paper-writer
VerifiedMedical/scientific paper writing workflow skill. Manages the full pipeline from literature search to submission-ready manuscript. Creates and manages a project directory with IMRAD-format section files, literature matrix, reference management, and quality checklists. Supports both English and Japanese papers. Triggers: 'write paper', 'paper-write', 'start manuscript', '論文を書く', '論文執筆', '論文プロジェクト', 'manuscript', 'research paper', '原稿作成'.
references/journal-selection.md
View on GitHub# Journal Selection Decision Framework
## Overview
Selecting the right journal is one of the most consequential decisions in the publication process. A poor choice wastes months in review cycles. This guide provides a systematic framework for evaluating and selecting target journals, with a focus on medical AI and digital health.
---
## Decision Criteria Matrix
Use this matrix to score candidate journals on a 1-5 scale for each criterion. The weights can be adjusted based on your priorities.
| Criterion | Weight | Description | How to Evaluate |
|-----------|--------|-------------|-----------------|
| **Scope Fit** | 5 (Critical) | Does the journal publish papers like yours? | Read last 12 months of TOC, check aims & scope |
| **Impact Factor (IF)** | 3 | Journal prestige and citation metrics | Check JCR, Scopus, or journal website |
| **Acceptance Rate** | 3 | Probability of acceptance | Check journal website, ask colleagues, estimate from submission volume |
| **Time to Decision** | 4 | First decision turnaround | Check journal website, ScholarOne stats, ask colleagues |
| **Open Access Options** | 2 | OA availability (full OA, hybrid, green) | Check journal OA policy page |
| **APC Cost** | 2 | Article Processing Charge for OA | Check journal website; typical range $2,000-$5,000 |
| **Readership/Audience** | 4 | Will your target audience read this journal? | Consider who needs to see your work |
| **Indexing** | 3 | PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science indexed? | Check NCBI, Scopus source list |
| **Reputation in Field** | 3 | How peers view the journal | Ask mentors, check conference citation patterns |
| **Page/Word Limits** | 1 | Does your paper fit the format? | Check author guidelines |
### Scoring Template
| Criterion | Weight | Journal A | Journal B | Journal C |
|-----------|--------|-----------|-----------|-----------|
| Scope Fit | ×5 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Impact Factor | ×3 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Acceptance Rate | ×3 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Time to Decision | ×4 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| OA Options | ×2 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| APC Cost | ×2 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Readership | ×4 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Indexing | ×3 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Reputation | ×3 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| Word Limits | ×1 | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ | _/5 = _ |
| **TOTAL** | **/150** | **__** | **__** | **__** |
---
## Journal Tier Strategy
### The Cascade Approach
Always prepare a submission cascade before your first submission. This prevents wasted time deciding where to go after a rejection.
```
Tier 1 (Reach) → Rejection → Tier 2 (Target)
↓ ↓
Accept! Rejection → Tier 3 (Safety)
↓
Accept!
```
**Planning Rules:**
1. **Tier 1 (Reach):** 1-2 journals above your expected level. Worth trying if the paper is strong. Budget 2-4 months.
2. **Tier 2 (Target):** 2-3 journals that regularly publish similar work. This is where you realistically expect to land.
3. **Tier 3 (Safety):** 1-2 journals with higher acceptance rates. Your paper should fit comfortably here.
4. **Never submit to more than one journal simultaneously** (this is considered misconduct).
5. **Reformat efficiently.** Choose journals within the same publisher family when possible (e.g., Nature → Nature Medicine → npj Digital Medicine all use similar formats).
### Timing Considerations
| Journal Tier | Typical First Decision | Full Review Cycle |
|-------------|----------------------|-------------------|
| Top tier (Nature, NEJM, Lancet) | 1-2 weeks (desk reject) or 2-4 months | 6-12 months |
| High tier (specialty flagships) | 2-4 weeks | 3-6 months |
| Mid tier | 4-8 weeks | 3-5 months |
| Lower tier / rapid review | 2-4 weeks | 1-3 months |
**Tip:** If you have a career deadline (graduation, promotion, grant renewal), work backward from the deadline and choose your cascade accordingly.
---
## How to Check Journal Scope
### Step 1: Read the Aims & Scope Statement
Every journal has an "Aims & Scope" or "About" page. Look for:
- Specific topics listed as in scope
- Types of articles accepted (original research, reviews, case reports, etc.)
- Methodological preferences (RCTs only? Observational OK? Computational?)
- Geographic or disease-area focus
### Step 2: Review the Recent Table of Contents
Browse the last 6-12 months of published articles:
- Are there papers with similar methods to yours?
- Is the target population similar?
- Are AI/ML papers included (for medical AI work)?
- What is the typical study design?
### Step 3: Check the Editorial Board
- Do board members have expertise in your area?
- Are there AI/informatics experts (for medical AI papers)?
- Is there geographic diversity?
### Step 4: Search for Similar Papers
Use PubMed or Google Scholar:
```
site:[journal-url] "your key methodology" OR "your key topic"
```
If you find 3+ similar papers published in the last 2 years, the journal is likely a good fit.
### Step 5: Use Journal Finder Tools
- **Elsevier Journal Finder:** https://journalfinder.elsevier.com/
- **Springer Journal Suggester:** https://journalsuggester.springer.com/
- **Wiley Journal Finder:** https://journalfinder.wiley.com/
- **JANE (Journal/Author Name Estimator):** https://jane.biosemantics.org/
Paste your abstract and get ranked journal suggestions.
---
## Red Flags for Predatory Journals
### Warning Signs
| Red Flag | Description |
|----------|-------------|
| Unsolicited email invitations | "Dear esteemed researcher, please submit your excellent work..." |
| Extremely rapid review | "Guaranteed acceptance within 7 days" |
| No clear editorial board | Board members cannot be verified, or are unrelated to the field |
| No clear peer review process | Vague or absent description of review procedures |
| Journal name mimics a legitimate journal | "International Journal of..." with slight spelling variations |
| No rejection rate mentioned or implied 100% acceptance | Legitimate journals reject substantial portions of submissions |
| APC demanded before review | Legitimate OA journals charge after acceptance, not before |
| Poor website quality | Grammatical errors, broken links, no ISSN |
| Not indexed in major databases | Not in PubMed, Scopus, or Web of Science |
| Scope is impossibly broad | "We accept papers from all fields of science and engineering" |
### Verification Checklist
- [ ] **Check Beall's List:** https://beallslist.net/ (list of potential predatory publishers)
- [ ] **Check DOAJ:** https://doaj.org/ (Directory of Open Access Journals -- legitimate OA journals are listed here)
- [ ] **Check PubMed indexing:** Search the journal name in NLM Catalog (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/nlmcatalog)
- [ ] **Check JCR / Scopus:** Does the journal have an Impact Factor or CiteScore?
- [ ] **Check COPE membership:** https://publicationethics.org/ (Committee on Publication Ethics)
- [ ] **Ask your mentor or librarian** -- they often know which journals to avoid
---
## Medical AI Journals Ranked by Relevance
### Tier 1: Top-Tier / High-Impact General Medical + AI
| Journal | IF (approx.) | Scope | OA | APC | Notes |
|---------|-------------|-------|-----|-----|-------|
| **NEJM AI** | New (high) | Clinical AI, regulatory, policy | Hybrid | ~$5,000 | Highest prestige for medical AI; very selective |
| **Nature Medicine** | ~80 | All medicine including AI/ML | Hybrid | ~$11,000 | Landmark AI studies; very competitive |
| **The Lancet Digital Health** | ~30 | Digital health, AI, telemedicine | Full OA | ~$5,000 | Premier dedicated digital health journal |
| **Nature Digital Medicine (npj)** | ~15 | Digital medicine, wearables, AI | Full OA | ~$3,000 | Growing rapidly; strong AI focus |
| **JAMA Network Open** | ~13 | All medicine (OA arm of JAMA) | Full OA | ~$3,000 | Broad audience; welcomes AI studies |
### Tier 2: Strong Specialty and Informatics Journals
| Journal | IF (approx.) | Scope | OA | APC | Notes |
|---------|-------------|-------|-----|-----|-------|
| **JAMIA** | ~7 | Medical informatics, clinical NLP | Hybrid | ~$3,500 | Gold standard for health informatics |
| **Journal of Biomedical Informatics** | ~5 | Biomedical informatics, NLP, ML | Hybrid | ~$3,300 | Methods-focused; welcomes technical work |
| **JMIR (J Med Internet Res)** | ~7 | eHealth, mHealth, digital health | Full OA | ~$2,500 | Fast review; large readership |
| **JMIR Medical Informatics** | ~3 | Health informatics, clinical decision support | Full OA | ~$1,800 | Good for applied informatics |
| **International Journal of Medical Informatics** | ~4 | Health informatics broadly | Hybrid | ~$3,500 | European-leaning but international |
| **BMJ Health & Care Informatics** | ~3 | Health informatics, AI in NHS | Full OA | ~$2,500 | UK/NHS focus but international scope |
| **Artificial Intelligence in Medicine** | ~7 | AI/ML methods for medicine | Hybrid | ~$3,300 | Strong methods focus |
| **npj Health Systems** | ~4 | Health systems, implementation | Full OA | ~$3,000 | Good for implementation studies |
### Tier 3: Solid Mid-Tier and Specialty Options
| Journal | IF (approx.) | Scope | OA | APC | Notes |
|---------|-------------|-------|-----|-----|-------|
| **JMIR AI** | New | AI in healthcare specifically | Full OA | ~$1,800 | New but growing; dedicated AI focus |
| **Digital Health (SAGE)** | ~3 | Digital health broadly | Full OA | ~$1,500 | Accessible; fast turnaround |
| **Frontiers in Digital Health** | ~3 | Digital health, AI | Full OA | ~$2,000 | Fast review; open access |
| **BMC Medical Informatics & Decision Making** | ~3 | Informatics, clinical decision support | Full OA | ~$2,500 | Solid, well-indexed |
| **Health Informatics Journal** | ~3 | Health informatics | Hybrid | ~$2,800 | Good for applied studies |
| **Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine** | ~6 | Computational methods in biomedicine | Hybrid | ~$3,000 | Methods-heavy; technical audience |
| **PLOS Digital Health** | New | Digital health, equity | Full OA | ~$2,000 | Open data friendly |
| **medRxiv / arXiv** | N/A | Preprints | Free | Free | Not peer-reviewed; use for priority claims |
### Specialty Medical Journals That Accept AI Papers
If your AI work is disease-specific, consider the flagship journal of that specialty:
| Specialty | Journal | Notes |
|-----------|---------|-------|
| Radiology | Radiology: AI, European Radiology | Strong AI track record |
| Pathology | Modern Pathology, Lab Investigation | Computational pathology welcome |
| Ophthalmology | Ophthalmology, JAMA Ophthalmology | Retinal AI well established |
| Dermatology | British Journal of Dermatology | Skin image classification papers |
| Cardiology | European Heart Journal - Digital Health | Dedicated digital cardiology |
| Oncology | JCO Clinical Cancer Informatics | Cancer informatics focus |
| Emergency Medicine | Annals of Emergency Medicine | Clinical prediction models |
| Primary Care | BJGP, Annals of Family Medicine | AI for primary care |
---
## Journal Comparison Recording Template
Use this template to document your journal evaluation and cascade plan.
### Paper Information
- **Working Title:** [Your paper title]
- **Paper Type:** [Original research / Review / Case report / etc.]
- **Key Topics:** [e.g., LLM, patient education, systematic review]
- **Target Audience:** [e.g., clinical informaticians, general physicians, AI researchers]
- **Word Count:** [Current word count]
- **Deadline Pressure:** [None / Moderate / Urgent -- specify date if applicable]
### Cascade Plan
| Priority | Journal Name | Tier | Scope Fit (1-5) | IF | Time to Decision | Status |
|----------|-------------|------|-----------------|-----|-----------------|--------|
| 1st choice | | Reach | /5 | | | Not submitted |
| 2nd choice | | Target | /5 | | | |
| 3rd choice | | Target | /5 | | | |
| 4th choice | | Safety | /5 | | | |
### Decision Log
| Date | Journal | Action | Outcome | Notes |
|------|---------|--------|---------|-------|
| | | Submitted | | |
| | | Decision received | | |
| | | Revised & resubmitted | | |
| | | Accepted/Rejected | | |
### Notes
[Free-form notes about journal selection decisions, mentor feedback, etc.]
---
## Quick Reference: Journal Selection Flowchart
```
Start: What kind of paper is it?
│
├─ Clinical AI with patient outcomes
│ ├─ Large RCT/prospective study → NEJM AI, Lancet Digital Health, Nature Medicine
│ ├─ Retrospective/observational → JAMA Network Open, npj Digital Medicine
│ └─ Pilot/feasibility study → JMIR, Digital Health, BMC Med Inform
│
├─ AI/ML methodology for medicine
│ ├─ Novel architecture/algorithm → Nature Machine Intelligence, AI in Medicine
│ ├─ Applied ML with clinical data → JAMIA, J Biomed Inform, JMIR Med Inform
│ └─ NLP/LLM in healthcare → JAMIA, JMIR AI, J Biomed Inform
│
├─ Systematic review / meta-analysis
│ ├─ Broad clinical AI topic → Lancet Digital Health, npj Digital Medicine
│ ├─ Informatics-focused → JAMIA, Int J Med Inform
│ └─ Methodology-focused → J Biomed Inform, Comp Methods Programs Biomed
│
├─ Digital health / mHealth / telemedicine
│ ├─ Large-scale deployment → Lancet Digital Health, JAMA Network Open
│ ├─ App evaluation / usability → JMIR mHealth, Digital Health
│ └─ Implementation science → npj Health Systems, BMJ Health Care Inform
│
└─ Disease-specific AI application
└─ Consider specialty journal first (see table above), then general AI journals
```
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| writing-skillsobra/superpowersUse when creating new skills, editing existing skills, or verifying skills work before deployment | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| xlsxanthropics/skillsUse this skill any time a spreadsheet file is the primary input or output. This means any task where the user wants to: open, read, edit, or fix an existing .xlsx, .xlsm, .xltx, .csv, or .tsv file (e.g., adding columns, computing formulas, formatting, charting, cleaning messy data); create a new spreadsheet from scratch or from other data sources; or convert between tabular file formats. Trigger especially when the user references a spreadsheet file by name or path — even casually (like "the xlsx in my downloads") — and wants something done to it or produced from it. Also trigger for cleaning or restructuring messy tabular data files (malformed rows, misplaced headers, junk data) into proper spreadsheets. The deliverable must be a spreadsheet file. Do NOT trigger when the primary deliverable is a Word document, HTML report, standalone Python script, database pipeline, or Google Sheets API integration, even if tabular data is involved. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| shipping-and-launchaddyosmani/agent-skillsPrepares production launches. Use when preparing to deploy to production, or when asking what needs to be in place before shipping. Use when you need a pre-launch checklist, when setting up monitoring, when planning a staged rollout, or when you need a rollback strategy. | Stars: 119k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| childhoodthedotmack/claude-memBabysit a shipped release after merge, publication, or deployment. Verify published packages, production behavior, installed plugins, and late CI or user reports until the observation window is clean; use babysit for PR readiness before release. | Stars: 118k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |