Skip to content

GarethManning/education-agent-skills / skills/original-frameworks/learning-target-authoring-guide

learning-target-authoring-guide

Verified

Author learning targets for a competency across developmental bands with precise, observable progression language. Use when writing 'I can' statements for competency-based programmes.

FileKindSize
SKILL.mdskill md38.4 KB
agents/openai.yamlconfig43 B
references/worked-examples.mdmarkdown24.8 KB

references/worked-examples.md

View on GitHub
## Example Output

**Scenario 1 (Type 2):** *Competency name: "Critical Thinking" / Competency definition: "The ability to analyse information, evaluate evidence, and construct well-reasoned arguments" / Band range: "Bands A-D (ages 5-14)" / Programme purpose: "Our mission requires students who can contribute to a world that needs them. Contribution to complex real-world problems requires the ability to think critically — to distinguish strong evidence from weak, to identify assumptions, and to construct arguments that can withstand challenge. Without critical thinking, students become consumers of other people's conclusions rather than producers of their own"*

---

## Learning Target Set: Critical Thinking

**Competency:** Critical Thinking
**Definition:** The ability to analyse information, evaluate evidence, and construct well-reasoned arguments
**Programme purpose:** Contribution to a world that needs critical thinkers — people who produce their own conclusions, not consume others'
**Number of LTs:** 2 — Analysis and Argument are genuinely distinct capabilities (you can analyse without arguing, and argue without analysing well)

### Competency Review

This competency is well-framed. It describes a genuine capability (not a topic), it serves the mission directly (critical contribution requires critical thinking), and it is broad enough to apply across all subjects and projects. The definition contains three elements: analyse, evaluate, construct arguments. Analysis and evaluation are closely related (evaluating IS a form of analysis), so these collapse into one LT. Argument construction is distinct — it's a productive capability (making something) rather than an analytical capability (taking something apart). Two LTs.

### Step 0: Knowledge Type Classification

| LT Strand | Knowledge Type | Assessment Route | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Analysis of Evidence | Type 2 | Reasoning quality rubric | Multiple valid analytical frameworks exist; reasoning quality determines outcome; no single correct answer; analytical depth increases with experience. Transfer to novel situations is the test. |
| Reasoned Argument | Type 2 | Reasoning quality rubric | Argument quality is assessed through reasoning sophistication, not correctness; multiple valid positions exist; what develops is the ability to construct and defend a position, not recall a right answer. |

No Type 3 elements detected. Critical thinking as a DISPOSITION (the habit of questioning spontaneously, not just when asked) is a real and important capacity — but it is not what this competency measures. If the programme wants to capture the disposition to think critically, that requires a separate Type 3 LT with its own observation pathway.

### LT Decomposition

**LT1: Analysis of Evidence**
- **Definition:** "I can examine information and evidence to identify what is relevant, reliable, and significant"
- **Knowledge Type:** Type 2
- **Assessment Route:** Reasoning quality rubric
- **Prerequisites:** N/A
- **Rationale:** This LT covers the ANALYTICAL dimension of critical thinking — the ability to take information apart, assess its quality, and determine what matters. It is the input side of critical thinking: processing what is given.

**LT2: Reasoned Argument**
- **Definition:** "I can construct a clear argument supported by evidence and reasoning"
- **Knowledge Type:** Type 2
- **Assessment Route:** Reasoning quality rubric
- **Prerequisites:** N/A
- **Rationale:** This LT covers the PRODUCTIVE dimension of critical thinking — the ability to build a case, support it with evidence, and present it in a way that can be examined and challenged. It is the output side of critical thinking: producing a position.

**Decomposition tests:**
- **Coverage:** Together, LT1 (analysis) and LT2 (argument) cover the full meaning of "Critical Thinking." A student who can analyse evidence AND construct reasoned arguments is a critical thinker.
- **Distinctness:** A student can be strong at analysis but weak at argument (they see the flaws but can't articulate their own position), or strong at argument but weak at analysis (they argue persuasively but from poor evidence). These are genuinely different capabilities.
- **Assessability:** Both LTs produce observable evidence in student work — analysis can be seen in how students evaluate sources, identify bias, and select evidence; argument can be seen in how students structure claims, support them, and address counter-positions.
- **Knowledge-type test:** Both LTs are Type 2. No compound knowledge-type issue.

### Band Statements

**LT1: Analysis of Evidence**
Knowledge Type: Type 2
Assessment Route: Reasoning quality rubric
Authoring Mode: Mode 2

| Band | Statement | Progression Lever(s) |
|---|---|---|
| A | I can identify relevant information from a given source | Scope: single source; Independence: given source |
| B | I can compare information from more than one source and identify differences | Complexity: multiple sources; Reasoning: comparison |
| C | I can evaluate the reliability of sources and explain why some evidence is stronger than others | Reasoning: evaluative judgment; Precision: explaining why |
| D | I can analyse competing evidence, identify assumptions and bias, and justify which evidence is most credible for a given purpose | Transfer: applying analysis to novel contexts; Complexity: competing evidence, multiple criteria |
| E | I can evaluate a body of evidence, identify systemic gaps or biases in what is available, and justify which interpretive framework best fits the purpose | Reasoning: evaluating the evidence base as a whole, not just individual sources; Scope: systemic pattern across a body, not a single comparison |
| F | I can construct a critical account of a body of evidence that accounts for the conditions under which it was produced, the interests it serves, and the limits of what it can show | Independence: self-directed critical construction; Reasoning: second-order analysis of the evidence base itself |

**LT2: Reasoned Argument**
Knowledge Type: Type 2
Assessment Route: Reasoning quality rubric
Authoring Mode: Mode 2

| Band | Statement | Progression Lever(s) |
|---|---|---|
| A | I can state my opinion and give a reason for it | Independence: single claim, single reason |
| B | I can present a claim supported by more than one piece of evidence | Complexity: multiple evidence points |
| C | I can construct an argument with a clear claim, supporting evidence, and acknowledgement of a different viewpoint | Scope: includes counter-position; Reasoning: structural awareness |
| D | I can build a sustained argument that integrates evidence, addresses counterarguments, and evaluates the strength of my own position | Transfer: self-evaluation of argument; Precision: sustained and integrated |
| E | I can construct a sustained argument that integrates competing perspectives, anticipates likely objections, and addresses the strongest version of the counter-position | Complexity: integrating competing perspectives; Reasoning: steelmanning the counter-position |
| F | I can evaluate the limits of my own argument — identifying where evidence is insufficient, where assumptions are load-bearing, and what it would take to shift my position | Independence: self-critical evaluation of own argument; Reasoning: identifying epistemic limits |

### Quality Check

- [x] **Single-construct rule:** Each statement assesses one coherent capability. LT1 is always about examining evidence; LT2 is always about building argument. No statement combines both.
- [x] **Compound knowledge-type check:** Both LTs are Type 2. No mixed-type elements.
- [x] **No parentheses or inline examples:** None present. No "such as" or "for example."
- [x] **Observable verbs only:** identify, compare, evaluate, explain, analyse, justify, state, present, construct, build, integrate, address. No "understand," "know," or "appreciate."
- [x] **Vertical coherence:** Within each LT, Band D is genuinely more advanced than Band A — the progression is clear and continuous through the levers.
- [x] **Horizontal coherence:** Band B across both LTs describes a similar developmental demand — comparing sources and presenting multi-evidence claims are both Band B level tasks.
- [x] **LT definition describes all band levels:** "I can examine information and evidence to identify what is relevant, reliable, and significant" applies to all bands — Band A does this simply (single source), Band D does this with sophistication (competing evidence with bias analysis).
- [x] **Knowledge Type fields:** Both LTs have Type 2 and Reasoning quality rubric specified.
- [x] **Assessment route verification:** Reasoning quality rubric is appropriate for Type 2 horizontal knowledge. Transfer to novel situations is the test.
- [x] **2 LTs:** Justified — analysis and argument are genuinely distinct.

### Known Limitations

1. **Critical thinking is domain-dependent as well as domain-general.** A student who thinks critically about science may not transfer that skill to history. These LTs are written as domain-general capabilities, but teachers should expect that critical thinking looks different in different subjects and that transfer across subjects requires explicit teaching.

2. **Band A is deliberately modest.** "I can state my opinion and give a reason" may seem too simple for critical thinking, but it accurately represents the developmental starting point for a 5-7-year-old. Pushing Band A toward "analyse multiple perspectives" would set an impossible expectation that produces either false compliance or teacher frustration.

3. **The LTs do not capture the DISPOSITION to think critically.** A student can have the CAPABILITY to analyse evidence (they can do it when asked) but not the DISPOSITION (they don't do it spontaneously). If the programme requires the disposition, author a separate Type 3 LT — "Critical Thinking as Practice" — assessed through multi-informant observation, not rubric.

---

**Scenario 2 (Type 3 — demonstrating observation indicator pathway):** *Competency name: "Self-Regulation" / Competency definition: "The ability to monitor and adjust one's emotional and behavioural responses across different situations" / Band range: "Bands A-D (ages 5-14)" / Programme purpose: "Our mission asks students to take increasing ownership of their learning and their impact on others. Self-regulation is the foundation — without it, autonomy becomes impulsivity and collaboration becomes conflict"*

---

## Learning Target Set: Self-Regulation

**Competency:** Self-Regulation
**Definition:** The ability to monitor and adjust one's emotional and behavioural responses across different situations
**Programme purpose:** Self-regulation is the foundation for autonomy and collaboration — without it, ownership of learning and impact on others cannot develop
**Number of LTs:** 3 — Knowledge-type analysis reveals three genuinely distinct strands that MUST be separated to avoid assessment misrouting

### Competency Review

This competency is well-framed but contains elements from all three knowledge types. "Monitor and adjust" appears to be a single capability, but it actually bundles: (a) understanding what the stress response is and how regulation works (Type 1 — teachable, testable knowledge), (b) analysing one's own patterns and selecting appropriate strategies in structured situations (Type 2 — reasoning about self-regulation), and (c) actually regulating in real situations over time (Type 3 — enacted disposition). If these are collapsed into a single rubric-assessed LT, only the Type 1 and Type 2 elements get captured. The Type 3 enactment — which is the whole point — disappears from the evidence. Three LTs are required. This is correct design, not inflation.

### Step 0: Knowledge Type Classification

| LT Strand | Knowledge Type | Assessment Route | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Understanding the Stress Response | Type 1 | Rubric with clear criteria | Prerequisite chain exists: students must understand what happens physiologically and psychologically during stress before they can reason about strategies. Errors at lower levels propagate — a student who misunderstands the stress response will misapply regulation strategies. |
| Regulation Strategy Analysis | Type 2 | Reasoning quality rubric | Multiple valid strategies exist for any situation; reasoning quality determines whether the student selects an appropriate strategy; analytical depth increases with experience; transfer to novel situations is the test. |
| Self-Regulation as Practice | Type 3 | Multi-informant observation | This capacity exists only in enactment across time and contexts. A student who can analyse strategies in a scenario (Type 2) but does not regulate in real situations has not developed the disposition. Observation of real behaviour is required. Knowledge-contingent: requires both Type 1 and Type 2 prerequisites. |

COMPOUND KNOWLEDGE-TYPE FLAG: The original competency definition bundles all three types. The decomposition below separates them into distinct LTs with distinct assessment routes.

### LT Decomposition

**LT1: Understanding the Stress Response**
- **Definition:** "I can describe how the body and mind respond to stress and explain how regulation strategies work"
- **Knowledge Type:** Type 1
- **Assessment Route:** Rubric with clear criteria
- **Prerequisites:** N/A
- **Rationale:** This is the knowledge base. Without understanding what happens during a stress response, a student cannot reason about which strategies apply or why. This LT is assessed efficiently through explanation tasks and knowledge checks.

**LT2: Regulation Strategy Analysis**
- **Definition:** "I can analyse a situation and select a regulation strategy that fits the context"
- **Knowledge Type:** Type 2
- **Assessment Route:** Reasoning quality rubric
- **Prerequisites:** N/A (though LT1 knowledge deepens performance)
- **Rationale:** This is the reasoning capability. The student can examine a situation through multiple lenses and reason about which strategy fits. Assessed through scenario tasks requiring transfer to novel situations — not recall of a practised example.

**LT3: Self-Regulation as Practice**
- **Definition:** "I can regulate my responses to stress across different settings. [Assessed through multi-informant observation — see observation protocol.]"
- **Knowledge Type:** Type 3
- **Assessment Route:** Multi-informant observation — teacher notes, student self-reflection, parent input, Strive data. Synthesised in the developmental conversation. Not a summative grade.
- **Prerequisites:** LT1 (Understanding the Stress Response) and LT2 (Regulation Strategy Analysis) must be established. The Type 3 observation is only valid evidence once the student has the knowledge and analytical repertoire in place.
- **Rationale:** This is the enacted disposition. A student who can describe regulation (LT1) and analyse strategy selection (LT2) but does not regulate in real situations has not developed self-regulation. This LT captures what the others cannot — actual practice over time.

**Decomposition tests:**
- **Coverage:** Together, the three LTs cover the full meaning of Self-Regulation: knowing what regulation is (LT1), reasoning about when and how to apply it (LT2), and actually doing it (LT3).
- **Distinctness:** A student can know the science but not apply it (strong LT1, weak LT2/3). A student can reason about strategies in a scenario but not use them under real stress (strong LT2, weak LT3). These are genuinely separate.
- **Assessability:** LT1 through explanation tasks. LT2 through scenario analysis. LT3 through multi-informant observation.
- **Knowledge-type test:** Each LT contains one knowledge type only. No compound violations.

### Band Statements / Observation Indicators

**LT1: Understanding the Stress Response**
Knowledge Type: Type 1
Assessment Route: Rubric with clear criteria
Authoring Mode: Mode 2

| Band | Statement | Progression Lever(s) |
|---|---|---|
| A | I can identify when my body feels calm and when it feels stressed | Independence: recognising states with adult support; Scope: own body only |
| B | I can describe what happens in the body during a stress response and name strategies that help | Reasoning: describing mechanisms; Complexity: connecting response to strategy |
| C | I can explain how the stress response affects thinking and behaviour, and compare how different strategies target different aspects of the response | Reasoning: explaining cause-effect; Complexity: comparing strategies against mechanisms |
| D | I can analyse how individual and contextual factors influence the stress response and evaluate which regulation approaches are supported by evidence | Transfer: applying to varied contexts; Reasoning: evaluative judgment about evidence |
| E | I can critically evaluate explanations of the stress response, identify where the evidence is strong and where it is contested, and explain how individual and contextual variation affects which regulation principles apply | Transfer: applying critical evaluation to the evidence base itself; Reasoning: identifying limits of general principles |
| F | I can construct an account of the mechanisms underlying my own stress-regulation profile, drawing on the evidence base, and evaluate the conditions under which general regulation principles apply less reliably to me specifically | Independence: self-authored theoretical account; Transfer: generalising from evidence to personal profile |

**LT2: Regulation Strategy Analysis**
Knowledge Type: Type 2
Assessment Route: Reasoning quality rubric
Authoring Mode: Mode 1

| Band | Statement | Progression Lever(s) |
|---|---|---|
| A | I can choose a calming strategy from options offered when I am upset | Independence: supported choice; Scope: immediate situation |
| B | I can consider more than one strategy for a given situation and explain why I chose one | Complexity: multiple options; Reasoning: justifying choice |
| C | I can analyse a situation through more than one lens and select a strategy that fits the context and the people involved | Scope: considering context and others; Reasoning: multi-lens analysis |
| D | I can evaluate competing strategies for a complex situation, identify tensions between them, and justify my approach across more than one context | Transfer: cross-context application; Complexity: competing strategies with tensions |
| E | I can construct a regulation plan for a sustained high-stakes situation, anticipate the conditions under which my preferred strategies are likely to break down, and identify contingency approaches | Reasoning: anticipatory and contingency planning; Scope: sustained high-stakes situations |
| F | I can design a regulation approach for a novel high-stakes context, justify my design with reference to mechanism and evidence, and evaluate its effectiveness with reference to observed outcomes over time | Independence: self-designed approach; Transfer: applying principles to novel design problem; Reasoning: evaluating own design against evidence |

**LT3: Self-Regulation as Practice**
Knowledge Type: Type 3
Assessment Route: Multi-informant observation
Prerequisites: LT1 (Understanding the Stress Response), LT2 (Regulation Strategy Analysis)

Band A indicators — the teacher notices:
- The student accepts comfort or redirection from an adult when upset and begins to return to the activity
- The student uses a named calming strategy with adult prompting during an unstructured real situation

Band B indicators — the teacher notices:
- The student independently initiates a regulation strategy during a real moment of difficulty without adult prompting
- The student can name what they did to regulate after the event, with reasonable accuracy

Band C indicators — the teacher notices:
- The student selects different strategies in different contexts, showing awareness that what works in one situation may not work in another
- The student recovers from setbacks within a reasonable timeframe and re-engages with the task or interaction

Band D indicators — the teacher notices:
- The student maintains regulation across sustained periods of challenge without external scaffolding
- The student can name and explain their own regulation patterns when asked, including what has shifted over time

Band E indicators — the teacher notices:
- The student recognises early signs of dysregulation before full activation and initiates a strategy without adult prompting, including in high-stakes situations
- The student adjusts their strategy during a situation based on real-time assessment of what is and is not working
- The student reflects after an event with specificity about what shifted their state and what they would do differently

Band F indicators — the teacher notices:
- The student demonstrates consistent regulation across sustained high-stakes real-world contexts without scaffolding or post-hoc adult intervention
- The student can construct an account of their own regulation profile across multiple years, identifying what has changed and what conditions still challenge them
- The student takes responsibility for arranging conditions — environmental, social, or temporal — that support their own regulation ahead of demanding situations

Student self-reflection prompts:
- Band A: Tell me about a time this week when something was hard and what you did
- Band B: Describe one pattern you noticed about how you handle difficult moments this term
- Band C: Compare what you noticed about your regulation with what your teacher observed — where do you agree and disagree?
- Band D: Analyse how your regulation works across different settings and explain what has changed over the past term
- Band E: Evaluate how your regulation has changed over the past year — what has shifted, what conditions made the shift possible, and where you still lose hold
- Band F: Construct an account of how you regulate across different high-stakes contexts over time — what your profile looks like, what remains unresolved, and what you would need to work on next

### Quality Check

**Format checks:**
- [x] Every Type 1/2 band statement begins with "I can..."
- [x] Every LT Definition begins with "I can..."
- [x] Competency Definition begins with "The ability to..."
- [x] All statements present tense, active voice
- [x] Type 3 LT (LT3) uses observation indicator format, not rubric band statements

**Prohibition checks:**
- [x] No parentheses anywhere
- [x] No inline examples in band statements or definitions
- [x] No "such as" or "for example" anywhere
- [x] No content inventories
- [x] No vague quality descriptors without observable criteria

**Construct checks:**
- [x] Single-construct rule passes for all statements
- [x] Compound knowledge-type check passes: LT1 is purely Type 1, LT2 is purely Type 2, LT3 is purely Type 3. No mixed-type elements in any statement.

**Knowledge type checks:**
- [x] Every LT has a Knowledge Type field
- [x] Every LT has an Assessment Route that matches its knowledge type (rubric/reasoning rubric/multi-informant observation)
- [x] Type 3 LT does not have rubric band statements — uses observation indicators only
- [x] Knowledge-contingent Type 3 LT (LT3) has prerequisites named (LT1, LT2)
- [x] No Type 3 element is buried inside LT1 or LT2

**Coherence checks:**
- [x] Vertical coherence: clear A-D progression within each LT
- [x] Horizontal coherence: LT definitions describe what all band levels do
- [x] Progression uses levers (independence, complexity, scope, reasoning, transfer), not topic escalation

**Language checks:**
- [x] Plain, assessable language throughout
- [x] UK English spelling convention
- [x] Strong action verbs only — no "understand," "know," or "appreciate"

**Completeness checks:**
- [x] All cells filled
- [x] Knowledge Type and Assessment Route fields completed for every LT

### Known Limitations

1. **LT3 evidence depends on observation infrastructure.** Multi-informant observation requires teachers to store dated, retrievable notes. Until a dedicated observation app exists, the simplest sustainable system the teacher will actually use is the right system. Notes that cannot be retrieved and compared across a term are impressions, not evidence.

2. **LT3 is knowledge-contingent — timing matters.** The Type 3 observation pathway for LT3 should not begin until LT1 and LT2 prerequisites are reasonably established. Observing a student's self-regulation before they have the knowledge and strategy repertoire produces invalid evidence.

3. **Disagreement between sources is information, not error.** If a teacher's observation notes and a student's self-reflection diverge on LT3, this is developmental information to surface in the developmental conversation — not a problem to resolve before the conversation.

4. **The disposition is not the capability.** A student may score well on LT1 and LT2 (they know the science and can reason about strategies) but show limited evidence on LT3 (they don't regulate in practice). This is not an assessment failure — it is a genuine and important finding. The three LTs exist precisely to make this visible.

slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack."Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall