Skip to content

borghei/Claude-Skills / legal/whistleblower-compliance

whistleblower-compliance

Verified

Audit whistleblower systems and draft compliant reporting policies. Use when assessing or building whistleblower programs.

references/assessment_checklist.md

View on GitHub
# Whistleblower Compliance Assessment Checklist

8-phase, 60-checkpoint assessment framework for evaluating whistleblower system compliance.

## Table of Contents

- [Priority Classification System](#priority-classification-system)
- [Phase 1: Applicability](#phase-1-applicability)
- [Phase 2: Reception Channel](#phase-2-reception-channel)
- [Phase 3: Designated Persons](#phase-3-designated-persons)
- [Phase 4: Verification and Processing](#phase-4-verification-and-processing)
- [Phase 5: Confidentiality](#phase-5-confidentiality)
- [Phase 6: Dissemination and Information](#phase-6-dissemination-and-information)
- [Phase 7: Data Protection and GDPR](#phase-7-data-protection-and-gdpr)
- [Phase 8: Sector-Specific Requirements](#phase-8-sector-specific-requirements)
- [Common Errors](#common-errors)
- [Assessment Scoring Guide](#assessment-scoring-guide)

## Priority Classification System

| Priority | Definition | Action Required | Example |
|----------|-----------|-----------------|---------|
| CRITICAL | Legal non-compliance creating immediate regulatory risk. Failure to address exposes organization to enforcement action, fines, or liability. | Immediate remediation required within 30 days. Escalate to board/management. | No reporting channel exists; reporter identity disclosed without consent |
| IMPORTANT | Significant gap that reduces system effectiveness or creates material risk. System exists but does not meet key requirements. | Remediation within 90 days. Include in next compliance review cycle. | Acknowledgment exceeds 7-day timeline; no designated person backup |
| IMPROVEMENT | Enhancement opportunity. Current state is not non-compliant but falls below best practice. Addressing improves system effectiveness. | Plan for next annual review. Track as improvement item. | Single channel type only; training frequency below annual |

## Phase 1: Applicability

Determine whether the organization falls within the scope of whistleblower protection regulations.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 1.1 | Jurisdiction identified | CRITICAL | Primary jurisdiction(s) documented with applicable regulations listed |
| 1.2 | Headcount threshold met | CRITICAL | EU: 50+ employees (private sector) or any public sector entity; US/UK: all covered entities |
| 1.3 | Sector-specific obligations identified | IMPORTANT | Regulated sectors (financial, healthcare, defense, nuclear) have additional requirements documented |

## Phase 2: Reception Channel

Evaluate the existence and adequacy of reporting channels.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 2.1 | Internal reporting channel exists | CRITICAL | At least one operational internal reporting channel available |
| 2.2 | Channel supports required modes | IMPORTANT | Written and oral reporting supported; in-person available on request (EU) |
| 2.3 | Channel is accessible to all reporters | IMPORTANT | Available to employees, contractors, and other protected persons; no access barriers |
| 2.4 | Anonymous reporting option available | IMPROVEMENT | Anonymous submissions accepted where legally permitted; system preserves anonymity |
| 2.5 | External reporting channel information provided | IMPORTANT | Information about external reporting to competent authorities is documented and accessible |

## Phase 3: Designated Persons

Assess the appointment and qualification of persons handling reports.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 3.1 | Designated person(s) appointed | CRITICAL | Named individual(s) or department formally designated for receiving and following up reports |
| 3.2 | Independence verified | CRITICAL | Designated person has no conflicts of interest; reports independently of management chain |
| 3.3 | Competence confirmed | IMPORTANT | Designated person has training in investigation procedures, confidentiality, and applicable law |
| 3.4 | Contact information published | IMPORTANT | Contact details accessible to all potential reporters via multiple channels |
| 3.5 | Backup person designated | IMPORTANT | Alternate designated person appointed for absence, conflict, or recusal scenarios |
| 3.6 | Mandate documented | IMPROVEMENT | Written mandate defining responsibilities, authority, and reporting line |
| 3.7 | Annual training completed | IMPROVEMENT | Designated person(s) complete annual refresher training with documented attendance |

## Phase 4: Verification and Processing

Evaluate investigation and follow-up procedures.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 4.1 | Acknowledgment within timeline | CRITICAL | EU: written acknowledgment within 7 calendar days; US/UK: prompt acknowledgment |
| 4.2 | Feedback within timeline | CRITICAL | EU: feedback within 3 months of acknowledgment; US/UK: reasonable timeframe |
| 4.3 | Triage process defined | IMPORTANT | Documented process for initial assessment, categorization, and routing of reports |
| 4.4 | Investigation procedure documented | IMPORTANT | Written procedure covering evidence gathering, interviews, analysis, and conclusion |
| 4.5 | Impartiality safeguards | IMPORTANT | Investigator has no connection to reported persons; conflict of interest checks in place |
| 4.6 | Case tracking system | IMPORTANT | Unique case identifiers, status tracking, audit trail for all actions taken |
| 4.7 | Outcome communication | IMPORTANT | Process for communicating investigation outcome to reporter without compromising confidentiality |
| 4.8 | Corrective action tracking | IMPROVEMENT | System for tracking implementation of corrective actions arising from investigations |

## Phase 5: Confidentiality

Assess measures protecting reporter identity and report contents.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 5.1 | Identity protection policy | CRITICAL | Written policy prohibiting disclosure of reporter identity without consent |
| 5.2 | Access restricted to designated persons | CRITICAL | Only designated person(s) and authorized investigators can access reporter identity |
| 5.3 | Secure communication channel | IMPORTANT | Reporting channel uses encrypted or secure communication; no unprotected email |
| 5.4 | Physical security of records | IMPORTANT | Paper records locked; digital records access-controlled and encrypted |
| 5.5 | Anonymization procedures | IMPORTANT | Process for anonymizing information shared beyond designated persons during investigation |
| 5.6 | Consent process for disclosure | IMPORTANT | Documented process for obtaining reporter consent before any identity disclosure |
| 5.7 | Breach notification procedure | IMPORTANT | Process for notifying reporter if confidentiality is compromised |
| 5.8 | Penalty for unauthorized disclosure | IMPORTANT | Disciplinary consequences defined for staff who breach confidentiality |
| 5.9 | Third-party confidentiality | IMPROVEMENT | Confidentiality obligations extend to external investigators, counsel, and auditors |

## Phase 6: Dissemination and Information

Evaluate awareness, training, and accessibility of whistleblower information.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 6.1 | Policy published and accessible | CRITICAL | Whistleblower policy available on intranet, website, or equivalent accessible location |
| 6.2 | All employees informed | CRITICAL | All current employees have received the policy and confirmation of receipt is documented |
| 6.3 | New employee onboarding | IMPORTANT | Whistleblower policy included in onboarding process; new hires briefed within first week |
| 6.4 | Contractor/vendor coverage | IMPORTANT | Policy and channel information communicated to contractors, suppliers, and partners |
| 6.5 | Regular awareness reminders | IMPORTANT | Periodic reminders (minimum annual) about reporting channels and protections |
| 6.6 | Training program | IMPORTANT | Formal training program covering policy, channels, protections, and procedures |
| 6.7 | Management training | IMPORTANT | Managers and supervisors receive specific training on handling disclosures and preventing retaliation |
| 6.8 | Multilingual availability | IMPROVEMENT | Policy available in all languages used by the workforce |
| 6.9 | Accessibility compliance | IMPROVEMENT | Policy and channels accessible to persons with disabilities |
| 6.10 | Reporting channel prominently displayed | IMPROVEMENT | Channel contact information displayed in common areas (physical and digital) |

## Phase 7: Data Protection and GDPR

Assess compliance with data protection requirements for whistleblower data.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 7.1 | Legal basis for processing documented | CRITICAL | Art. 6 GDPR legal basis identified and documented (typically legal obligation or public interest) |
| 7.2 | Data Protection Impact Assessment | CRITICAL | DPIA completed for whistleblower reporting and investigation processing activities |
| 7.3 | Privacy notice for reporters | IMPORTANT | Reporters informed of how their data will be processed, stored, and protected |
| 7.4 | Privacy notice for reported persons | IMPORTANT | Reported persons informed of data processing (without compromising investigation) |
| 7.5 | Data minimization | IMPORTANT | Only data necessary for assessment and investigation is collected and processed |
| 7.6 | Retention policy defined | IMPORTANT | Specific retention periods defined for reports, investigation files, and supporting documents |
| 7.7 | Deletion procedures | IMPORTANT | Process for secure deletion of data when retention period expires |
| 7.8 | Data subject rights procedures | IMPORTANT | Procedures for handling access, rectification, and erasure requests in whistleblower context |
| 7.9 | Cross-border transfer safeguards | IMPORTANT | Appropriate safeguards for transferring whistleblower data across borders (SCCs, adequacy decisions) |
| 7.10 | Processor agreements | IMPROVEMENT | Data processing agreements in place with external service providers handling whistleblower data |
| 7.11 | Data breach response | IMPROVEMENT | Specific procedures for responding to breaches of whistleblower data security |
| 7.12 | Records of processing activities | IMPROVEMENT | Whistleblower data processing included in Art. 30 GDPR records |

## Phase 8: Sector-Specific Requirements

Evaluate compliance with additional requirements for regulated sectors.

| # | Checkpoint | Priority | Pass Criteria |
|---|-----------|----------|---------------|
| 8.1 | Sector-specific regulations identified | IMPORTANT | All applicable sector-specific whistleblower/reporting requirements documented |
| 8.2 | Regulatory authority notification | IMPORTANT | Process for notifying sector regulator when required (e.g., FCA, nuclear safety authority) |
| 8.3 | Integration with existing reporting | IMPORTANT | Whistleblower channel integrated with (but separate from) existing mandatory reporting (AML, safety) |
| 8.4 | Sector-specific training | IMPROVEMENT | Training addresses sector-specific reporting obligations and distinctions |
| 8.5 | Regulatory examination readiness | IMPROVEMENT | Documentation and procedures ready for regulatory examination or audit |
| 8.6 | Industry benchmarking | IMPROVEMENT | Whistleblower system benchmarked against sector peers and regulatory expectations |

## Common Errors

| # | Error | Risk Level | Typical Consequence | Correction |
|---|-------|-----------|---------------------|------------|
| 1 | No reporting channel established | CRITICAL | Regulatory non-compliance; fines; inability to detect wrongdoing early | Implement internal reporting channel immediately; consult legal counsel |
| 2 | Designated person has conflict of interest | CRITICAL | Investigation compromised; reporter retaliation risk; legal challenge | Appoint independent designated person; implement conflict checks |
| 3 | Acknowledgment timeline exceeded | CRITICAL | Non-compliance with EU Directive (7-day requirement); regulatory scrutiny | Automate acknowledgment; set calendar alerts; designate backup |
| 4 | Reporter identity disclosed without consent | CRITICAL | Breach of confidentiality obligation; retaliation risk; legal liability | Implement strict access controls; train all personnel; disciplinary consequences |
| 5 | No GDPR compliance measures | CRITICAL | Data protection violation; regulatory fine up to 4% annual turnover | Complete DPIA; document legal basis; implement privacy notices |
| 6 | Policy not disseminated to all staff | IMPORTANT | Employees unaware of reporting options; reduced effectiveness | Include in onboarding; annual reminders; publish on intranet |
| 7 | No feedback provided to reporter | IMPORTANT | Reporter loses confidence; may escalate to external/public channels | Implement feedback tracking; set 3-month calendar reminders |
| 8 | Single jurisdiction approach for multinational | IMPORTANT | Non-compliance in other jurisdictions; inconsistent protections | Assess each jurisdiction separately; implement strictest-standard approach |
| 9 | Anonymous reports not accepted | IMPROVEMENT | Reduced reporting rates; reporters fear identification | Enable anonymous channel; consider third-party hotline provider |
| 10 | No periodic reassessment | IMPROVEMENT | System degrades over time; regulatory changes missed | Schedule annual reassessment; assign compliance owner |

## Assessment Scoring Guide

### Score Calculation

```
Phase Score = (Checkpoints Passed / Total Checkpoints in Phase) x 100
Overall Score = (Total Checkpoints Passed / Total Checkpoints) x 100
```

### Score Interpretation

| Overall Score | Rating | Interpretation |
|--------------|--------|----------------|
| 90-100% | Excellent | System meets or exceeds all requirements; minor improvements only |
| 75-89% | Good | System substantially compliant; some IMPORTANT gaps to address |
| 60-74% | Fair | System operational but significant gaps exist; prioritize CRITICAL items |
| 40-59% | Poor | Major compliance gaps; immediate remediation required |
| 0-39% | Non-Compliant | System inadequate or non-existent; urgent action needed |

### Remediation Priority Matrix

| Gap Priority | Score Impact | Remediation Timeline | Escalation Level |
|-------------|-------------|---------------------|------------------|
| CRITICAL | High (blocks compliance) | Within 30 days | Board/executive management |
| IMPORTANT | Medium (reduces effectiveness) | Within 90 days | Compliance committee |
| IMPROVEMENT | Low (enhancement) | Next annual review | Compliance officer |

### Reassessment Schedule

| Trigger | Action |
|---------|--------|
| Initial assessment complete | Schedule 6-month follow-up assessment |
| CRITICAL gaps identified | Reassess specific phases within 30 days of remediation |
| Annual cycle | Full 8-phase reassessment annually |
| Regulatory change | Targeted reassessment of affected phases within 60 days |
| Organizational change (merger, restructure) | Full reassessment within 90 days |
| Whistleblower incident | Post-incident review of relevant phases within 30 days |
rea-analysis-optimizationmorluto/reaOptimize REA providers and shared analysis workflows for agent context, latency, CPU, and memory while preserving correctness and Evidence. Use for analysis bottlenecks and cache or query design; CI/test-suite optimization belongs to rea-ci-tests-audit.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
rea-ci-tests-auditmorluto/reaAudit REA CI and test suites for correctness, fixture drift, false passes, and measured performance; use for suite or workflow investigations and efficiency changes, rather than ordinary feature testing or a single test failure.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
rea-tool-designmorluto/reaAudit, investigate, design, or change REA investigation tools, CLI/MCP contracts, provider capabilities, and Evidence semantics.Stars: 472kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
ponytail-auditDietrichGebert/ponytailQuality audit of the whole repo: bugs, security, real load, missing tests, speed, and what to delete. Most important first.Stars: 194kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall