GeoGeekLab/nature-reviewer-skills / nature-earth-system-reviewer-skills/skills/nature-hydrology-reviewer-skill
nature-hydrology-reviewer
VerifiedNature-style hydrology manuscript reviewer skill for testing streamflow, runoff, groundwater, water storage, drought, flood, hydroclimate and water-resource claims against water-balance closure, hydrologic signatures, model structure and observational constraints.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| LICENSE | other | 1.1 KB |
| MANIFEST.json | config | 359 B |
| README.md | markdown | 7.4 KB |
| SKILL.md | skill md | 13.8 KB |
| checksums.sha256 | other | 1.7 KB |
| docs/SECURITY.md | markdown | 114 B |
| examples/evaluation_prediction.json | config | 260 B |
| references/claim_evidence_protocol.md | markdown | 550 B |
| references/domain_gate.md | markdown | 158 B |
| references/evaluation_contract.md | markdown | 306 B |
| requirements-dev.txt | markdown | 30 B |
| reviewer_db/patterns.csv | other | 71.8 KB |
| reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl | other | 182.8 KB |
| reviewer_db/summary.json | config | 944 B |
| scripts/extract_text_with_anchors.py | script | 1.2 KB |
| scripts/render_review_docx.py | script | 971 B |
| scripts/reviewer_db.py | script | 1.6 KB |
| scripts/validate_package.py | script | 928 B |
| templates/review_report.md | markdown | 953 B |
| tests/test_package.py | script | 640 B |
reviewer_db/patterns.csv
View on GitHubpattern_id,gate,claim_type,evidence_risk,reviewer_concern,revision_direction,triggers,severity_hint,supporting_unit_count_by_gate,abstraction_level,source_basis
HYDRO-PAT-001,claim_evidence_calibration,global hydrological change claim,observed association is framed as a demonstrated process,Separate directly observed patterns from inferred mechanisms and avoid stronger causal language than the evidence permits.,"Rewrite claims by evidence tier and state which conclusions are descriptive, inferential, or causal.",global trend; intensification; climate-driven; impact,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-002,claim_evidence_calibration,novel dataset or method claim,technical contribution is conflated with hydrological discovery,A new product may be valuable even if the process interpretation remains under-supported.,"Distinguish product generation, product validation, and scientific interpretation in the abstract and conclusions.",new dataset; global assessment; baseline,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-003,claim_evidence_calibration,policy or management implication,decision-oriented message exceeds the reliability of the hydrological evidence,A management recommendation needs explicit uncertainty and scope conditions.,Add bounded implications and specify where the analysis is diagnostic rather than prescriptive.,policy; planning; water security,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-004,claim_evidence_calibration,hydroclimate impact claim,short or indirect evidence is used to imply long-term change,The language should not imply long-term climate change where the record supports only recent variability.,Replace attribution language with cautious variability language unless formal attribution is provided.,climate change; recent period; trend,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-005,claim_evidence_calibration,mechanistic explanation,multiple plausible drivers are available but one is privileged,The manuscript should not select a single mechanism without ruling out confounders.,Test competing explanations or recast as hypotheses.,mechanism; driver; explain,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-006,claim_evidence_calibration,cross-regional comparison,heterogeneous basins are summarized as a uniform global response,"Regional aggregation can hide hydroclimatic, human, and data-density differences.",Report stratified results and clarify limits of global summary metrics.,global; regional; basin,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-007,claim_evidence_calibration,risk-mapping claim,"mapped exposure is presented as hazard, risk, or realized impact","Exposure, hazard and vulnerability are distinct evidence layers.",Define each risk component and avoid substituting one for another.,exposure; hazard; vulnerability,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-008,claim_evidence_calibration,water-resource deficit claim,demand-side and supply-side uncertainty are collapsed,A water gap estimate must track both hydrological supply uncertainty and human demand assumptions.,Propagate demand and supply uncertainties separately.,water gap; scarcity; demand,major if central claim depends on it,339,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-009,hydrological_variable_validity,river-change claim from river stage,stage is treated as discharge or storage without rating-curve support,"River stage does not directly equal discharge, volume, or riverine water availability.",Validate stage-discharge transferability or narrow the claim to water-level variability.,river stage; RWL; discharge,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-010,hydrological_variable_validity,groundwater claim from TWS,total water storage is interpreted as groundwater without partitioning,TWS integrates multiple stores and cannot by itself identify aquifer change.,Partition storage components or frame groundwater inference as conditional.,GRACE; TWS; groundwater,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-011,hydrological_variable_validity,drought impact claim from precipitation anomaly,meteorological anomaly is equated with hydrological or agricultural drought,"Precipitation deficits need propagation through soil moisture, runoff, groundwater or demand pathways.",Use drought typology and include relevant hydrological response metrics.,drought; precipitation anomaly,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-012,hydrological_variable_validity,flood hazard claim from inundation extent,mapped water extent is interpreted as hazard magnitude or damage,"Flood extent alone cannot establish depth, velocity, duration, or damage potential.",Add hydraulic/hazard metrics or constrain the language to inundation mapping.,flood extent; hazard,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-013,hydrological_variable_validity,water-quality load claim from concentration,concentrations are discussed as fluxes or source loads,"Concentration, load and export are not interchangeable in hydrological transport.",Combine concentration with discharge and sampling frequency or revise to concentration-only claims.,concentration; load; flux,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-014,hydrological_variable_validity,evapotranspiration claim,ET product is used without discussing energy/water balance closure,ET estimates are model- and forcing-sensitive and may not diagnose water limitation alone.,Benchmark ET against independent products or flux observations and state closure assumptions.,evapotranspiration; ET,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-015,hydrological_variable_validity,soil-moisture constraint claim,near-surface soil moisture is extended to root-zone or basin storage,Vertical representativeness should be demonstrated before inferring plant or runoff response.,Validate depth sensitivity or limit claim to the observed soil layer.,soil moisture; root zone,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-016,hydrological_variable_validity,lake/wetland hydrology claim,surface area or optical water occurrence is treated as storage change,Area-water-level-storage relations vary by bathymetry and seasonality.,"Use hypsometry, altimetry or bounded language.",lake; wetland; storage,major if central claim depends on it,587,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-017,scale_basin_consistency,basin process from grid output,administrative/grid aggregation ignores drainage boundaries,"Hydrological processes are organized by basins, not arbitrary pixels or administrative units.",Recompute or stratify using watershed boundaries and upstream areas.,grid; basin; administrative,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-018,scale_basin_consistency,local validation for global product,validation basins do not represent target hydroclimates,"A global conclusion requires testing across climate, terrain, river size and human regulation gradients.",Add stratified validation or state geographic limits.,global; validation; region,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-019,scale_basin_consistency,coarse forcing for small catchments,forcing resolution is mismatched to runoff-generating processes,"Sub-grid precipitation, snow and land-use heterogeneity can dominate catchment response.",Quantify resolution sensitivity or limit claims to supported scales.,resolution; catchment,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-020,scale_basin_consistency,station-to-basin inference,point gauge behavior is generalized to basin-scale storage or risk,Gauge locations sample only part of a river network and may not represent upstream hydrology.,"Report network position, contributing area and representativeness.",station; upstream; network,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-021,scale_basin_consistency,river reach comparison,reach-scale hydraulics are conflated with basin-scale hydrology,Reach geometry and backwater effects can alter stage independent of discharge.,Separate reach hydraulics from basin water-balance interpretation.,reach; backwater; river stage,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-022,scale_basin_consistency,delta/coastal groundwater claim,coastal or deltaic units are analyzed without boundary-condition clarity,"Marine boundary, subsidence and river inputs can confound hydrological interpretation.",Define boundary conditions and include sensitivity to sea level/subsidence/river forcing.,delta; coastal; boundary,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-023,scale_basin_consistency,mountain water tower claim,elevation-zone processes are aggregated across basins,"Snow/glacier signals depend on elevation, aspect and melt timing.",Stratify by elevation band and basin outlet relevance.,mountain; elevation; snow,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-024,scale_basin_consistency,urban flood claim,impervious-surface effects are mixed with drainage-network constraints,"Urban flood response depends on sub-catchment drainage, not only rainfall or impervious fraction.",Add drainage-scale analysis or constrain urban interpretation.,urban; drainage; impervious,major if central claim depends on it,940,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-025,sampling_gauge_representativeness,ungauged-basin performance,training regions dominate validation statistics,"Performance in gauged, data-rich basins may not transfer to ungauged basins.",Use leave-region/basin-out validation and report ungauged performance separately.,ungauged; gauge; validation,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-026,sampling_gauge_representativeness,sparse-network trend claim,observing network gaps bias trend or impact assessment,Sparse gauges can create false certainty in regions where impacts matter most.,Map data-density effects and test sensitivity to station availability.,gauge gaps; sparse network,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-027,sampling_gauge_representativeness,remote-sensing validation,in-situ checks are concentrated in a few countries,Regional validation cannot support global error claims.,Expand validation sources or label the error budget as regionally constrained.,in situ; China; United States; GRDC,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-028,sampling_gauge_representativeness,high-flow/low-flow product claim,validation focuses on normal conditions,Products often fail at extremes that drive the paper’s conclusions.,"Report performance by flow percentile, season, and event class.",high flow; low flow; extremes,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-029,sampling_gauge_representativeness,mountain/arid/tropical inference,difficult hydroclimates are underrepresented,"Terrain, aridity and tropical cloud/vegetation conditions alter observability and model behavior.",Stratify validation by hydroclimatic class.,mountain; arid; tropical,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-030,sampling_gauge_representativeness,water-quality monitoring claim,sampling frequency misses event-driven transport,Solute and nutrient fluxes can be dominated by short runoff events.,Assess event sampling bias or use load estimation with uncertainty.,sampling frequency; nutrient; event,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-031,sampling_gauge_representativeness,groundwater observation claim,well distribution does not represent aquifer systems,Monitoring wells are unevenly distributed and may overrepresent managed or accessible aquifers.,"Report well-screen depth, aquifer type and spatial sampling bias.",well; aquifer; monitoring,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-032,sampling_gauge_representativeness,precipitation-network claim,station availability is treated as neutral,Network density itself is a source of uncertainty and can bias impact estimation.,Quantify missing-station influence on downstream hydrological indicators.,precipitation network; data gaps,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-033,validation_independent_testing,ML hydrological prediction,training and evaluation are not independent in space/time,Hydrological autocorrelation can create apparent skill through leakage.,"Use spatial, temporal and basin-holdout validation protocols.",machine learning; prediction; leakage,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-034,validation_independent_testing,data-assimilation product,assimilated observations are reused for evaluation,Evaluation is not independent if it uses data already assimilated or calibrated.,Identify assimilated data and use independent benchmarks.,data assimilation; validation,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-035,validation_independent_testing,model intercomparison claim,benchmark models are weak or inconsistently forced,A claimed advance needs fair comparison with strong baselines and identical inputs.,Benchmark against established models with common forcing and metrics.,benchmark; model intercomparison,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-036,validation_independent_testing,extreme-event forecasting,skill is reported with aggregate metrics only,Mean skill can hide failure for rare high-impact events.,"Include event-based metrics, reliability, lead-time and false-alarm diagnostics.",forecast; extreme event,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-037,validation_independent_testing,remote-sensing algorithm,validation only tests retrieval accuracy but not scientific downstream metrics,A product can be accurate on pixels yet unstable for trends or extremes.,"Validate the derived hydrological indicators, not only retrievals.",algorithm; product; trend,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-038,validation_independent_testing,water-quality model,calibration and validation periods share hydrological regimes,Performance should be tested across wet/dry years and event regimes.,Use independent periods and hydrologic-regime stratification.,calibration; water quality,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-039,validation_independent_testing,ungauged transfer,basins similar to training set dominate apparent generalization,Hydrological transferability requires tests across unseen physiographic classes.,"Use leave-cluster-out validation by climate, geology, regulation and basin size.",transferability; ungauged,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-040,validation_independent_testing,scenario impact analysis,historical validation is insufficient for scenario claims,Scenario credibility depends on process realism under changed forcing.,Add stress tests for non-stationary forcing and parameter sensitivity.,scenario; validation,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-041,trend_attribution_temporal_support,climate-change trend from short satellite record,record length cannot separate forced trend from variability,"Short records support recent variability, not robust climate-change attribution.",Extend with legacy records or reframe as recent change/variability.,Sentinel; 2016-2024; climate change,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-042,trend_attribution_temporal_support,event cluster interpreted as trend,recent extreme years are treated as a monotonic change,Clusters of events can arise from variability and sampling.,Use formal trend tests and event-count uncertainty.,extreme years; trend,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-043,trend_attribution_temporal_support,pre/post comparison,baseline periods are arbitrary or climatologically inconsistent,Attribution depends on defensible baseline and seasonality handling.,Justify baseline selection and test alternate baselines.,baseline; pre-post,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-044,trend_attribution_temporal_support,anthropogenic attribution,human and climate drivers are not separated,"Reservoirs, pumping, irrigation and land use can mimic climate signals.",Decompose drivers or explicitly qualify attribution.,anthropogenic; climate; human,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-045,trend_attribution_temporal_support,long-term extrapolation,observed short-window slope is projected forward,"Linear extrapolation ignores variability, management response and non-stationarity.",Avoid projection or use scenario models with uncertainty.,slope; projection,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-046,trend_attribution_temporal_support,hydrological drought attribution,drought propagation is not traced through storage/flow,Meteorological trends do not prove hydrological drought mechanisms.,"Analyze propagation from precipitation to soil moisture, runoff and groundwater.",drought propagation,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-047,trend_attribution_temporal_support,snow-loss claim,"snow metrics are sensitive to temperature, precipitation phase and elevation","Snow trends need phase, accumulation and melt-process separation.",Stratify by elevation/temperature regime and season.,snow loss; temperature,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-048,trend_attribution_temporal_support,groundwater recovery claim,recovery timing is confounded by pumping and policy changes,Aquifer trends cannot be attributed without withdrawal/recharge context.,"Include pumping, recharge and management histories.",groundwater recovery; pumping,major if central claim depends on it,305,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-049,human_water_interaction,river-flow change,reservoir regulation is acknowledged but not quantified,"Regulation can change timing, amplitude and extremes independent of climate.","Include reservoir indices, dam operation data or sensitivity excluding regulated basins.",reservoir; dam; regulation,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-050,human_water_interaction,water scarcity,withdrawals and return flows are simplified,Human demand and return-flow assumptions can dominate scarcity estimates.,"Report withdrawal, consumption and return-flow uncertainty.",withdrawal; water demand,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-051,human_water_interaction,irrigation impact,irrigation is treated as static or exogenous,"Irrigation adapts to climate, policy and energy constraints.",Model adaptive irrigation behavior or bound demand scenarios.,irrigation; demand,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-052,human_water_interaction,groundwater depletion,pumping data are missing or aggregated,Aquifer decline interpretations require extraction and recharge context.,"Add pumping proxies, management data or caveat driver attribution.",pumping; aquifer,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-053,human_water_interaction,land-use hydrology,land-cover change is used as a driver without runoff-process evidence,"Land-use effects depend on soil, slope, vegetation and rainfall intensity.",Show process pathways or test hydrological response sensitivity.,land use; runoff,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-054,human_water_interaction,transboundary allocation,hydrological availability is mixed with institutional allocation,Equity/efficiency conclusions depend on both flow variability and allocation rules.,Separate physical water availability from rule-based distribution.,transboundary; allocation,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-055,human_water_interaction,urban flood risk,socioeconomic exposure is conflated with drainage-controlled hazard,"Urban risk requires linking rainfall, drainage capacity and exposure.",Add drainage/hydraulic layer or bound claims to exposure.,urban flood; exposure,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-056,human_water_interaction,environmental flow,ecological flow needs are assumed without hydrological regime analysis,"Environmental flows require magnitude, timing, duration and frequency considerations.",Define flow-regime metrics and ecological thresholds.,environmental flow; flow regime,major if central claim depends on it,108,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-057,model_assumption_sensitivity,global hydrological model,model structure omits key water stores or operations,Structural omissions can bias water-balance and extreme-event conclusions.,State structural limits and run sensitivity with alternative models/modules.,global hydrological model; structure,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-058,model_assumption_sensitivity,precipitation forcing,single forcing product drives runoff conclusions,Precipitation uncertainty is often the dominant hydrological forcing uncertainty.,Use multiple forcing products or quantify forcing sensitivity.,precipitation forcing,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-059,model_assumption_sensitivity,ET/runoff partitioning,partitioning is controlled by untested parameter choices,"Water balance partitioning is sensitive to soil, vegetation and calibration assumptions.",Report partitioning diagnostics and parameter sensitivity.,ET; runoff partitioning,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-060,model_assumption_sensitivity,groundwater representation,groundwater is simplified in a surface-water model,Aquifer storage and baseflow errors propagate into drought and low-flow claims.,Clarify groundwater formulation and compare with groundwater observations.,groundwater module; baseflow,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-061,model_assumption_sensitivity,routing assumption,river routing affects timing metrics but is not evaluated,"Routing errors can alter flood timing, travel time and peak attenuation.",Validate routing against hydrographs or travel-time metrics.,routing; flood timing,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-062,model_assumption_sensitivity,reservoir operation module,operation rules are generic or unavailable,Dam operation assumptions can dominate downstream extremes and scarcity.,Test alternative operation rules or isolate regulated basins.,reservoir operation,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-063,model_assumption_sensitivity,scenario ensemble,ensemble spread is presented without model-dependence diagnosis,"Uncertainty is not just spread; it includes model selection, forcing and scenario choices.",Decompose uncertainty sources and avoid overconfident scenario statements.,ensemble; scenario,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-064,model_assumption_sensitivity,calibration period,calibration does not cover extremes or non-stationarity,Models calibrated to normal periods can fail under extremes.,Use regime-stratified calibration/validation or stress testing.,calibration period; extremes,major if central claim depends on it,254,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-065,extreme_event_definition,flood definition,threshold selection changes event count and spatial pattern,Flood conclusions are sensitive to percentile/return-period thresholds.,Justify thresholds and show sensitivity to alternative definitions.,flood threshold,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-066,extreme_event_definition,drought definition,"metric mixes meteorological, agricultural and hydrological drought",Different drought types have different lags and impacts.,Define drought class and propagate across relevant variables.,drought metric,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-067,extreme_event_definition,compound hazard,components are analyzed independently,"Compound risk requires joint dependence, timing and exposure analysis.",Model joint occurrence and dependence rather than stacking single hazards.,compound hazard,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-068,extreme_event_definition,event duration,short spikes and persistent events are conflated,Duration controls hydrological impact and management relevance.,"Report duration, persistence and recovery metrics.",duration; persistence,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-069,extreme_event_definition,antecedent condition,event attribution ignores pre-event storage and soil moisture,Flood and drought severity depends on antecedent catchment state.,Include antecedent moisture/storage diagnostics.,antecedent moisture,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-070,extreme_event_definition,seasonality,annual thresholds ignore seasonal hydrological regimes,A high flow in dry season may be more anomalous than the same flow in wet season.,Use season-specific thresholds or explain annual-threshold choice.,seasonality; threshold,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-071,extreme_event_definition,return period,return periods are estimated from short or non-stationary samples,Rare-event statistics are unstable under short/non-stationary records.,Report uncertainty and consider non-stationary extreme-value methods.,return period,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-072,extreme_event_definition,impact inference,hazard event is treated as social/ecological impact,Hazard occurrence does not prove realized damage or ecological response.,Add impact data or restrict claim to hazard potential.,impact; hazard,major if central claim depends on it,173,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-073,water_quality_transport,nutrient export,sampling misses storm-driven transport pulses,Nutrient export is event-sensitive and cannot be inferred from sparse concentration samples alone.,Use discharge-weighted loads or event sampling uncertainty.,nutrient export; storm,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-074,water_quality_transport,groundwater quality trend,quality trends are not linked to recharge age or hydroclimate,"Groundwater chemistry integrates residence time, recharge and pumping history.",Discuss lag times and aquifer pathways.,groundwater quality; recharge,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-075,water_quality_transport,DOC/wetland runoff,concentration changes are interpreted without hydrological flow paths,Biogeochemical signals need flow-path and residence-time context.,Connect chemistry to runoff generation and wetland connectivity.,DOC; wetland; runoff,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-076,water_quality_transport,contaminant transport,"source, pathway and receptor are collapsed","Transport evidence should distinguish source strength, mobilization and hydrological pathway.",Separate source attribution from transport inference.,contaminant; transport,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-077,water_quality_transport,sediment flux,sediment concentration is treated as morphological change,Sediment load requires flow integration and geomorphic context.,Estimate loads and link to geomorphic process metrics.,sediment; flux,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-078,water_quality_transport,water-quality management,concentration standard is used as ecological or human-health outcome,"Standards, exposure and ecological response are different evidence levels.",Clarify endpoint and avoid outcome claims without endpoint data.,water quality; standard,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-079,water_quality_transport,solute model,reaction and transport processes are underspecified,Hydrological transport cannot be interpreted without reaction or retention assumptions.,State reaction/retention parameters and sensitivity.,solute; reaction,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-080,water_quality_transport,river chemistry trend,trend is not flow-normalized,Changing discharge can create concentration trends unrelated to sources.,Use flow normalization or analyze load and concentration separately.,river chemistry; flow-normalized,major if central claim depends on it,33,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-081,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,satellite altimetry river claim,"retrieval quality depends on river width, slope and surrounding terrain",Altimetry performance is not uniform across rivers and landscapes.,"Report error by river width, slope, land cover and orbit geometry.",satellite altimetry; river width,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-082,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,sensor-era trend,algorithm or sensor changes can mimic hydrological trends,Product discontinuities must be separated from environmental change.,Document sensor/algorithm consistency and run break-point checks.,sensor; algorithm; trend,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-083,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,GRACE storage inference,coarse spatial footprints are mapped to small basins,GRACE-scale signals may not resolve local basin or aquifer processes.,Discuss leakage/scaling and compare with independent data.,GRACE; basin scale,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-084,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,SAR flood mapping,"classification performance differs by vegetation, urban cover and topography","Flood maps can fail in forests, cities and steep terrain.",Report omission/commission errors by land-cover and terrain class.,SAR; flood mapping,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-085,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,data fusion product,fused product inherits untracked biases from inputs,Fusion does not remove input bias unless explicitly corrected and validated.,Trace input uncertainty into final hydrological indicators.,data fusion; bias,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-086,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,data assimilation,assimilation increments are interpreted as process evidence,Assimilation corrections may compensate model error rather than reveal physical change.,Analyze increments separately and avoid overinterpreting them as observations.,assimilation increment,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-087,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,retrieval validation,pixel retrieval accuracy is not evaluated for extremes,Extremes often occur in conditions where retrieval quality degrades.,"Report retrieval quality for high water, snow, cloud, turbidity or dense vegetation cases.",retrieval; extremes,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-088,remote_sensing_data_assimilation,remote-sensing reproducibility,processing code and masks are unavailable,"Hydrological products require reproducible masks, thresholds and quality flags.","Release processing code, masks, flags and product versioning.",code; masks; quality flags,major if central claim depends on it,74,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-089,statistical_uncertainty,trend significance,autocorrelation and multiple testing are ignored,Spatial and temporal dependence inflate apparent significance.,"Account for autocorrelation, field significance and multiple comparisons.",trend; significance,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-090,statistical_uncertainty,global aggregate,uncertainty is summarized only as a mean or median,Aggregates can hide regional uncertainty and skewed distributions.,Report uncertainty distributions and stratified summaries.,global aggregate; uncertainty,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-091,statistical_uncertainty,regression interpretation,correlation coefficients are treated as mechanisms,Statistical association is not process attribution.,Add mechanism tests or frame as association.,regression; correlation,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-092,statistical_uncertainty,model performance,one metric is used for multi-objective hydrological behavior,"NSE/RMSE or accuracy alone may miss bias, timing and extremes.","Report complementary metrics for bias, timing, extremes and reliability.",RMSE; NSE; performance,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-093,statistical_uncertainty,uncertainty propagation,input uncertainty is not carried to final claims,Hydrological conclusions can be dominated by forcing/product uncertainty.,Propagate uncertainty through derived indicators and conclusions.,uncertainty propagation,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-094,statistical_uncertainty,sample-size claim,small sample is used for broad inference,Small or uneven samples limit generalization and statistical power.,Report power/coverage limits and avoid broad claims.,sample size,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-095,statistical_uncertainty,threshold sensitivity,binary classifications are based on one arbitrary cutoff,Maps and counts can be threshold artifacts.,Run sensitivity across plausible thresholds.,threshold sensitivity,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-096,statistical_uncertainty,non-stationarity,stationary statistics are used under changing climate and management,Hydrological extremes and demand may be non-stationary.,Test non-stationary alternatives or state stationarity assumption.,non-stationary; stationary,major if central claim depends on it,69,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-097,reproducibility_data_code,basin analysis,basin boundaries and station lists are not released,"Without exact spatial units, hydrological analysis cannot be replicated.","Release basin polygons, station IDs, masks and joins.",basin boundaries; station IDs,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-098,reproducibility_data_code,model workflow,configuration and parameter files are absent,"Code alone is insufficient without forcing, parameters and run settings.","Archive model configs, parameter sets and forcing versions.",configuration; parameters,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-099,reproducibility_data_code,remote-sensing workflow,quality flags and filtering rules are underspecified,Product-derived conclusions depend on filtering and masking decisions.,"Document flags, thresholds and exclusion rules.",quality flags; filtering,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-100,reproducibility_data_code,data availability,figure data do not reproduce the analysis,Figure data rarely allow rerunning spatial or model workflows.,Provide analysis-ready data and scripts for main figures.,figure data; scripts,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-101,reproducibility_data_code,third-party datasets,dataset versions and access dates are not recorded,Hydrological products change across versions and reprocessing.,"Record product version, access date and preprocessing.",dataset version,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-102,reproducibility_data_code,water-quality data,sampling metadata are missing,"Time, flow condition and method metadata are required to interpret concentration data.",Release sampling metadata and lab/method details.,sampling metadata,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-103,reproducibility_data_code,ML reproducibility,random seeds and splits are not fixed,Prediction results cannot be audited without exact splits and seeds.,"Release train/test splits, seeds and trained-model metadata.",random seed; splits,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-104,reproducibility_data_code,scenario reproducibility,scenario files and assumptions are not machine-readable,Scenario claims need transparent assumptions and reproducible input files.,Publish scenario tables/configs and processing scripts.,scenario files,major if central claim depends on it,51,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-105,novelty_related_work_positioning,new global product,closest existing products are not compared,Novelty depends on what is added beyond existing datasets and models.,"Compare scope, resolution, validation and scientific use cases against closest work.",existing product; novelty,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-106,novelty_related_work_positioning,methodological advance,technical novelty is not tied to hydrological value,A method must improve a hydrological inference or reduce a known limitation.,State the hydrological problem solved and benchmark improvement.,method; advance,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-107,novelty_related_work_positioning,regional case study,general claims exceed case-study novelty,Regional insight can be important but should not be framed as universal without transfer evidence.,Position as regional process evidence or add cross-region tests.,case study; generalization,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-108,novelty_related_work_positioning,dataset paper,data contribution lacks use-case validation,A dataset claim should show reliability and relevance for target applications.,Add benchmark tasks or application-oriented validation.,dataset; benchmark,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-109,novelty_related_work_positioning,climate-impact paper,related attribution/impact literature is under-synthesized,Hydroclimate claims must be positioned against established impact and attribution work.,Add focused related-work comparison by claim type.,climate impact; literature,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-110,novelty_related_work_positioning,water-resource assessment,water scarcity literature definitions differ,"Scarcity, stress, gap and security have distinct definitions.",Define terms and compare with closest metrics.,water scarcity; water security,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-111,novelty_related_work_positioning,hydrological remote sensing,prior missions or coarser products are ignored,Recent high-resolution products should be compared with legacy missions for context.,Add legacy-product context and limits.,legacy missions; altimetry,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-112,novelty_related_work_positioning,interdisciplinary claim,disciplinary contribution is unclear,"Hydrology, climate, ecology and policy claims need separate novelty statements.",Clarify primary contribution and secondary implications.,interdisciplinary; contribution,major if central claim depends on it,121,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-113,management_policy_interpretation,allocation recommendation,welfare or equity metric rests on simplified hydrology,Normative conclusions must reflect hydrological reliability and allocation rules.,Separate normative metric assumptions from hydrological uncertainty.,equity; allocation,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-114,management_policy_interpretation,adaptation planning,model resolution is too coarse for operational use,Planning guidance requires scale-appropriate uncertainty and decision context.,Describe decision scale and avoid operational prescriptions.,adaptation; planning,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-115,management_policy_interpretation,reservoir policy,operation constraints are omitted,"Reservoir decisions depend on legal, flood-control, energy and ecological constraints.",State operational constraints and scenario scope.,reservoir policy,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-116,management_policy_interpretation,water security ranking,ranking uncertainty is not shown,Rankings can be unstable under data and weighting uncertainty.,Report rank uncertainty and sensitivity to weights.,ranking; water security,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-117,management_policy_interpretation,transboundary systems,political feasibility is implied from hydrological optimization,Hydrological efficiency does not guarantee institutional feasibility.,Separate optimization from governance interpretation.,transboundary; governance,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-118,management_policy_interpretation,early warning claim,forecast skill is not mapped to actionable lead time,"Warning value depends on reliability, lead time and user thresholds.",Report operational metrics and decision-relevant thresholds.,early warning; lead time,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-119,management_policy_interpretation,risk reduction,hazard reduction is treated as loss reduction,"Risk reduction also depends on exposure, vulnerability and behavior.",Add risk pathway or restrict to hazard changes.,risk reduction; vulnerability,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-120,management_policy_interpretation,data-gap policy,observation expansion is recommended without value-of-information logic,Network recommendations need to show where additional data would change inference.,Use uncertainty/value-of-information analysis or qualify recommendation.,data gap; observing network,major if central claim depends on it,12,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-121,detail_audit,definition consistency,"key hydrological terms shift across text, methods and figures",Inconsistent terms weaken interpretation and reproducibility.,Create a definitions table and use terms consistently.,definition; terminology,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-122,detail_audit,unit consistency,"water quantities mix depth, volume, flow and area-normalized metrics",Hydrological units encode different physical quantities.,Audit units and conversions across figures and tables.,units; conversion,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-123,detail_audit,figure interpretability,"maps lack uncertainty, basin boundaries or validation overlays",Hydrological maps need context to support claims.,"Add uncertainty, validation points and basin boundaries where relevant.",map; figure,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-124,detail_audit,supplementary traceability,critical methodological details are buried or fragmented,Reviewers must be able to trace each claim to methods and data.,Move essential definitions and validation summaries into the main text or structured supplement.,supplementary; methods,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-125,detail_audit,threshold documentation,thresholds appear in captions but not methods,Classification thresholds must be reproducible.,"List all thresholds, baselines and sensitivity tests in methods.",threshold; caption,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-126,detail_audit,acronym and variable clarity,variables are not defined at first use,Ambiguous variables invite misunderstanding of the hydrological evidence chain.,Define variables and use standard hydrological notation.,acronym; variable,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-127,detail_audit,reference alignment,claims cite broad literature rather than closest methodological precedent,References should support the specific method or claim.,Replace generic citations with closest data/model/method precedents.,reference; related work,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-128,detail_audit,data-code statement,availability statement is too generic,Generic availability statements do not satisfy hydrological reproducibility.,"Specify repositories, licenses, versions and access restrictions.",availability; repository,minor to major depending on claim dependence,592,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-129,referee_voice_output_format,review report structure,comments become a checklist disconnected from the manuscript claim,Nature-style reports should first identify contribution and central evidence-chain risk.,"Open with contribution, then organize major concerns by claim support.",review structure,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-130,referee_voice_output_format,review tone,critique is either hostile or too vague,"A strong referee is firm, precise and revision-oriented.","State issue, reason and feasible revision path.",tone; reviewer voice,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-131,referee_voice_output_format,publication judgment,no clear severity distinction is made,Authors need to know which issues affect publication-level support.,"Separate fatal, major, revision-required and minor issues.",severity; judgment,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-132,referee_voice_output_format,specific comments,line comments repeat major concerns without actionable detail,"Specific comments should improve definitions, metrics, uncertainty and reproducibility.",Use targeted comments tied to claim calibration.,specific comments,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-133,referee_voice_output_format,independent referees,multiple referees repeat the same gate,Independent reports should stress different parts of the evidence chain.,Assign complementary emphases across 2-4 referees.,independent referees,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-134,referee_voice_output_format,hidden internals,gate labels or pattern IDs leak into final report,"The output should read like referee comments, not a diagnostic trace.",Use gates internally only and remove IDs from final review.,gate labels; pattern IDs,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-135,referee_voice_output_format,revision direction,major comments lack a path forward,Critique should explain what additional analysis or reframing would resolve the concern.,Attach each major concern to revision or bounded claim language.,revision path,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-136,referee_voice_output_format,balance,review ignores manuscript strengths,Nature-style review recognizes contribution before evidence limits.,"State contribution, then calibrate limitations.",contribution; strengths,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim domain reviewer pattern,abstracted from public peer-review files; no reviewer text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-137,trend_attribution_temporal_support,design-standard or return-period claim,historical stationarity is assumed after arguing that climate or basin conditions changed,A manuscript cannot both rely on stationary design logic and claim non-stationary hydroclimate without reconciling the two.,"State whether the analysis is descriptive, design-oriented or adaptation-oriented, and test baseline/return-period sensitivity under non-stationary assumptions.",stationarity; return period; design standard; baseline,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-138,management_policy_interpretation,adaptation or water-planning claim,climate projection uncertainty is invoked without a decision-relevant pathway,"Water-management claims need to connect changing information, uncertainty and decision time scales rather than simply declaring historical practice obsolete.","Define the decision context, planning horizon and uncertainty treatment, or narrow the claim to scientific diagnosis.",adaptation; planning; decision; management,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-139,scale_basin_consistency,global freshwater threshold claim,a global water limit is treated as a basin-scale or aquifer-scale management threshold,Freshwater constraints are spatially heterogeneous and cannot be transferred from global accounting to local management without allocation logic.,"Translate global metrics into basin, aquifer, green-water and blue-water terms, and state limits of threshold interpretation.",planetary boundary; freshwater use; basin allocation,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-140,claim_evidence_calibration,global water-security or biodiversity threat map,composite threat scores are interpreted as measured impact,"Composite indices depend on weighting, normalization and mitigation assumptions and should not be presented as directly observed harm.","Report component-wise sensitivity and separate mapped pressure, mitigation capacity, exposure and realized consequence.",water security; biodiversity; threat index; composite,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-141,statistical_uncertainty,composite hydrological index claim,index weights and transformations are hidden or treated as neutral,"Composite indicators can be dominated by normalization choices, correlation structure or arbitrary weights.","Provide weight, normalization and leave-one-component-out sensitivity; identify which components drive conclusions.",index; weighting; normalization; sensitivity,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-142,hydrological_variable_validity,drought change claim,a single drought metric is treated as the drought phenomenon itself,"Drought conclusions are metric-dependent and should distinguish meteorological, agricultural, hydrological and groundwater drought.",Compare drought indicators or state which drought type the chosen metric can support.,PDSI; SPEI; drought index; aridity,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-143,model_assumption_sensitivity,evaporative-demand drought claim,PET or atmospheric-demand formulation controls drying conclusions,Drought projections can be sensitive to how evaporative demand and soil-water limitation are represented.,Test alternate PET/ET formulations or propagate this structural uncertainty into drought interpretation.,PET; evaporative demand; aridity; soil moisture,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-144,human_water_interaction,virtual-water or food-trade groundwater claim,water withdrawal is conflated with non-renewable depletion or trade responsibility,"Embodied-water conclusions need explicit distinctions among withdrawal, depletion, recharge, irrigation source and trade allocation.","Provide depletion accounting, source-water assumptions and trade-allocation sensitivity before making responsibility claims.",virtual water; groundwater depletion; crop trade; irrigation,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-145,claim_evidence_calibration,global flood-risk projection claim,"hazard, exposure, vulnerability and protection standards are collapsed into one risk narrative","Flood risk is an evidence chain, not a single modeled layer.","Separate hazard change, exposed population/assets, vulnerability, protection standards and climate-model spread.",global flood risk; exposure; vulnerability; flood protection,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-146,model_assumption_sensitivity,basin runoff loss under warming,"temperature, snow, ET, precipitation and operations are not decomposed","Basin water-balance attribution requires separating thermodynamic, cryospheric, precipitation and management pathways.",Decompose runoff sensitivity and test reservoir/demand assumptions before policy-level conclusions.,Colorado River; snow; warming; runoff sensitivity,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-147,management_policy_interpretation,water scarcity to conflict claim,hydrological scarcity is treated as a deterministic driver of conflict or cooperation,"Water scarcity effects are mediated by institutions, infrastructure, allocation rules and exposure.",Frame conflict/cooperation claims as conditional and include governance or socioeconomic mediators where possible.,water scarcity; conflict; transboundary; governance,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-148,reproducibility_data_code,global synthesis or boundary claim,classification masks and thresholds are insufficiently reproducible,"High-level global conclusions depend on exact masks, thresholds, component data and aggregation choices.","Release masks, threshold values, component datasets and aggregation scripts needed to reproduce core maps and summary numbers.",global synthesis; threshold; mask; aggregation,contextual stress-test; does not raise severity without manuscript-specific evidence,0,non-verbatim cross-literature stress-test pattern,abstracted from classic Nature/Science hydrology controversies; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-149,detail_audit,figure-level claim anchoring,figure panels are cited for claims they do not directly show,Figure-level support should match the exact claim made in the surrounding text.,"Ask authors to revise the claim, add the missing analysis, or adjust the caption so the figure and text align.",figure; panel; caption; headline claim,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-150,detail_audit,table-level aggregation check,tables report global or pooled metrics that hide regional or regime-specific failures,"Hydrological performance and inference often change by basin, aquifer, climate region, event type or regulation status.",Request stratified table entries or supplementary tables for regimes that control the conclusion.,table; global mean; pooled metric; stratified,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-151,detail_audit,method-to-result traceability,"headline numbers cannot be traced to masks, thresholds, filters, data versions or aggregation rules",A high-impact hydrology claim should be reproducible from methods to figure and summary number.,"Ask for a figure-to-method traceability table with datasets, masks, thresholds, uncertainty treatment and scripts.",methods; mask; threshold; dataset version; headline number,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-152,detail_audit,wording calibration by short quotation,a local sentence or phrase overstates what the data demonstrate,Directly quoting a short claim can make overstatement concerns precise and fair.,Quote a short exact phrase in bold and explain the evidence boundary; do not quote long passages or invent text anchors.,wording; overclaim; exact phrase; quote,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-153,novelty_related_work_positioning,closest-product comparison,"novelty is stated without comparison to the nearest product, model, dataset or regional inventory","Novelty should be established against the closest hydrological precedent, not against broad field gaps.","Request a comparison table covering domain, resolution, period, validation, uncertainty, limitations and hydrological inference.",novel; first; product; dataset; model; inventory,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-154,novelty_related_work_positioning,product novelty versus scientific insight,improved coverage or resolution is presented as new process understanding,"A new map, model or dataset is not automatically a new hydrological mechanism or conclusion.","Ask authors to state whether the advance is technical capability, empirical description, prediction skill or process insight.",high resolution; global map; dataset; process insight,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-155,novelty_related_work_positioning,failure-domain comparison,performance claims ignore where the method fails relative to earlier work,"Top-journal novelty should include the limits of improvement, especially in difficult basins and events.","Request comparison in data-sparse, regulated, arid, mountainous, tropical or extreme-event regimes.",performance; improvement; comparison; regime,minor to major depending on claim dependence,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-156,referee_voice_output_format,specific comments depth,"specific comments remain generic and do not help authors revise figures, tables or methods",Specific comments should identify local evidence anchors and concrete corrections.,"Include concise comments tied to figures, tables, methods, definitions, thresholds, uncertainty or reproducibility.",specific comments; figure; table; methods,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-157,referee_voice_output_format,question-based clarification,uncertain local choices are criticized too bluntly or left ambiguous,A short question can make a technical clarification request precise and collegial.,"Use questions sparingly for unclear masks, thresholds, validation splits, definitions or data availability.",could the authors clarify; threshold; split; definition,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
HYDRO-PAT-158,referee_voice_output_format,major-minor separation,minor presentation problems are inflated or major evidence problems are buried as line edits,Publication-level review should separate central evidence-chain risks from local clarity fixes.,"Place claim-threatening issues in major comments and local figure, wording or notation issues in specific comments.",major comments; minor comments; specific comments,format integrity issue,0,non-verbatim output-control pattern,abstracted as reviewer style control; contextual only; no source text redistributed
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| finishing-a-development-branchobra/superpowersUse when implementation is complete, all tests pass, and you need to decide how to integrate the work | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| systematic-debuggingobra/superpowersUse when encountering any bug, test failure, or unexpected behavior, before proposing fixes | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| test-driven-developmentobra/superpowersUse when implementing any feature or bugfix, before writing implementation code | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| skill-creatoranthropics/skillsCreate new skills, modify and improve existing skills, and measure skill performance. Use when users want to create a skill from scratch, edit, or optimize an existing skill, run evals to test a skill, benchmark skill performance with variance analysis, or optimize a skill's description for better triggering accuracy. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |