GeoGeekLab/nature-reviewer-skills / nature-earth-system-reviewer-skills/skills/nature-atmospheric-science-reviewer-skill
nature-atmospheric-science-reviewer
VerifiedNature-style atmospheric science manuscript reviewer skill for testing observation, reanalysis, model, aerosol-cloud-radiation, extreme-event, circulation-mechanism and attribution claims against their physical evidence chain.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| LICENSE | other | 1.1 KB |
| MANIFEST.json | config | 368 B |
| README.md | markdown | 7.5 KB |
| SKILL.md | skill md | 10.4 KB |
| checksums.sha256 | other | 1.7 KB |
| docs/SECURITY.md | markdown | 114 B |
| examples/evaluation_prediction.json | config | 260 B |
| references/claim_evidence_protocol.md | markdown | 550 B |
| references/domain_gate.md | markdown | 155 B |
| references/evaluation_contract.md | markdown | 306 B |
| requirements-dev.txt | markdown | 30 B |
| reviewer_db/patterns.csv | other | 17.4 KB |
| reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl | other | 55.9 KB |
| reviewer_db/summary.json | config | 919 B |
| scripts/extract_text_with_anchors.py | script | 1.2 KB |
| scripts/render_review_docx.py | script | 971 B |
| scripts/reviewer_db.py | script | 1.6 KB |
| scripts/validate_package.py | script | 928 B |
| templates/review_report.md | markdown | 953 B |
| tests/test_package.py | script | 640 B |
reviewer_db/patterns.jsonl
View on GitHub{"concern": "Broad atmospheric claims are stronger than the demonstrated variable, domain, or diagnostic supports.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P001", "revision_direction": "Require each headline claim to be mapped to the actual observable, model output, validation target, and inference boundary.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Broad atmospheric claims are stronger than the demonstrated variable, domain, or diagnostic supports.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "264", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P001", "revision_direction": "Require each headline claim to be mapped to the actual observable, model output, validation target, and inference boundary.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Broad atmospheric claims are stronger than the demonstrated variable, domain, or diagnostic supports.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "A paper treats a proxy, index, or diagnostic as the target atmospheric quantity without quantifying the proxy relationship.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P002", "revision_direction": "State what is directly observed or simulated and validate the proxy-target link under relevant regimes.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "A paper treats a proxy, index, or diagnostic as the target atmospheric quantity without quantifying the proxy relationship.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "264", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P002", "revision_direction": "State what is directly observed or simulated and validate the proxy-target link under relevant regimes.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "A paper treats a proxy, index, or diagnostic as the target atmospheric quantity without quantifying the proxy relationship.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The novelty claim is not calibrated against the closest atmospheric dynamics, chemistry, observation, or modelling literature.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P003", "revision_direction": "Compare against the nearest prior work using the same scale, phenomenon, data family, and diagnostic metric.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "The novelty claim is not calibrated against the closest atmospheric dynamics, chemistry, observation, or modelling literature.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "264", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P003", "revision_direction": "Compare against the nearest prior work using the same scale, phenomenon, data family, and diagnostic metric.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "The novelty claim is not calibrated against the closest atmospheric dynamics, chemistry, observation, or modelling literature.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Policy-facing or public-impact statements exceed the physical evidence chain.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P004", "revision_direction": "Separate physical attribution, exposure/risk framing, and policy implication; soften claims not directly tested.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Policy-facing or public-impact statements exceed the physical evidence chain.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "264", "gate": "atmospheric_claim_evidence_calibration", "pattern_id": "P004", "revision_direction": "Separate physical attribution, exposure/risk framing, and policy implication; soften claims not directly tested.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Policy-facing or public-impact statements exceed the physical evidence chain.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Reanalysis, satellite, or station products are used as truth without product-specific bias and uncertainty checks.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P005", "revision_direction": "Add product intercomparison, independent validation, known retrieval limitations, and regime-specific bias tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Reanalysis, satellite, or station products are used as truth without product-specific bias and uncertainty checks.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "210", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P005", "revision_direction": "Add product intercomparison, independent validation, known retrieval limitations, and regime-specific bias tests.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Reanalysis, satellite, or station products are used as truth without product-specific bias and uncertainty checks.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The observational product is evaluated at aggregate scale while conclusions concern extremes, vertical structure, clouds, aerosols, or local circulation.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P006", "revision_direction": "Validate the product at the scale and atmospheric state used in the claim.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "The observational product is evaluated at aggregate scale while conclusions concern extremes, vertical structure, clouds, aerosols, or local circulation.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "210", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P006", "revision_direction": "Validate the product at the scale and atmospheric state used in the claim.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "The observational product is evaluated at aggregate scale while conclusions concern extremes, vertical structure, clouds, aerosols, or local circulation.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Retrieval validity under clouds, aerosols, precipitation, boundary-layer conditions, or complex terrain is assumed.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P007", "revision_direction": "Document retrieval screening, representativeness, missingness, and sensitivity to quality flags.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Retrieval validity under clouds, aerosols, precipitation, boundary-layer conditions, or complex terrain is assumed.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "210", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P007", "revision_direction": "Document retrieval screening, representativeness, missingness, and sensitivity to quality flags.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Retrieval validity under clouds, aerosols, precipitation, boundary-layer conditions, or complex terrain is assumed.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "A single observational product drives the result although alternative products disagree or have known structural uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P008", "revision_direction": "Use multi-product comparison and show whether the conclusion is robust to product choice.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "A single observational product drives the result although alternative products disagree or have known structural uncertainty.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "210", "gate": "observational_product_reanalysis_validity", "pattern_id": "P008", "revision_direction": "Use multi-product comparison and show whether the conclusion is robust to product choice.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "A single observational product drives the result although alternative products disagree or have known structural uncertainty.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The case, station network, campaign, season, or event sample is too narrow for the claimed atmospheric generalization.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P009", "revision_direction": "Define the sampling frame and test whether conclusions hold across seasons, regions, regimes, and event types.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "The case, station network, campaign, season, or event sample is too narrow for the claimed atmospheric generalization.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "166", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P009", "revision_direction": "Define the sampling frame and test whether conclusions hold across seasons, regions, regimes, and event types.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "The case, station network, campaign, season, or event sample is too narrow for the claimed atmospheric generalization.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Event selection or compositing may condition on the outcome variable.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P010", "revision_direction": "Separate discovery and evaluation samples; predefine event thresholds or test alternative definitions.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Event selection or compositing may condition on the outcome variable.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "166", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P010", "revision_direction": "Separate discovery and evaluation samples; predefine event thresholds or test alternative definitions.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Event selection or compositing may condition on the outcome variable.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Sparse vertical, temporal, or regional coverage is not propagated into inference uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P011", "revision_direction": "Quantify representativeness error and avoid spatial/temporal extrapolation not supported by coverage.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Sparse vertical, temporal, or regional coverage is not propagated into inference uncertainty.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "166", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P011", "revision_direction": "Quantify representativeness error and avoid spatial/temporal extrapolation not supported by coverage.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Sparse vertical, temporal, or regional coverage is not propagated into inference uncertainty.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The reference period or baseline changes the sign or magnitude of the claimed anomaly.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P012", "revision_direction": "Test baseline sensitivity and report whether conclusions are reference-period dependent.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "The reference period or baseline changes the sign or magnitude of the claimed anomaly.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "166", "gate": "sampling_event_representativeness", "pattern_id": "P012", "revision_direction": "Test baseline sensitivity and report whether conclusions are reference-period dependent.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "The reference period or baseline changes the sign or magnitude of the claimed anomaly.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "A process resolved at one scale is interpreted at another scale without closure.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P013", "revision_direction": "Align claim scale, model grid, observational footprint, and process scale; discuss unresolved subgrid processes.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "A process resolved at one scale is interpreted at another scale without closure.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "162", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P013", "revision_direction": "Align claim scale, model grid, observational footprint, and process scale; discuss unresolved subgrid processes.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "A process resolved at one scale is interpreted at another scale without closure.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Boundary conditions, domain choice, or nesting strategy may impose the atmospheric response.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P014", "revision_direction": "Add domain and boundary sensitivity tests or limit conclusions to the simulated domain.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Boundary conditions, domain choice, or nesting strategy may impose the atmospheric response.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "162", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P014", "revision_direction": "Add domain and boundary sensitivity tests or limit conclusions to the simulated domain.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Boundary conditions, domain choice, or nesting strategy may impose the atmospheric response.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Mesoscale, boundary-layer, convective, or orographic processes are inferred from coarse products.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P015", "revision_direction": "Use scale-aware diagnostics or revise claims to match resolvable dynamics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Mesoscale, boundary-layer, convective, or orographic processes are inferred from coarse products.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "162", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P015", "revision_direction": "Use scale-aware diagnostics or revise claims to match resolvable dynamics.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Mesoscale, boundary-layer, convective, or orographic processes are inferred from coarse products.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Spatial aggregation hides regime-dependent or sign-changing effects.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P016", "revision_direction": "Report heterogeneity across regimes, seasons, altitudes, and dynamical settings.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Spatial aggregation hides regime-dependent or sign-changing effects.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "162", "gate": "scale_resolution_boundary_consistency", "pattern_id": "P016", "revision_direction": "Report heterogeneity across regimes, seasons, altitudes, and dynamical settings.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Spatial aggregation hides regime-dependent or sign-changing effects.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "A model-based conclusion depends on parameterizations, forcing, initialization, or structural choices not stress-tested.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P017", "revision_direction": "Run or cite targeted sensitivity tests and identify parameters that control the claim.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "A model-based conclusion depends on parameterizations, forcing, initialization, or structural choices not stress-tested.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "204", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P017", "revision_direction": "Run or cite targeted sensitivity tests and identify parameters that control the claim.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "A model-based conclusion depends on parameterizations, forcing, initialization, or structural choices not stress-tested.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The model reproduces headline metrics but not the relevant circulation, flux, cloud, aerosol, or chemistry process.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P018", "revision_direction": "Evaluate process fidelity, not only outcome fit.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "The model reproduces headline metrics but not the relevant circulation, flux, cloud, aerosol, or chemistry process.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "204", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P018", "revision_direction": "Evaluate process fidelity, not only outcome fit.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "The model reproduces headline metrics but not the relevant circulation, flux, cloud, aerosol, or chemistry process.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Single-model evidence is used for attribution or mechanism claims.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P019", "revision_direction": "Use ensembles, alternative models, or structural uncertainty analysis; downgrade if unavailable.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Single-model evidence is used for attribution or mechanism claims.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "204", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P019", "revision_direction": "Use ensembles, alternative models, or structural uncertainty analysis; downgrade if unavailable.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Single-model evidence is used for attribution or mechanism claims.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Tuning or calibration may use information later treated as independent validation.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P020", "revision_direction": "Separate calibration, selection, and validation; disclose tuning targets.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Tuning or calibration may use information later treated as independent validation.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "204", "gate": "model_physics_assumption_sensitivity", "pattern_id": "P020", "revision_direction": "Separate calibration, selection, and validation; disclose tuning targets.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Tuning or calibration may use information later treated as independent validation.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "AI weather or climate models are judged mainly by headline skill metrics without physical-fidelity tests.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P021", "revision_direction": "Evaluate conservation, spectra, extremes, vertical coupling, regime transitions, and climate statistics.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "AI weather or climate models are judged mainly by headline skill metrics without physical-fidelity tests.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "222", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P021", "revision_direction": "Evaluate conservation, spectra, extremes, vertical coupling, regime transitions, and climate statistics.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "AI weather or climate models are judged mainly by headline skill metrics without physical-fidelity tests.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Training, validation, or benchmark design may allow temporal leakage, reanalysis memorization, or unfair baselines.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P022", "revision_direction": "Audit data splits, baselines, lead times, initialization, and operational comparability.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Training, validation, or benchmark design may allow temporal leakage, reanalysis memorization, or unfair baselines.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "222", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P022", "revision_direction": "Audit data splits, baselines, lead times, initialization, and operational comparability.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Training, validation, or benchmark design may allow temporal leakage, reanalysis memorization, or unfair baselines.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Short-range skill is extrapolated to climate, extremes, or out-of-distribution regimes.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P023", "revision_direction": "Test OOD periods, climate-state shifts, rare events, and long-rollout stability.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Short-range skill is extrapolated to climate, extremes, or out-of-distribution regimes.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "222", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P023", "revision_direction": "Test OOD periods, climate-state shifts, rare events, and long-rollout stability.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Short-range skill is extrapolated to climate, extremes, or out-of-distribution regimes.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Computational advantage is claimed without equivalent accuracy, uncertainty, and deployment constraints.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P024", "revision_direction": "Compare cost, resolution, latency, reliability, ensembles, and failure modes on matched tasks.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Computational advantage is claimed without equivalent accuracy, uncertainty, and deployment constraints.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "222", "gate": "ai_weather_climate_model_fidelity", "pattern_id": "P024", "revision_direction": "Compare cost, resolution, latency, reliability, ensembles, and failure modes on matched tasks.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Computational advantage is claimed without equivalent accuracy, uncertainty, and deployment constraints.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Aerosol-cloud or aerosol-radiation effects are inferred from aerosol amount alone.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P025", "revision_direction": "Separate amount, composition, vertical distribution, meteorology, cloud regime, and radiative kernel.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Aerosol-cloud or aerosol-radiation effects are inferred from aerosol amount alone.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P025", "revision_direction": "Separate amount, composition, vertical distribution, meteorology, cloud regime, and radiative kernel.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Aerosol-cloud or aerosol-radiation effects are inferred from aerosol amount alone.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Cloud adjustment, semi-direct effects, or meteorological covariability is not separated from microphysical forcing.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P026", "revision_direction": "Use process decomposition, controls, or causal design to isolate mechanisms.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Cloud adjustment, semi-direct effects, or meteorological covariability is not separated from microphysical forcing.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P026", "revision_direction": "Use process decomposition, controls, or causal design to isolate mechanisms.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Cloud adjustment, semi-direct effects, or meteorological covariability is not separated from microphysical forcing.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "New-particle formation, CCN, or cloud response is sensitive to precursor chemistry not independently constrained.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P027", "revision_direction": "Add precursor, mechanism, and rate sensitivity; validate against field or chamber constraints where possible.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "New-particle formation, CCN, or cloud response is sensitive to precursor chemistry not independently constrained.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P027", "revision_direction": "Add precursor, mechanism, and rate sensitivity; validate against field or chamber constraints where possible.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "New-particle formation, CCN, or cloud response is sensitive to precursor chemistry not independently constrained.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Radiative forcing estimates omit uncertainty from optical properties, vertical overlap, cloud masking, or humidity dependence.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P028", "revision_direction": "Propagate radiative and microphysical uncertainty into the headline forcing result.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Radiative forcing estimates omit uncertainty from optical properties, vertical overlap, cloud masking, or humidity dependence.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "aerosol_cloud_radiation_microphysics", "pattern_id": "P028", "revision_direction": "Propagate radiative and microphysical uncertainty into the headline forcing result.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Radiative forcing estimates omit uncertainty from optical properties, vertical overlap, cloud masking, or humidity dependence.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Atmospheric chemistry or emissions conclusions depend on inventories or lifetimes that are not independently checked.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P029", "revision_direction": "Compare inventory families, source apportionment assumptions, chemical lifetimes, and observation constraints.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Atmospheric chemistry or emissions conclusions depend on inventories or lifetimes that are not independently checked.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "54", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P029", "revision_direction": "Compare inventory families, source apportionment assumptions, chemical lifetimes, and observation constraints.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Atmospheric chemistry or emissions conclusions depend on inventories or lifetimes that are not independently checked.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Reactive species are aggregated although sign, lifetime, or forcing differs across compounds and pathways.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P030", "revision_direction": "Disaggregate chemical pathways and report regime-dependent net effects.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Reactive species are aggregated although sign, lifetime, or forcing differs across compounds and pathways.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "54", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P030", "revision_direction": "Disaggregate chemical pathways and report regime-dependent net effects.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Reactive species are aggregated although sign, lifetime, or forcing differs across compounds and pathways.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Budget closure is claimed without reconciling sources, sinks, transport, deposition, and chemical transformation.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P031", "revision_direction": "Provide budget closure diagnostics and residual analysis.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Budget closure is claimed without reconciling sources, sinks, transport, deposition, and chemical transformation.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "54", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P031", "revision_direction": "Provide budget closure diagnostics and residual analysis.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Budget closure is claimed without reconciling sources, sinks, transport, deposition, and chemical transformation.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Emission-reduction implications are inferred without considering co-emitted species or non-atmospheric parts of the life cycle.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P032", "revision_direction": "Define the atmospheric boundary and state excluded life-cycle terms.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Emission-reduction implications are inferred without considering co-emitted species or non-atmospheric parts of the life cycle.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "54", "gate": "chemistry_emissions_budget", "pattern_id": "P032", "revision_direction": "Define the atmospheric boundary and state excluded life-cycle terms.", "severity_default": "minor_major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Emission-reduction implications are inferred without considering co-emitted species or non-atmospheric parts of the life cycle.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Extreme-event attribution depends on event definition, spatial extent, duration, or threshold choices.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P033", "revision_direction": "Show sensitivity to event definitions and justify the physical relevance of thresholds.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Extreme-event attribution depends on event definition, spatial extent, duration, or threshold choices.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "45", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P033", "revision_direction": "Show sensitivity to event definitions and justify the physical relevance of thresholds.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Extreme-event attribution depends on event definition, spatial extent, duration, or threshold choices.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Counterfactual forcing, model evaluation, or internal variability is insufficient for causal attribution.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P034", "revision_direction": "Evaluate factual/counterfactual model fidelity and quantify internal variability.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Counterfactual forcing, model evaluation, or internal variability is insufficient for causal attribution.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "45", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P034", "revision_direction": "Evaluate factual/counterfactual model fidelity and quantify internal variability.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Counterfactual forcing, model evaluation, or internal variability is insufficient for causal attribution.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Return periods or risk ratios are extrapolated beyond data/model support.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P035", "revision_direction": "Report uncertainty, tail sensitivity, and whether extrapolation dominates the conclusion.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Return periods or risk ratios are extrapolated beyond data/model support.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "45", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P035", "revision_direction": "Report uncertainty, tail sensitivity, and whether extrapolation dominates the conclusion.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Return periods or risk ratios are extrapolated beyond data/model support.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Attribution to emitters, sectors, or regions is presented more precisely than the causal chain supports.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P036", "revision_direction": "Separate climate-forcing contribution from event-specific impact and allocation uncertainty.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Attribution to emitters, sectors, or regions is presented more precisely than the causal chain supports.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "45", "gate": "extreme_event_attribution_counterfactual", "pattern_id": "P036", "revision_direction": "Separate climate-forcing contribution from event-specific impact and allocation uncertainty.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Attribution to emitters, sectors, or regions is presented more precisely than the causal chain supports.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Trend claims are made from short, selected, or autocorrelated time series.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P037", "revision_direction": "Account for autocorrelation, internal variability, reference period, and multiple testing.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Trend claims are made from short, selected, or autocorrelated time series.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "69", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P037", "revision_direction": "Account for autocorrelation, internal variability, reference period, and multiple testing.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Trend claims are made from short, selected, or autocorrelated time series.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Forced signal and natural variability are not separated.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P038", "revision_direction": "Use control simulations, ensembles, pacemaker diagnostics, or formal detection-attribution framing.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Forced signal and natural variability are not separated.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "69", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P038", "revision_direction": "Use control simulations, ensembles, pacemaker diagnostics, or formal detection-attribution framing.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Forced signal and natural variability are not separated.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "A regional trend is interpreted as global mechanism or forced response without teleconnection validation.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P039", "revision_direction": "Validate regional-to-global scaling and circulation pathways.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "A regional trend is interpreted as global mechanism or forced response without teleconnection validation.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "69", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P039", "revision_direction": "Validate regional-to-global scaling and circulation pathways.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "A regional trend is interpreted as global mechanism or forced response without teleconnection validation.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "The sign or significance of trend changes under alternative products, seasons, or endpoints.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P040", "revision_direction": "Report endpoint sensitivity and avoid categorical claims where robustness is weak.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "The sign or significance of trend changes under alternative products, seasons, or endpoints.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "69", "gate": "trend_internal_variability_signal_detection", "pattern_id": "P040", "revision_direction": "Report endpoint sensitivity and avoid categorical claims where robustness is weak.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "The sign or significance of trend changes under alternative products, seasons, or endpoints.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Mechanistic explanation is inferred from correlation, composites, or post-hoc diagnostics.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P041", "revision_direction": "Use process diagnostics, perturbation tests, lag structure, or causal exclusion of alternatives.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Mechanistic explanation is inferred from correlation, composites, or post-hoc diagnostics.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P041", "revision_direction": "Use process diagnostics, perturbation tests, lag structure, or causal exclusion of alternatives.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Mechanistic explanation is inferred from correlation, composites, or post-hoc diagnostics.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Circulation pathway, moisture transport, energy budget, or feedback loop is not closed.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P042", "revision_direction": "Add budget/pathway diagnostics and quantify competing mechanisms.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Circulation pathway, moisture transport, energy budget, or feedback loop is not closed.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P042", "revision_direction": "Add budget/pathway diagnostics and quantify competing mechanisms.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Circulation pathway, moisture transport, energy budget, or feedback loop is not closed.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Confounding by ENSO, modes of variability, land forcing, aerosols, or background warming is not controlled.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P043", "revision_direction": "Condition on or remove major confounders and test mechanism persistence.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Confounding by ENSO, modes of variability, land forcing, aerosols, or background warming is not controlled.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P043", "revision_direction": "Condition on or remove major confounders and test mechanism persistence.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Confounding by ENSO, modes of variability, land forcing, aerosols, or background warming is not controlled.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Causal verbs are used where the design supports association only.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P044", "revision_direction": "Replace causal language or add causal design.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Causal verbs are used where the design supports association only.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "77", "gate": "mechanism_causality_circulation_dynamics", "pattern_id": "P044", "revision_direction": "Replace causal language or add causal design.", "severity_default": "minor_major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Causal verbs are used where the design supports association only.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Uncertainty intervals omit structural, product, ensemble, or parameter uncertainty.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P045", "revision_direction": "Propagate all uncertainty sources that materially affect the central claim.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Uncertainty intervals omit structural, product, ensemble, or parameter uncertainty.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "46", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P045", "revision_direction": "Propagate all uncertainty sources that materially affect the central claim.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Uncertainty intervals omit structural, product, ensemble, or parameter uncertainty.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Statistical significance is reported without multiple-testing, autocorrelation, spatial dependence, or effective sample size correction.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P046", "revision_direction": "Use field significance, block bootstrap, hierarchical uncertainty, or equivalent methods.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Statistical significance is reported without multiple-testing, autocorrelation, spatial dependence, or effective sample size correction.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "46", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P046", "revision_direction": "Use field significance, block bootstrap, hierarchical uncertainty, or equivalent methods.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Statistical significance is reported without multiple-testing, autocorrelation, spatial dependence, or effective sample size correction.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Forecast or model skill metrics are insufficiently tied to the atmospheric phenomenon being claimed.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P047", "revision_direction": "Use phenomenon-specific metrics for extremes, spectra, circulation, fluxes, and vertical structure.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Forecast or model skill metrics are insufficiently tied to the atmospheric phenomenon being claimed.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "46", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P047", "revision_direction": "Use phenomenon-specific metrics for extremes, spectra, circulation, fluxes, and vertical structure.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Forecast or model skill metrics are insufficiently tied to the atmospheric phenomenon being claimed.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Validation is not independent of model/product construction.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P048", "revision_direction": "Use withheld data, independent observations, or out-of-sample tests.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Validation is not independent of model/product construction.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "46", "gate": "uncertainty_statistics_skill_metrics", "pattern_id": "P048", "revision_direction": "Use withheld data, independent observations, or out-of-sample tests.", "severity_default": "central", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Validation is not independent of model/product construction.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Data, code, configuration, or model version information is insufficient for reproduction.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P049", "revision_direction": "Provide exact data versions, preprocessing, scripts, configuration, and random seeds where relevant.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Data, code, configuration, or model version information is insufficient for reproduction.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "24", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P049", "revision_direction": "Provide exact data versions, preprocessing, scripts, configuration, and random seeds where relevant.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Data, code, configuration, or model version information is insufficient for reproduction.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Complex workflows lack provenance for intermediate products.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P050", "revision_direction": "Document workflow DAG, checksums, generated products, and quality-control flags.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Complex workflows lack provenance for intermediate products.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "24", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P050", "revision_direction": "Document workflow DAG, checksums, generated products, and quality-control flags.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Complex workflows lack provenance for intermediate products.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Large atmospheric datasets are cited generically without temporal, spatial, or processing specification.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P051", "revision_direction": "Specify product version, access date, subset, processing level, and transformations.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Large atmospheric datasets are cited generically without temporal, spatial, or processing specification.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "24", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P051", "revision_direction": "Specify product version, access date, subset, processing level, and transformations.", "severity_default": "minor_major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Large atmospheric datasets are cited generically without temporal, spatial, or processing specification.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Definitions, units, thresholds, signs, or abbreviations are inconsistent across text, figures, tables, and methods.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P052", "revision_direction": "Audit terminology, units, and sign conventions throughout.", "severity": "minor", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Definitions, units, thresholds, signs, or abbreviations are inconsistent across text, figures, tables, and methods.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "187", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P052", "revision_direction": "Audit terminology, units, and sign conventions throughout.", "severity_default": "minor", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Definitions, units, thresholds, signs, or abbreviations are inconsistent across text, figures, tables, and methods.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Figure captions do not state data source, period, region, uncertainty, or sample size.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P053", "revision_direction": "Make each figure interpretable without relying on hidden methods.", "severity": "minor", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Figure captions do not state data source, period, region, uncertainty, or sample size.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "187", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P053", "revision_direction": "Make each figure interpretable without relying on hidden methods.", "severity_default": "minor", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Figure captions do not state data source, period, region, uncertainty, or sample size.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Supplementary methods contain essential information not visible in the main evidence chain.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P054", "revision_direction": "Move central validation and uncertainty information into the main text or extended data summary.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Supplementary methods contain essential information not visible in the main evidence chain.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "187", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P054", "revision_direction": "Move central validation and uncertainty information into the main text or extended data summary.", "severity_default": "minor_major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Supplementary methods contain essential information not visible in the main evidence chain.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Terminology confuses weather forecast skill, climate projection, attribution, and mechanism diagnosis.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P055", "revision_direction": "Use distinct language for prediction, projection, attribution, and explanation.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Terminology confuses weather forecast skill, climate projection, attribution, and mechanism diagnosis.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "187", "gate": "detail_audit", "pattern_id": "P055", "revision_direction": "Use distinct language for prediction, projection, attribution, and explanation.", "severity_default": "minor_major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Terminology confuses weather forecast skill, climate projection, attribution, and mechanism diagnosis.", "triggers": []}
{"concern": "Reviewers request clearer availability of trained AI weights, inference code, and benchmark scripts.", "domain": "nature-atmospheric-science", "evidence_risk": "", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P056", "revision_direction": "Provide archived code, model weights where possible, executable benchmarks, and environment files.", "severity": "major", "source_fields": {"abstract_risk_pattern": "Reviewers request clearer availability of trained AI weights, inference code, and benchmark scripts.", "corpus_unit_count_for_gate": "24", "gate": "reproducibility_data_code", "pattern_id": "P056", "revision_direction": "Provide archived code, model weights where possible, executable benchmarks, and environment files.", "severity_default": "major", "source_type": "abstracted_from_public_peer_review_files_and_stress_test_anchors", "verbatim_reviewer_text": "not_stored"}, "title": "Reviewers request clearer availability of trained AI weights, inference code, and benchmark scripts.", "triggers": []}
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| finishing-a-development-branchobra/superpowersUse when implementation is complete, all tests pass, and you need to decide how to integrate the work | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| systematic-debuggingobra/superpowersUse when encountering any bug, test failure, or unexpected behavior, before proposing fixes | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| test-driven-developmentobra/superpowersUse when implementing any feature or bugfix, before writing implementation code | Stars: 323k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| skill-creatoranthropics/skillsCreate new skills, modify and improve existing skills, and measure skill performance. Use when users want to create a skill from scratch, edit, or optimize an existing skill, run evals to test a skill, benchmark skill performance with variance analysis, or optimize a skill's description for better triggering accuracy. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |