kelegele/oh-my-pm / skills/competitive-analysis
competitive-analysis
Verified竞品功能对比分析,生成对比矩阵并识别战略机会。当用户提到竞品、竞品研究、功能对比、"竞品有什么"、"对比XX产品"、市场定位,或需要了解竞争格局时使用。即使没有明确说"竞品分析",当用户明显在评估自己产品与竞品差异时也应激活。 Also triggers on: competitive analysis, what do competitors offer, compare X products, feature comparison.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 7.0 KB |
SKILL.md
View on GitHub---
name: competitive-analysis
description: '竞品功能对比分析,生成对比矩阵并识别战略机会。当用户提到竞品、竞品研究、功能对比、"竞品有什么"、"对比XX产品"、市场定位,或需要了解竞争格局时使用。即使没有明确说"竞品分析",当用户明显在评估自己产品与竞品差异时也应激活。 Also triggers on: competitive analysis, what do competitors offer, compare X products, feature comparison.'
layer: perception
input-from: market-research
output-to: product-strategy,prd-gen
---
# Competitive Analysis
## When to Use
- User mentions competitor names or asks "what do competitors offer" (e.g. "What features do ClickUp and Asana have that we don't?")
- Comparing features between products ("does X have feature Y?", "Do competitors offer dark mode?")
- Evaluating market differentiation for a new feature, or preparing product positioning / strategy documents
- User says things like "competitive analysis", "market research", "competitor comparison" (e.g. "How does our pricing compare to Stripe and Braintree?" → `feature_focus="pricing"`)
## Execution Methodology
本 skill 生成竞品情报:竞品有什么功能、强在哪里、差异化机会在哪里,输出服务于功能优先级排序与产品定位。具体执行方法论(竞品识别与映射、多源采集与交叉验证、对比矩阵构建与 parity 评分、差距分析与战略机会识别框架、各 `analysis_depth` 的执行细节、Markdown 报告模板):独立使用时按本文件契约执行并输出;Claude Code 宿主由 `competitive-analyst` subagent 承载,见末尾 Execution Profile。
## Anti-Hallucination Rules (Self-Contained)
The following rules are mandatory for this skill. They are inlined here for standalone installation compatibility.
### 1. Mandatory Search First
输出任何竞品数据前必须先使用 WebSearch/WebReader 访问竞品官网或文档。
- 禁止仅凭训练记忆输出任何具体数据(功能列表、定价、用户数据等)
- 每个数据点必须来自实际搜索和访问的页面
- 搜索查询应包含年份,例如 `Notion pricing 2025 2026`
### 2. Every Claim Must Have a Source
每个功能声明、定价、用户评价必须有 URL 来源。
- **没有来源 = 不得写入**
- 来源格式:`{ "claim": "...", "source": "https://...", "source_name": "...", "fetched_at": "..." }`
### 3. Unknown is Acceptable
无法确认的功能标注 "Unknown",禁止编造。标注未知是诚实,不是失败。
### 4. Confidence Rating
每个功能声明标注 confidence (high/medium/low)。
- `high`: 官方文档、财报、权威报告
- `medium`: 竞品官网、行业报告、可靠媒体
- `low`: 社区讨论、博客、推测性分析
### 5. Distinguish Fact from Inference
明确区分已验证功能和推断。推断必须标注 basis 和 confidence。
### 6. Quality Gate (Non-negotiable)
以下任一条未满足,不得输出结果:
- [ ] 所有具体功能/定价/趋势声明都有来源 URL
- [ ] 无法验证的数据已标注 "Unknown"
- [ ] 每个数据点标注了 confidence 等级
- [ ] facts 和 inferences 已明确区分
- [ ] 搜索记录已附在输出中
### Search Record
每个分析输出必须附带搜索记录:`{ "search_queries_used": [...], "sources_accessed": [{ "url": "...", "title": "...", "used_for": "..." }] }`
## Input Parameters
| Parameter | Type | Required | Description |
|:---|:---|:---|:---|
| `competitors` | list | Yes | Competitor products or company names to analyze |
| `feature_focus` | string | No | Specific feature area to focus on (e.g., "pricing", "user management") |
| `analysis_depth` | string | No | `overview` (quick), `detailed` (standard, default), or `deep-dive` (comprehensive) — 各深度执行细节由 agent 承载 |
## Output Structure
1. **JSON file** (`docs/product/.ompm/competitive-analysis.json`) - Structured data for other skills to consume
2. **Markdown report** - Human-readable analysis; 至少包含 Overview、Feature Comparison Matrix、Gap Analysis(Missing Features / Unique Advantages)、Strategic Recommendations(short/medium/long-term)四节,完整模板由 agent 承载
### JSON Output Format
```json
{
"analyses": [{
"id": "uuid",
"timestamp": "2026-03-11T...",
"competitors": ["Competitor A", "Competitor B"],
"feature_matrix": {
"Feature 1": {
"our_product": "supported",
"competitor_a": { "status": "supported", "confidence": "high", "source": { "url": "https://competitor-a.com/features", "fetched_at": "2026-03-11T..." } },
"competitor_b": { "status": "partial", "confidence": "high", "source": { "url": "https://competitor-b.com/pricing", "fetched_at": "2026-03-11T..." } }
}
},
"gaps": {
"missing_features": [
{ "feature": "Feature X", "supported_by": ["Competitor A", "Competitor B"], "confidence": "high" }
],
"unique_advantages": [
{ "feature": "Feature Z", "confidence": "medium", "basis": "No competitor found offering this" }
]
},
"opportunities": [{ "opportunity": "Opportunity 1", "confidence": "medium", "basis": "..." }],
"recommendations": [{ "recommendation": "Recommendation 1", "priority": "high" }]
}],
"search_record": {
"search_queries_used": ["Competitor A features 2026", "Competitor B pricing page"],
"sources_accessed": [{ "url": "https://...", "title": "Competitor A Features", "used_for": "feature verification" }]
},
"last_updated": "2026-03-11T..."
}
```
## Quality Standards
- Cover at least 2 competitors and compare 5+ core feature areas
- Provide 3+ actionable recommendations based on real data
- Distinguish between "missing features" and "strategic omissions"
- Be valid JSON for downstream skills to consume
- Pass the Anti-Hallucination Quality Gate above (source URLs, confidence ratings, "Unknown" marking, fact/inference separation, search record)
## Context Integration
- **Reads:** `docs/product/.ompm/market-analysis.json` - Market trends that inform competitive landscape
- **Writes:** `docs/product/.ompm/competitive-analysis.json` - Analysis results for other skills (prd-gen, product-strategy); `docs/product/competitive-analysis/{feature-name}-{date}.md` - Human-readable markdown report (versioned artifact)
## Execution Profile (执行建议)
- **模型建议**:标准(sonnet 级)——宿主支持多模型/子代理时按此分配;单模型宿主忽略
- **工具姿态**:读写 + 联网搜索——遵循最小权限
- **记忆文件**:`docs/product/.ompm/memory/competitive-analysis.md`——跨会话积累经验(优质信源、领域基线、分析框架);执行开始时读取、结束时更新;文件不存在则新建
- **Claude Code 增强**:本 profile 在该宿主由 competitive-analyst subagent 以隔离上下文实现
## 下一步
本 skill 完成后,如果用户没有明确下一步,引导用户使用 ompm skill 做意图路由——它会读取本轮产出和当前状态,判断最有价值的下一步。不要替用户预设固定长链;output-to 声明的是数据流向,不是强制路径。
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |