Skip to content

charlieviettq/awesome-agent-skill / .claude/skills/biz-swot

"biz-swot"

Verified

"Conduct SWOT analysis with TOWS matrix for strategic planning. Use this skill when the user needs to evaluate a company, product, or project by identifying strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats, or wants to generate strategic options from internal and external factors. Also use when the user mentions competitive positioning, strategic assessment, or asks 'what are our advantages and risks', even without naming SWOT explicitly.".

FileKindSize
SKILL.mdskill md9.6 KB
evals/evals.jsonconfig1.9 KB
examples/sample_scenario.mdmarkdown5.9 KB
references/framework-comparison.mdmarkdown13.4 KB
references/tows-case-studies.mdmarkdown19.4 KB

references/framework-comparison.md

View on GitHub
# Framework Comparison: SWOT vs. Adjacent Strategy Tools

## Quick Selection Guide

| Question you're trying to answer | Best primary framework | SWOT role |
|---|---|---|
| "What is our competitive position and what should we do?" | **SWOT + TOWS** | Primary |
| "How attractive is this industry for entry?" | **Porter's Five Forces** | Optional supplement |
| "What macro trends affect us over the next 5 years?" | **PESTEL** | Feed into SWOT (O/T quadrants) |
| "Which product lines should we invest in or cut?" | **BCG Matrix** | Separate analysis; SWOT for each SBU |
| "What does the competitive landscape look like?" | **Porter's Five Forces** | Feed into SWOT (T quadrant) |
| "We need both internal and external factors to generate strategies" | **SWOT + TOWS** | Primary |

**Decision rule:** If your end goal is generating strategic action options, SWOT + TOWS is the correct final step. Porter's, PESTEL, and BCG are *input generators* — they surface factors that feed the SWOT quadrants. SWOT is the synthesis layer.

---

## SWOT vs. Porter's Five Forces

### What each covers

| Dimension | SWOT | Porter's Five Forces |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Organization-level (internal + external) | Industry-level (external only) |
| Internal factors | Yes (S, W) | No |
| Output | Strategic options (via TOWS) | Industry attractiveness score + structural diagnosis |
| Unit of analysis | A specific company, product, or project | The industry as a whole |
| Time orientation | Current state + near-term strategy | Structural forces (medium to long-term) |

### What Porter's Five Forces contributes to SWOT

Porter's Five Forces analyzes five structural forces:

1. **Threat of new entrants** → feeds SWOT **Threat** quadrant
2. **Bargaining power of suppliers** → feeds SWOT **Threat** (if high power) or **Opportunity** (if low)
3. **Bargaining power of buyers** → feeds SWOT **Threat** or **Opportunity**
4. **Threat of substitutes** → feeds SWOT **Threat** quadrant
5. **Competitive rivalry** → feeds SWOT **Threat** quadrant; high rivalry can also surface **Opportunities** via competitor weaknesses

### Integration pattern: Five Forces → SWOT

Run Porter's Five Forces first when you lack structured data on industry dynamics. Extract the findings as SWOT O/T inputs:

```
Five Forces analysis of Taiwan bubble tea industry:
  - Threat of new entrants: HIGH (low capex, no IP protection)
  - Supplier power: LOW (sugar/tea commodities, many vendors)
  - Buyer power: MEDIUM (low switching cost, but price-sensitive segment)
  - Substitutes: MEDIUM (coffee, convenience store drinks)
  - Rivalry: HIGH (Gong Cha, CoCo, Tiger Sugar, dozens of locals)

↓ Extract as SWOT inputs:

Threats:
  T1 - High entry threat means any SO strategy based on first-mover advantage
       has a short window (from: new entrants force)
  T2 - Intense rivalry compresses margins; premium pricing requires strong
       differentiation (from: rivalry force)

Opportunities:
  O1 - Low supplier power = flexible sourcing; opportunity to localize
       ingredients in new markets to reduce cost (from: supplier force)
```

### When NOT to use Five Forces instead of SWOT

- Five Forces does not assess your organization's internal capabilities. If a company has a structural Five Forces advantage (e.g., low supplier power) but lacks the internal capability to act on it (e.g., no procurement team), the strategy will fail. SWOT catches this; Five Forces alone does not.
- Five Forces produces a structural snapshot, not strategy options. You still need TOWS to generate actionable steps.

---

## SWOT vs. PESTEL

### What each covers

| Dimension | SWOT | PESTEL |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Organization-level (internal + external) | Macro-environment only (external) |
| Internal factors | Yes (S, W) | No |
| Granularity | High-level quadrants | Six specific macro dimensions (Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Environmental, Legal) |
| Output | Strategy options (TOWS) | Macro risk/opportunity inventory |
| Best use | Strategic planning, competitive positioning | Scenario planning, market entry assessment |

### PESTEL dimensions mapped to SWOT quadrants

PESTEL factors always map to **O or T** in SWOT — never to S or W, because all PESTEL factors are external (an organization cannot directly control political or economic conditions).

| PESTEL Dimension | Maps to SWOT | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Political | O or T | Trade policy change → T if restrictive, O if opens new market |
| Economic | O or T | Currency depreciation → T for import-dependent firm |
| Social | O or T | Aging population → O for healthcare, T for youth-targeted products |
| Technological | O or T | AI automation → O if adoptable, T if competitors adopt first |
| Environmental | O or T | ESG regulation tightening → T for high-emission industries |
| Legal | O or T | Data privacy law → T for data brokers, O for compliance tools |

**Critical check:** If you catch yourself putting a PESTEL factor under S or W, stop. A technological capability your organization *possesses* (e.g., "we have proprietary AI") is a Strength (internal). The *industry trend toward AI adoption* is an Opportunity (external). These are different things.

### Integration pattern: PESTEL → SWOT

Use PESTEL as a checklist to ensure you haven't missed macro factors before locking down O/T quadrants:

```
PESTEL scan for Japanese market entry (bubble tea chain):
  P - Japan-Taiwan diplomatic relations stable; no trade barriers         → O (favorable)
  E - Yen at multi-decade low vs NTD (as of 2024)                        → T (repatriation risk)
  S - Japanese "Taiwan boom"; cultural affinity high, tourism up 40% YoY  → O
  T - Japanese cashless penetration >90%; need payment system integration  → T (operational cost)
  E - Japan's food import regulations strict (ingredient certification)     → T
  L - Japan franchise law requires disclosure document registration         → T (compliance burden)

→ Pull the high-impact items into SWOT O/T quadrants:
  O2 - Cultural affinity and Japan-Taiwan tourism boom creates demand signal
  T3 - Yen depreciation increases NTD-denominated costs for Japan operations
  T4 - Strict import/franchise regulations require local legal/ops capacity
```

### When PESTEL is overkill

For a stable domestic market where the business has operated for years, running a full PESTEL adds time without proportional insight. In these cases, scan only the two or three PESTEL dimensions most likely to shift (e.g., only Technological and Legal for a fintech startup). SWOT is still the synthesis framework; you just don't need the full six-dimension PESTEL as input.

---

## SWOT vs. BCG Matrix

### What each covers

| Dimension | SWOT | BCG Matrix |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Single entity (organization, product, or project) | Portfolio of business units or products |
| Question answered | "What should this entity do?" | "Where should we invest, hold, or divest across the portfolio?" |
| Internal vs. External | Both | Primarily relative position (market share = internal proxy; market growth = external) |
| Output | Strategy options per entity | Capital allocation decisions across units |
| Granularity | Deep on one subject | Shallow on many subjects |

### BCG Matrix mechanics (brief)

The BCG Matrix plots each business unit (SBU) or product on two axes:

```
Y-axis: Market growth rate (external — industry trend)
X-axis: Relative market share = own share ÷ largest competitor's share

          High growth │  Question Mark  │  Star
                      │  (low share,    │  (high share,
                      │  high growth)   │  high growth)
                      ├─────────────────┼──────────────
          Low growth  │  Dog            │  Cash Cow
                      │  (low share,    │  (high share,
                      │  low growth)    │  low growth)
                      └─────────────────┴──────────────
                            Low share      High share
                         (relative market share)
```

Note: Market growth rate is **external** (O or T in SWOT); relative market share is a **proxy for internal competitive position** (S or W in SWOT).

### Integration pattern: BCG → SWOT

BCG tells you *which SBU to focus on*; SWOT then tells you *what to do with it*.

```
Portfolio analysis (fictional multi-brand tea company):
  SBU A — Classic bubble tea brand   → Star (high share, high growth)
  SBU B — Premium matcha line        → Question Mark (low share, high growth)
  SBU C — Packaged RTD beverages     → Cash Cow (high share, low growth)
  SBU D — Western-style café         → Dog (low share, low growth)

Decision: SBU B (Question Mark) needs strategic direction.
→ Run SWOT for SBU B to determine whether to invest-and-grow or divest.

SWOT for SBU B (Premium matcha line):
  S1 — Proprietary matcha sourcing agreement with Uji farm
  W1 — Premium price point limits volume; higher production cost
  O1 — Health-conscious consumer segment growing 20% YoY
  T1 — Japanese matcha brands (Ippodo, Marukyu) have stronger brand authority

TOWS:
  SO — Use farm relationship (S1) to certify origin story and capture
       health-conscious premium segment (O1)
  WT — If brand authority gap (T1) + cost structure (W1) can't be resolved
       within 18 months, exit and redeploy capital to Star (SBU A)
```

### When NOT to conflate BCG with SWOT

BCG positions are descriptive, not prescriptive in isolation:
- "Dog" does not automatically mean divest — a Dog may be strategically important for a customer segment that anchors relationships for other SBUs.
- "Star" does not automatically mean invest more — the Star's competitive moat may be eroding (a Weakness).

SWOT catches these nuances. BCG cannot.

---

## Combining Frameworks: Recommended Sequences

### Sequence A: Market entry decision

```
1. PESTEL → identify macro risks and enablers in the target market
2. Porter's Five Forces → assess industry attractiveness and structural dynamics
3. SWOT (internal + PESTEL/Five Forces outputs as O/T) → generate strategy options
4. TOWS → select entry strategy
```

### Sequence B: Portfolio reallocation

```
1. BCG Matrix → identify which SBUs need strategic direction
2. SWOT for each flagged SBU → generate options
3. TOWS per SBU → compare strategies, select best allocation
```

### Sequence C: Competitive positioning (no portfolio complexity)

```
1. SWOT (internal scan + market knowledge as O/T) → quick synthesis
2. TOWS → strategy options
   (Porter's/PESTEL optional if O/T inputs are already well-informed)
```

---

## Framework Overlap and Conflict Resolution

### "Relative market share" appears in both BCG and SWOT — which is it?

- In **BCG Matrix**: relative market share is an *axis variable* used to classify the SBU's portfolio position. It's a ratio (your share ÷ leader's share), used as a proxy for competitive advantage.
- In **SWOT**: "We hold 35% market share vs. competitor's 20%" is a **Strength** (internal competitive advantage). The *trend* of market share shifting (competitors gaining) is a **Threat** (external).

They are not conflicting — BCG uses the number for classification; SWOT uses it as evidence for a factor. Both can be correct simultaneously.

### "Technological change" appears in both PESTEL and Porter's Five Forces

- In **PESTEL**: Technological dimension covers macro trends — AI, automation, platform economics, infrastructure shifts.
- In **Porter's Five Forces**: Technology matters through the *threat of substitutes* (new technology enabling substitute products) and *threat of new entrants* (low-cost technology reducing barriers to entry).

When the same trend appears in both, consolidate it into a single SWOT factor rather than counting it twice. Duplicate factors inflate the perceived magnitude of a single trend.

### Choosing depth vs. breadth

| Scenario | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Time-constrained (single session) | SWOT only; skip Five Forces/PESTEL unless O/T are weak |
| High-stakes market entry | Full sequence A (PESTEL + Five Forces + SWOT + TOWS) |
| Internal strategy review (no new markets) | SWOT only; BCG if multi-product |
| Academic or consulting deliverable | Full documentation of all applicable frameworks |

---

## Anti-Patterns Specific to Multi-Framework Use

**Double-counting factors**: If you ran PESTEL first and listed "AI adoption accelerating" as a macro trend, do not also list it as a separate opportunity in SWOT unless you are describing a specific, distinct manifestation. Consolidate: PESTEL flags the trend; SWOT specifies what it means for *this organization*.

**Framework substitution**: Running Porter's Five Forces and declaring "the industry is attractive, therefore we should enter" is not a strategy. Porter's Five Forces is a diagnosis tool, not a decision tool. TOWS generates the actual strategic options.

**Mixing units of analysis**: BCG is for portfolios; SWOT is for a single entity. Do not run BCG on a single-product company and call it a SWOT substitute. Do not run one SWOT for an entire portfolio and skip BCG — you will miss which SBU the strategy should apply to.

**Outdated frameworks masking current dynamics**: All four frameworks are static snapshots. If you run Porter's Five Forces in January and SWOT in June, the inputs may no longer be consistent. When combining frameworks in one analysis, run them close in time and flag any inputs that may have changed.
rea-analysis-optimizationmorluto/reaOptimize REA providers and shared analysis workflows for agent context, latency, CPU, and memory while preserving correctness and Evidence. Use for analysis bottlenecks and cache or query design; CI/test-suite optimization belongs to rea-ci-tests-audit.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
rea-ci-tests-auditmorluto/reaAudit REA CI and test suites for correctness, fixture drift, false passes, and measured performance; use for suite or workflow investigations and efficiency changes, rather than ordinary feature testing or a single test failure.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
rea-tool-designmorluto/reaAudit, investigate, design, or change REA investigation tools, CLI/MCP contracts, provider capabilities, and Evidence semantics.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-auditDietrichGebert/ponytailQuality audit of the whole repo: bugs, security, real load, missing tests, speed, and what to delete. Most important first.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall