequence it causes,"For each action: the first-order effect, what that effect causes next, what to do about it",core,
7,missing,Assumption Audit,"List every assumption, rate it, stress the weakest","A table of assumptions rated for confidence and impact, then the three weakest stress-tested",core,
8,missing,Expert Panel,"Several experts read it, each from their own field, without seeing each other","One expert's reading from their own field: what they see, what concerns them, and the change each concern calls for, located in the draft",core,Expert Panel Review
9,missing,Six Thinking Hats,"Facts, feelings, caution, optimism, creativity, process, one at a time","Six short sections, one per hat",more,
10,premise,First Principles Analysis,Strip the assumptions and rebuild from what is known to be true,"The assumptions stripped, the truths that remain, the approach rebuilt from them",core,
11,premise,5 Whys,"Ask why until the root cause, not the symptom, is in hand","The chain of whys, five deep, ending at the root cause and what changes because of it",more,5 Whys Deep Dive
12,future,Inversion Analysis,"Ask what would guarantee failure, then avoid it","A recipe for guaranteeing failure, then what the draft must do to avoid each step",more,
13,premise,Question the Question,Ask whether the stated problem is the real problem,"The stated problem, the better problem, and what the draft becomes if it solves that one",core,Reframe the Question
14,premise,Abstraction Laddering,"Move up for why and down for how, then pick the altitude","The draft restated one level up and one level down, and which altitude it should sit at",core,
15,simplify,Subtraction,"Improve by removing, against the habit of adding","What to remove, one line each with what is lost and gained, then the leaner draft",core,
16,simplify,Occam's Razor,Keep the simplest version that is still sufficient,"The competing versions, and the simplest one that still does the job",more,Occam's Razor Application
17,simplify,Adjust for Audience,Match depth and detail to who will read it,"Who reads it, what they need, and each passage that is too much or too little for them",core,Expand or Contract for Audience
18,simplify,Feynman Technique,"Explain it simply, every stall is a gap","The draft explained to a smart twelve-year-old, every place the explanation stalls marked as a gap",core,
19,simplify,Problem Decomposition,Split the whole into parts that can be solved alone,"The whole split into independent parts, each solvable on its own, the order to reassemble, and where the draft's split differs",core,
20,future,Pre-mortem Analysis,"Assume it failed, explain why","Written from after the failure: what went wrong, in order, and what in the draft made it likely",core,
21,future,Hindsight Reflection,Look back from after it worked,"Written from a year after success: what mattered, what did not, and what the draft spent effort on that never counted",core,
22,future,Cascading Failure Simulation,Break one thing on purpose and trace where the break travels,"One failure triggered, its path through the dependencies traced, the amplifiers and single points named, and what hardens each",core,Chaos Monkey Scenarios
23,future,What If Scenarios,Put the draft in situations it did not plan for,"Three scenarios the draft did not plan for, and how it fares in each",core,
24,other-side,Steelmanning,Build the opposing case at its strongest before answering it,"The opposing case argued as its best advocate would, then only what honestly survives",core,
25,other-side,Red Team,"Attack it as an adversary would, then harden it","An attacker's plan against the draft, step by step, then the hardening for each step",core,Red Team vs Blue Team
26,other-side,Devil's Advocate,"Press the case against, hardest where the draft is weakest","The case against, pressed hard, naming the point where the draft is weakest",more,Challenge from Critical Perspective
27,other-side,Socratic Questioning,Question until the draft cannot answer,"A chain of questions, each answered from the draft, until one it cannot answer",core,
28,wrong,Explain Reasoning,Show the steps from premise to conclusion and where one does not follow,"The reasoning laid out step by step, each step marked as given, inferred or asserted",core,
29,wrong,Code Review Gauntlet,Reviewers with different philosophies read the same code,"One reviewer's findings in their own voice, from their philosophy, each located in the code with its fix",more,
30,wrong,Performance Profiler Panel,"Database, frontend and operations specialists hunt the bottleneck","One specialist's suspects from their own layer, ranked, each with its evidence in the draft and the fix",more,
31,wrong,Source Triangulation,Demand three independent kinds of evidence before a claim stands,"Each claim with the evidence the draft gives for it by kind, a confidence rating, and the claims that stand on one kind alone",more,
32,premise,Comparative Analysis Matrix,Score the options against weighted criteria,"Options against criteria with scores, and the recommendation that falls out",more,
33,wrong,Map Is Not the Territory,Check where the model or diagram parts from the real system,"Each point where the representation and reality differ, and which to trust",more,
34,missing,Delphi Method,"Independent estimates with their reasoning, for the merge to compare","One estimator's figures with the reasoning behind each, and where the draft's own numbers differ",more,
35,missing,User Focus Group,The product's users react to it,"One user's reaction in their own words: what they would use, what puts them off, and what would change their mind",more,User Persona Focus Group
36,missing,Cross-Functional War Room,"Product, engineering and design settle the trade-offs together","One function's constraints, the trade-offs it can and cannot accept, and the changes it asks of the draft",more,
37,premise,Morphological Analysis,"List the parameters, the options for each, and the combinations nobody tried","A grid of parameters and options, then the untried combinations worth a look",more,
38,premise,Tree of Thoughts,"Follow several reasoning paths, then judge them","Each path to its conclusion, the judgment of each, and the one chosen",more,
39,premise,SCAMPER Method,"Substitute, combine, adapt, modify, put to other use, eliminate, reverse","One line per lens, with what it would change",more,
40,premise,Analogy Mapping,Borrow the structure of a problem already solved elsewhere,"The parallel domain, the mapping, and what it says about this draft",more,
41,premise,Reverse Engineering,Start from the end state and work back to the path,"The end state, the steps backward, the path forward, and where the draft's path differs",more,
42,premise,Constraint Injection,Add a hard limit and see what it forces,"The constraint added, what it forces, and what survives when it is lifted",more,
43,premise,Architecture Decision Record,"Options with their trade-offs, then the decision and its reason","Options, trade-offs, decision, rationale, and where the draft's choice or its stated reasons differ",more,Architecture Decision Records
44,future,Identify Potential Risks,List what could go wrong by category,"Risks by category, each with its mitigation",more,
47,other-side,Debate,"Each side argues alone at full strength, for the merge to weigh","One side's case argued at full strength against the draft's position, and the changes it would force",more,Debate Club Showdown
48,other-side,Investor Pitch,Pitch it to investors who ask about the moat and the numbers,"The pitch, the investors' hardest questions, and the answers the draft can and cannot give",more,Shark Tank Pitch
49,other-side,Thesis Defense,Defend it before a committee with different concerns,"Each committee member's challenge, the defense, what changes",more,Thesis Defense Simulation
50,other-side,Security Audit Personas,"Attacker, defender and auditor examine it from their threat models","Vulnerabilities, defenses, compliance gaps",more,
reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness.Stars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependenciesStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is availableStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall