HaiyiMei/scorestarling-plugins / skills/scorestarling-arrange-for-level
scorestarling-arrange-for-level
VerifiedArrange or simplify a piece for a chosen instrument at a chosen level, then check it lands there. Routes across piano, violin, viola, cello, double bass, flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon, saxophone, recorder, trumpet, trombone, horn, classical and pop guitar, ukulele, voice, drums and the Chinese erhu, guzheng and dizi, from beginner to Grade 8 (Chinese instruments to 10), with the level as an ABRSM, Trinity, RCM, AMEB or Chinese 考级 number or in plain words (beginner, easy, 初学, 入门). Use whenever someone wants an easier, graded or "playable for my student or child" version of a piece for a particular instrument ("Grade 3 piano", "英皇五级小提琴", "尤克里里弹唱简单版", "古筝三级", "flute version for a year-two player"), wants a part fitted to a learner's level, or asks whether a score is really at some grade, even if they never say "arrange". If the instrument or the level is missing, ask one short question with options instead of guessing. Not for faithful transcriptions or for tidying a score without making it easier.
references/instruments/drums.md
View on GitHub# Drum kit: difficulty by level (Trinity College London Rock & Pop Drums 2018; RSL/Rockschool Drums 2018)
**Read this when** the target instrument is drums, at any level. Numbers come from Trinity and RSL Rock & Pop drums (2018); the checker reads them from [../profiles/drums.json](../profiles/drums.json): `python3 scripts/check_level.py arrangement.musicxml --instrument drums --grade N`. S1, S2 … in the tables point to the Sources section at the end; the master list with a confidence note for each is [../sources.md](../sources.md). Compiled 2026-10-14.
## Contents
- Table by grade
- What changes between neighbouring grades
- Arranging implications
- Confidence and gaps
- Sources
## Table by grade
Columns: keys are n/a (unpitched). "Typical range" is read as kit use and tempo. Own-choice-song rules are Trinity's ceilings ("it is not expected that songs contain everything in the list"); all items are cumulative.
| Level | Keys | Time signatures | Note values and rhythms | Typical range (kit, tempo) | Technique demands | Other features | Reading parameters (playback / sight reading / improvisation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Initial (RSL Debut) | n/a | 4/4, 2/4, 3/4 [T] | mostly quarter + eighth notes and rests, occasional 16ths; no syncopation; mp, mf, f with few changes [T]. RSL Debut: eighth-note singles, doubles, paradiddles q=70 [R] | full 5-piece kit with sticks; 60-130 bpm; basic right-foot (bass drum) independence only [T] | cross stick, snares on/off, short notated solo breaks/fills, trashy/tight hi-hat [T] | 45 s-2 min; no improvisation [T]. RSL Debut pieces max 1:00 [R] | [T] playback 8 bars, 2-bar repeats, 4/4 and 2/4, half/quarter/eighth values, single line on SD, BD, high+low tom, crash, no dynamics; improvise 4 bars of 4/4, one chord per bar, simple rock/pop. [R] sight-read 4 bars on snare: half and quarter notes, quarter rests, q=80, 90 s prep |
| 1 | n/a | as Initial [T] | adds dotted quarter, 16ths used more often, matching rests; p to f with occasional hairpins, accents, slash notation; syncopation limited to very simple repeated eighth off-beats [T] | as Initial; 60-160 bpm [T] | as Initial [T]. RSL: singles/doubles in 8ths and 16ths (alternate bars), single paradiddle in 16ths, q=70, one-bar fill to groove [R] | 1-2.5 min; no improvisation [T]; RSL pieces max 1:15 [R] | [T] playback adds p and f, mid tom, some 2-way coordination; improvise in ballad/heavy rock. [R] sight reading unchanged (4 bars, half/quarter); improvisation = notated 1-bar groove + 1-bar fill |
| 2 | n/a | 2/4 as printed plus occasional time-signature changes [T] (2/4 is already in Initial, so the printed entry may be a typo; unknown) | adds dotted eighth, ties, more eighth off-beats; crescendo/decrescendo inside phrases, subito dynamics [T] | brushes (non-swish patterns), hot rods/rutes; 50-160 bpm; basic right-hand independence around the kit [T] | open/closed hi-hat, fills containing grace-note rudiments, very simple swing; occasional ad-lib fills, cont. sim. with minor variation [T]. RSL: flams in quarters, eighth-note triplets alternating sticking, paradiddles around kit [R] | 1.5-3 min [T]; RSL pieces max 1:30 [R] | [T] playback adds 3/4, dotted halves, hi-hat + ride, mostly 2-way coordination, ties, accents; improvise country, 3/4. [R] sight reading adds 16ths and eighth rests, q=70 |
| 3 | n/a | 6/8, 12/8 [T]; improvise 2/2 with swung quavers (blues) [T] | adds 16th rest, 16th-8th-16th figure, eighth and 16th triplets, more complex ties; pp, ff, marcato, phrase marks; simple 16th off-beats [T] | soft mallets; full tempo range with tempo changes inside songs; simple 16th independence between snare and bass drum [T] | simple rolls, 16th hi-hat grooves hand-to-hand; ad-lib fills more often [T]. RSL: eighth triplets and 16ths, doubles on snare+toms, flams+drags, accented triplets, tech q=75 [R] | 1.5-3.5 min [T]; RSL max 2:00 [R] | [T] playback 8-12 bars, 2-4 bar repeats, 16ths, dotted quarters, mp/mf, hi-hat with foot, off-beat bass drum, 3-way coordination; improvise 8 bars. [R] improvisation tempo 80-100 |
| 4 | n/a | all regular time signatures [T]; playback 6/8 | adds 32nd notes, more complex 16th triplets; any dynamics; syncopation slightly above G3, also in fills [T] | brushes; independence a bit busier [T] | ghost notes, simple scrub/swish brush work, 3 against 2; 4-bar improvised solos [T]. RSL: single + triple paradiddles, flam tap + ruffs, 4 hands-and-feet patterns [R] | 2.5-4 min [T]; RSL max 2:15, pieces span two pages [R] | [T] playback adds eighth-note triplets, dotted-quarter rests, cresc/dim, whole kit with open/closed hi-hat, rim clicks, rolls, flams, drags, ruffs; improvise 6/8 with syncopation, 2 chords per bar (reggae, R&B). [R] sight reading 8 bars on whole kit in 4/4 with 16ths and dotted values, 2-bar development, q=80-90 |
| 5 | n/a | occasional irregular signatures, more frequent changes [T]; playback 12/8 | any value; free 16th/eighth-triplet syncopation across the kit [T]; playback adds dotted eighths, 16th triplets, sextuplets, pp/ff/sfz | simple left-foot (hi-hat with foot) independence [T]; tempo ranges as G3 | faster hi-hat may need Moeller/multiple-motion strokes, solo breaks around phrasing/band hits, full brush swing pattern, longer interpretive cont. sim.; 8-bar improvised solos [T]. RSL: five-stroke roll, flam accent, drag tap, bass drum follows right hand in paradiddles, q=75-90 [R] | 2.5-4 min [T]; RSL max 2:30 [R] | [T] playback 12-16 bars, extended independence; improvise 12 bars of 12/8 (funk, shuffle, disco). [R] sight reading 8 bars, q=80-120 |
| 6 | n/a | more irregular signatures [T]; playback 2/2, 9/8, 3/8 | playback adds semibreves, dotted 16ths, 32nds, matching rests [T] | double bass-drum pedal optional for fast patterns [T]; electronic kit still allowed to G6 [T] | more complex left-hand off-beats under right-hand 16ths, faster rebounded bass-drum strokes, choked hi-hat; 12-bar solos; ghost notes in playback [T]. RSL: sextuplets, flam paradiddle, ratamacue, 5- and 9-stroke rolls q=80; style studies (metal half-open hi-hat + busy 16th bass drum; funk ghost notes; jazz/Latin polyrhythm) [R] | 3-4.5 min [T]; RSL max 2:45 [R] | [T] playback 16-20 bars, 4-8 bar repeats; improvise 16 bars of 9/8 with solo break up to 2 bars (Latin, metal). [R] Quick Study Piece from lead sheet with improvised bars, 3 min preparation |
| 7 | n/a | playback 7/4, 7/8, 5/4, 5/8 [T]; improvise 5/4, 7/8 | playback adds crotchet triplets and duplets, any common terms and signs [T] | double bass-drum pedal listed as a kit item (G6 says 'as an option') [T]; acoustic kit required in face-to-face exams [T] | double-pedal patterns, faster double-stroke rolls on toms, more left-hand lead around the drums; 16-bar solos [T]. RSL: singles up to 32nds incl. quintuplet/sextuplet/septuplet 16ths (q=65), pataflafla, double ratamacue, 7-stroke roll; bell-of-ride 7/8 or 6/8 patterns, linear funk, splashed hi-hat [R] | 3-4.5 min [T]; RSL max 3:10 [R] | [T] improvise with more varied harmonic rhythm (jazz, boogie-woogie, boogie-style rock). [R] Quick Study Piece |
| 8 | n/a | time-signature changes in playback and improvisation [T] | all values; RSL tests up to nontuplet and double-quintuplet 32nds [R] | more complex left-foot independence on hi-hat or bass drum [T] | extended solo sections, more challenging double-pedal writing, varied tone production; multiple improvised solos of any length [T]. RSL: Swiss Army triplet, triple ratamacue, combined rolls, rhythmic displacement + 5/4 coordination, linear funk with 32nds + stepped hi-hat, 3-2/2-3 clave [R] | 3.5-5 min [T]; RSL max 3:45 [R] | [T] playback 20-24 bars; improvise any common style incl. hybrids (jazz funk, Latin soul, samba), solo break up to 4 bars. [R] Quick Study Piece, groove-recall up to 160 bpm |
## What changes between neighbouring grades
- Initial to 1: tempo ceiling 130 to 160; dotted quarter and more 16ths; first accents and slash bars; still no fills beyond short breaks.
- 1 to 2: first time-signature changes, brushes/rutes, open/closed hi-hat, grace-note fills, right-hand work around toms and ride; ad-lib fills start.
- 2 to 3: triplet feels (6/8, 12/8, swung), simple rolls, 16th hi-hat, 16th snare/kick independence; tempo range opens fully.
- 3 to 4: all regular time signatures, ghost notes, 3-against-2, brushes again, syncopation inside fills, 4-bar solos.
- 4 to 5: left-foot hi-hat independence, free triplet/16th syncopation, irregular meters appear, 8-bar solos, Moeller-type motion for fast hi-hat.
- 5 to 6: more irregular meters, double bass-drum pedal as an option, choked hi-hat, left-hand off-beats under 16ths, 12-bar solos.
- 6 to 7: double pedal moves from option to listed kit item, left-hand lead, double-stroke tom rolls, 7/8 and 5/4 in tests, acoustic kit only.
- 7 to 8: complex left-foot patterns, extended solos, hybrid styles, tone variety.
## Arranging implications
- Define the target by ceilings: Initial = quarter/eighth only, 4/4 (2/4, 3/4), 60-130 bpm, hi-hat/snare/kick with only the right foot busy, no syncopation, no improvised fills.
- Keep 16th notes sparse until G1 and make them the norm only from G3; add 16th triplets/sextuplets only from G3-G5 (triplets and shuffles from G3, 12/8 at G3, free syncopation at G5).
- Use 6/8 or 12/8 grooves from G3; reserve 7/8, 5/4, 9/8 for G6+; time-signature changes inside a song from G2 (occasional) and G5 (frequent).
- Fills: G1 short notated 1-bar breaks; G2 add grace-note rudiment fills (flams); G3 simple rolls; G4 syncopated fills and 4-bar solos; G5+ breaks around band hits; solos 8/12/16 bars for G5/G6/G7.
- Limb independence ladder: right foot only (Initial); right hand around kit (G2); snare+kick 16ths (G3); busier (G4); left-foot hi-hat (G5); left-hand off-beats against RH 16ths and double pedal option (G6); double pedal, left-hand lead (G7); left-foot complexity (G8).
- Colour devices to add or strip: cross stick/snares off (Initial), brushes and rutes (G2), mallets (G3), ghost notes (G4), choked hi-hat (G6). Remove these to simplify down.
- To write a song down a level: drop one ceiling item per step (e.g. replace ghost notes with plain backbeat, 16th hi-hat with eighths, double-kick with single kick, odd meter with 4/4).
- Song length guide: Trinity own-choice durations grow from 45 s-2 min (Initial) to 3.5-5 min (G8); RSL piece maxima 1:00 (Debut) to 3:45 (G8).
## Confidence and gaps
- Time signatures, note values, dynamics, tempo, kit/beaters, independence, technique, duration, improvisation: verbatim from official Trinity tables [T] (read from the PDF text and page images). Playback/improvising columns verbatim from official tables.
- RSL technical exercises, tempi, sight-reading, ear-test content, piece maxima: verbatim from official RSL spec [R].
- Gaps: the G2 time-signature entry is printed as 2/4 and looks inconsistent (unknown intent). Trinity gives no keys, no note counts per bar, and no fill-density figures; RSL gives no time-signature list per grade. The statement "drop one ceiling per step" is my inference, not board text. ABRSM drum-kit equivalent not found. Song-level groove vocabulary (e.g. which beats the kick may hit) is not published, so arranging below ceiling level is judgment.
## Sources
- [T] Trinity College London, "Rock & Pop DRUMS Syllabus, qualification specifications for graded exams from 2018" (PDF, 23 pp, current digital + face-to-face edition), https://www.trinitycollege.com/resource/?id=7898 (link found on https://www.trinityrock.com/instruments/drums). Taken: own-choice song parameter tables Initial-8 (duration, rhythmic values, dynamics, syncopation, time signatures, kit/beaters, tempo, independence, techniques, improvisation), session-skills Playback and Improvising tables (bars, time signatures, note values, styles), kit rules (electronic kit allowed to G6, acoustic from G7 face-to-face; double pedal optional G6).
- [R] RSL (Rockschool), "Drums Syllabus Specification 2018" (rev. 31 May 2019, 87 pp), mirror https://www.newschool.ie/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/RSL_Drums_Syllabus_Guide_2018_DIGITAL_31May2019-1.pdf. Taken: Debut-G8 technical exercises (rudiments, subdivisions, tempi), maximum piece length, sight-reading / improvisation / Quick Study parameters, ear-test groove content, stylistic studies.
- Tried, not used: ABRSM has no drum-kit grades in what I checked (ABRSM html pages return 403; not pursued, brief allowed Trinity/RSL). Trinity news page "showcasing-rock-and-pop-2018-drums" (no per-grade content). Retailer pages (song lists only, not copied).
- Terms: UK names used with US equivalents: crotchet=quarter, quaver=eighth, semiquaver=16th, demisemiquaver=32nd, minim=half, semibreve=whole. Tags [T]/[R] mark the source of each fact. "cont. sim." = continue similarly.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |