Skip to content

GeoGeekLab/nature-reviewer-skills / nature-earth-system-reviewer-skills/skills/nature-remote-sensing-reviewer-skill

nature-remote-sensing-reviewer

Verified

Nature-style remote-sensing manuscript reviewer skill for evaluating Earth-observation products, retrievals, machine-learning maps, validation design, uncertainty propagation, spatial transferability and claim-scope calibration.

reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl

View on GitHub
{"concern": "Surface reflectance or retrieval claims depend on atmospheric correction that is not described, validated, or sensitivity-tested.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Surface reflectance or retrieval claims depend on atmospheric correction that is not described, validated, or sensitivity-tested.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-001", "revision_direction": "Describe correction workflow; test plausible alternatives; compare with independent observations.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Surface reflectance or retrieval claims depend on atmospheric correction that is not described, validated, or sensitivity-tested.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-001", "pattern_name": "Atmospheric correction assumptions", "reviewer_concern": "Surface reflectance or retrieval claims depend on atmospheric correction that is not described, validated, or sensitivity-tested.", "revision_direction": "Describe correction workflow; test plausible alternatives; compare with independent observations.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "atmospheric correction; surface reflectance; retrieval"}, "title": "Atmospheric correction assumptions", "triggers": ["atmospheric correction", "surface reflectance", "retrieval"]}
{"concern": "Mask definitions can reshape sampled populations and bias spatial or temporal conclusions.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Mask definitions can reshape sampled populations and bias spatial or temporal conclusions.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-002", "revision_direction": "Report masks, valid-observation coverage, and threshold sensitivity.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Mask definitions can reshape sampled populations and bias spatial or temporal conclusions.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-002", "pattern_name": "Cloud, shadow, snow, water, and quality masking", "reviewer_concern": "Mask definitions can reshape sampled populations and bias spatial or temporal conclusions.", "revision_direction": "Report masks, valid-observation coverage, and threshold sensitivity.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "cloud; shadow; snow; water; mask; quality"}, "title": "Cloud, shadow, snow, water, and quality masking", "triggers": ["cloud", "shadow", "snow", "water", "mask", "quality"]}
{"concern": "QA screening may remove difficult cases and overstate product reliability.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "QA screening may remove difficult cases and overstate product reliability.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-003", "revision_direction": "State flag logic, quantify removals, and stratify validation by QA state.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "QA screening may remove difficult cases and overstate product reliability.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-003", "pattern_name": "Quality flags and retrieval screening", "reviewer_concern": "QA screening may remove difficult cases and overstate product reliability.", "revision_direction": "State flag logic, quantify removals, and stratify validation by QA state.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "quality flag; QA; screening"}, "title": "Quality flags and retrieval screening", "triggers": ["quality flag", "QA", "screening"]}
{"concern": "The claimed process occurs below sensor resolution or within heterogeneous pixels.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "The claimed process occurs below sensor resolution or within heterogeneous pixels.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-004", "revision_direction": "Quantify mixtures, add higher-resolution checks, and calibrate fine-scale claims.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "The claimed process occurs below sensor resolution or within heterogeneous pixels.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-004", "pattern_name": "Mixed pixels and sub-pixel heterogeneity", "reviewer_concern": "The claimed process occurs below sensor resolution or within heterogeneous pixels.", "revision_direction": "Quantify mixtures, add higher-resolution checks, and calibrate fine-scale claims.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "mixed pixel; sub-pixel; heterogeneity"}, "title": "Mixed pixels and sub-pixel heterogeneity", "triggers": ["mixed pixel", "sub-pixel", "heterogeneity"]}
{"concern": "Predictors, validation observations, and products are compared on incompatible spatial supports.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Predictors, validation observations, and products are compared on incompatible spatial supports.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-005", "revision_direction": "Harmonize spatial support and report scale-sensitive uncertainty.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Predictors, validation observations, and products are compared on incompatible spatial supports.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-005", "pattern_name": "Spatial resolution mismatch", "reviewer_concern": "Predictors, validation observations, and products are compared on incompatible spatial supports.", "revision_direction": "Harmonize spatial support and report scale-sensitive uncertainty.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "resolution; scale mismatch; aggregation"}, "title": "Spatial resolution mismatch", "triggers": ["resolution", "scale mismatch", "aggregation"]}
{"concern": "Compositing, revisit frequency, or missing observations vary over season or time.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Compositing, revisit frequency, or missing observations vary over season or time.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-006", "revision_direction": "Show coverage and test composite-window sensitivity.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Compositing, revisit frequency, or missing observations vary over season or time.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-006", "pattern_name": "Temporal compositing and sampling bias", "reviewer_concern": "Compositing, revisit frequency, or missing observations vary over season or time.", "revision_direction": "Show coverage and test composite-window sensitivity.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "temporal composite; revisit; missing observations"}, "title": "Temporal compositing and sampling bias", "triggers": ["temporal composite", "revisit", "missing observations"]}
{"concern": "Satellite and field observations lack defensible space-time collocation rules.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Satellite and field observations lack defensible space-time collocation rules.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-007", "revision_direction": "State match-up windows and quantify collocation uncertainty.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Satellite and field observations lack defensible space-time collocation rules.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-007", "pattern_name": "In situ match-up design", "reviewer_concern": "Satellite and field observations lack defensible space-time collocation rules.", "revision_direction": "State match-up windows and quantify collocation uncertainty.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "in situ; matchup; collocation"}, "title": "In situ match-up design", "triggers": ["in situ", "matchup", "collocation"]}
{"concern": "Validation data overlap training, calibration, or product construction.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Validation data overlap training, calibration, or product construction.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-008", "revision_direction": "Use withheld independent observations and region-wise reporting.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Validation data overlap training, calibration, or product construction.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-008", "pattern_name": "Independent validation", "reviewer_concern": "Validation data overlap training, calibration, or product construction.", "revision_direction": "Use withheld independent observations and region-wise reporting.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "independent validation; test set; calibration"}, "title": "Independent validation", "triggers": ["independent validation", "test set", "calibration"]}
{"concern": "A new product is not compared with established alternatives.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "A new product is not compared with established alternatives.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-009", "revision_direction": "Compare products, explain disagreements, and stratify by condition.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "A new product is not compared with established alternatives.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-009", "pattern_name": "Product intercomparison", "reviewer_concern": "A new product is not compared with established alternatives.", "revision_direction": "Compare products, explain disagreements, and stratify by condition.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "intercomparison; baseline product"}, "title": "Product intercomparison", "triggers": ["intercomparison", "baseline product"]}
{"concern": "Random folds leak spatial autocorrelation and inflate generalization metrics.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Random folds leak spatial autocorrelation and inflate generalization metrics.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-010", "revision_direction": "Use spatial blocks or leave-region-out validation.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Random folds leak spatial autocorrelation and inflate generalization metrics.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-010", "pattern_name": "Spatial leakage in machine-learning validation", "reviewer_concern": "Random folds leak spatial autocorrelation and inflate generalization metrics.", "revision_direction": "Use spatial blocks or leave-region-out validation.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "spatial leakage; cross-validation; autocorrelation"}, "title": "Spatial leakage in machine-learning validation", "triggers": ["spatial leakage", "cross-validation", "autocorrelation"]}
{"concern": "Training and test partitions share adjacent or overlapping periods.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Training and test partitions share adjacent or overlapping periods.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-011", "revision_direction": "Use blocked time splits and leave-year-out validation.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Training and test partitions share adjacent or overlapping periods.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-011", "pattern_name": "Temporal leakage in model validation", "reviewer_concern": "Training and test partitions share adjacent or overlapping periods.", "revision_direction": "Use blocked time splits and leave-year-out validation.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "temporal leakage; future information; time split"}, "title": "Temporal leakage in model validation", "triggers": ["temporal leakage", "future information", "time split"]}
{"concern": "The validation unit does not match the unit of claimed inference.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "The validation unit does not match the unit of claimed inference.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-012", "revision_direction": "Align folds with regions, sites, events, or years.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "The validation unit does not match the unit of claimed inference.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-012", "pattern_name": "Cross-validation unit design", "reviewer_concern": "The validation unit does not match the unit of claimed inference.", "revision_direction": "Align folds with regions, sites, events, or years.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "validation unit; grouped fold; pixel"}, "title": "Cross-validation unit design", "triggers": ["validation unit", "grouped fold", "pixel"]}
{"concern": "Broad applicability is inferred from a narrow training domain.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Broad applicability is inferred from a narrow training domain.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-013", "revision_direction": "Test domain shift and identify unsupported operating domains.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Broad applicability is inferred from a narrow training domain.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-013", "pattern_name": "Machine-learning generalization", "reviewer_concern": "Broad applicability is inferred from a narrow training domain.", "revision_direction": "Test domain shift and identify unsupported operating domains.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "generalization; domain shift; out-of-domain"}, "title": "Machine-learning generalization", "triggers": ["generalization", "domain shift", "out-of-domain"]}
{"concern": "Technical advance is claimed without transparent baselines or ablation tests.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Technical advance is claimed without transparent baselines or ablation tests.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-014", "revision_direction": "Add simple baselines and component-wise ablations.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Technical advance is claimed without transparent baselines or ablation tests.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-014", "pattern_name": "Baseline comparison and ablation", "reviewer_concern": "Technical advance is claimed without transparent baselines or ablation tests.", "revision_direction": "Add simple baselines and component-wise ablations.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "baseline; ablation; machine learning"}, "title": "Baseline comparison and ablation", "triggers": ["baseline", "ablation", "machine learning"]}
{"concern": "Input, retrieval, model, and validation uncertainty is not propagated to final estimates.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Input, retrieval, model, and validation uncertainty is not propagated to final estimates.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-015", "revision_direction": "Propagate uncertainty and report intervals and sensitivity.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Input, retrieval, model, and validation uncertainty is not propagated to final estimates.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-015", "pattern_name": "Uncertainty propagation", "reviewer_concern": "Input, retrieval, model, and validation uncertainty is not propagated to final estimates.", "revision_direction": "Propagate uncertainty and report intervals and sensitivity.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "uncertainty; confidence interval; sensitivity"}, "title": "Uncertainty propagation", "triggers": ["uncertainty", "confidence interval", "sensitivity"]}
{"concern": "Trend magnitude is emphasized without robust intervals or significance tests.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Trend magnitude is emphasized without robust intervals or significance tests.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-016", "revision_direction": "State the trend model and report robust confidence intervals.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Trend magnitude is emphasized without robust intervals or significance tests.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-016", "pattern_name": "Trend significance and confidence intervals", "reviewer_concern": "Trend magnitude is emphasized without robust intervals or significance tests.", "revision_direction": "State the trend model and report robust confidence intervals.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "trend; significance; confidence interval"}, "title": "Trend significance and confidence intervals", "triggers": ["trend", "significance", "confidence interval"]}
{"concern": "Time-series inference assumes independent residuals despite serial dependence.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Time-series inference assumes independent residuals despite serial dependence.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-017", "revision_direction": "Model autocorrelation and use appropriate trend tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Time-series inference assumes independent residuals despite serial dependence.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-017", "pattern_name": "Temporal autocorrelation", "reviewer_concern": "Time-series inference assumes independent residuals despite serial dependence.", "revision_direction": "Model autocorrelation and use appropriate trend tests.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "temporal autocorrelation; serial dependence"}, "title": "Temporal autocorrelation", "triggers": ["temporal autocorrelation", "serial dependence"]}
{"concern": "Neighbouring samples are treated as independent replicates.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Neighbouring samples are treated as independent replicates.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-018", "revision_direction": "Use spatially aware uncertainty, blocking, or clustered errors.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Neighbouring samples are treated as independent replicates.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-018", "pattern_name": "Spatial autocorrelation", "reviewer_concern": "Neighbouring samples are treated as independent replicates.", "revision_direction": "Use spatially aware uncertainty, blocking, or clustered errors.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "spatial autocorrelation; pseudoreplication"}, "title": "Spatial autocorrelation", "triggers": ["spatial autocorrelation", "pseudoreplication"]}
{"concern": "Many spatial tests are interpreted without discovery control.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Many spatial tests are interpreted without discovery control.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-019", "revision_direction": "Define the test family and control false discoveries.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Many spatial tests are interpreted without discovery control.", "gate": "spatiotemporal_inference", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-019", "pattern_name": "Multiple testing across maps or regions", "reviewer_concern": "Many spatial tests are interpreted without discovery control.", "revision_direction": "Define the test family and control false discoveries.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "multiple testing; false discovery; significance map"}, "title": "Multiple testing across maps or regions", "triggers": ["multiple testing", "false discovery", "significance map"]}
{"concern": "Observational association is phrased as demonstrated causation.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Observational association is phrased as demonstrated causation.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-020", "revision_direction": "Calibrate causal wording and test alternative explanations.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Observational association is phrased as demonstrated causation.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-020", "pattern_name": "Causal overclaiming", "reviewer_concern": "Observational association is phrased as demonstrated causation.", "revision_direction": "Calibrate causal wording and test alternative explanations.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "causal; attribution; observational"}, "title": "Causal overclaiming", "triggers": ["causal", "attribution", "observational"]}
{"concern": "Patterns with multiple explanations are presented as a demonstrated mechanism.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Patterns with multiple explanations are presented as a demonstrated mechanism.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-021", "revision_direction": "Separate observations from mechanism and add discriminating tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Patterns with multiple explanations are presented as a demonstrated mechanism.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-021", "pattern_name": "Mechanism overclaiming", "reviewer_concern": "Patterns with multiple explanations are presented as a demonstrated mechanism.", "revision_direction": "Separate observations from mechanism and add discriminating tests.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "mechanism; alternative explanation"}, "title": "Mechanism overclaiming", "triggers": ["mechanism", "alternative explanation"]}
{"concern": "Global language is based on limited regions, sensors, or conditions.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Global language is based on limited regions, sensors, or conditions.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-022", "revision_direction": "Report geographic coverage, region-wise performance, and validity limits.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Global language is based on limited regions, sensors, or conditions.", "gate": "validation_and_generalization", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-022", "pattern_name": "Global generalization", "reviewer_concern": "Global language is based on limited regions, sensors, or conditions.", "revision_direction": "Report geographic coverage, region-wise performance, and validity limits.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "global; cross-region; validity domain"}, "title": "Global generalization", "triggers": ["global", "cross-region", "validity domain"]}
{"concern": "Priority or novelty is asserted without verified comparison to prior work.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Priority or novelty is asserted without verified comparison to prior work.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-023", "revision_direction": "Specify the advance and calibrate first or unprecedented claims.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Priority or novelty is asserted without verified comparison to prior work.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-023", "pattern_name": "Novelty overclaiming", "reviewer_concern": "Priority or novelty is asserted without verified comparison to prior work.", "revision_direction": "Specify the advance and calibrate first or unprecedented claims.", "severity_default": "moderate", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "novelty; first; unprecedented"}, "title": "Novelty overclaiming", "triggers": ["novelty", "first", "unprecedented"]}
{"concern": "Relevant literature, products, or algorithms are omitted or under-discussed.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Relevant literature, products, or algorithms are omitted or under-discussed.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-024", "revision_direction": "Use verified references and compare with established approaches.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Relevant literature, products, or algorithms are omitted or under-discussed.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-024", "pattern_name": "Citation and prior-work positioning", "reviewer_concern": "Relevant literature, products, or algorithms are omitted or under-discussed.", "revision_direction": "Use verified references and compare with established approaches.", "severity_default": "moderate", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "citation; prior work; algorithm"}, "title": "Citation and prior-work positioning", "triggers": ["citation", "prior work", "algorithm"]}
{"concern": "Central computational results cannot be independently assessed from available materials.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Central computational results cannot be independently assessed from available materials.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-025", "revision_direction": "Provide review-stage access, processing documentation, licences, and persistent identifiers.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Central computational results cannot be independently assessed from available materials.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-025", "pattern_name": "Code and data availability", "reviewer_concern": "Central computational results cannot be independently assessed from available materials.", "revision_direction": "Provide review-stage access, processing documentation, licences, and persistent identifiers.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "code; data; reproducibility; availability"}, "title": "Code and data availability", "triggers": ["code", "data", "reproducibility", "availability"]}
{"concern": "A figure is used to support a claim it does not directly show.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "A figure is used to support a claim it does not directly show.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-026", "revision_direction": "Display uncertainty and sample coverage; revise prose to match the figure.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "A figure is used to support a claim it does not directly show.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-026", "pattern_name": "Figure evidence mismatch", "reviewer_concern": "A figure is used to support a claim it does not directly show.", "revision_direction": "Display uncertainty and sample coverage; revise prose to match the figure.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "figure; evidence; uncertainty display"}, "title": "Figure evidence mismatch", "triggers": ["figure", "evidence", "uncertainty display"]}
{"concern": "A sentence, equation, figure, or term is ambiguous or unsupported.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "A sentence, equation, figure, or term is ambiguous or unsupported.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-027", "revision_direction": "Anchor the request to a real section, paragraph, page, figure, or table without inventing line numbers.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "A sentence, equation, figure, or term is ambiguous or unsupported.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-027", "pattern_name": "Location-specific clarity", "reviewer_concern": "A sentence, equation, figure, or term is ambiguous or unsupported.", "revision_direction": "Anchor the request to a real section, paragraph, page, figure, or table without inventing line numbers.", "severity_default": "moderate", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "clarity; anchor; line comment"}, "title": "Location-specific clarity", "triggers": ["clarity", "anchor", "line comment"]}
{"concern": "A revision only partially resolves prior concerns or introduces new assumptions.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "A revision only partially resolves prior concerns or introduces new assumptions.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-028", "revision_direction": "Map responses to concerns and classify remaining issues explicitly.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "A revision only partially resolves prior concerns or introduces new assumptions.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-028", "pattern_name": "Revision-stage concern resolution", "reviewer_concern": "A revision only partially resolves prior concerns or introduces new assumptions.", "revision_direction": "Map responses to concerns and classify remaining issues explicitly.", "severity_default": "moderate", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "revision; response letter; unresolved"}, "title": "Revision-stage concern resolution", "triggers": ["revision", "response letter", "unresolved"]}
{"concern": "Sensor physics or modality is not justified for the target variable and scale.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Sensor physics or modality is not justified for the target variable and scale.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-029", "revision_direction": "Justify observability and validate in the target regime.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Sensor physics or modality is not justified for the target variable and scale.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-029", "pattern_name": "Domain-specific sensor suitability", "reviewer_concern": "Sensor physics or modality is not justified for the target variable and scale.", "revision_direction": "Justify observability and validate in the target regime.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "sensor; suitability; SAR; LiDAR; altimetry"}, "title": "Domain-specific sensor suitability", "triggers": ["sensor", "suitability", "SAR", "LiDAR", "altimetry"]}
{"concern": "Change estimates depend on thresholds, class definitions, or temporal baselines.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Change estimates depend on thresholds, class definitions, or temporal baselines.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-030", "revision_direction": "Report sensitivity and propagate classification error.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Change estimates depend on thresholds, class definitions, or temporal baselines.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-030", "pattern_name": "Change-detection threshold sensitivity", "reviewer_concern": "Change estimates depend on thresholds, class definitions, or temporal baselines.", "revision_direction": "Report sensitivity and propagate classification error.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "change detection; threshold; class"}, "title": "Change-detection threshold sensitivity", "triggers": ["change detection", "threshold", "class"]}
{"concern": "Policy or societal implications exceed spatial, temporal, or causal evidence.", "domain": "nature-remote-sensing", "evidence_risk": "Policy or societal implications exceed spatial, temporal, or causal evidence.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-031", "revision_direction": "Constrain implications to the validated evidence domain.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"evidence_risk": "Policy or societal implications exceed spatial, temporal, or causal evidence.", "gate": "remote_sensing_evidence_integrity", "pattern_id": "RS-PAT-031", "pattern_name": "Policy or broader-significance overreach", "reviewer_concern": "Policy or societal implications exceed spatial, temporal, or causal evidence.", "revision_direction": "Constrain implications to the validated evidence domain.", "severity_default": "major", "source_basis": "normalized from the upstream public remote-sensing issue-pattern database; no verbatim review report stored", "triggers": "policy; management; societal implication"}, "title": "Policy or broader-significance overreach", "triggers": ["policy", "management", "societal implication"]}
brainstormingobra/superpowersYou MUST use this before any creative work - creating features, building components, adding functionality, modifying behavior, or planning anything new, in software or out of it (a talk, a business, a renovation).Stars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
brand-guidelinesanthropics/skillsApplies Anthropic's official brand colors and typography to any sort of artifact that may benefit from having Anthropic's look-and-feel. Use it when brand colors or style guidelines, visual formatting, or company design standards apply.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
frontend-designanthropics/skillsGuidance for distinctive, intentional visual design when building new UI or reshaping an existing one. Helps with aesthetic direction, typography, and making choices that don't read as templated defaults.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
mcp-builderanthropics/skillsGuide for creating high-quality MCP (Model Context Protocol) servers that enable LLMs to interact with external services through well-designed tools. Use when building MCP servers to integrate external APIs or services, whether in Python (FastMCP) or Node/TypeScript (MCP SDK).Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall