Skip to content

charlieviettq/awesome-agent-skill / .claude/skills/biz-value-chain

"biz-value-chain"

Verified

"Apply Porter's Value Chain Analysis to identify competitive advantage sources within an organization's activities. Use this skill when the user needs to find where value is created or lost in their operations, analyze cost structure by activity, optimize internal processes, or identify outsourcing candidates — even if they say 'where do we make money' or 'which activities should we keep in-house'.".

FileKindSize
SKILL.mdskill md7.3 KB
examples/sample_scenario.mdmarkdown6.5 KB
references/framework-comparison.mdmarkdown9.7 KB

examples/sample_scenario.md

View on GitHub
# Example: 台灣 B2B SaaS 公司找出毛利率下滑原因

## Scenario

**公司:** CloudOps Taiwan(雲端 IT 資產管理 SaaS,成立 2019,ARR $180M NTD)

**用戶提問:**
> 「我們的毛利率從三年前的 78% 掉到現在的 61%,但我們的 ARR 還在成長。我們搞不清楚錢到底漏在哪裡,是要降成本還是要重新定價?」

**背景資訊(用戶提供):**
- 主要客群:台灣中大型企業 IT 部門(200–2000 人規模)
- 競爭對手:ServiceNow(國際)、叡揚資訊(本土)
- 近期變化:2024 年擴大 CS 團隊(+8 人),新增企業客製化服務線
- 銷售以 enterprise 直銷為主,搭配少量通路商

---

## Analysis

### Step 1: Map Primary Activities

| Activity | Key Processes |
|----------|--------------|
| Inbound Logistics | 雲端基礎設施採購(AWS、GCP);第三方 API 授權(監控工具、資安掃描) |
| Operations | SaaS 平台開發維運;企業客製化開發;SLA 維持 99.9% uptime |
| Outbound Logistics | 帳號開通、環境部署;客製化環境交付;客戶 onboarding |
| Marketing & Sales | 企業直銷(5 人業務);行銷活動(itSMF Taiwan 年會、CIO 論壇) |
| Service | CSM 客戶成功團隊(8 人);技術支援 L1/L2;續約管理 |

### Step 2: Map Support Activities

| Activity | Key Processes |
|----------|--------------|
| Firm Infrastructure | 財務、法務(NDA、SLA 合約);ISO 27001 認證維護 |
| HR Management | 工程師招募(搶手,常被挖角到大廠);薪資結構偏低於市場 |
| Technology Development | 核心平台 R&D;AI 功能開發(資產異常偵測);技術債清償 |
| Procurement | AWS Reserved Instances 採購;SaaS 工具授權議價 |

### Step 3: Assess Each Activity

**Primary Activities:**

| Activity | Value Contribution | Cost % | vs Competitors |
|----------|-------------------|--------|----------------|
| Inbound Logistics | Low | 12% | Worse — AWS 採購無 RI 策略,按需計費 |
| Operations | **High** | 28% | Better — 本土化深度整合(HR 系統、會計系統)競爭對手難複製 |
| Outbound Logistics | Medium | 11% | Worse — 企業客製化交付週期平均 47 天,競對 ServiceNow 約 30 天 |
| Marketing & Sales | Medium | 9% | Same — 論壇口碑佳但缺乏 inbound pipeline |
| Service | **High** | 18% | Worse — CSM 人力大幅增加但無標準化流程,成本失控 |

**Support Activities:**

| Activity | Value Contribution | Cost % | vs Competitors |
|----------|-------------------|--------|----------------|
| Firm Infrastructure | Low | 5% | Same |
| HR Management | **High** | 8% | Worse — 工程師流失率年約 22%,重招成本估每人 NT$300K |
| Technology Development | **High** | 6% | Better — AI 功能是市場差異化,但投資佔比偏低 |
| Procurement | Medium | 3% | Worse — AWS 無 RI,估計可節省 30–35% 雲端費用 |

**成本結構重建(對應毛利率下滑):**

| 主要原因 | 估計影響 |
|---------|---------|
| AWS 按需計費 vs RI | 約 -4% 毛利率 |
| CS 團隊人力暴增(無流程槓桿) | 約 -7% 毛利率 |
| 企業客製化服務邊際成本被低估 | 約 -6% 毛利率 |
| **合計** | **-17%(符合 78% → 61%)** |

### Step 4: Identify Advantage Sources

**Cost advantage:**
- 無(目前沒有任何一個活動做到比競爭對手更低成本)

**Differentiation advantage:**
- **Operations**(本土化深度整合)— 客戶切換成本高,這是護城河
- **Technology Development**(AI 資產異常偵測)— 目前市場唯一,但投資偏低

**Key linkages:**
- Technology Development ↔ Operations:AI 功能直接嵌入核心平台,強化本土化優勢
- Service ↔ Outbound Logistics:CSM 團隊介入交付流程,延長 onboarding 週期且成本疊加
- Procurement ↔ Inbound Logistics:AWS 議價失敗直接墊高雲端 COGS

---

## Result

```markdown
# Value Chain Analysis: CloudOps Taiwan

## Primary Activities

| Activity | Key Processes | Value Contribution | Cost % | vs Competitors |
|----------|-------------|-------------------|--------|----------------|
| Inbound Logistics | AWS/GCP 採購;第三方 API 授權 | Low | 12% | Worse |
| Operations | 平台維運;本土化整合;企業客製化 | High | 28% | Better |
| Outbound Logistics | Onboarding;客製化環境交付 | Medium | 11% | Worse |
| Marketing & Sales | 企業直銷;CIO 論壇活動 | Medium | 9% | Same |
| Service | CSM 管理;技術支援;續約 | High | 18% | Worse |

## Support Activities

| Activity | Key Processes | Value Contribution | Cost % | vs Competitors |
|----------|-------------|-------------------|--------|----------------|
| Infrastructure | 財務、法務、ISO 認證 | Low | 5% | Same |
| HR Management | 工程師招募與留任 | High | 8% | Worse |
| Technology Dev | AI 功能 R&D;核心平台演進 | High | 6% | Better |
| Procurement | AWS RI 議價;SaaS 工具授權 | Medium | 3% | Worse |

## Advantage Sources
- **Differentiation advantage in**: Operations(本土化整合)、Technology Development(AI 偵測)
- **No cost advantage** in any activity — 需優先修復
- **Key linkages**:
  - Technology Development ↔ Operations(AI 強化本土化,護城河加深)
  - Service ↔ Outbound Logistics(CSM 介入交付 = 成本疊加,需解耦)

## Recommendations

1. **Strengthen**: Technology Development — 將 AI 預算從 6% 提升至 10%;這是目前唯一市場差異化來源,且競爭對手(ServiceNow)尚未本土化 AI 功能

2. **Optimize**: Service — 建立 CSM playbook 與 self-service portal;目前 8 人 CSM 每人服務約 15 個客戶,業界標竿為 25–30;目標在 6 個月內讓 CSM 成本佔比從 18% 降至 12%

3. **Optimize**: Outbound Logistics — 標準化 onboarding 流程;將企業交付週期從 47 天壓縮至 30 天;解耦 CSM 與交付流程避免成本疊加

4. **Outsource/Negotiate**: Procurement — 立即評估 AWS 1 年期 Reserved Instances;按目前用量估算年省 NT$4–6M;委外 FinOps 顧問做一次性優化即可

5. **投資**: HR Management — 提升工程師薪資至市場 P75(預估年增 NT$3M 薪資支出,但可降低 22% 流失率,每年省下 NT$6M 重招成本)
```

**核心結論:** 毛利率下滑不是定價問題,是成本失控。三個主要漏點是雲端採購(RI 策略缺失)、CS 人力無槓桿、企業客製化成本被低估。護城河在 Operations + Technology Development — 這兩個活動要加碼,不能砍。
reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness.Stars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependenciesStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is availableStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall