GarethManning/education-agent-skills / skills/curriculum-assessment/scope-and-sequence-designer
scope-and-sequence-designer
VerifiedDesign a scope and sequence showing vertical and horizontal curriculum coherence across a programme or year. Use when building new programmes, restructuring subjects, or ensuring progression.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 35.3 KB |
| references/worked-examples.md | markdown | 21.9 KB |
references/worked-examples.md
View on GitHub## Example Output
**Scenario:** *Subject or programme: "Wellbeing, REAL School Budapest" / Developmental bands: "Bands A–D (approximately ages 5–15)" / Intended outcomes: "Students develop self-regulation, agency, care for others, and the scientific literacy to understand their own wellbeing" / Existing units or competencies: "Existing competencies: Self-Awareness & Regulation, Health Literacy & Habits, Reflective Thinking & Decision-Making, Social Awareness & Empathy, Communication & Collaboration. New competency being added: Wellbeing Science & Literacy (hierarchical knowledge of neuroscience, stress response, habits science)"*
---
## Scope and Sequence: Wellbeing, REAL School Budapest
**Programme:** Wellbeing — self-regulation, agency, care for others, scientific literacy for understanding own wellbeing
**Developmental bands:** Bands A–D (approximately ages 5–15)
**Intended outcomes:** Students develop self-regulation, agency, care for others, and the scientific literacy to understand their own wellbeing
**Time available:** Not specified
**Input state:** State D — competency definitions supplied without KUD charts, LT types, or prerequisite map. Medium-low confidence. Supplying KUD charts via KUD Chart Author would substantially improve sequencing reliability.
### Confidence Level
Medium-low. Prerequisite relationships inferred from competency definitions and knowledge domain conventions. Supplying KUD charts (Know/Understand/Do per band) would raise confidence to high for hierarchical relationships. Subject expert review required for all inferred hard prerequisites before treating them as non-negotiable.
### 0. Prerequisite Map
*Inferred from competency definitions and knowledge domain. Subject expert review required — particularly for neuroscience prerequisites, which are non-obvious from competency text alone.*
| LT / Concept | Relationship | LT / Concept | Rationale | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Body awareness | hard | Fight-flight-freeze | Cannot understand automatic physical stress responses without first noticing physical sensations | High |
| Fight-flight-freeze | hard | Autonomic nervous system | ANS content assumes the concept of automatic stress responses is established | High |
| Autonomic nervous system | hard | HPA axis | HPA axis extends the ANS model — cannot teach neuroendocrine pathway without the ANS concept | High |
| Basic brain awareness | hard | Amygdala & threat detection | Amygdala content requires prior concept that brain structures underlie emotional responses | High |
| Habits science | conceptual_accelerator | Health Literacy & Habits (dispositional) | Habits science makes dispositional habit practice more portable and self-directed | Medium |
| Autonomic nervous system | conceptual_accelerator | Self-Awareness & Regulation | Knowing WHY calming techniques work makes strategy selection more transferable | Medium |
| Reflective Thinking & Decision-Making | soft_enabler | Agency | Reflective capacity enriches agentic decision-making but does not gate early agency expression | Medium |
| Self-Awareness & Regulation | soft_enabler | Care for others | Developed self-awareness makes noticing others' states more reliable, but care can begin before regulation is mature | Medium |
### 1. Knowledge Architecture Diagnosis
**Hierarchical elements:**
- **Wellbeing Science & Literacy** (new competency): Neuroscience of the stress response, brain structures involved in emotional processing, the HPA axis, cortisol and adrenaline pathways, the autonomic nervous system (sympathetic/parasympathetic), the physiological basis of calming techniques, habits science (cue-routine-reward loop, neuroplasticity), sleep science, nutrition and wellbeing connections
- **Health Literacy & Habits** (existing competency, partially hierarchical): Factual knowledge about physical health — nutrition basics, sleep hygiene, exercise science — that has right/wrong answers and prerequisite chains
**Horizontal elements:**
- **Reflective Thinking & Decision-Making** (existing competency): Analysing situations through multiple lenses, weighing competing considerations, evaluating the quality of one's own reasoning — thinking sophistication must increase across bands
- **Social Awareness & Empathy** (existing competency, partially horizontal): Understanding different perspectives, recognising that emotional responses are influenced by context, history, and interpretation — perspectival knowledge that deepens through analytical sophistication
- **Communication & Collaboration** (existing competency, partially horizontal): The quality of collaborative thinking, conflict resolution reasoning, and communication strategy must become more sophisticated, not just more frequent
**Dispositional elements:**
- **Self-Awareness & Regulation** (existing competency): Enacted self-regulation — noticing emotional escalation and choosing a response rather than reacting. This is a disposition, not a skill: it exists in patterns of behaviour over time, not in task performance
- **Agency** (intended outcome, not yet a named competency): The orientation toward taking purposeful action — not compliance and not defiance, but self-directed engagement with challenges. Develops as a continuous thread
- **Care for others** (intended outcome, not yet a named competency): The interpersonal disposition to notice and respond to others' wellbeing. Not the same as social awareness (which is partly horizontal knowledge) — care is enacted, not analysed
- **Health Literacy & Habits** (existing competency, partially dispositional): The habit dimension — actually maintaining routines that support wellbeing, as distinct from knowing what the routines should be
**Architecture summary:**
This programme is a **mixed architecture with a significant dispositional core and a new hierarchical strand**. The five existing competencies are primarily dispositional and horizontal — they describe ways of being and ways of thinking, not factual knowledge to be acquired. The addition of Wellbeing Science & Literacy introduces a genuinely hierarchical strand with prerequisite chains that must be respected. The central design challenge is connecting the hierarchical knowledge (neuroscience, stress science, habits science) to the dispositional goals (self-regulation, agency, care) — the science is not an end in itself but the knowledge foundation that makes the dispositions more informed, more intentional, and more effective.
### 2. Sequencing Constraints
| LT or Competency | Constraint Type | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Body awareness → Fight-flight-freeze | hard | Physical sensation awareness is logically required to understand automatic physical stress responses |
| Fight-flight-freeze → Autonomic nervous system | hard | ANS content builds directly on the established concept of automatic arousal |
| Autonomic nervous system → HPA axis | hard | Neuroendocrine pathway requires ANS concept as foundation |
| Basic brain awareness → Amygdala content | hard | Brain structure content requires the prior concept that emotions have a neural basis |
| Self-Awareness & Regulation (experiential, early bands) before ANS content | recommended | Experiential readiness logic — practised regulation encounters the explanation as confirmation, not abstraction |
| Habits science before Health Literacy & Habits (informed practice, Band D) | recommended | Conceptual accelerator — habits science makes dispositional practice more self-directed |
| Reflective Thinking before meta-reflective Agency | recommended | Soft enabler — reflective capacity enriches but does not gate early agency |
### 3. Recommended Sequence with Rationale
**Band A:**
- Body awareness — *Hard prerequisite foundation: no prior concept required; directly observable; entry point for all wellbeing science*
- Basic brain awareness — *Hard prerequisite: follows body awareness; age-appropriate framing that prepares amygdala content*
- Emotions vocabulary — *Hard prerequisite chain: builds on body awareness; more nuanced vocabulary requires basic awareness*
- Self-Awareness & Regulation (emergent, experiential) — *Experiential readiness: disposition practice begins before explanation; experience-first is correct for T3 social-emotional LTs* ⚑ teacher discretion
- Care for others (emergent) — *Experiential readiness: enacted care begins as prompted kindness before contextual understanding* ⚑ teacher discretion
- Agency (emergent) — *Experiential readiness: early choice-making experience precedes reflective framing* ⚑ teacher discretion
**Band B:**
- Fight-flight-freeze response — *Hard prerequisite logic: body awareness secured at Band A; fight-flight-freeze concept requires it*
- Reflective Thinking (Developing level) — *Sophistication progression: moves from identifying choices (A) to reasoning about consequences (B)*
- Social Awareness & Empathy (Developing level) — *Sophistication progression: from recognising emotions in others (A) to recognising others feel differently (B)*
- Self-Awareness & Regulation (understanding automatic reactions) — *Conceptual accelerator from fight-flight-freeze: practice becomes more informed; still recommended not hard* ⚑ teacher discretion
**Band C:**
- Amygdala & threat detection — *Hard prerequisite logic: fight-flight-freeze and basic brain awareness both secured; introduces specific neural structure*
- Autonomic nervous system — *Hard prerequisite logic: fight-flight-freeze secured; ANS content explains why techniques work — must precede informed regulation expectations*
- Habits science — *Hard prerequisite logic: basic brain awareness secured; neuroplasticity concept accessible at this band*
- Self-Awareness & Regulation (science-informed, strategy selection) — *Conceptual accelerator activated: ANS content must precede this expectation — teach ANS first in Band C, then move to informed strategy selection*
- Reflective Thinking (Competent level) — *Sophistication progression: weighing competing considerations*
- Social Awareness (Competent level) — *Sophistication progression: contextual analysis of emotional responses*
**Band D:**
- HPA axis and acute vs chronic stress — *Hard prerequisite logic: ANS and amygdala both secured; completes the neuroendocrine pathway*
- Sleep science — *Hard prerequisite logic: ANS concept required to explain sleep as active physiological process*
- Self-Awareness & Regulation (distinguishing acute from chronic stress) — *Hard prerequisite logic: HPA axis content must precede this capability*
- Agency (meta-reflective) — *Soft enabler activated: Reflective Thinking at Extending level enriches but does not fully gate this* ⚑ teacher discretion
- Reflective Thinking (Extending level — meta-reflective) — *Sophistication progression: thinking about thinking; explicit teaching required* ⚑ teacher discretion
### 4. Prerequisite Violations
No prerequisite violations detected in the recommended sequence above. **Risk to monitor:** If the autonomic nervous system content at Band C is scheduled after the regulation expectation for "informed strategy selection" — within the same band — this would constitute a hard prerequisite violation. Teach ANS content in Term 1 of Band C before moving to science-informed regulation expectations in Term 2.
### 5. Coherence Checks
**Vertical coherence:**
*Hierarchical:* The proposed Wellbeing Science & Literacy prerequisite chain is coherent: body awareness (A) → fight-flight-freeze (B) → amygdala, autonomic nervous system, habits science (C) → HPA axis, acute vs chronic stress, sleep science (D). Each concept builds on the previous. Risk: density at Band C — three new hierarchical concepts introduced simultaneously. If time is limited, prioritise autonomic nervous system (it is the prerequisite for the largest number of downstream capabilities).
*Horizontal:* Reflective Thinking, Social Awareness, and Communication & Collaboration show genuine sophistication increases. The critical transition to monitor is Band C → D: all three shift to meta-level thinking. Without explicit teaching of what meta-reflection looks like, students will stay at Band C sophistication with harder content — a plateau, not a spiral.
*Dispositional:* All four dispositional threads are present across all four bands with increasing expectations. Band B risk: dispositional threads develop through practice alone, without knowledge support. Self-Regulation at Band B is practice-based ("use these techniques because they work"), not science-informed. This is developmentally appropriate — the knowledge arrives at Band C — but teachers must understand that the transition to informed regulation happens at Band C, not before.
**Horizontal coherence:**
*Band A:* Primarily dispositional and concrete experiential. Hierarchical content minimal. Horizontal at Emerging level. Balance is developmentally appropriate. Internal connections are strong — body awareness, emotions vocabulary, noticing others' emotions, and simple regulation strategies are naturally linked through embodied experience.
*Band B:* Dispositional threads continue. One new hierarchical concept (fight-flight-freeze). Horizontal at Developing level. Balance appropriate but hierarchical strand is thin — one concept must be taught with sufficient depth to justify its placement. Connection between scientific concept and dispositional practice needs to be made explicit by teachers.
*Band C:* Most demanding band. Three new hierarchical concepts, horizontal at Competent level, dispositional expectations now science-informed. Risk of overload. Internal connections are potentially strong but span competencies — if competencies are taught in isolation, students will not see the connections. Recommend at least one cross-competency unit explicitly connecting ANS science to regulation practice.
*Band D:* All three types at maximum demand. Internal connections are strongest if made explicit: HPA axis → chronic stress → habits → agency → care for others with respect for autonomy forms a coherent synthesis. If taught as separate units, it fragments.
### 6. Sequencing Principles
The following principles were applied in producing this sequence. Review them. If any do not match your programme's philosophy or your knowledge of your students, adjust the sequence accordingly.
**Default principles applied:**
1. **Hard prerequisite logic (T1):** Where LT B genuinely cannot be accessed without LT A's content, LT A is placed earlier. These constraints are non-negotiable — reordering them produces prerequisite violations.
2. **Soft scaffold logic:** Where LT A enriches or makes LT B more transferable without fully gating it, LT A is placed earlier as a recommendation. Teachers can adjust soft scaffold ordering based on student readiness.
3. **Experiential readiness logic (T3):** For social-emotional dispositional capabilities, experience of the capability generally precedes the T1/T2 content that explains it. Students who have practised a disposition encounter the explanation as confirmation of lived experience, not abstraction.
**Exception applied:**
4. **Metacognitive T3 exception:** For metacognitive and reflective LTs, light conceptual framing before practice may improve practice quality (Flavell, 1979). These LTs are flagged for teacher discretion in Section 7.
**Note on the counterargument:** Explicit instruction research (Kirschner et al., 2006) argues novice learners benefit from explanation before practice in many domains. The experiential readiness default applies most strongly to social-emotional dispositions. For hierarchical knowledge LTs, explicit instruction first is assumed.
### 7. Teacher Discretion Flags and Questions
**Self-Awareness & Regulation — experiential practice beginning at Band A before ANS science**
This placement follows the experiential readiness default: students practise regulation before they can explain why techniques work. This is recommended, not hard-constrained.
- Have students in this band had previous school or home experience with regulation practice? If so, the experiential base is already established and science-first may be a reasonable alternative.
- Is there a programme-specific reason to introduce the neuroscience concept earlier (e.g. a schoolwide emphasis on body-based learning that would make ANS accessible at Band B)? If yes, supply this as a sequencing principle.
- Does this school's Band A population include students with significant trauma histories? If so, experience-first regulation practice may be more important, not less — the science can wait.
**Agency and Care for others — beginning at Band A**
Both are recommended to begin as emergent experiential practice at Band A before reflective framing is introduced.
- What does "agency" look like in this school's Band A context — structured choice? student-led projects? If the programme already foregrounds student choice, the experiential base is established.
- For Care for others: do Band A students already show prosocial behaviour in unstructured settings? If the disposition is already present, the focus is on naming and developing it, not on introducing it from scratch.
**Meta-reflective Reflective Thinking and Agency at Band D**
The shift to thinking-about-thinking is flagged as requiring explicit teaching rather than natural emergence.
- Have students in Band D been explicitly introduced to metacognitive vocabulary before? If yes, the transition to meta-reflection may require less scaffolding.
- Does this term's project create natural moments for students to observe their own reasoning processes? If so, concept-before-practice may be appropriate — introduce meta-reflection vocabulary before the project begins, then practise it in the project itself.
- Are there students entering Band D from outside this programme who lack the Band C experiential base? If so, the recommended sequence assumes continuity that may not be present for some students.
### 8. Design Flags and Recommendations
**Gaps:**
- **Scientific reasoning about evidence** is required at Band D (evaluating wellness claims) but is not included in the Wellbeing Science & Literacy strand. Students need to understand what counts as evidence for a health claim — controlled studies, sample size, correlation vs causation. Either add this to the wellbeing programme or verify it is covered in the science curriculum by Band D.
- **Agency is not currently a named competency.** The intended outcomes include agency, and it is mapped across all four bands, but it does not appear in the existing competency structure. **Recommendation:** Either add Agency as a sixth competency or ensure it is explicitly embedded within Self-Awareness & Regulation and Reflective Thinking — but if embedded, it must be named and tracked.
- **Care for others is not currently a named competency.** The Social Awareness & Empathy competency covers the horizontal knowledge dimension but not the dispositional dimension of enacted care. **Recommendation:** Either add Care as a competency or split Social Awareness & Empathy into an analytical strand (horizontal) and an enacted strand (dispositional).
**Overlaps:**
- **Self-Awareness & Regulation** and **Health Literacy & Habits** overlap in the area of "strategies for managing wellbeing." The distinction — regulation is about emotional responses in the moment, habits are about sustained routines — must be made explicit to teachers. **Recommendation:** Define the boundary clearly and where they overlap (e.g. a breathing technique used both in-the-moment and as a daily practice), name the overlap explicitly.
- **Reflective Thinking** and the meta-reflective dimension of **Self-Awareness & Regulation** at Band D overlap. **Recommendation:** At Band D, design assessment tasks that integrate both competencies — a reflective portfolio on personal regulation development would serve both.
**Difficult transitions:**
- **Band B → C** is the most significant transition: from experiential, practice-based learning to science-informed, analytically demanding content. Three new hierarchical concepts, a step up in horizontal sophistication, and informed rather than practised dispositional expectations. **Recommendation:** Begin Band C with a bridging unit connecting Band B experiential knowledge to new scientific content — "You already know deep breathing calms you down. Now we're going to learn WHY — and that understanding will help you choose the right technique for different situations."
- **Band C → D** for horizontal elements: the shift to meta-level thinking will not happen spontaneously for most students. **Recommendation:** Explicit modelling of meta-reflective thinking at the start of Band D.
**Compound competencies:**
- **Health Literacy & Habits** is compound across knowledge types: hierarchical knowledge (nutrition, sleep, exercise science), horizontal thinking (evaluating health claims), and dispositional practice (maintaining routines). The same competency is being sequenced by three different logics simultaneously. **Recommendation:** Consider splitting into Health Knowledge (hierarchical — assessed by structured responses) and Wellbeing Practice (dispositional — assessed through self-reflection and developmental conversation).
**Priority actions (in order of impact):**
1. **Ensure autonomic nervous system content is taught at the START of Band C** before regulation expectations assume students understand why techniques work. This is the highest-impact sequencing decision.
2. **Design a cross-competency bridging unit at the start of Band C** connecting experiential Band B learning to scientific Band C content.
3. **Add scientific reasoning about evidence** to the Wellbeing Science & Literacy strand at Band D, or verify it is covered in the science curriculum.
4. **Make Agency and Care for Others explicitly named and tracked** — unnamed intended outcomes are not assessed and tend to be neglected.
5. **Define the boundary between Self-Awareness & Regulation and Health Literacy & Habits** explicitly for teachers, so both competencies are taught with clear scope.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| brainstormingobra/superpowersYou MUST use this before any creative work - creating features, building components, adding functionality, modifying behavior, or planning anything new, in software or out of it (a talk, a business, a renovation). | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| brand-guidelinesanthropics/skillsApplies Anthropic's official brand colors and typography to any sort of artifact that may benefit from having Anthropic's look-and-feel. Use it when brand colors or style guidelines, visual formatting, or company design standards apply. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| frontend-designanthropics/skillsGuidance for distinctive, intentional visual design when building new UI or reshaping an existing one. Helps with aesthetic direction, typography, and making choices that don't read as templated defaults. | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| mcp-builderanthropics/skillsGuide for creating high-quality MCP (Model Context Protocol) servers that enable LLMs to interact with external services through well-designed tools. Use when building MCP servers to integrate external APIs or services, whether in Python (FastMCP) or Node/TypeScript (MCP SDK). | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |