Skip to content

brycewang-stanford/Auto-Empirical-Research-Skills / skills/17-DAAF-Contribution-Community-daaf/dot-claude/skills/education-data-source-pseo

education-data-source-pseo

Verified

PSEO — Census data linking graduates to employment via LEHD wage records. Earnings percentiles at 1/5/10 years post-graduation by institution, degree, CIP. Use for graduate earnings analysis. Coverage: ~29% of graduates from ~31 states.

references/state-coverage.md

View on GitHub
# State Coverage

Participating states, coverage rates, data partners, and experimental data status.

## Contents

- [Coverage Overview](#coverage-overview)
- [Participating States and Partners](#participating-states-and-partners)
- [Coverage Rates](#coverage-rates)
- [Experimental Data Status](#experimental-data-status)
- [Coverage Implications](#coverage-implications)
- [Joining PSEO](#joining-pseo)

## Coverage Overview

As of 2025, PSEO covers approximately **29% of all U.S. college graduates** through partnerships in:

- **31 states** + District of Columbia
- **1 online-only institution** (Western Governors University)
- **825+ institutions**

Coverage varies significantly by state based on:
- Which institutions/systems have partnered
- Whether state-level coordination exists
- Historical timing of partnership

## Participating States and Partners

| State | Data Partner(s) | Coverage |
|-------|-----------------|----------|
| Alabama | University of Alabama System | 21% |
| Arizona | Arizona Board of Regents | 25% |
| Colorado | Colorado Department of Higher Education | 72% |
| Connecticut | CT Independent Colleges, CT State Colleges, UConn | 69% |
| District of Columbia | University of the District of Columbia | 3% |
| Georgia | Georgia Independent College Association, University System of Georgia | 43% |
| Hawaii | University of Hawaii System | 72% |
| Illinois | IL Board of Higher Ed, IL Community College Board | 69% |
| Indiana | Indiana Commission for Higher Education | 77% |
| Iowa | Iowa Board of Regents, Iowa Dept of Education | 66% |
| Louisiana | Louisiana Board of Regents | 74% |
| Maine | Maine Community College System, University of Maine System | 54% |
| Massachusetts | Massachusetts Department of Higher Education | 32% |
| Michigan | Institute for Research on Innovation and Science (UMich) | 10% |
| Minnesota | Minnesota Office of Higher Education | 74% |
| Missouri | Missouri Dept of Higher Ed and Workforce Development | 50% |
| Montana | Montana University System | 83% |
| New York | CUNY, SUNY | 44% |
| Ohio | Ohio Department of Higher Education | 61% |
| Oklahoma | Oklahoma State Regents for Higher Education | 66% |
| Oregon | Oregon Higher Education Coordinating Commission | 70% |
| Pennsylvania | The Pennsylvania State University | 11% |
| Rhode Island | Bryant University, Providence College | 10% |
| South Carolina | South Carolina Commission on Higher Education | 86% |
| South Dakota | SD Board of Regents, SD Board of Technical Education | 80% |
| Texas | TX Higher Ed Coordinating Board, University of Texas System | 77% |
| Utah | Utah System of Higher Education | 73% |
| Virginia | State Council of Higher Education for Virginia | 87% |
| West Virginia | West Virginia Higher Education Policy Commission | 43% |
| Wisconsin | IRIS (UW-Madison), University of Wisconsin System | 45% |
| Wyoming | University of Wyoming, Wyoming Community College Commission | 86% |
| Online | Western Governors University | -- |

*Coverage percentages based on share of state's public and private graduates from 2015 IPEDS Completions data.*

## Coverage Rates

### High Coverage States (>70%)

| State | Coverage | Notes |
|-------|----------|-------|
| Virginia | 87% | Comprehensive state agency partnership |
| South Carolina | 86% | State commission coordinates |
| Wyoming | 86% | Small state, comprehensive coverage |
| Montana | 83% | University system partnership |
| South Dakota | 80% | Multiple boards coordinating |
| Indiana | 77% | State commission partnership |
| Texas | 77% | Multiple major partners |
| Louisiana | 74% | Board of Regents |
| Minnesota | 74% | State office partnership |
| Utah | 73% | System-wide participation |
| Colorado | 72% | Dept of Higher Ed |
| Hawaii | 72% | University system |
| Oregon | 70% | Coordinating commission |

### Medium Coverage States (40-70%)

| State | Coverage | Notes |
|-------|----------|-------|
| Connecticut | 69% | Multiple system partnerships |
| Illinois | 69% | State board + community colleges |
| Iowa | 66% | Board of Regents + Dept of Ed |
| Oklahoma | 66% | State regents |
| Ohio | 61% | Dept of Higher Ed |
| Maine | 54% | Community college + university systems |
| Missouri | 50% | State agency |
| Wisconsin | 45% | Partial system coverage |
| New York | 44% | CUNY + SUNY (public only) |
| Georgia | 43% | University system + independents |
| West Virginia | 43% | Policy commission |

### Low Coverage States (<40%)

| State | Coverage | Notes |
|-------|----------|-------|
| Massachusetts | 32% | Dept of Higher Ed (partial) |
| Arizona | 25% | Board of Regents only |
| Alabama | 21% | UA System only |
| Pennsylvania | 11% | Penn State only |
| Michigan | 10% | UMich only (through IRIS) |
| Rhode Island | 10% | Two private institutions only |
| D.C. | 3% | UDC only |

### Non-Participating States

As of 2025, these states have no PSEO coverage:
- Alaska, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Florida, Idaho, Kansas, Kentucky
- Maryland, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey
- New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Tennessee, Vermont, Washington

## Experimental Data Status

### What "Experimental" Means

PSEO is designated as an **experimental data product** by the Census Bureau:

| Characteristic | Implication |
|----------------|-------------|
| **Not official statistics** | May not meet all federal statistical standards |
| **Methodology may change** | Future releases may use different methods |
| **Partial coverage** | Not representative of all U.S. graduates |
| **Quality varies** | Some cells have higher noise/uncertainty |
| **User feedback incorporated** | Product evolves based on user input |

### Experimental vs. Official Products

| Feature | Experimental (PSEO) | Official (e.g., QWI) |
|---------|---------------------|----------------------|
| Federal standards | Developing | Fully compliant |
| Coverage | Partial (participating institutions) | Comprehensive |
| Methodology | May evolve | Stable |
| Use guidance | Research/exploration | Official statistics |
| OMB clearance | Limited | Full |

### Appropriate Uses

**Appropriate:**
- Research and analysis
- Program evaluation
- Student information tools
- Policy exploration
- Institutional planning

**Caution required:**
- Comparisons across institutions with different coverage
- Time series with changing partner composition
- Small-cell estimates (high noise)

**Not appropriate:**
- Definitive rankings without caveats
- High-stakes decisions without supplementary data

## Coverage Implications

### Selection Bias Concerns

Participating states/institutions may differ from non-participants:

| Potential Bias | Direction |
|----------------|-----------|
| State policy environment | Progressive states may be more likely to participate |
| Institutional resources | Large systems more likely to have data infrastructure |
| Student outcomes | Unknown if participating institutions differ systematically |

### Interpreting Results

When analyzing PSEO data:

1. **Check coverage**: Know what percentage of graduates are represented
2. **Consider selection**: Participating institutions may not be representative
3. **Note changes**: Partner composition changes over time
4. **Report limitations**: Always disclose experimental status

### Comparison Guidelines

| Comparison | Validity | Notes |
|------------|----------|-------|
| Same institution over time | High | If institution continuously participates |
| Programs within same institution | High | Same data source/methodology |
| Same program across institutions (same state) | Medium | Same state partner, but institutional differences |
| Same program across states | Lower | Different data sources, selection |
| State-level aggregates | Medium | Coverage rates vary |

## Joining PSEO

### PSEO Coalition

The **PSEO Coalition** coordinates partnerships between:
- State higher education agencies
- University systems
- Individual institutions
- Census Bureau LEHD program

### Partnership Process

1. **Initial contact**: Institution/agency contacts Census Bureau or PSEO Coalition
2. **Data sharing agreement**: Legal framework established
3. **Data specification review**: Ensure transcript data meets requirements
4. **Secure data transmission**: Transfer graduation records to Census
5. **Processing and validation**: Census matches and validates data
6. **Publication**: Data included in next release

### Data Requirements

Partners must provide for each graduate:
- Social Security Number (required for matching)
- Date of birth
- Graduation year
- Degree/credential type
- Major (CIP code)
- Institution identifier (OPEID)

### Contact Information

- **Census Bureau PSEO Team**: CES.PSEO.Feedback@census.gov
- **PSEO Coalition**: https://pseocoalition.org/contact/

### Benefits of Participation

| Benefit | Description |
|---------|-------------|
| National earnings data | Track graduates across state lines |
| Comparative benchmarking | Compare to similar institutions |
| Program evaluation | Assess employment outcomes by major |
| Consumer information | Inform prospective students |
| No additional surveys | Uses existing administrative data |
| Privacy protection | Differential privacy protects individuals |

## Timeline of Coverage Expansion

| Year | Milestone |
|------|-----------|
| ~2014 | University of Texas System pilot |
| 2018 | First PSEO data released |
| 2020 | Public release, initial partners |
| 2022 | Expansion to 29 states |
| 2024 | State-level aggregations added |
| 2025 | 31 states + D.C., ~29% coverage |
finishing-a-development-branchobra/superpowersUse when implementation is complete, all tests pass, and you need to decide how to integrate the workStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
systematic-debuggingobra/superpowersUse when encountering any bug, test failure, or unexpected behavior, before proposing fixesStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
test-driven-developmentobra/superpowersUse when implementing any feature or bugfix, before writing implementation codeStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
skill-creatoranthropics/skillsCreate new skills, modify and improve existing skills, and measure skill performance. Use when users want to create a skill from scratch, edit, or optimize an existing skill, run evals to test a skill, benchmark skill performance with variance analysis, or optimize a skill's description for better triggering accuracy.Stars: 198kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall