existential-birds/beagle / plugins/beagle-analysis/skills/strategy-interview
strategy-interview
VerifiedUse when the user wants to build or think through a strategy via guided conversation — for a company, product, team, career, or initiative. Triggers on "help me figure out our direction", "what should we focus on", strategic planning, competitive positioning, go-to-market strategy. Also catches indirect requests like prioritization struggles or "we have too many priorities". Does NOT review existing strategy documents (use strategy-review) or brainstorm project features (use brainstorm-beagle).
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 30.5 KB |
| references/bad-strategy.md | markdown | 6.3 KB |
| references/blue-ocean.md | markdown | 11.7 KB |
| references/kernel.md | markdown | 7.9 KB |
| references/output-template.md | markdown | 8.6 KB |
| references/playing-to-win.md | markdown | 10.4 KB |
| references/pressure-tests.md | markdown | 1.7 KB |
| references/wardley-mapping.md | markdown | 10.8 KB |
references/blue-ocean.md
View on GitHub# Value Innovation: When the Real Problem Is the Competitive Arena Itself
This reference loads during Phase 2 when the user's language suggests they are locked in competitive thinking — fighting for share in a crowded, commoditizing space where every player converges on the same value factors. The intervention reframes the conversation: instead of "how do we beat competitor X," ask "should we be competing on these terms at all?"
Do not name-drop frameworks, books, or authors to the user. The concepts show up in what you ask, not in citations.
## When to deploy this lens
### Red ocean signals — patterns in the user's language
Listen for these during discovery and pressure-testing. Any cluster of three or more is a strong signal.
**Classic tells:**
- Persistent competitor fixation: "They launched X, so we need to match it." "We're losing deals to Y on feature Z."
- Benchmarking as strategy: "We need to be best-in-class on every dimension they compete on."
- Margin erosion framed as inevitable: "The market is commoditizing — everyone's cutting price."
- Feature arms race: "We need to close the gap on [feature list]." "We're behind on 4 of 7 evaluation criteria."
- Market share as the goal: "We need to take 3 points of share from the leader."
- Industry conventions treated as laws: "That's just how this category works." "Customers expect X, Y, Z."
- Customer segmentation that mirrors competitors exactly: same segments, same tiers, same buyer personas.
**What it sounds like as a whole:** The user is trying to be a slightly better version of their competitors rather than a fundamentally different kind of offering. They're optimizing within an accepted set of rules nobody has questioned.
**Why it's dangerous:** Incremental improvement in a crowded space produces incremental results at increasing cost. When every competitor converges on the same value factors, the only differentiator left is price — and that's a race nobody wins.
### When NOT to use this lens
Not every strategy needs a value-innovation reframe. Skip it when:
- The user has a clear, defensible advantage in the existing space (cost structure, regulatory moat, network effects, switching costs). Telling them to abandon working terrain is bad advice.
- The market is genuinely growing and the user's share problem is an execution problem, not a positioning problem. Blue ocean thinking applied to an execution gap produces distraction, not insight.
- The user is in a winner-take-all market where network effects or standards lock-in make creating a new space structurally impractical.
- The user is early-stage and hasn't established product-market fit yet. They need to find *one* market that works before they can think about redefining categories.
If you're unsure, test with one or two questions. If the user's situation clearly fits within an existing competitive frame, respect that and move on.
## Core concepts — how to use them in the interview
### 1. The competitive convergence problem
Every industry develops a shared mental model of "what we compete on." Over time, all players converge on the same factors: more features, lower price, better support, faster delivery. The strategy canvas is the diagnostic tool — plot your offering and competitors' offerings against the factors the industry competes on, and look for where everyone's curves overlap.
You won't literally draw this with the user. Instead, build the picture conversationally.
**Interview prompts:**
- "Walk me through the 5-6 factors that matter most when a customer evaluates you versus alternatives. Price, features, support — what's on that list?"
- "Now — for each of those factors, how different are you from the top two competitors? Where are you roughly the same?"
- "If I lined up your offering and your two closest competitors on those dimensions, where would a buyer actually see a difference?"
- "Which of those factors does your industry spend the most time and money competing on — and are customers actually willing to pay more for improvement there, or has it become table stakes?"
What you're listening for: if the user describes 5-6 factors and their offering is roughly similar to competitors on most of them, that's the convergence pattern. The entire industry is fighting over the same saturated, convention-bound space.
### 2. Breaking the value-cost tradeoff — Eliminate, Reduce, Raise, Create
The conventional assumption is that you can either differentiate (high cost) or lead on cost (low differentiation). Value innovation breaks this by changing *which* factors you compete on, not just *how hard* you compete on the existing ones.
Four moves:
- **Eliminate** — which factors does the industry take for granted that buyers don't actually value, or that serve the industry's ego more than the customer's need?
- **Reduce** — which factors have been over-designed well beyond what buyers use or need?
- **Raise** — which factors should be raised well above the industry standard because they solve real pain?
- **Create** — which factors should the industry offer that it has never offered — factors that would unlock entirely new demand?
The classic illustration: Cirque du Soleil eliminated animal acts and star performers (massive cost), reduced the thrill and danger emphasis, raised the artistic and theatrical production quality, and created an experience closer to theater than circus — attracting adults who would never buy a ticket to Ringling Brothers.
Southwest Airlines eliminated meals, lounges, seat assignments, and hub routing (cost and complexity), reduced turnaround time, raised departure frequency, and created a "fun" low-cost flying experience that pulled customers away from driving, not just from other airlines.
**Interview prompts:**
- "Think about what your industry competes hardest on. Which of those factors do your customers actually care about — and which ones do they tolerate because everyone offers them?"
- "Is there something your customers are over-served on? Something the industry keeps improving that buyers stopped caring about three iterations ago?"
- "What's a pain point in the buyer's experience that nobody in your space addresses because it's considered 'not our problem'?"
- "If you could strip out half of what you currently offer and redirect that effort into one or two things done dramatically better, what would you strip and what would you pour into?"
### 3. Three tiers of noncustomers — where new demand lives
Most strategy focuses on existing customers. But the biggest growth often comes from people who *aren't* buying — not because they don't have the need, but because the current offerings don't work for them.
Three tiers:
- **Soon-to-be noncustomers** — they buy minimally, out of necessity, and are actively looking for alternatives. They're on the edge of your market and would leave if they could.
- **Refusing noncustomers** — they've considered your category and consciously decided against it. They see the offerings and say "not for me." Their objections reveal what the category gets wrong.
- **Unexplored noncustomers** — they've never considered your category at all because it seems irrelevant to them. The largest pool, the hardest to see.
Nintendo Wii is the textbook case. Sony and Microsoft competed for hardcore gamers (existing customers) with better graphics and processing power. Nintendo asked: who isn't gaming? Families. Older adults. People intimidated by complex controllers. The Wii created a motion-based, simple, social experience — and outsold both competitors by pulling in people who'd never owned a console.
**Interview prompts:**
- "Who *almost* buys your product but doesn't quite get there? What's the friction that stops them?"
- "Is there a group that has consciously looked at what your industry offers and said 'no thanks'? What turned them off?"
- "Who has the underlying need your product serves but has never even considered your category as a solution? What would have to change for them to see it as relevant?"
- "Right now you're fighting for share of existing buyers. What would it look like to create new buyers instead?"
### 4. Buyer experience pain points
Map the buyer's full journey — from purchase evaluation through delivery, use, maintenance, and disposal. At each stage, ask: is there friction, waste, complexity, or risk that the industry accepts as normal but buyers would love to see eliminated?
This is the operational version of "Create" in the four actions framework. It finds specific places where value innovation can land.
**Interview prompts:**
- "Walk me through what it's like to buy and use your product, from the customer's first Google search to a year after purchase. Where do they get frustrated, confused, or surprised by cost?"
- "What do your customers complain about that every company in your space treats as 'just how it works'?"
- "Is there a stage of the experience — onboarding, support, renewal, switching — that nobody in your industry has tried to make dramatically better?"
## How blue ocean findings reshape the kernel
A value-innovation insight doesn't sit alongside the kernel — it transforms it. When you surface this pattern, help the user see how it rewrites what they already have:
**Diagnosis shift:** The diagnosis often moves from "we're losing to competitor X on features" to something structural: "The real challenge isn't that we're behind on features — it's that the entire category has converged on the same value factors, and further investment in those factors produces declining returns. We're in a commodity fight."
**Guiding policy shift:** Instead of "catch up on features and compete on execution," the policy becomes "redefine what we compete on — eliminate [factors], create [factors], and target [noncustomer tier] rather than fighting for existing market share."
**Coherent action shift:** Actions move from matching competitors to deliberately diverging: stopping investment in industry-standard factors, building capabilities that serve noncustomers, and pricing/packaging for a different buyer entirely.
**Redirection scripts for the kernel mapping:**
- "We started with a diagnosis about falling behind competitors. But what I'm hearing now is something bigger — the industry itself has converged, and catching up just puts you back in the same commodity fight. Is the real challenge the category structure, not your position in it?"
- "Your guiding policy was about competing harder on the same dimensions. But you've also told me that customers barely differentiate between you and the top three competitors on those dimensions. What if the policy was about competing on *different* dimensions entirely?"
- "These actions are all about closing gaps with competitors. What if instead of closing gaps, you deliberately opened new ones — in a direction nobody else is going?"
## Posture when introducing this lens
Don't lecture about value innovation theory. Use the interview prompts above to let the user discover the pattern themselves. If they describe 5 factors where everyone converges, reflect it back: "So on the dimensions your industry competes on, you and the top competitors are roughly similar. What's that tell you about the value of investing more in those same dimensions?"
If the user engages with it, run the four actions and noncustomer prompts. If they resist — "no, we just need to execute better on what we have" — note it in `strategy-notes.md` as an open question and move on. They may be right. They may also not be ready to hear it yet. Either way, forcing it helps nobody.
If the user does reframe, this changes the interview significantly. Go back to Phase 1 briefly to explore the noncustomer landscape, then re-enter Phase 3 with a new diagnosis. The kernel will likely look very different the second time through.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| planning-and-task-breakdownaddyosmani/agent-skillsBreaks work into ordered tasks. Use when you have a spec or clear requirements and need to break work into implementable tasks. Use when a task feels too large to start, when you need to estimate scope, or when parallel work is possible. | Stars: 119k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| screenpipethedotmack/claude-memSearch screen and audio history recorded by Screenpipe and optionally save selected context into claude-mem. Use when the user asks to recall desktop activity, a meeting, or something seen in another app through Screenpipe. | Stars: 118k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| contact-widgetnexu-io/open-designSelf-contained floating chat widget with welcome screen, social links, meeting button, and message input. Single HTML file, zero dependencies. | Stars: 108k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| meeting-notesnexu-io/open-designMeeting notes page — title bar with attendees, agenda checklist, decisions block, action items table with owners + dates, and a "next meeting" footer. Use when the brief mentions "meeting notes", "minutes", "1:1 notes", "all-hands recap", or "会议纪要". | Stars: 108k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |