GeoGeekLab/nature-reviewer-skills / nature-chemistry-reviewer-skill
nature-chemistry-reviewer
VerifiedNature-style chemistry manuscript reviewer skill for testing synthesis, catalysis, chemical biology, molecular/materials chemistry and analytical claims against identity, purity, controls, selectivity, mechanism, scope, reproducibility and quantitative comparison.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| LICENSE | other | 1.1 KB |
| MANIFEST.json | config | 358 B |
| README.md | markdown | 7.3 KB |
| SKILL.md | skill md | 11.2 KB |
| checksums.sha256 | other | 1.7 KB |
| docs/SECURITY.md | markdown | 114 B |
| examples/evaluation_prediction.json | config | 260 B |
| references/claim_evidence_protocol.md | markdown | 550 B |
| references/domain_gate.md | markdown | 171 B |
| references/evaluation_contract.md | markdown | 306 B |
| requirements-dev.txt | markdown | 24 B |
| reviewer_db/patterns.csv | other | 30.4 KB |
| reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl | other | 72.0 KB |
| reviewer_db/summary.json | config | 864 B |
| scripts/extract_text_with_anchors.py | script | 1.2 KB |
| scripts/render_review_docx.py | script | 971 B |
| scripts/reviewer_db.py | script | 1.6 KB |
| scripts/validate_package.py | script | 928 B |
| templates/review_report.md | markdown | 953 B |
| tests/test_package.py | script | 640 B |
reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl
View on GitHub{"concern": "The demonstrated evidence may support a local finding but not the full mechanistic, synthetic, or generality claim.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The demonstrated evidence may support a local finding but not the full mechanistic, synthetic, or generality claim.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-001", "revision_direction": "Ask authors to recalibrate language, separate demonstrated scope from hypotheses, and state the exact evidence domain.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A manuscript advances a general chemistry claim from a narrow reaction, material, molecular system, or assay.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The demonstrated evidence may support a local finding but not the full mechanistic, synthetic, or generality claim.", "frequency_proxy_units": "5", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-001", "pattern_name": "Claim class is broader than the evidence class", "reviewer_concern": "The demonstrated evidence may support a local finding but not the full mechanistic, synthetic, or generality claim.", "revision_direction": "Ask authors to recalibrate language, separate demonstrated scope from hypotheses, and state the exact evidence domain.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "90cb2ebd591ff7e3;31efc3f4be9bf5f4;5b6197439f4b65af;9397232c7b796a17;6196f2d9bf5490da", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Claim class is broader than the evidence class", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Performance alone does not establish the chemical origin of the effect.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Performance alone does not establish the chemical origin of the effect.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-002", "revision_direction": "Require explicit mechanistic alternatives, discriminating experiments, and limits on causal wording.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A successful reaction, catalyst, sensor, or molecular tool is presented as mechanistically explained.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Performance alone does not establish the chemical origin of the effect.", "frequency_proxy_units": "5", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-002", "pattern_name": "Demonstration is not equivalent to explanation", "reviewer_concern": "Performance alone does not establish the chemical origin of the effect.", "revision_direction": "Require explicit mechanistic alternatives, discriminating experiments, and limits on causal wording.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "90cb2ebd591ff7e3;31efc3f4be9bf5f4;5b6197439f4b65af;9397232c7b796a17;6196f2d9bf5490da", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Demonstration is not equivalent to explanation", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The claim may be driven by cherry-picked conditions rather than representative behaviour.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim may be driven by cherry-picked conditions rather than representative behaviour.", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-003", "revision_direction": "Request full distributions, failed cases, boundary cases, and transparent selection criteria.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A conclusion relies on unusually successful substrates, catalysts, cells, or operating windows.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The claim may be driven by cherry-picked conditions rather than representative behaviour.", "frequency_proxy_units": "5", "gate": "claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-003", "pattern_name": "Best-case examples anchor the central message", "reviewer_concern": "The claim may be driven by cherry-picked conditions rather than representative behaviour.", "revision_direction": "Request full distributions, failed cases, boundary cases, and transparent selection criteria.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "90cb2ebd591ff7e3;31efc3f4be9bf5f4;5b6197439f4b65af;9397232c7b796a17;6196f2d9bf5490da", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Best-case examples anchor the central message", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Originality may be overstated if prior conceptual precedents are not acknowledged.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Originality may be overstated if prior conceptual precedents are not acknowledged.", "gate": "novelty_and_positioning", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-004", "revision_direction": "Require a precise novelty statement against the closest reaction class, catalyst family, molecular design, or analytical approach.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A manuscript introduces a term or framing for chemistry already present in adjacent literature.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Originality may be overstated if prior conceptual precedents are not acknowledged.", "frequency_proxy_units": "51", "gate": "novelty_and_positioning", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-004", "pattern_name": "Incremental chemistry is framed as conceptual novelty", "reviewer_concern": "Originality may be overstated if prior conceptual precedents are not acknowledged.", "revision_direction": "Require a precise novelty statement against the closest reaction class, catalyst family, molecular design, or analytical approach.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "3fd2ee08265c84e5;6ef348ad9e539149;566abce1c9169201;32ba23f46e6ed3c4;ec4007319fb75f4d;5f701a3fcfb55645", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Incremental chemistry is framed as conceptual novelty", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may appear more novel than it is because the comparator set is incomplete.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript may appear more novel than it is because the comparator set is incomplete.", "gate": "novelty_and_positioning", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-005", "revision_direction": "Ask for broader, cross-subfield literature positioning and explicit differences from the closest analogues.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A study positions itself within one chemical literature while overlooking catalysis, materials, chemical biology, or physical chemistry precedents.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The manuscript may appear more novel than it is because the comparator set is incomplete.", "frequency_proxy_units": "51", "gate": "novelty_and_positioning", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-005", "pattern_name": "Adjacent subfields are under-cited", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may appear more novel than it is because the comparator set is incomplete.", "revision_direction": "Ask for broader, cross-subfield literature positioning and explicit differences from the closest analogues.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "3fd2ee08265c84e5;6ef348ad9e539149;566abce1c9169201;32ba23f46e6ed3c4;ec4007319fb75f4d;5f701a3fcfb55645", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Adjacent subfields are under-cited", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "A term can obscure whether the contribution is a new mechanism, new system, or new application.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "A term can obscure whether the contribution is a new mechanism, new system, or new application.", "gate": "novelty_and_positioning", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-006", "revision_direction": "Require authors to define terms operationally and distinguish naming from evidence of a new principle.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "New labels are used for effects that may arise from known chemical principles.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "A term can obscure whether the contribution is a new mechanism, new system, or new application.", "frequency_proxy_units": "51", "gate": "novelty_and_positioning", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-006", "pattern_name": "Terminology amplifies perceived significance", "reviewer_concern": "A term can obscure whether the contribution is a new mechanism, new system, or new application.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to define terms operationally and distinguish naming from evidence of a new principle.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "3fd2ee08265c84e5;6ef348ad9e539149;566abce1c9169201;32ba23f46e6ed3c4;ec4007319fb75f4d;5f701a3fcfb55645", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Terminology amplifies perceived significance", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Without negative controls, background chemistry or assay artefacts can explain the result.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Without negative controls, background chemistry or assay artefacts can explain the result.", "gate": "controls_and_validation", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-007", "revision_direction": "Require blank, inactive analogue, no-light/no-current/no-enzyme/no-metal, or scrambled-control tests as appropriate.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A reaction, catalytic activity, imaging signal, binding event, or chemical-biology response is attributed to the designed component.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Without negative controls, background chemistry or assay artefacts can explain the result.", "frequency_proxy_units": "11", "gate": "controls_and_validation", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-007", "pattern_name": "Missing negative or inactive controls", "reviewer_concern": "Without negative controls, background chemistry or assay artefacts can explain the result.", "revision_direction": "Require blank, inactive analogue, no-light/no-current/no-enzyme/no-metal, or scrambled-control tests as appropriate.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;f1a21ba138c0ff07;c29cfe41a8d20ecf;206652080e715b08;571323861b1601d7;560aa76f5190b6dd", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Missing negative or inactive controls", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The comparison may conflate intrinsic chemistry with experimental setup.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The comparison may conflate intrinsic chemistry with experimental setup.", "gate": "controls_and_validation", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-008", "revision_direction": "Ask for matched controls and normalization to chemically meaningful denominators.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "The comparator differs in loading, surface area, concentration, solvent, illumination, potential, assay window, or normalization.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The comparison may conflate intrinsic chemistry with experimental setup.", "frequency_proxy_units": "11", "gate": "controls_and_validation", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-008", "pattern_name": "Reference systems are not aligned", "reviewer_concern": "The comparison may conflate intrinsic chemistry with experimental setup.", "revision_direction": "Ask for matched controls and normalization to chemically meaningful denominators.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;f1a21ba138c0ff07;c29cfe41a8d20ecf;206652080e715b08;571323861b1601d7;560aa76f5190b6dd", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Reference systems are not aligned", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Internal validation can overstate robustness.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Internal validation can overstate robustness.", "gate": "controls_and_validation", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-009", "revision_direction": "Request independent validation, orthogonal analytical methods, external datasets, or held-out substrate classes.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Performance is supported by the same platform, dataset, instrument, or condition used for discovery.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Internal validation can overstate robustness.", "frequency_proxy_units": "11", "gate": "controls_and_validation", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-009", "pattern_name": "Validation is internal only", "reviewer_concern": "Internal validation can overstate robustness.", "revision_direction": "Request independent validation, orthogonal analytical methods, external datasets, or held-out substrate classes.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;f1a21ba138c0ff07;c29cfe41a8d20ecf;206652080e715b08;571323861b1601d7;560aa76f5190b6dd", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Validation is internal only", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Substrate scope may not test steric, electronic, functional-group, heteroatom, stereochemical, or scale boundaries.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Substrate scope may not test steric, electronic, functional-group, heteroatom, stereochemical, or scale boundaries.", "gate": "reaction_scope_and_selectivity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-010", "revision_direction": "Require a scope table designed around chemical diversity, limitations, and failed substrates.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A synthesis or catalytic method is claimed as general from a narrow or biased substrate set.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Substrate scope may not test steric, electronic, functional-group, heteroatom, stereochemical, or scale boundaries.", "frequency_proxy_units": "18", "gate": "reaction_scope_and_selectivity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-010", "pattern_name": "Scope does not support generality", "reviewer_concern": "Substrate scope may not test steric, electronic, functional-group, heteroatom, stereochemical, or scale boundaries.", "revision_direction": "Require a scope table designed around chemical diversity, limitations, and failed substrates.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "8539b2b7a1751491;23d24489c8ee9c4f;af2eb903fde67a9e;6944835eb9cdc542;b9812862c28cfadd;c5ad76a052b9f8b7", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Scope does not support generality", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The proposed origin can be plausible but unproven.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The proposed origin can be plausible but unproven.", "gate": "reaction_scope_and_selectivity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-011", "revision_direction": "Ask for competition experiments, matched substrate pairs, kinetic probes, isotopic tests, or computational selectivity models.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Regio-, chemo-, stereo-, or enantioselectivity is explained by a proposed structural or mechanistic feature.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The proposed origin can be plausible but unproven.", "frequency_proxy_units": "18", "gate": "reaction_scope_and_selectivity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-011", "pattern_name": "Selectivity origin is asserted rather than tested", "reviewer_concern": "The proposed origin can be plausible but unproven.", "revision_direction": "Ask for competition experiments, matched substrate pairs, kinetic probes, isotopic tests, or computational selectivity models.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "8539b2b7a1751491;23d24489c8ee9c4f;af2eb903fde67a9e;6944835eb9cdc542;b9812862c28cfadd;c5ad76a052b9f8b7", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Selectivity origin is asserted rather than tested", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Readers cannot assess practical utility or compare with existing methods.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Readers cannot assess practical utility or compare with existing methods.", "gate": "reaction_scope_and_selectivity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-012", "revision_direction": "Require harmonized reporting of conversion, isolated yield, selectivity, side products, scale, and purification losses.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Reaction performance is discussed without consistent conversion, isolated yield, selectivity, mass balance, or scale information.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Readers cannot assess practical utility or compare with existing methods.", "frequency_proxy_units": "18", "gate": "reaction_scope_and_selectivity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-012", "pattern_name": "Yields are reported without comparability context", "reviewer_concern": "Readers cannot assess practical utility or compare with existing methods.", "revision_direction": "Require harmonized reporting of conversion, isolated yield, selectivity, side products, scale, and purification losses.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "8539b2b7a1751491;23d24489c8ee9c4f;af2eb903fde67a9e;6944835eb9cdc542;b9812862c28cfadd;c5ad76a052b9f8b7", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Yields are reported without comparability context", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Misassignment or impurity can compromise the core conclusion.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Misassignment or impurity can compromise the core conclusion.", "gate": "synthesis_characterization_and_analytical_evidence", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-013", "revision_direction": "Request appropriate NMR, HRMS, elemental analysis, crystallography, chromatography, spectroscopy, or purity evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A central molecule, intermediate, catalyst, polymer, framework, or labelled product lacks orthogonal characterization.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Misassignment or impurity can compromise the core conclusion.", "frequency_proxy_units": "13", "gate": "synthesis_characterization_and_analytical_evidence", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-013", "pattern_name": "Identity evidence is insufficient for a key compound", "reviewer_concern": "Misassignment or impurity can compromise the core conclusion.", "revision_direction": "Request appropriate NMR, HRMS, elemental analysis, crystallography, chromatography, spectroscopy, or purity evidence.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "1560e4fecf68354d;d1a1a62903ccdd84;e1796b25b66e232c;e240700fafc9dae6;7a1877c5475844f5;816c42e25fd40005", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Identity evidence is insufficient for a key compound", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Impurities, morphology, counterions, residual metal, or solvent can drive apparent effects.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Impurities, morphology, counterions, residual metal, or solvent can drive apparent effects.", "gate": "synthesis_characterization_and_analytical_evidence", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-014", "revision_direction": "Require batch-to-batch data, purity metrics, impurity screens, and synthetic reproducibility evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Chemical performance depends on synthesized materials or molecular samples with limited batch documentation.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Impurities, morphology, counterions, residual metal, or solvent can drive apparent effects.", "frequency_proxy_units": "13", "gate": "synthesis_characterization_and_analytical_evidence", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-014", "pattern_name": "Purity and batch variability are not controlled", "reviewer_concern": "Impurities, morphology, counterions, residual metal, or solvent can drive apparent effects.", "revision_direction": "Require batch-to-batch data, purity metrics, impurity screens, and synthetic reproducibility evidence.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "1560e4fecf68354d;d1a1a62903ccdd84;e1796b25b66e232c;e240700fafc9dae6;7a1877c5475844f5;816c42e25fd40005", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Purity and batch variability are not controlled", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The data may be consistent with several chemical structures or environments.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The data may be consistent with several chemical structures or environments.", "gate": "synthesis_characterization_and_analytical_evidence", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-015", "revision_direction": "Require orthogonal methods, uncertainty in fitting, standards, controls, and alternative structural models.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Spectroscopic or diffraction data are used to assign local structure, oxidation state, binding mode, or packing.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The data may be consistent with several chemical structures or environments.", "frequency_proxy_units": "13", "gate": "synthesis_characterization_and_analytical_evidence", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-015", "pattern_name": "Spectral assignments exceed resolution", "reviewer_concern": "The data may be consistent with several chemical structures or environments.", "revision_direction": "Require orthogonal methods, uncertainty in fitting, standards, controls, and alternative structural models.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "1560e4fecf68354d;d1a1a62903ccdd84;e1796b25b66e232c;e240700fafc9dae6;7a1877c5475844f5;816c42e25fd40005", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Spectral assignments exceed resolution", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Correlation does not identify the operative mechanism.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Correlation does not identify the operative mechanism.", "gate": "mechanism_and_causality", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-016", "revision_direction": "Request perturbation experiments, kinetic discrimination, isotope effects, intermediate trapping, or direct observation where feasible.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Activity, selectivity, or molecular response is correlated with a structural descriptor, spectroscopic feature, or computed parameter.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Correlation does not identify the operative mechanism.", "frequency_proxy_units": "38", "gate": "mechanism_and_causality", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-016", "pattern_name": "Mechanism relies on correlation", "reviewer_concern": "Correlation does not identify the operative mechanism.", "revision_direction": "Request perturbation experiments, kinetic discrimination, isotope effects, intermediate trapping, or direct observation where feasible.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "6ac5be7e59ecc645;55e9c8d26769b7bb;7ff1732d49ad33dd;bb0bc6a923d30a96;dc09cdd13135e8cd;45f6f1b41f940d63", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Mechanism relies on correlation", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Competing radical, ionic, surface, solvent, transport, or degradation pathways may explain the observations.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Competing radical, ionic, surface, solvent, transport, or degradation pathways may explain the observations.", "gate": "mechanism_and_causality", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-017", "revision_direction": "Require a mechanism section that tests and narrows plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A single pathway is presented for a reaction, catalytic cycle, photochemical process, or biological response.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Competing radical, ionic, surface, solvent, transport, or degradation pathways may explain the observations.", "frequency_proxy_units": "38", "gate": "mechanism_and_causality", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-017", "pattern_name": "Alternative mechanisms are not excluded", "reviewer_concern": "Competing radical, ionic, surface, solvent, transport, or degradation pathways may explain the observations.", "revision_direction": "Require a mechanism section that tests and narrows plausible alternatives.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "6ac5be7e59ecc645;55e9c8d26769b7bb;7ff1732d49ad33dd;bb0bc6a923d30a96;dc09cdd13135e8cd;45f6f1b41f940d63", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Alternative mechanisms are not excluded", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Spectroscopic and performance evidence may not separate spectator sites from active sites.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Spectroscopic and performance evidence may not separate spectator sites from active sites.", "gate": "mechanism_and_causality", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-018", "revision_direction": "Request operando/in situ evidence, poisoning or site-blocking tests, isotope/kinetic probes, and reconstruction analysis.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A catalyst or material is assigned a specific active site or coordination environment.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Spectroscopic and performance evidence may not separate spectator sites from active sites.", "frequency_proxy_units": "38", "gate": "mechanism_and_causality", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-018", "pattern_name": "Active-site assignment is underdetermined", "reviewer_concern": "Spectroscopic and performance evidence may not separate spectator sites from active sites.", "revision_direction": "Request operando/in situ evidence, poisoning or site-blocking tests, isotope/kinetic probes, and reconstruction analysis.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "6ac5be7e59ecc645;55e9c8d26769b7bb;7ff1732d49ad33dd;bb0bc6a923d30a96;dc09cdd13135e8cd;45f6f1b41f940d63", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Active-site assignment is underdetermined", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Observed performance may reflect surface area, loading, morphology, mass transport, or light absorption rather than intrinsic activity.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Observed performance may reflect surface area, loading, morphology, mass transport, or light absorption rather than intrinsic activity.", "gate": "catalysis_and_performance", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-019", "revision_direction": "Ask for normalization by active site, electrochemically active surface area, absorbed photons, turnover metrics, or matched loading.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Catalytic performance is reported by mass, geometric area, mole of material, optical density, or total product.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Observed performance may reflect surface area, loading, morphology, mass transport, or light absorption rather than intrinsic activity.", "frequency_proxy_units": "95", "gate": "catalysis_and_performance", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-019", "pattern_name": "Activity metrics are not intrinsically normalized", "reviewer_concern": "Observed performance may reflect surface area, loading, morphology, mass transport, or light absorption rather than intrinsic activity.", "revision_direction": "Ask for normalization by active site, electrochemically active surface area, absorbed photons, turnover metrics, or matched loading.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1;1e3f3ba86572e040;508b72d00556c384;357405621be06800", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Activity metrics are not intrinsically normalized", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Short tests cannot exclude deactivation, reconstruction, leaching, fouling, or product inhibition.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Short tests cannot exclude deactivation, reconstruction, leaching, fouling, or product inhibition.", "gate": "catalysis_and_performance", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-020", "revision_direction": "Require longer-term operation, post-catalysis characterization, leaching analysis, and activity recovery tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A catalyst is claimed stable under limited time, cycling, current, illumination, solvent, or substrate stress.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Short tests cannot exclude deactivation, reconstruction, leaching, fouling, or product inhibition.", "frequency_proxy_units": "95", "gate": "catalysis_and_performance", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-020", "pattern_name": "Stability evidence is too short or too idealized", "reviewer_concern": "Short tests cannot exclude deactivation, reconstruction, leaching, fouling, or product inhibition.", "revision_direction": "Require longer-term operation, post-catalysis characterization, leaching analysis, and activity recovery tests.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1;1e3f3ba86572e040;508b72d00556c384;357405621be06800", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Stability evidence is too short or too idealized", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Faradaic, photon, atom, carbon, nitrogen, or mass balances may be incomplete.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Faradaic, photon, atom, carbon, nitrogen, or mass balances may be incomplete.", "gate": "catalysis_and_performance", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-021", "revision_direction": "Require calibration curves, detection limits, isotopic controls, product balance, and uncertainty propagation.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Catalytic selectivity or efficiency is reported without complete product accounting.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Faradaic, photon, atom, carbon, nitrogen, or mass balances may be incomplete.", "frequency_proxy_units": "95", "gate": "catalysis_and_performance", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-021", "pattern_name": "Product quantification lacks closure", "reviewer_concern": "Faradaic, photon, atom, carbon, nitrogen, or mass balances may be incomplete.", "revision_direction": "Require calibration curves, detection limits, isotopic controls, product balance, and uncertainty propagation.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1;1e3f3ba86572e040;508b72d00556c384;357405621be06800", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Product quantification lacks closure", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Calculations can rationalize observations without discriminating alternatives.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Calculations can rationalize observations without discriminating alternatives.", "gate": "computational_model_assumptions", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-022", "revision_direction": "Require model assumptions, sensitivity to functional/model/solvent/surface, competing pathways, and clear limits.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "DFT, quantum chemistry, molecular dynamics, or ML models are aligned with the preferred mechanism.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Calculations can rationalize observations without discriminating alternatives.", "frequency_proxy_units": "4", "gate": "computational_model_assumptions", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-022", "pattern_name": "Computation is used as confirmation rather than a falsifiable test", "reviewer_concern": "Calculations can rationalize observations without discriminating alternatives.", "revision_direction": "Require model assumptions, sensitivity to functional/model/solvent/surface, competing pathways, and clear limits.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "4e76350ee0f8d8da;80914f20c45c15f6;80ccf34ae6f6904b;374e19cb0b117a99", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Computation is used as confirmation rather than a falsifiable test", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The model may omit counterions, solvent, morphology, dynamics, concentration, defects, or interface structure.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The model may omit counterions, solvent, morphology, dynamics, concentration, defects, or interface structure.", "gate": "computational_model_assumptions", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-023", "revision_direction": "Ask authors to justify the model and test whether conclusions are robust to chemically plausible alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A simplified molecule, cluster, slab, solvation environment, protein model, or reaction coordinate represents a complex experiment.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The model may omit counterions, solvent, morphology, dynamics, concentration, defects, or interface structure.", "frequency_proxy_units": "4", "gate": "computational_model_assumptions", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-023", "pattern_name": "Model chemistry is mismatched to experiment", "reviewer_concern": "The model may omit counterions, solvent, morphology, dynamics, concentration, defects, or interface structure.", "revision_direction": "Ask authors to justify the model and test whether conclusions are robust to chemically plausible alternatives.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "4e76350ee0f8d8da;80914f20c45c15f6;80ccf34ae6f6904b;374e19cb0b117a99", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Model chemistry is mismatched to experiment", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Performance may not transfer to new chemotypes, substrates, catalysts, or experimental conditions.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Performance may not transfer to new chemotypes, substrates, catalysts, or experimental conditions.", "gate": "computational_model_assumptions", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-024", "revision_direction": "Require prospective tests, scaffold splits, out-of-domain examples, uncertainty estimates, and failure analysis.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A computational or AI chemistry workflow is presented as predictive from retrospective benchmarks.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Performance may not transfer to new chemotypes, substrates, catalysts, or experimental conditions.", "frequency_proxy_units": "4", "gate": "computational_model_assumptions", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-024", "pattern_name": "Predictions lack prospective validation", "reviewer_concern": "Performance may not transfer to new chemotypes, substrates, catalysts, or experimental conditions.", "revision_direction": "Require prospective tests, scaffold splits, out-of-domain examples, uncertainty estimates, and failure analysis.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "4e76350ee0f8d8da;80914f20c45c15f6;80ccf34ae6f6904b;374e19cb0b117a99", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Predictions lack prospective validation", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Uncertainty may be underestimated or not independent.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Uncertainty may be underestimated or not independent.", "gate": "statistical_inference_and_uncertainty", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-025", "revision_direction": "Require replicate definitions, sample sizes, error propagation, statistical tests, and raw/processed data availability.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Chemical measurements are summarized without clear biological, synthetic, instrumental, or technical replicate definitions.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Uncertainty may be underestimated or not independent.", "frequency_proxy_units": "1", "gate": "statistical_inference_and_uncertainty", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-025", "pattern_name": "Replicate structure is unclear", "reviewer_concern": "Uncertainty may be underestimated or not independent.", "revision_direction": "Require replicate definitions, sample sizes, error propagation, statistical tests, and raw/processed data availability.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "e2adacc2a1546853", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Replicate structure is unclear", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The difference may fall within experimental or fitting uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The difference may fall within experimental or fitting uncertainty.", "gate": "statistical_inference_and_uncertainty", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-026", "revision_direction": "Ask for confidence intervals, significance analysis where appropriate, and practical-effect thresholds.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Claims depend on modest changes in yield, selectivity, rate, binding, or spectroscopic parameters.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The difference may fall within experimental or fitting uncertainty.", "frequency_proxy_units": "1", "gate": "statistical_inference_and_uncertainty", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-026", "pattern_name": "Small differences are interpreted as chemical effects", "reviewer_concern": "The difference may fall within experimental or fitting uncertainty.", "revision_direction": "Ask for confidence intervals, significance analysis where appropriate, and practical-effect thresholds.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "e2adacc2a1546853", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Small differences are interpreted as chemical effects", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Parameter identifiability and covariance can affect the interpretation.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Parameter identifiability and covariance can affect the interpretation.", "gate": "statistical_inference_and_uncertainty", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-027", "revision_direction": "Request residuals, confidence intervals, fitting models, parameter sensitivity, and raw data.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Kinetic, spectroscopic, binding, or computational fits are used to infer parameters.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Parameter identifiability and covariance can affect the interpretation.", "frequency_proxy_units": "1", "gate": "statistical_inference_and_uncertainty", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-027", "pattern_name": "Fitting uncertainty is hidden", "reviewer_concern": "Parameter identifiability and covariance can affect the interpretation.", "revision_direction": "Request residuals, confidence intervals, fitting models, parameter sensitivity, and raw data.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "e2adacc2a1546853", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Fitting uncertainty is hidden", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Off-target chemistry, permeability, metabolism, toxicity, or nonspecific binding can drive effects.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Off-target chemistry, permeability, metabolism, toxicity, or nonspecific binding can drive effects.", "gate": "chemical_biology_and_biointerface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-028", "revision_direction": "Require orthogonal probes, inactive analogues, rescue experiments, dose response, and target engagement evidence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A probe, inhibitor, binder, labelling reagent, or molecular perturbation is used to infer biological function.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Off-target chemistry, permeability, metabolism, toxicity, or nonspecific binding can drive effects.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "chemical_biology_and_biointerface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-028", "pattern_name": "Chemical specificity in biological systems is insufficient", "reviewer_concern": "Off-target chemistry, permeability, metabolism, toxicity, or nonspecific binding can drive effects.", "revision_direction": "Require orthogonal probes, inactive analogues, rescue experiments, dose response, and target engagement evidence.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Chemical specificity in biological systems is insufficient", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Assay response integrates uptake, stability, localization, downstream signalling, and toxicity.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Assay response integrates uptake, stability, localization, downstream signalling, and toxicity.", "gate": "chemical_biology_and_biointerface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-029", "revision_direction": "Ask for mechanistic separation of chemical binding/reactivity from biological response.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Cellular or biomolecular activity is attributed to a designed chemical interaction.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Assay response integrates uptake, stability, localization, downstream signalling, and toxicity.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "chemical_biology_and_biointerface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-029", "pattern_name": "Biological assay readout is treated as direct chemistry", "reviewer_concern": "Assay response integrates uptake, stability, localization, downstream signalling, and toxicity.", "revision_direction": "Ask for mechanistic separation of chemical binding/reactivity from biological response.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Biological assay readout is treated as direct chemistry", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The method may report a specific timescale, state, or construct rather than the general biological mechanism.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The method may report a specific timescale, state, or construct rather than the general biological mechanism.", "gate": "chemical_biology_and_biointerface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-030", "revision_direction": "Require construct controls, timescale limits, orthogonal measurements, and cautious wording.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Spectroscopic or structural data are used to infer functional dynamics.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The method may report a specific timescale, state, or construct rather than the general biological mechanism.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "chemical_biology_and_biointerface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-030", "pattern_name": "Protein or biomolecular dynamics interpretation is overextended", "reviewer_concern": "The method may report a specific timescale, state, or construct rather than the general biological mechanism.", "revision_direction": "Require construct controls, timescale limits, orthogonal measurements, and cautious wording.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Protein or biomolecular dynamics interpretation is overextended", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Performance may reflect morphology, transport, defects, additives, electrolyte, or device architecture rather than chemical design alone.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Performance may reflect morphology, transport, defects, additives, electrolyte, or device architecture rather than chemical design alone.", "gate": "materials_energy_interface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-031", "revision_direction": "Require matched morphology/device controls and chemical-interface characterization.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A material, electrode, polymer, framework, nanostructure, or interface exhibits desirable performance.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Performance may reflect morphology, transport, defects, additives, electrolyte, or device architecture rather than chemical design alone.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "materials_energy_interface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-031", "pattern_name": "Materials performance is interpreted without chemical boundary control", "reviewer_concern": "Performance may reflect morphology, transport, defects, additives, electrolyte, or device architecture rather than chemical design alone.", "revision_direction": "Require matched morphology/device controls and chemical-interface characterization.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Materials performance is interpreted without chemical boundary control", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Ex situ data may miss transient states or air-sensitive reconstruction.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Ex situ data may miss transient states or air-sensitive reconstruction.", "gate": "materials_energy_interface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-032", "revision_direction": "Require operando/in situ evidence where feasible and explicit limits on ex situ interpretation.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Interfacial composition or active phase is assigned after operation.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Ex situ data may miss transient states or air-sensitive reconstruction.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "materials_energy_interface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-032", "pattern_name": "Interface chemistry is inferred from ex situ evidence", "reviewer_concern": "Ex situ data may miss transient states or air-sensitive reconstruction.", "revision_direction": "Require operando/in situ evidence where feasible and explicit limits on ex situ interpretation.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Interface chemistry is inferred from ex situ evidence", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Laboratory success may not address feedstock variability, cost, durability, safety, or process integration.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Laboratory success may not address feedstock variability, cost, durability, safety, or process integration.", "gate": "materials_energy_interface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-033", "revision_direction": "Ask for scope of practical claims, process metrics, and realistic comparison to incumbent chemistry.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A chemistry is linked to sustainability, recycling, energy, or industrial relevance from laboratory-scale evidence.", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Laboratory success may not address feedstock variability, cost, durability, safety, or process integration.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "materials_energy_interface", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-033", "pattern_name": "Scale-up or practical relevance is overstated", "reviewer_concern": "Laboratory success may not address feedstock variability, cost, durability, safety, or process integration.", "revision_direction": "Ask for scope of practical claims, process metrics, and realistic comparison to incumbent chemistry.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Scale-up or practical relevance is overstated", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Small procedural changes can alter chemistry.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Small procedural changes can alter chemistry.", "gate": "reproducibility_data_and_code", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-034", "revision_direction": "Require complete experimental details, instrument settings, calibration, and batch history.", "severity": "unknown", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A key result depends on a procedure with missing concentrations, atmosphere, light intensity, electrode geometry, purification, timing, or material history.", "default_severity": "specific", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Small procedural changes can alter chemistry.", "frequency_proxy_units": "5", "gate": "reproducibility_data_and_code", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-034", "pattern_name": "Synthetic procedure is not reproducible enough", "reviewer_concern": "Small procedural changes can alter chemistry.", "revision_direction": "Require complete experimental details, instrument settings, calibration, and batch history.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "3573de31501d61a4;3107f2478b35112a;9077e51e719b8893;f64768058a2d9230;21a48b4e6da01097", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Synthetic procedure is not reproducible enough", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Readers cannot audit assignments, quantification, or model outputs.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Readers cannot audit assignments, quantification, or model outputs.", "gate": "reproducibility_data_and_code", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-035", "revision_direction": "Require raw spectra/chromatograms, processing scripts, coordinate files, computational inputs, and accession links.", "severity": "unknown", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Claims depend on spectra, chromatograms, images, simulations, or code that are only summarized.", "default_severity": "specific", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Readers cannot audit assignments, quantification, or model outputs.", "frequency_proxy_units": "5", "gate": "reproducibility_data_and_code", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-035", "pattern_name": "Underlying data are insufficiently accessible", "reviewer_concern": "Readers cannot audit assignments, quantification, or model outputs.", "revision_direction": "Require raw spectra/chromatograms, processing scripts, coordinate files, computational inputs, and accession links.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "3573de31501d61a4;3107f2478b35112a;9077e51e719b8893;f64768058a2d9230;21a48b4e6da01097", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Underlying data are insufficiently accessible", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Inconsistent reporting weakens comparability.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Inconsistent reporting weakens comparability.", "gate": "reproducibility_data_and_code", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-036", "revision_direction": "Request harmonized units, tables of conditions, and source-data alignment.", "severity": "unknown", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Different figures or experiments report different denominators, conditions, units, or normalization.", "default_severity": "specific", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Inconsistent reporting weakens comparability.", "frequency_proxy_units": "5", "gate": "reproducibility_data_and_code", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-036", "pattern_name": "Reporting standards are inconsistently applied", "reviewer_concern": "Inconsistent reporting weakens comparability.", "revision_direction": "Request harmonized units, tables of conditions, and source-data alignment.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "3573de31501d61a4;3107f2478b35112a;9077e51e719b8893;f64768058a2d9230;21a48b4e6da01097", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Reporting standards are inconsistently applied", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Ambiguous terms make claims difficult to evaluate.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Ambiguous terms make claims difficult to evaluate.", "gate": "detail_audit_and_clarity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-037", "revision_direction": "Ask for operational definitions, quantitative thresholds, and evidence for each descriptor.", "severity": "unknown", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Terms such as hierarchical, robust, efficient, stable, green, universal, or programmable are used without thresholds.", "default_severity": "specific", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Ambiguous terms make claims difficult to evaluate.", "frequency_proxy_units": "21", "gate": "detail_audit_and_clarity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-037", "pattern_name": "Definitions are rhetorically strong but operationally vague", "reviewer_concern": "Ambiguous terms make claims difficult to evaluate.", "revision_direction": "Ask for operational definitions, quantitative thresholds, and evidence for each descriptor.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "915b29db2b676177;aaf0c70b79bd4cfe;4291441730fb05d8;4e175e188a61f657;ffc1fe02e2cdd1cd;6c7722bc75a3352f", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Definitions are rhetorically strong but operationally vague", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The plotted evidence may not show the claimed comparison or the conditions may be unclear.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The plotted evidence may not show the claimed comparison or the conditions may be unclear.", "gate": "detail_audit_and_clarity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-038", "revision_direction": "Require clearer labels, controls, sample sizes, uncertainty, and direct statement of what the figure establishes.", "severity": "unknown", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "A figure, table, or supplementary result is cited as supporting a specific claim.", "default_severity": "specific", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "The plotted evidence may not show the claimed comparison or the conditions may be unclear.", "frequency_proxy_units": "21", "gate": "detail_audit_and_clarity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-038", "pattern_name": "Figure-to-text alignment is weak", "reviewer_concern": "The plotted evidence may not show the claimed comparison or the conditions may be unclear.", "revision_direction": "Require clearer labels, controls, sample sizes, uncertainty, and direct statement of what the figure establishes.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "915b29db2b676177;aaf0c70b79bd4cfe;4291441730fb05d8;4e175e188a61f657;ffc1fe02e2cdd1cd;6c7722bc75a3352f", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Figure-to-text alignment is weak", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Auditability and reproducibility suffer.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "Auditability and reproducibility suffer.", "gate": "detail_audit_and_clarity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-039", "revision_direction": "Ask for consistent nomenclature, structure files, labels, and abbreviation definitions.", "severity": "unknown", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "Compound names, catalyst labels, structures, charge states, stereochemistry, or abbreviations are inconsistent.", "default_severity": "specific", "domain_scope": "general chemistry manuscripts", "evidence_risk": "Auditability and reproducibility suffer.", "frequency_proxy_units": "21", "gate": "detail_audit_and_clarity", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-039", "pattern_name": "Nomenclature and chemical notation reduce auditability", "reviewer_concern": "Auditability and reproducibility suffer.", "revision_direction": "Ask for consistent nomenclature, structure files, labels, and abbreviation definitions.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "915b29db2b676177;aaf0c70b79bd4cfe;4291441730fb05d8;4e175e188a61f657;ffc1fe02e2cdd1cd;6c7722bc75a3352f", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Nomenclature and chemical notation reduce auditability", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong late-stage or method-development claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits substrate diversity, functional-group tolerance, selectivity, and preparative utility.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-040", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit substrate diversity, functional-group tolerance, selectivity, and preparative utility.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "late-stage or method-development claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "organic_synthesis", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits substrate diversity, functional-group tolerance, selectivity, and preparative utility.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-040", "pattern_name": "Organic Synthesis evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong late-stage or method-development claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit substrate diversity, functional-group tolerance, selectivity, and preparative utility.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "36afd2059d355ec2;f3f4186c07ff0023;36f33539c5b75198;c29cfe41a8d20ecf;db83f408d702e329;d926ade9bafacaa1", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Organic Synthesis evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong catalytic performance claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits normalization, active-site identity, product closure, and stability.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-041", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit normalization, active-site identity, product closure, and stability.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "catalytic performance claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "catalysis", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits normalization, active-site identity, product closure, and stability.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-041", "pattern_name": "Catalysis evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong catalytic performance claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit normalization, active-site identity, product closure, and stability.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;90cb2ebd591ff7e3;8539b2b7a1751491;0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Catalysis evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong light-driven chemistry claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits photon flux, absorption, quenching, ROS/product quantification, and dark controls.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-042", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit photon flux, absorption, quenching, ROS/product quantification, and dark controls.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "light-driven chemistry claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "photocatalysis", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits photon flux, absorption, quenching, ROS/product quantification, and dark controls.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-042", "pattern_name": "Photocatalysis evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong light-driven chemistry claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit photon flux, absorption, quenching, ROS/product quantification, and dark controls.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;90cb2ebd591ff7e3;8539b2b7a1751491;0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Photocatalysis evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong electrochemical activity claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits reference electrode calibration, iR correction, mass transport, Faradaic efficiency, and post-test phase.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-043", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit reference electrode calibration, iR correction, mass transport, Faradaic efficiency, and post-test phase.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "electrochemical activity claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "electrocatalysis", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits reference electrode calibration, iR correction, mass transport, Faradaic efficiency, and post-test phase.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-043", "pattern_name": "Electrocatalysis evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong electrochemical activity claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit reference electrode calibration, iR correction, mass transport, Faradaic efficiency, and post-test phase.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Electrocatalysis evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong chemical-biology mechanism claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits target engagement, off-target chemistry, orthogonal probes, and biological assay specificity.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-044", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit target engagement, off-target chemistry, orthogonal probes, and biological assay specificity.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "chemical-biology mechanism claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "chemical_biology", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits target engagement, off-target chemistry, orthogonal probes, and biological assay specificity.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-044", "pattern_name": "Chemical Biology evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong chemical-biology mechanism claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit target engagement, off-target chemistry, orthogonal probes, and biological assay specificity.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "4291441730fb05d8;566abce1c9169201;45f6f1b41f940d63;508b72d00556c384;357405621be06800;4e175e188a61f657", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Chemical Biology evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong polymer or macromolecular claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits molecular-weight distribution, dispersity, composition, degradation, and batch reproducibility.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-045", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit molecular-weight distribution, dispersity, composition, degradation, and batch reproducibility.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "polymer or macromolecular claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "polymer_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits molecular-weight distribution, dispersity, composition, degradation, and batch reproducibility.", "frequency_proxy_units": "3", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-045", "pattern_name": "Polymer Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong polymer or macromolecular claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit molecular-weight distribution, dispersity, composition, degradation, and batch reproducibility.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "6c7722bc75a3352f;3573de31501d61a4;792c6cd46336fdb6", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Polymer Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong assembly or host–guest claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits stoichiometry, binding model, concentration dependence, morphology, and alternative assemblies.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-046", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit stoichiometry, binding model, concentration dependence, morphology, and alternative assemblies.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "assembly or host–guest claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "supramolecular_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits stoichiometry, binding model, concentration dependence, morphology, and alternative assemblies.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-046", "pattern_name": "Supramolecular Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong assembly or host–guest claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit stoichiometry, binding model, concentration dependence, morphology, and alternative assemblies.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;90cb2ebd591ff7e3;8539b2b7a1751491;0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Supramolecular Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong structure–property claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits phase purity, morphology, defect chemistry, interface state, and matched materials controls.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-047", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit phase purity, morphology, defect chemistry, interface state, and matched materials controls.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "structure–property claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "materials_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits phase purity, morphology, defect chemistry, interface state, and matched materials controls.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-047", "pattern_name": "Materials Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong structure–property claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit phase purity, morphology, defect chemistry, interface state, and matched materials controls.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "c01735fb882370e8;90cb2ebd591ff7e3;8539b2b7a1751491;0a6ed244a124ffe2;54c34538f80ef899;6b2d69fbd4d473d1", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Materials Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong computed chemistry claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits model system, sensitivity, competing pathways, uncertainty, and experimental validation.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-048", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit model system, sensitivity, competing pathways, uncertainty, and experimental validation.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "computed chemistry claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "computational_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits model system, sensitivity, competing pathways, uncertainty, and experimental validation.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-048", "pattern_name": "Computational Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong computed chemistry claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit model system, sensitivity, competing pathways, uncertainty, and experimental validation.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "8adb9f7952ce2c6f;0815bbc636e86615;02058f6f51515476;6743273829dbd71a;13938ecce22bfabd;5aa7d800e6fd97dc", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Computational Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong measurement or mapping claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits calibration, limits of detection, matrix effects, standards, and uncertainty.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-049", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit calibration, limits of detection, matrix effects, standards, and uncertainty.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "measurement or mapping claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "analytical_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits calibration, limits of detection, matrix effects, standards, and uncertainty.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-049", "pattern_name": "Analytical Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong measurement or mapping claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit calibration, limits of detection, matrix effects, standards, and uncertainty.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "6c7722bc75a3352f;3573de31501d61a4;792c6cd46336fdb6;9471b344f2935978;6d11e9e73c06efcc;df9d3d8a0d745e84", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Analytical Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong sustainability claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits mass balance, solvent/reagent burden, energy input, feedstock variability, and practical comparator.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-050", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit mass balance, solvent/reagent burden, energy input, feedstock variability, and practical comparator.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "sustainability claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "green_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits mass balance, solvent/reagent burden, energy input, feedstock variability, and practical comparator.", "frequency_proxy_units": "6", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-050", "pattern_name": "Green Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong sustainability claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit mass balance, solvent/reagent burden, energy input, feedstock variability, and practical comparator.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "6c7722bc75a3352f;3573de31501d61a4;792c6cd46336fdb6;5070f744615692c1;9a92b5fe1996fb2c;8ae85f196a8d95cd", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Green Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The manuscript may make a strong energy-conversion or storage chemistry claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "domain": "nature-chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits device-normalized versus chemistry-normalized performance, degradation, and interface evolution.", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-051", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit device-normalized versus chemistry-normalized performance, degradation, and interface evolution.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"claim_type": "energy-conversion or storage chemistry claim", "default_severity": "major", "domain_scope": "energy_chemistry", "evidence_risk": "The claim can be accepted only if the evidence chain audits device-normalized versus chemistry-normalized performance, degradation, and interface evolution.", "frequency_proxy_units": "0", "gate": "subfield_specific_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "CHEM-PAT-051", "pattern_name": "Energy Chemistry evidence audit", "reviewer_concern": "The manuscript may make a strong energy-conversion or storage chemistry claim while leaving one or more critical audit layers under-specified.", "revision_direction": "Require authors to explicitly test, quantify, or delimit device-normalized versus chemistry-normalized performance, degradation, and interface evolution.", "supporting_unit_hashes": "", "verbatim_text_included": "no"}, "title": "Energy Chemistry evidence audit", "triggers": []}
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| finishing-a-development-branchobra/superpowersUse when implementation is complete, all tests pass, and you need to decide how to integrate the work | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| systematic-debuggingobra/superpowersUse when encountering any bug, test failure, or unexpected behavior, before proposing fixes | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| test-driven-developmentobra/superpowersUse when implementing any feature or bugfix, before writing implementation code | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| skill-creatoranthropics/skillsCreate new skills, modify and improve existing skills, and measure skill performance. Use when users want to create a skill from scratch, edit, or optimize an existing skill, run evals to test a skill, benchmark skill performance with variance analysis, or optimize a skill's description for better triggering accuracy. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |