GeoGeekLab/nature-reviewer-skills / nature-materials-science-reviewer-skill
nature-materials-science-reviewer
VerifiedNature-style materials science manuscript reviewer skill for testing materials design, synthesis, processing, structure-property, mechanism, stability, scalability, computational prediction and application claims against materials evidence chains.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| LICENSE | other | 1.1 KB |
| MANIFEST.json | config | 366 B |
| README.md | markdown | 7.5 KB |
| SKILL.md | skill md | 14.3 KB |
| checksums.sha256 | other | 1.7 KB |
| docs/SECURITY.md | markdown | 114 B |
| examples/evaluation_prediction.json | config | 260 B |
| references/claim_evidence_protocol.md | markdown | 550 B |
| references/domain_gate.md | markdown | 164 B |
| references/evaluation_contract.md | markdown | 306 B |
| requirements-dev.txt | markdown | 24 B |
| reviewer_db/patterns.csv | other | 69.3 KB |
| reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl | other | 164.1 KB |
| reviewer_db/summary.json | config | 969 B |
| scripts/extract_text_with_anchors.py | script | 1.2 KB |
| scripts/render_review_docx.py | script | 971 B |
| scripts/reviewer_db.py | script | 1.6 KB |
| scripts/validate_package.py | script | 928 B |
| templates/review_report.md | markdown | 953 B |
| tests/test_package.py | script | 640 B |
reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl
View on GitHub{"concern": "Reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0001", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0001", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "33", "support_units": "197", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a material identity or phase claim."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a material identity or phase claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0002", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0002", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "14", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0003", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0003", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "55", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0004", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0004", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "28", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0005", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0005", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "7", "support_units": "29", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0006", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0006", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "14", "support_units": "58", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on composition phase purity and identity evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0007", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0007", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "28", "support_units": "169", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a computational prediction or design claim."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a computational prediction or design claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0008", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0008", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "70", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0009", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0009", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "10", "support_units": "39", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0010", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0010", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "12", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0011", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0011", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "5", "support_units": "14", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0012", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0012", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "27", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on computational design and model validation evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0013", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0013", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "33", "support_units": "142", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a superiority or comparison claim."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a superiority or comparison claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0014", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0014", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "5", "support_units": "12", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0015", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0015", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "27", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0016", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0016", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "13", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0017", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0017", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "7", "support_units": "18", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0018", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0018", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "13", "support_units": "60", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on control materials and benchmarking evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0019", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0019", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "minor_to_major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "39", "support_units": "395", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a reproducibility or reporting claim."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a reproducibility or reporting claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0020", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0020", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "3", "support_units": "19", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0021", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0021", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "10", "support_units": "112", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0022", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0022", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "5", "support_units": "16", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0023", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0023", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "32", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0024", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0024", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "10", "support_units": "95", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0025", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0025", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "18", "support_units": "109", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on data code materials and reporting completeness evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0026", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0026", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "41", "support_units": "444", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a novel material or general advance claim."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a novel material or general advance claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0027", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0027", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "41", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0028", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0028", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "90", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0029", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0029", "reviewer_concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "general_materials_science", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "9", "trigger": "When general materials science claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When general materials science claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0030", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0030", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "12", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0031", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0031", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "16", "support_units": "69", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0032", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0032", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "89", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0033", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript presents an advance without distinguishing it from closest prior materials, mechanisms, or devices.", "gate": "editorial_significance_and_novelty", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0033", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers may see the contribution as incremental, insufficiently positioned, or too narrow for Nature-level scope.", "revision_direction": "State the exact advance over closest work, quantify the improvement, and align the claimed scope with the evidence.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "21", "support_units": "131", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."}, "title": "novel_material_or_general_advance_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on editorial significance and novelty evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0034", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0034", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "35", "support_units": "247", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a material property or performance claim."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a material property or performance claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0035", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0035", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "8", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0036", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0036", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "11", "support_units": "46", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0037", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0037", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "3", "support_units": "11", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0038", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0038", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "27", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0039", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0039", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "6", "support_units": "11", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0040", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0040", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "16", "support_units": "135", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on property measurement and metric validity evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0041", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0041", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "minor_to_major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "42", "support_units": "707", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a presentation or cross field accessibility claim."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a presentation or cross field accessibility claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0042", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0042", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "3", "support_units": "136", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0043", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0043", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "123", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0044", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0044", "reviewer_concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "general_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "25", "trigger": "When general materials science claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When general materials science claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In manufacturing processing and device integration, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0045", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0045", "reviewer_concern": "In manufacturing processing and device integration, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "manufacturing_processing_and_device_integration", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "2", "support_units": "17", "trigger": "When manufacturing processing and device integration claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When manufacturing processing and device integration claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0046", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0046", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "5", "support_units": "23", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0047", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0047", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "51", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0048", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0048", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "10", "support_units": "103", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0049", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0049", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "17", "support_units": "229", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on reader logic and figure narrative evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0050", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "application_or_translation_claim", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0050", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "28", "support_units": "146", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a application or translation claim."}, "title": "application_or_translation_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a application or translation claim."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0051", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "application_or_translation_claim", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0051", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "7", "support_units": "23", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on scalability processability and application boundary evidence."}, "title": "application_or_translation_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on scalability processability and application boundary evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0052", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "application_or_translation_claim", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0052", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "6", "support_units": "9", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on scalability processability and application boundary evidence."}, "title": "application_or_translation_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on scalability processability and application boundary evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0053", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "application_or_translation_claim", "evidence_risk": "Proof-of-concept results may be overextended to manufacturability, device deployment, or industrial relevance.", "gate": "scalability_processability_and_application_boundary", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0053", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for scale, processability, throughput, cost, integration, or realistic operating constraints.", "revision_direction": "State the application boundary, add scale/process evidence where available, and avoid industrial claims not directly tested.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "13", "support_units": "102", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on scalability processability and application boundary evidence."}, "title": "application_or_translation_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on scalability processability and application boundary evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0054", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0054", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "21", "support_units": "149", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a stability or long term utility claim."}, "title": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a stability or long term utility claim."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0055", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0055", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "8", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."}, "title": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0056", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0056", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "27", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."}, "title": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0057", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0057", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "5", "support_units": "16", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."}, "title": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0058", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0058", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "93", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."}, "title": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on stability durability and operando relevance evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0059", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0059", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "17", "support_units": "39", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a quantitative difference or generalization claim."}, "title": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a quantitative difference or generalization claim."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0060", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0060", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "6", "support_units": "11", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on statistical inference uncertainty and replicates evidence."}, "title": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on statistical inference uncertainty and replicates evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0061", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0061", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "11", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on statistical inference uncertainty and replicates evidence."}, "title": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on statistical inference uncertainty and replicates evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0062", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0062", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "42", "support_units": "655", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a structure or morphology claim."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a structure or morphology claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0063", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0063", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "6", "support_units": "26", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0064", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0064", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "186", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0065", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0065", "reviewer_concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "general_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "3", "support_units": "23", "trigger": "When general materials science claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When general materials science claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0066", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0066", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "6", "support_units": "23", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0067", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0067", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "13", "support_units": "49", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0068", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0068", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "9", "support_units": "87", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0069", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0069", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "26", "support_units": "256", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on structural characterization and spatial evidence evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0070", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0070", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "39", "support_units": "249", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a mechanistic or structure property claim."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a mechanistic or structure property claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0071", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0071", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "6", "support_units": "11", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0072", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0072", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "11", "support_units": "65", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0073", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0073", "reviewer_concern": "In general materials science, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "general_materials_science", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "3", "support_units": "12", "trigger": "When general materials science claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When general materials science claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0074", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0074", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "8", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0075", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0075", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "12", "support_units": "27", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0076", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0076", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "58", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0077", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0077", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "17", "support_units": "67", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on structure property causality and mechanism evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0078", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0078", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Write as a materials-science referee: firm, evidence-linked, and revision-oriented.", "support_dois": "39", "support_units": "278", "trigger": "When a manuscript makes a synthesis or processing claim."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When a manuscript makes a synthesis or processing claim."]}
{"concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0079", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0079", "reviewer_concern": "In computational materials design, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "4", "support_units": "16", "trigger": "When computational materials design claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When computational materials design claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."]}
{"concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0080", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0080", "reviewer_concern": "In energy and electrochemical materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "11", "support_units": "69", "trigger": "When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When energy and electrochemical materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."]}
{"concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0081", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "moderate", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0081", "reviewer_concern": "In optical photonic and emissive materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "optical_photonic_and_emissive_materials", "severity_default": "moderate", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "5", "support_units": "18", "trigger": "When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When optical photonic and emissive materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."]}
{"concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0082", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0082", "reviewer_concern": "In porous frameworks and sorbents, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "11", "support_units": "37", "trigger": "When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When porous frameworks and sorbents claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."]}
{"concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0083", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0083", "reviewer_concern": "In soft polymers and bioelectronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "8", "support_units": "39", "trigger": "When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When soft polymers and bioelectronic materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."]}
{"concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0084", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0084", "reviewer_concern": "In two dimensional and electronic materials, reviewers commonly test whether reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Tie the concern to the specific material system, measurement protocol, and claim strength.", "support_dois": "15", "support_units": "92", "trigger": "When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["When two dimensional and electronic materials claims rely on synthesis route and reproducibility evidence."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0085", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "evidence_risk": "The claimed material identity may be confounded by impurity phases, mixed composition, solvent, dopants, or incomplete assignment.", "gate": "composition_phase_purity_and_identity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0085", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask whether the observed properties arise from the stated phase and composition.", "revision_direction": "Provide orthogonal compositional and phase evidence, quantify purity, assign phases, and rule out likely impurities.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "33", "support_units": "197", "trigger": "If a property is assigned to a newly named phase, ask for orthogonal identity evidence and impurity exclusion."}, "title": "material_identity_or_phase_claim", "triggers": ["If a property is assigned to a newly named phase", "ask for orthogonal identity evidence and impurity exclusion."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0086", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "evidence_risk": "Structural, morphological, or interfacial claims may be under-supported by limited or non-representative characterization.", "gate": "structural_characterization_and_spatial_evidence", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0086", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers request higher-resolution, more representative, or orthogonal structural evidence.", "revision_direction": "Add complementary microscopy/spectroscopy/diffraction, representative sampling, image quantification, and clear assignment of features.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "42", "support_units": "655", "trigger": "For porous/framework materials, require pore structure, crystallinity, solvent/guest occupancy, and post-activation integrity to align with sorption claims."}, "title": "structure_or_morphology_claim", "triggers": ["For porous/framework materials", "require pore structure", "crystallinity", "solvent/guest occupancy", "and post-activation integrity to align with sorption claims."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0087", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "evidence_risk": "The selected metric, measurement protocol, or unit normalization may not support the claimed performance.", "gate": "property_measurement_and_metric_validity", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0087", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers challenge sensitivity, capacity, modulus, conductivity, efficiency, adsorption, or other property measurements.", "revision_direction": "Define protocols, justify metrics, normalize consistently, add controls, and report uncertainty and replicate statistics.", "scope": "porous_frameworks_and_sorbents", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "35", "support_units": "247", "trigger": "For adsorption or capture claims, check units, normalization, kinetics, cycling, selectivity, humidity, and comparison to appropriate sorbents."}, "title": "material_property_or_performance_claim", "triggers": ["For adsorption or capture claims", "check units", "normalization", "kinetics", "cycling", "selectivity", "humidity", "and comparison to appropriate sorbents."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0088", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "evidence_risk": "A model, simulation, DFT calculation, or machine-learning design may not be sufficiently validated experimentally or out of distribution.", "gate": "computational_design_and_model_validation", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0088", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for assumptions, convergence, descriptors, training/test split, ablations, external validation, and uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Report model settings, validation strategy, failure modes, uncertainty, and experimental confirmation of key predictions.", "scope": "computational_materials_design", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "28", "support_units": "169", "trigger": "For AI or computational discovery claims, ask how training data, validation split, chemical feasibility, and experimental confirmation constrain the design space."}, "title": "computational_prediction_or_design_claim", "triggers": ["For AI or computational discovery claims", "ask how training data", "validation split", "chemical feasibility", "and experimental confirmation constrain the design space."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0089", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "evidence_risk": "A correlation between structure and performance is presented as a causal mechanism.", "gate": "structure_property_causality_and_mechanism", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0089", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for perturbation, control, in situ, operando, or alternative-mechanism tests.", "revision_direction": "Separate correlation from causality, add targeted controls, validate proposed pathways, and discuss plausible alternatives.", "scope": "two_dimensional_and_electronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "39", "support_units": "249", "trigger": "For 2D/electronic materials, require that device behavior is separated from contact, substrate, defect, and integration artifacts."}, "title": "mechanistic_or_structure_property_claim", "triggers": ["For 2D/electronic materials", "require that device behavior is separated from contact", "substrate", "defect", "and integration artifacts."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0090", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "evidence_risk": "Short-term or ideal-condition tests may not support claims of durability, stability, cycling, or operational robustness.", "gate": "stability_durability_and_operando_relevance", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0090", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers request long-term tests, environmental stressors, cycling, degradation analysis, and post-test characterization.", "revision_direction": "Add durability protocols, stress conditions, failure analysis, before/after characterization, and realistic use-condition tests.", "scope": "soft_polymers_and_bioelectronic_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "21", "support_units": "149", "trigger": "For soft devices and self-healing polymers, require operational cycling after damage/healing rather than standalone healing demonstrations."}, "title": "stability_or_long_term_utility_claim", "triggers": ["For soft devices and self-healing polymers", "require operational cycling after damage/healing rather than standalone healing demonstrations."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0091", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "evidence_risk": "The comparison set may be incomplete, unfair, outdated, or not measured under equivalent conditions.", "gate": "control_materials_and_benchmarking", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0091", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for state-of-the-art controls, commercial comparators, or identical testing conditions.", "revision_direction": "Benchmark against closest materials and devices using matched protocols, transparent baselines, and literature context.", "scope": "energy_and_electrochemical_materials", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "33", "support_units": "142", "trigger": "For energy materials, require matched controls and realistic operating conditions before claiming performance advantage."}, "title": "superiority_or_comparison_claim", "triggers": ["For energy materials", "require matched controls and realistic operating conditions before claiming performance advantage."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0092", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "evidence_risk": "The target material may not be reproducibly accessible from the described route or processing window.", "gate": "synthesis_route_and_reproducibility", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0092", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for complete synthesis details, batch-to-batch consistency, process windows, yields, and failure cases.", "revision_direction": "Add full protocols, key parameters, replicate batches, yield/throughput information, and limits of the synthesis route.", "scope": "manufacturing_processing_and_device_integration", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "39", "support_units": "278", "trigger": "For processing or manufacturing claims, require process-window evidence, reproducibility across samples, and failure/yield information."}, "title": "synthesis_or_processing_claim", "triggers": ["For processing or manufacturing claims", "require process-window evidence", "reproducibility across samples", "and failure/yield information."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0093", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "evidence_risk": "Quantitative differences may be based on too few replicates, unclear statistics, or unreported uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_uncertainty_and_replicates", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0093", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers request replicate counts, error bars, significance tests, variance, and sample representativeness.", "revision_direction": "Report n, independent repeats, uncertainty intervals, statistical tests, and criteria for excluding measurements.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "17", "support_units": "39", "trigger": "For microscopy, devices, and property tests, ask whether reported examples are representative and supported by independent repeats."}, "title": "quantitative_difference_or_generalization_claim", "triggers": ["For microscopy", "devices", "and property tests", "ask whether reported examples are representative and supported by independent repeats."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0094", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "evidence_risk": "Methods, figures, data, units, source data, code, or materials availability are insufficient for verification or reuse.", "gate": "data_code_materials_and_reporting_completeness", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0094", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers flag missing methodological details, inconsistent figure labels, inaccessible data/code, or ambiguous definitions.", "revision_direction": "Complete methods, units, captions, data/code availability, materials provenance, and figure-level consistency checks.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "minor_to_major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "39", "support_units": "395", "trigger": "For complex materials studies, require source data, raw/processed characterization, code or model settings, and unambiguous units."}, "title": "reproducibility_or_reporting_claim", "triggers": ["For complex materials studies", "require source data", "raw/processed characterization", "code or model settings", "and unambiguous units."]}
{"concern": "Reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "domain": "nature-materials-science", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0095", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "evidence_risk": "A complex materials story may be hard to follow or may ask readers to infer the evidence chain from scattered figures.", "gate": "reader_logic_and_figure_narrative", "non_verbatim": "true", "pattern_id": "MS-PAT-0095", "reviewer_concern": "Reviewers ask for clearer definitions, schematic logic, figure sequencing, and separation of major and minor claims.", "revision_direction": "Clarify the central claim, define terms early, align figures with claims, and move secondary details to supplement if needed.", "scope": "cross_materials_science", "severity_default": "minor_to_major", "style_note": "Apply only when the manuscript claim actually depends on this evidence chain.", "support_dois": "42", "support_units": "707", "trigger": "For multi-technique studies, ask authors to make the evidence chain visible: material identity, structure, property, mechanism, and application boundary."}, "title": "presentation_or_cross_field_accessibility_claim", "triggers": ["For multi-technique studies", "ask authors to make the evidence chain visible: material identity", "structure", "property", "mechanism", "and application boundary."]}
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| finishing-a-development-branchobra/superpowersUse when implementation is complete, all tests pass, and you need to decide how to integrate the work | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| systematic-debuggingobra/superpowersUse when encountering any bug, test failure, or unexpected behavior, before proposing fixes | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| test-driven-developmentobra/superpowersUse when implementing any feature or bugfix, before writing implementation code | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| skill-creatoranthropics/skillsCreate new skills, modify and improve existing skills, and measure skill performance. Use when users want to create a skill from scratch, edit, or optimize an existing skill, run evals to test a skill, benchmark skill performance with variance analysis, or optimize a skill's description for better triggering accuracy. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |