Skip to content

JasonColapietro/suede-creator-skills / skills/suede-marketing-plan

suede-marketing-plan

Verified

Suede Marketing Planning Skills: a scored tactic shortlist or a full AARRR operating plan with a 90-day plan, 12-month roadmap, and measurement. Use when asked "what should we try next" or for a marketing plan grounded in budget, capacity, and evidence. NOT FOR: channel execution, contested bets (suede-marketing-council), recurring loops (suede-marketing-loops), or positioning alone (suede-product-marketing).

references/current-state-rubric.md

View on GitHub
# Current State Rubric: 17-Section Scoring Lens

This 17-section rubric is the source of truth for Section 3 ("Current State") of every marketing plan. Score each section 0–5 from available materials, then write a 2–4 sentence "shape interpretation" that names where strengths and gaps cluster.

## How to score

**From rich materials.** When the team has shared decks, prior content audits,
a brand voice doc, kickoff transcript, app store and analytics snapshots, score
only what those artifacts currently support. Mark the source, capture date,
client or cohort scope, and metric definition beside every score.

**From a separately scored audit.** Treat a prior assessment as an evidence
input, not automatic ground truth. Record its date and scope, verify that its
underlying sources and definitions still match the current client state, and
rescore or mark unknown where they do not.

**Evidence gate for every score.** A score of 0, 2, 4, 5, or any intermediate
value requires a current, client-specific source or a clearly identified cohort
source that matches the client context. Record:

- source and capture date;
- client, surface, segment, and cohort/window;
- metric or judgment definition;
- observed evidence and counterevidence;
- confidence and unresolved data-quality limits.

Use `Unknown: evidence required` rather than converting missing access,
intentional inactivity, company stage, or an external benchmark into a numeric
score. Do not include unknown sections in the denominator. The score-guide
language below describes evidence states; it never substitutes for cited
client or cohort evidence.

The output is a 17-row table with evidence citations, a denominator that
reflects scored sections, and a shape paragraph that distinguishes facts from
hypotheses.

## The 17 sections (scored 0–5 each)

### 1. Positioning
**What's scored:** Clarity of category claim, differentiation, alignment across surfaces (homepage, app store, pitch deck, founder messaging).

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No positioning anywhere
- 2 = Inconsistent across surfaces; team can't articulate it on demand
- 4 = Clear, original, mostly consistent; minor surface gaps
- 5 = Distinctive, category-defining, every surface aligned

**Maps to AARRR:** Cross-cutting: feeds every stage.

### 2. Customer research
**What's scored:** Depth and recency of customer research, ICP clarity, voice-of-customer capture.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No formal research, only founder intuition
- 2 = Some research but stale or one-off
- 4 = Active research practice, customer language captured
- 5 = Continuous research, customer language flows into copy / product / messaging

**Maps to AARRR:** Cross-cutting: feeds especially Acquisition (channel choice) and Activation (onboarding voice).

### 3. Homepage
**What's scored:** Headline clarity, voice alignment, conversion architecture, mobile experience.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = Generic / broken / off-brand
- 2 = Functional but underperforming; voice mostly absent
- 4 = Clear, voice-aligned, converting; minor optimization opportunities
- 5 = Distinctive, converts strongly, fully voice-aligned

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition + Activation.

### 4. Sales / product pages
**What's scored:** Existence and quality of dedicated product / pricing / feature pages. Are SKUs documented? Is pricing scannable? Are upsells visible?

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No dedicated pages
- 2 = Pages exist but are stale or off-voice
- 4 = Quality pages for primary products; gaps on secondary
- 5 = Every product, tier, and upsell has a high-converting page

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition + Revenue.

### 5. Conversion pages
**What's scored:** Landing pages for specific campaigns, channels, or use cases. `/partner`, `/science`, `/ambassadors`, `/eye-mask` types of pages.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No conversion pages
- 2 = One or two exist; rest of needed pages missing
- 4 = Most needed conversion pages exist; quality is good
- 5 = Full conversion page library, each high-converting

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition + Activation.

### 6. Competitor comparison
**What's scored:** Existence of "vs. {competitor}" pages, comparison content. Does the brand acknowledge alternatives, or pretend they don't exist?

**Score guide:**
- 0 = Nothing: actively avoiding competitor mentions
- 2 = Some content exists but is weak or hidden
- 4 = Solid comparison pages for top 2–3 competitors
- 5 = Comprehensive comparison library; SEO-targeted; high-converting

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition (consideration-stage SEO + sales enablement).

### 7. Resources / content
**What's scored:** Blog, knowledge base, science page, whitepapers, research, founder essays, podcast.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No content surface
- 2 = Blog exists but is stale or thin
- 4 = Active content production; multiple formats
- 5 = Content is a moat: proprietary research, named pillars, daily volume

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition.

### 8. Onboarding
**What's scored:** New user onboarding (in-app + email). Time-to-value, completion rate, brand-voice alignment.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No onboarding flow
- 2 = Onboarding exists but is broken, off-voice, or underperforming
- 4 = Solid onboarding; clear bottlenecks identified
- 5 = Instrumented and tested against a dated client baseline; the
  pre-registered decision rule is met; brand review is recorded

**Maps to AARRR:** Activation.

### 9. Email lifecycle
**What's scored:** Existence and quality of lifecycle email programs. Welcome / onboarding / post-purchase / lapsed / win-back.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No lifecycle email
- 2 = Some flows exist but drafted not live, or live but stale
- 4 = Core flows live and performing; gaps on secondary flows
- 5 = Required lifecycle coverage is live and segmented; performance is traced
  to dated cohort baselines or a cited, cohort-matched external comparator

**Maps to AARRR:** Retention (+ Activation for onboarding emails).

### 10. Sales material
**What's scored:** Sales decks, one-pagers, demos, case studies, pricing sheets. (For B2B / hybrid companies: for pure D2C, this can be marked N/A or scored low without implication.)

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No sales material
- 2 = Founder uses a deck but other material is thin
- 4 = Solid sales kit; reps can self-serve content
- 5 = Required material is complete, versioned to the current offer, accessible
  to its owners, and includes evidence-backed objection handling

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition + Revenue (B2B).

### 11. Messaging
**What's scored:** Voice, tone, vocabulary, message hierarchy across surfaces. Is the brand voice documented, consistent, distinctive?

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No voice documented; surfaces inconsistent
- 2 = Voice exists in founder's head but isn't operationalized
- 4 = Documented voice; mostly consistent across surfaces
- 5 = Distinctive voice; documented; every surface respects it; voice is a moat

**Maps to AARRR:** Cross-cutting.

### 12. Pricing
**What's scored:** Pricing structure clarity, packaging logic, recent pressure-testing, listed vs. effective price reconciliation.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = Current client sources show no reconciled pricing or packaging decision
  record and no usable realized-price evidence
- 2 = Dated listed and realized prices exist, but plan mix, discounting,
  margin, retention, or cohort definitions remain unreconciled
- 4 = Current client and cohort evidence supports the pricing logic, unit
  economics, and latest approved test or review decision
- 5 = Pricing/packaging decisions have current evidence, an approved testing or
  review cadence, reconciled effective prices, and documented expansion options

**Maps to AARRR:** Revenue.

### 13. CRO (conversion rate optimization)
**What's scored:** Test cadence, instrumentation, A/B history, statistical rigor.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No tests run; no instrumentation
- 2 = Some ad-hoc tests; no statistical rigor
- 4 = Regular test cadence; some wins
- 5 = Continuous testing program; experimentation culture; documented wins

**Maps to AARRR:** Cross-cutting (most impactful at Activation + Revenue).

### 14. GTM launches
**What's scored:** Quality of past launch executions. Product launches, feature launches, campaign launches.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No structured launches; "soft launches" only
- 2 = Some launches but uneven execution
- 4 = Solid recent launches; playbook exists
- 5 = Repeatable launch workflow with owners, evidence, readbacks, and
  post-launch decisions documented across multiple launches

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition + Activation.

### 15. Ads (paid)
**What's scored:** Paid acquisition state. Active campaigns, channels, CAC tracking, creative quality.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No paid acquisition
- 2 = Some paid but unstructured / wasteful
- 4 = At least one measured paid workflow meets the company's approved
  economics and guardrails; remaining constraints are documented
- 5 = Paid decisions reconcile CAC, margin, retention, attribution, creative,
  owner capacity, and stop conditions from dated sources

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition.

**Note:** When paid acquisition is intentionally out of scope, mark this `N/A`
or `0: intentionally inactive` and explain the verified budget, evidence,
capacity, or strategy constraint. Do not infer the interpretation from funding
stage.

### 16. SEO
**What's scored:** Organic search performance. Domain rating, ranking keywords, organic traffic, content cluster strategy.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = No SEO; new domain or zero-authority
- 2 = Some content but no strategy; ranks for brand only
- 4 = Tracked content clusters show source-backed organic progress against the
  client's dated baseline; known gaps have owners
- 5 = Search contributes durable, measured value across priority queries and
  conversion paths, with current technical/content operations and review rules

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition.

### 17. Internationalization
**What's scored:** Geographic expansion, language localization, region-specific pricing.

**Score guide:**
- 0 = US/EN only; no international consideration
- 2 = International users exist but aren't served (one language, one currency)
- 4 = Multi-language, region-specific pricing, GTM playbook for new markets
- 5 = International is a strength; multi-region revenue; localized GTM

**Maps to AARRR:** Acquisition.

**Note:** If internationalization is outside the verified market strategy, mark
it `N/A` or score the current evidence without penalty. Company age, ARR, or
funding stage does not determine the score.

## How to compute the scored result + read the shape

**Scored result = sum of known scores / (5 × number of known sections).**
Report unknown sections separately; use `/85` only when all 17 evidence gates
pass.

The total matters less than the *shape*. After the scoring table, write a 2–4 sentence "shape interpretation":

> *"High in {strong sections}, low in {weak sections}. That shape is the gap the rest of the plan closes, Sections X (AARRR stage) is the longest because that's where the gap is widest."*

## Candidate shapes to investigate

### "Strong voice / messaging, weak distribution"
- High: Positioning (#1), Customer research (#2), Messaging (#11)
- Low: SEO (#16), Ads (#15), GTM launches (#14)
- Hypothesis to test: messaging evidence is stronger than measured qualified
  distribution. Reconcile source quality, demand, downstream conversion,
  economics, capacity, and intentionally inactive channels before prioritizing
  an acquisition test. Low paid activity is not evidence that paid should start.

### "Strong acquisition, weak conversion"
- High: SEO (#16), Resources (#7), Ads (#15)
- Low: Homepage (#3), Onboarding (#8), Conversion pages (#5), Pricing (#12)
- Hypothesis to test: qualified traffic reaches the funnel but a defined cohort
  loses value before activation or purchase. Reconcile traffic quality, event
  definitions, cohort windows, research, and pricing before selecting a test.

### "Strong conversion, weak retention"
- High: Onboarding (#8), Homepage (#3), Pricing (#12)
- Low: Email lifecycle (#9), CRO (#13)
- Hypothesis to test: a comparable activated or paying cohort does not retain.
  Reconcile cohort definitions, product changes, expected behavior, support
  evidence, and margin before prioritizing retention work.

### "Strong product, weak everything-else"
- High: only Positioning (#1) and Customer research (#2), the founder knows the customer
- Low: everything operational
- Hypothesis to test: current sources support customer understanding but not the
  operating surfaces needed for an approved test. Identify the smallest
  evidence or infrastructure gap; do not infer a quarter, channel, or spend.

### "Strong recent revenue, weak compounding"
- High: Ads (#15), Sales material (#10), Pricing (#12)
- Low: SEO (#16), Resources (#7), Referral mechanics
- Hypothesis to test: current revenue is concentrated in a measured paid or
  sales workflow while compounding candidates remain unproven. Verify
  incrementality, margin, retention, attribution, owner capacity, and approved
  exposure before expanding, holding, or reallocating.

## When scores are subjective

Some sections are easier to score from outside than others. Subjectivity tier:

- **Objective (data-driven):** SEO (#16), Ads (#15), Email lifecycle (#9), Onboarding (#8): backed by analytics
- **Semi-objective:** Pricing (#12), CRO (#13), Conversion pages (#5), Sales material (#10): visible artifacts to evaluate
- **Subjective (judgment call):** Positioning (#1), Messaging (#11), Customer research (#2), Resources (#7): interpretive

For subjective sections, write the rationale into the "Note" column so the team can push back if they disagree.

## When a prior scored audit exists

If the team already has scored output from a current-state assessment, preserve
it as dated evidence. Reuse a score only when its source, scope, cohort/window,
and definition still match the current client state. Otherwise mark the row
unknown or rescore from current evidence, and document what changed.
reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness.Stars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependenciesStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is availableStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall