charlieviettq/awesome-agent-skill / .claude/skills/biz-4p-7p
"biz-4p-7p"
Verified"Apply the Marketing Mix (4P/7P) framework to design tactical marketing decisions across Product, Price, Place, Promotion — plus People, Process, Physical Evidence for services. Use this skill when the user needs to plan a product launch, design a go-to-market strategy, or audit their marketing mix — even if they say 'how should we price this', 'where should we sell', or 'what's our go-to-market plan'.".
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 7.2 KB |
| examples/sample_scenario.md | markdown | 7.3 KB |
| references/distribution-channels.md | markdown | 12.6 KB |
| references/pricing-strategies.md | markdown | 14.7 KB |
references/distribution-channels.md
View on GitHub# Distribution Channels
## Channel Structure Fundamentals
A distribution channel is the path a product takes from producer to end customer. Every channel decision trades off **control**, **cost**, and **coverage**.
```
Producer → [Channel Layers] → End Customer
Level 0 (Direct): Producer ────────────────────→ Customer
Level 1: Producer → Retailer ──────────→ Customer
Level 2: Producer → Wholesaler → Retailer → Customer
Level 3: Producer → Distributor → Wholesaler → Retailer → Customer
```
Each layer adds cost (typically 20–60% markup per layer) but also adds reach and local expertise. The deeper the channel, the less control the producer retains over pricing and presentation.
---
## Channel Coverage: The Three Modes
The SKILL.md lists three coverage modes. Here is how to choose between them.
| Mode | Definition | Use when... | Risk |
|------|-----------|-------------|------|
| **Intensive** | Available in every possible outlet | Commodities, convenience goods, impulse buys | Price war; brand dilution if placed alongside inferior substitutes |
| **Selective** | Chosen outlets that meet criteria | Mid-range goods with comparison shopping; want some control | Under-coverage in weak regions |
| **Exclusive** | One partner per territory | Premium/luxury goods; franchise systems; high-involvement purchases | Dependence on single partner; antitrust issues in some markets |
### Coverage Decision Checklist
Answer yes/no to each:
1. Is the product purchased by impulse or convenience? → **Intensive**
2. Is the target segment willing to seek out a specific retailer? → at least **Selective**
3. Does the product require trained staff to sell or install? → **Selective** or **Exclusive**
4. Does the price point or brand story require controlled presentation? → **Selective** or **Exclusive**
5. Is protecting price integrity critical? → **Exclusive**
If you answer yes to #1 but also yes to #4, you have a channel-brand conflict. Resolve at the Product/Price level first before choosing coverage.
---
## Direct vs. Indirect Channel Decision
### The Channel Economics Formula
**Direct channel (own website, own store, own sales team):**
```
Gross Margin (Direct) = Revenue − COGS − Fulfillment Cost − Marketing CAC
```
**Indirect channel (retailer, marketplace, distributor):**
```
Gross Margin (Indirect) = (Revenue × (1 − Channel Take Rate)) − COGS − Trade Spend
```
Where:
- **Channel Take Rate**: the percentage the intermediary keeps (Shopee/Lazada: 3–8%; physical retail: 40–60%; Amazon US: 8–15%)
- **Trade Spend**: slotting fees, promotional discounts, co-op advertising required by the channel
### Worked Example: Taiwanese Tea Brand
Product: NT$65 cold-brew oolong bottle. COGS = NT$18.
**Option A — Direct (own website + line shopping):**
- Fulfillment cost per unit: NT$12 (packaging + logistics)
- CAC amortized per unit: NT$8
- Gross margin per unit: 65 − 18 − 12 − 8 = **NT$27 (41.5%)**
**Option B — 7-ELEVEN selective placement:**
- Retail price: NT$65
- Retailer take: 40% → producer receives NT$39
- Trade spend (promo, listing): NT$3/unit amortized
- Gross margin per unit: 39 − 18 − 3 = **NT$18 (27.7%)**
**Option C — Shopee marketplace:**
- Commission: 5%; payment fee: 2% → take rate = 7%
- Fulfillment: NT$10
- CAC/ads: NT$6
- Gross margin per unit: (65 × 0.93) − 18 − 10 − 6 = 60.45 − 34 = **NT$26.45 (40.7%)**
**Decision:** Direct and Shopee have similar unit economics. 7-ELEVEN wins on volume and brand visibility but shrinks margins. The correct answer depends on volume assumptions, not unit margin alone.
### Volume-Adjusted Comparison
```
Annual Profit = Units Sold × Gross Margin per Unit
```
| Channel | Est. Monthly Units | Gross Margin/Unit | Monthly Profit |
|---------|-------------------|-------------------|----------------|
| Own website | 200 | NT$27 | NT$5,400 |
| 7-ELEVEN (100 stores) | 3,000 | NT$18 | NT$54,000 |
| Shopee | 800 | NT$26.45 | NT$21,160 |
At early stage, 7-ELEVEN dominates on absolute profit despite lower margins. At scale, own website becomes strategically valuable (customer data, pricing control).
---
## Channel Selection Framework (5-Factor Score)
Rate each candidate channel 1–5 on each factor, weight by importance to your situation.
| Factor | What to assess | Weight (adjust to your case) |
|--------|---------------|-------------------------------|
| **Reach** | How many target-segment customers does this channel already have? | 25% |
| **Fit** | Does the channel's positioning match your Product/Price positioning? | 25% |
| **Control** | Can you control pricing, presentation, and returns? | 20% |
| **Cost** | Total channel cost (take rate + trade spend + logistics) vs. margin floor | 20% |
| **Reversibility** | How hard is it to exit if this channel underperforms? | 10% |
**Scoring example — premium tea, three channels:**
| Factor | 7-ELEVEN | PChome | Own D2C |
|--------|----------|--------|---------|
| Reach (1–5) | 5 | 3 | 1 |
| Fit (1–5) | 3 | 2 | 5 |
| Control (1–5) | 2 | 3 | 5 |
| Cost (1–5, 5=low cost) | 2 | 3 | 4 |
| Reversibility (1–5) | 2 | 4 | 5 |
| **Weighted Score** | **2.85** | **2.90** | **3.95** |
D2C wins on fit and control but loses on reach. The practical strategy: use 7-ELEVEN for volume and brand awareness early, invest in D2C for long-term margin and data ownership.
---
## Channel Conflict
Channel conflict occurs when multiple channels compete for the same customer in ways that undercut each other.
### Types
**Horizontal conflict**: Two retailers in the same channel tier fight over customers (e.g., two 7-ELEVEN franchisees near each other — usually not your problem to solve).
**Vertical conflict**: Producer and channel partner disagree on pricing, territory, or promotional terms.
**Inter-channel conflict** (the most common problem): You sell direct online at NT$65 and also through 7-ELEVEN at NT$65. Shopee sellers start discounting to NT$50. The channel price integrity collapses.
### Conflict Prevention Rules
1. **Price floor policy**: Set a Minimum Advertised Price (MAP). State it contractually with every channel partner. NT$65 is the floor; you don't enforce it at 7-ELEVEN's register, but you refuse to supply any partner who advertises below it.
2. **SKU differentiation**: Sell different SKUs in different channels. 7-ELEVEN gets a 350ml bottle; D2C offers a 500ml bundle. Prevents direct price comparison.
3. **Territory isolation**: Exclusive distributors get geographic territory; reduces horizontal conflict.
4. **Margin protection**: Never let any channel partner's list cost drop below COGS + minimum acceptable margin. Once a channel starts dumping, brand equity erodes faster than you can recoup.
### The Premium Channel Exit Problem
Entering a discount channel (e.g., Costco, wholesale clubs, clearance promotions) is **very hard to reverse**:
- Customers who discovered you at NT$30 will not repurchase at NT$65
- Premium channels (boutiques, City Café shelf) will delist you if they see you at Costco
- SKU differentiation helps but cannot fully isolate perceived quality
The SKILL.md Iron Law applies here: "Place decisions are hard to reverse." Operationally, this means: **require board-level or founder approval before entering any channel whose average selling price is more than 20% below your primary channel price.**
---
## Platform Channel Reference (Taiwan + SEA)
Common channel options for product businesses in Taiwan and Southeast Asia:
| Channel | Category | Take Rate | Min Monthly Volume to Matter | Notes |
|---------|----------|-----------|-------------------------------|-------|
| 7-ELEVEN Taiwan | Physical retail | ~40% | 1,000 units/week | Requires distributor relationship; slotting fee |
| FamilyMart Taiwan | Physical retail | ~38% | 800 units/week | Slightly more accessible for new brands |
| Shopee Taiwan | Marketplace | 5–8% | 50 units/month | Easy entry; price pressure is intense |
| Momo 購物 | Marketplace | 12–18% | 100 units/month | Higher-income demographic than Shopee |
| LINE Shopping | Social commerce | 4–6% | Varies | Works well with LINE OA fan base |
| Own D2C (Shopify/91App) | Direct | 2–3% (payment) | N/A | Full margin; requires own traffic |
| Cosmed / Watsons | Health/beauty retail | 35–45% | 200 units/week | Very slow listing process |
| Shopee SEA (SG/MY/TH) | Marketplace | 3–9% by country | 100 units/month | Cross-border logistics adds ~NT$50–120 cost/unit |
*Rates are approximate ranges from publicly available sources; verify with each platform's current fee schedule.*
---
## Multi-Channel Sequencing Strategy
Most brands cannot launch every channel simultaneously. Common sequencing patterns:
### Pattern A: Prove at D2C, then expand (works for premium/niche)
```
Month 0–6: D2C only (own website, Instagram shop)
Goal: prove demand, collect customer data, refine messaging
Month 6–12: Add 1–2 selective marketplace channels (Momo > Shopee for premium)
Month 12+: Approach physical selective retail only after proven sell-through
```
**Why this order:** D2C validates the proposition cheaply. Marketplaces add volume without pricing risk if you enforce MAP. Physical retail requires consistent volume to justify trade spend.
### Pattern B: Retail-led, then defend with D2C (works for mass/convenience goods)
```
Month 0–3: Secure distributor → enter CVS or pharmacy chains
Goal: reach, trial, brand awareness via distribution
Month 3–9: Launch D2C to capture repeat buyers at higher margin
Month 9+: Use D2C data to negotiate better placement with physical retail
```
**Why this order:** For convenience goods, trial requires physical availability. D2C comes second as a margin-recapture play, not a primary launch vehicle.
### Pattern C: Marketplace-first (works for new brands with no distributor relationships)
```
Month 0–3: Shopee or Momo — lowest barrier to entry, fastest feedback
Month 3–6: If Shopee unit economics work, add D2C for margin; if not, fix product first
Month 6+: Selective physical retail only if product-market fit is confirmed
```
---
## Channel Readiness Checklist
Before committing to a new channel, confirm:
- [ ] Unit economics at that channel's take rate still exceed your margin floor
- [ ] You have sufficient inventory depth to meet the channel's minimum order / replenishment requirements
- [ ] Your packaging and labeling meet the channel's requirements (barcode, language, size)
- [ ] You have agreed MAP policy and the channel partner will enforce or accept it
- [ ] You have a clear plan to handle returns from that channel
- [ ] Entering this channel does not conflict with existing exclusivity agreements
- [ ] The channel's typical customer matches your STP target segment (verify with data, not assumption)
---
## Key Numbers to Know
| Metric | What it means | When to use |
|--------|--------------|-------------|
| **Channel Take Rate** | % of retail price kept by intermediary | Gross margin modeling |
| **Days Inventory Outstanding (DIO)** | Avg days from production to sale via this channel | Cash flow planning; physical retail often 60–90 days |
| **Sell-Through Rate** | % of units placed that actually sell to end customers | Predicts restocking; below 70% triggers delisting risk |
| **Trade Spend %** | Slotting, co-op, promotions as % of channel revenue | True cost of physical retail channel |
| **Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) by channel** | Total marketing spend ÷ new customers from that channel | Compare D2C vs marketplace vs paid media |
---
## Common Mistakes
**Entering too many channels at launch**: Stock splits across 5 channels means thin coverage everywhere. One or two channels done well outperform five channels done poorly.
**Confusing marketplace rank with brand equity**: High Shopee ranking is rented, not owned. If Shopee changes its algorithm or a competitor undercuts price, the rank disappears. D2C customer lists are owned assets.
**Assuming physical retail is "premium" by default**: A product placed on the wrong shelf (end-cap clearance vs. chilled premium section) can damage rather than enhance positioning. Placement within the store matters as much as which store.
**Ignoring channel data feedback loops**: Physical retail gives almost no customer data. Marketplaces give transaction data only. D2C gives behavioral data. If you only sell through physical retail, you are flying blind on customer behavior.
**Treating Place as a one-time decision**: Channel strategy should be reviewed quarterly in the first two years. Sell-through data, competitor moves, and channel economics all shift faster than most founders expect.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| rea-analysis-optimizationmorluto/reaOptimize REA providers and shared analysis workflows for agent context, latency, CPU, and memory while preserving correctness and Evidence. Use for analysis bottlenecks and cache or query design; CI/test-suite optimization belongs to rea-ci-tests-audit. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| rea-ci-tests-auditmorluto/reaAudit REA CI and test suites for correctness, fixture drift, false passes, and measured performance; use for suite or workflow investigations and efficiency changes, rather than ordinary feature testing or a single test failure. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| rea-tool-designmorluto/reaAudit, investigate, design, or change REA investigation tools, CLI/MCP contracts, provider capabilities, and Evidence semantics. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-auditDietrichGebert/ponytailQuality audit of the whole repo: bugs, security, real load, missing tests, speed, and what to delete. Most important first. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |