davepoon/buildwithclaude / plugins/all-skills/skills/mcm-o-guide
mcm-o-guide
VerifiedMCM/ICM 优秀论文写作全流程指南——基于 502 篇历年获奖论文(2004–2024)语料库的结构化分析与评委点评提炼。覆盖:摘要逐句模板、6 类题型模型选择矩阵、25 页页预算分配、图表黄金法则、灵敏度/稳健性分析范式、全文一致性检查清单。当用户准备美赛、写论文、打磨论文、查结构、选模型、做摘要、看评委标准、读优秀论文时使用。也适用于任何需要高质量数学建模论文写作的场景。
GUIDE.en.md
View on GitHub# MCM/ICM Paper-Writing Guide — User Guide
> [简体中文](使用指南.md) · **English**
## What this is
A writing skill distilled from a corpus of **502 award-winning MCM/ICM papers (2004–2024)** plus **3 official judges' commentaries**.
Every claim has data behind it — not "I think", but "of 449 O/F/M papers, 93% ran a sensitivity analysis".
## File structure
```
mcm-o-guide/
├── SKILL.md ← main skill file (~320 lines)
│ ├── 0 Quick start
│ ├── 1 The judges' view: three-round knockout
│ ├── 2 The Summary — one page decides everything
│ ├── 3 Paper skeleton and page budget
│ ├── 4 Model-selection matrix
│ ├── 5 Assumptions and data
│ ├── 6 Golden rules for figures and tables
│ ├── 7 Sensitivity analysis
│ ├── 8 Whole-paper consistency checklist
│ ├── 9 Writing checkpoints
│ ├── 10 Common fatal mistakes
│ ├── 11 The gap from Meritorious to Outstanding
│ ├── 12 Advanced modules
│ │ ├── 12.1 Writing Strengths & Weaknesses
│ │ ├── 12.2 Writing the Introduction
│ │ ├── 12.3 Memo / Letter (problem F)
│ │ └── 12.4 Model-innovation strategies
│ └── 13 Quick reference (templates + sentence bank)
├── SKILL.en.md ← full English translation of SKILL.md
├── 使用指南.md ← this guide (Chinese)
└── references/
├── model-matrix.md ← model matrix + baseline recommendations for 6 problem types
├── summary-template.md ← summary template + sentence-level breakdowns of 5 Outstanding summaries
├── checklist.md ← whole-paper consistency + pre-submission checklist
├── judge-commentary.md ← 3 official judges' commentaries + cross-analysis
├── strengths-weaknesses.md ← S/W templates + Outstanding examples
├── introduction-guide.md ← Introduction guide
├── memo-letter.md ← Memo/Letter format template (problem F)
├── model-innovation.md ← 6 model-innovation strategies
├── end-to-end-case.md ← end-to-end case: full 2023 A retrospective
├── quick-reference-card.md ← ⚡ quick-reference card (30 minutes before submission)
├── team-workflow.md ← 👥 team workflow (4-day contest)
└── self-evaluation.md ← 📊 100-point paper self-assessment
```
## When to use what
| Situation | Open this file |
|---|---|
| **Before the contest** | |
| Organising team roles | references/team-workflow.md |
| Just got the problem, need a paper plan | SKILL.md §3 page budget + §4 model matrix |
| **Writing** | |
| Writing the summary | SKILL.md §2 + references/summary-template.md |
| Writing the Introduction | references/introduction-guide.md |
| Choosing models | references/model-matrix.md |
| Want to innovate the model | references/model-innovation.md |
| Writing Strengths/Weaknesses | references/strengths-weaknesses.md |
| Writing Memo/Letter (problem F) | references/memo-letter.md |
| Looking for academic phrasing | references/sentence-patterns.md |
| **Reviewing** | |
| Self-check after the first draft | references/checklist.md |
| Want to grade the paper | references/self-evaluation.md |
| Want to know how judges think | SKILL.md §1 + references/judge-commentary.md |
| **Submitting** | |
| Final check before submission | references/quick-reference-card.md |
| Want to push from M to O | SKILL.md §11 + references/model-innovation.md |
| **Learning** | |
| Case study A (continuous/mechanistic) | references/end-to-end-case.md |
| Case study B (discrete/optimisation) | references/end-to-end-case-B.md |
| Case study C (data insight) | references/end-to-end-case-C.md |
| Case studies D/E/F (network/environment/policy) | references/end-to-end-case-DEF.md |
| Six-problem overview table | references/end-to-end-case-DEF.md §six-problem panorama |
| Anti-patterns from real papers | references/common-errors.md |
| Page-by-page dissection of 25 pages | references/page-by-page.md |
| Advanced techniques (sensitivity/validation/visualisation) | references/advanced-techniques.md |
| Top Outstanding strategy (data-driven) | references/top-award-strategy.md |
| Top Outstanding anatomy (2022 C Bitcoin) | references/top-paper-anatomy.md |
| **Team upskilling** | |
| Modeller | playbooks/modeling-playbook.md |
| Coder | playbooks/coding-playbook.md |
| Writer | playbooks/writing-playbook.md |
| Research | playbooks/research-playbook.md |
| **Paper skeletons** | |
| LaTeX skeleton | templates/latex-template.tex |
| Markdown skeleton | templates/markdown-template.md |
| Template notes | templates/README.md |
| **Automation** | |
| PDF to text | scripts/extract-pdf.mjs |
| Consistency check | scripts/check-paper.mjs |
| Parameter sweep (sensitivity) | scripts/parameter-sweep.mjs |
| Benchmark against top papers | scripts/benchmark-paper.mjs |
## Data basis
| Metric | Source |
|---|---|
| Corpus statistics (449 valid papers) | 502 PDFs extracted and analysed by the author |
| Judges' commentaries | COMAP official releases: 2009 A/B + 2021 Tips |
| Page budget / figure quotas | Median of 2021–2024 Outstanding papers |
| Common-error elimination rates | Judges' commentaries + corpus statistics |
| Outstanding summary breakdowns | Sentence-level analysis of 5 Outstanding papers (2021 C/D, 2023 A/E, 2024 A) |
## Relationship to the official rules
This skill **does not replace** the current-year COMAP rules. Before submitting you must check that year's official requirements:
- page limit
- file format
- submission method
- AI-use policy
- team number / anonymity requirements
The official rules can change year to year; the writing advice here is based on long-term observation and is relatively stable.
## Roadmap
### ✅ Done
1. ✅ Strengths/Weaknesses writing guide
2. ✅ Introduction writing guide
3. ✅ Memo/Letter template (problem F)
4. ✅ Model-innovation strategy guide
5. ✅ More Outstanding summary breakdowns (3 → 5: 2023 A, 2021 C, 2024 A, 2021 D, 2023 E)
6. ✅ End-to-end case (full 2023 A retrospective)
7. ✅ Quick-reference card (30 minutes before submission)
8. ✅ Team workflow guide (4-day contest)
9. ✅ Paper self-assessment rubric (100 points)
10. ✅ Academic sentence bank (mined from 498 papers)
11. ✅ Automation scripts (PDF extraction + consistency check)
12. ✅ Problem B case retrospective (2022 water resources, discrete/optimisation)
13. ✅ Problem C case retrospective (2021 bumblebees, data insight)
14. ✅ Common-error gallery (anti-patterns)
15. ✅ Combined D/E/F cases (+ A–F six-problem overview table)
16. ✅ 25-page dissection (modelled on the 2023 A Outstanding paper)
17. ✅ Ready-to-compile LaTeX skeleton
18. ✅ Markdown skeleton (Pandoc)
19. ✅ Advanced techniques handbook (6 sensitivity methods / 6 validation methods / visualisation decision tree / technique combos)
20. ✅ Parameter-sweep script (parameter-sweep.mjs, verified working)
21. ✅ Top-award strategy (data insights from 502 real papers)
22. ✅ Benchmarking script (benchmark-paper.mjs, verified working)
23. ✅ Top-paper anatomy (2022 C Bitcoin, 117 numbers, 17 figures)
24. ✅ Modeller upskilling handbook (decomposition / assumptions / model library / validation)
25. ✅ Coder upskilling handbook (Python/Matlab/Lingo templates + figure conventions)
26. ✅ Writer upskilling handbook (summary first / academic English / typesetting)
27. ✅ Research upskilling handbook (literature search / dataset sources / research ideas)
### 🔄 Planned
1. Extended sentence bank organised by problem type
2. Yearly updates with Outstanding analyses of each new contest
3. Larger error gallery (using real Meritorious papers as control group)
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |