Skip to content

borghei/Claude-Skills / legal/tech-contract-negotiation

tech-contract-negotiation

Verified

Negotiation frameworks for technology services agreements, B2B contracts, and professional services deals. Use when reviewing or negotiating tech contracts.

references/three_position_framework.md

View on GitHub
# Three-Position Framework for Technology Contract Negotiation

Complete position reference for 5 major provisions with exact language examples for Provider-Favorable, Balanced, and Client-Favorable positions, plus position selection matrix and deal-size tactics.

## Table of Contents

- [Position Framework Overview](#position-framework-overview)
- [1. Liability and Indemnification](#1-liability-and-indemnification)
- [2. Intellectual Property](#2-intellectual-property)
- [3. Payment Terms](#3-payment-terms)
- [4. Service Level Agreements](#4-service-level-agreements)
- [5. Warranties](#5-warranties)
- [Position Selection Matrix](#position-selection-matrix)
- [Deal-Size Tactics](#deal-size-tactics)

## Position Framework Overview

Every major contract provision exists on a spectrum from provider-favorable to client-favorable. Effective negotiation requires knowing all three positions, understanding where the current draft falls, and having a target position justified by deal context.

| Position | Description | When to Target |
|----------|-------------|----------------|
| Provider-Favorable | Maximum risk transfer to client, minimum provider obligation | Provider has dominant leverage; commodity service; client is price-sensitive |
| Balanced | Fair allocation of risk and obligation; industry standard | Most negotiations; neither party has dominant leverage; long-term relationship |
| Client-Favorable | Maximum provider obligation and client protection | Client has dominant leverage; mission-critical service; regulated industry |

## 1. Liability and Indemnification

### Provider-Favorable Position

**Liability Cap:** Total liability capped at fees paid in the 12 months preceding the claim.

> "Provider's aggregate liability under this Agreement shall not exceed the total fees paid by Client in the twelve (12) months immediately preceding the event giving rise to the claim."

**Consequential Damages:** Full exclusion of indirect, consequential, special, and incidental damages.

> "In no event shall Provider be liable for any indirect, incidental, special, consequential, or punitive damages, including but not limited to loss of profits, data, business opportunity, or goodwill."

**Indemnification:** Client indemnifies provider for client's misuse; no provider indemnification beyond IP infringement.

| Element | Provider-Favorable |
|---------|-------------------|
| Cap | 12 months fees paid |
| Consequential | Fully excluded |
| Indemnification | Mutual for IP only; client indemnifies for misuse |
| Carve-outs | None |
| Insurance | Not required |

### Balanced Position

**Liability Cap:** Total liability capped at fees paid in the 24 months preceding the claim, with a super-cap for specific claims (data breach, IP infringement, confidentiality).

> "Provider's aggregate liability shall not exceed the total fees paid in the twenty-four (24) months preceding the claim. For Excluded Claims (data breach, IP infringement, breach of confidentiality), liability shall not exceed two (2) times the general cap."

**Consequential Damages:** Mutual exclusion with carve-outs for willful misconduct, data breach, and confidentiality breach.

| Element | Balanced |
|---------|---------|
| Cap | 24 months fees paid |
| Consequential | Mutually excluded with carve-outs |
| Indemnification | Mutual: Provider for IP, data breach; Client for misuse |
| Carve-outs | Willful misconduct, data breach, confidentiality |
| Insurance | Commercially reasonable levels required |

### Client-Favorable Position

**Liability Cap:** Annual contract value as general cap; unlimited liability for data breach, IP infringement, willful misconduct, and confidentiality breach.

> "Provider's aggregate liability shall not exceed the total annual fees payable under this Agreement. The foregoing cap shall not apply to: (a) Provider's indemnification obligations; (b) breach of data protection obligations; (c) IP infringement; (d) breach of confidentiality; or (e) willful misconduct or gross negligence."

| Element | Client-Favorable |
|---------|-----------------|
| Cap | Annual contract value (general); unlimited for specified claims |
| Consequential | Recoverable for specified claims |
| Indemnification | Broad provider indemnification including data breach, regulatory fines |
| Carve-outs | Extensive: data breach, IP, confidentiality, willful misconduct, regulatory |
| Insurance | Specific minimum coverage amounts required |

## 2. Intellectual Property

### Provider-Favorable Position

Provider retains all IP, including all deliverables and customizations. Client receives a non-exclusive, non-transferable, limited license.

> "All intellectual property rights in the Services, Deliverables, and any modifications, enhancements, or derivative works thereof shall vest in and remain the exclusive property of Provider. Client is granted a non-exclusive, non-transferable, non-sublicensable license to use the Deliverables solely for Client's internal business purposes during the Term."

| Element | Provider-Favorable |
|---------|-------------------|
| Ownership | Provider owns all IP including custom deliverables |
| License | Non-exclusive, non-transferable, term-limited |
| Background IP | Provider retains; no license to client |
| Foreground IP | Provider owns |
| Source code | Not provided; no escrow |

### Balanced Position

Provider retains background IP and platform IP. Client owns bespoke deliverables. Mutual license-back arrangement.

> "Background IP shall remain the property of the originating party. Foreground IP developed specifically for Client ('Bespoke Deliverables') shall be owned by Client. Provider is granted a non-exclusive, royalty-free license to use Bespoke Deliverables for general product improvement, excluding Client's confidential business logic."

| Element | Balanced |
|---------|---------|
| Ownership | Split: background IP to originator; bespoke to client |
| License | Perpetual license to client for platform components; license-back to provider |
| Background IP | Each party retains own; cross-license for integration |
| Foreground IP | Client owns bespoke; provider owns general improvements |
| Source code | Escrow arrangement for critical components |

### Client-Favorable Position

Client owns all deliverables, customizations, and foreground IP. Work-for-hire designation where applicable.

> "All Deliverables, including any modifications, customizations, configurations, and derivative works, shall be considered works made for hire and shall be the exclusive property of Client. To the extent any Deliverable does not qualify as work for hire, Provider hereby irrevocably assigns all rights, title, and interest to Client."

| Element | Client-Favorable |
|---------|-----------------|
| Ownership | Client owns all foreground IP; work-for-hire |
| License | Perpetual, irrevocable, exclusive for deliverables |
| Background IP | Provider retains but grants perpetual, irrevocable license to client |
| Foreground IP | Client owns exclusively |
| Source code | Full source code delivery with documentation |

## 3. Payment Terms

### Provider-Favorable Position

| Element | Provider-Favorable |
|---------|-------------------|
| Payment timing | Net 15 or payment in advance |
| Invoicing | Annual upfront or quarterly in advance |
| Price escalation | Annual CPI + 3-5% increase, automatic |
| Late payment | 1.5% per month interest + suspension right after 15 days |
| Withholding | No right to withhold; dispute after payment |
| MFN | Not offered |
| Early termination | Full remaining contract value due |

### Balanced Position

| Element | Balanced |
|---------|---------|
| Payment timing | Net 30 |
| Invoicing | Quarterly in arrears or milestone-based |
| Price escalation | Annual CPI cap (max 5%), with 90-day notice |
| Late payment | Statutory interest rate; suspension after 30 days written notice |
| Withholding | Right to withhold disputed amounts in good faith |
| MFN | Not typically included |
| Early termination | Pro-rated fees for services rendered + reasonable wind-down costs |

### Client-Favorable Position

| Element | Client-Favorable |
|---------|-----------------|
| Payment timing | Net 60 or Net 90 |
| Invoicing | Monthly in arrears; milestone-based for projects |
| Price escalation | Fixed pricing for initial term; any increase capped at CPI (max 3%) |
| Late payment | No interest for first 30 days past due; statutory rate thereafter |
| Withholding | Broad right to withhold, offset, and set-off |
| MFN | Most-favored-customer pricing clause |
| Early termination | Termination for convenience with 30-60 days notice; pay only for delivered services |

## 4. Service Level Agreements

### Provider-Favorable Position

| Element | Provider-Favorable |
|---------|-------------------|
| Uptime | 99.5% monthly availability |
| Measurement | Provider-measured; excludes scheduled maintenance, force majeure, client-caused |
| Credits | Service credits up to 5% of monthly fees; sole and exclusive remedy |
| Response time | Best efforts; no guaranteed response SLAs |
| Reporting | Quarterly availability reports |
| Termination trigger | None |

### Balanced Position

| Element | Balanced |
|---------|---------|
| Uptime | 99.9% monthly availability |
| Measurement | Third-party monitoring acceptable; excludes scheduled maintenance with notice |
| Credits | Service credits up to 15% of monthly fees; escalating by severity |
| Response time | P1: 1 hour response, 4 hour resolution target; P2: 4 hour response |
| Reporting | Monthly SLA performance reports with root cause analysis for failures |
| Termination trigger | Right to terminate if SLA missed for 3 consecutive months |

### Client-Favorable Position

| Element | Client-Favorable |
|---------|-----------------|
| Uptime | 99.99% monthly availability |
| Measurement | Client-selected third-party monitoring; minimal exclusions |
| Credits | Service credits up to 100% of monthly fees; not sole remedy |
| Response time | P1: 15 min response, 1 hour resolution; P2: 1 hour response, 4 hour resolution |
| Reporting | Real-time dashboard + weekly reports + root cause analysis within 24 hours |
| Termination trigger | Right to terminate for any month below 99.5% or 2 months below 99.9% |

## 5. Warranties

### Provider-Favorable Position

| Element | Provider-Favorable |
|---------|-------------------|
| Scope | Services provided "as is" with limited conformity warranty |
| Duration | 90 days from delivery |
| Remedy | Re-performance only; if re-performance fails, refund pro-rata fees |
| Disclaimers | Full disclaimer of merchantability, fitness for purpose, non-infringement |
| Performance | No performance warranties beyond uptime SLA |

### Balanced Position

| Element | Balanced |
|---------|---------|
| Scope | Services conform to specifications and documentation |
| Duration | 12 months from acceptance |
| Remedy | Re-performance at no cost; if re-performance fails twice, refund + termination right |
| Disclaimers | Standard disclaimer of implied warranties except as expressly stated |
| Performance | Warranty that services meet agreed performance benchmarks |

### Client-Favorable Position

| Element | Client-Favorable |
|---------|-----------------|
| Scope | Services conform to specs, industry standards, and fitness for stated purpose |
| Duration | 24 months from acceptance; perpetual for latent defects |
| Remedy | Re-performance + damages; client may engage third party at provider's cost |
| Disclaimers | Limited disclaimer; express warranties of merchantability and fitness |
| Performance | Full performance warranty with measurable benchmarks and liquidated damages |

## Position Selection Matrix

Select your target position based on these 7 leverage factors:

| Leverage Factor | Provider Position | Balanced | Client Position |
|----------------|-------------------|----------|-----------------|
| Deal value relative to provider revenue | < 0.5% | 0.5% - 2% | > 2% |
| Competitive alternatives available | Few/none | Some | Many |
| Service criticality to client | Low | Moderate | Mission-critical |
| Regulatory requirements | None | Standard | Extensive |
| Client brand/reference value | Low | Moderate | High |
| Switching costs for client | Low | Moderate | High (lock-in) |
| Market demand for provider's service | High demand | Balanced | Oversupply |

**Scoring:** Count factors favoring each position. Majority determines your starting position. Adjust based on relationship strategy (long-term partnership vs. transactional).

## Deal-Size Tactics

### Tier 1: Standard ($100K - $500K)

| Parameter | Guideline |
|-----------|-----------|
| Timeline | 2-4 weeks |
| Rounds | 1-2 |
| Focus | Payment terms, basic SLA, standard warranties |
| Approach | Use provider's template with targeted redlines; limit to top 5 issues |
| Approval | Department head sign-off |
| IP | Standard license terms acceptable |
| Liability | 12-month fee cap generally acceptable |

### Tier 2: Enhanced ($500K - $1M)

| Parameter | Guideline |
|-----------|-----------|
| Timeline | 4-6 weeks |
| Rounds | 2-3 |
| Focus | Liability caps, IP provisions, SLA customization, data protection |
| Approach | Start from balanced position; negotiate liability and IP first |
| Approval | VP or Director level |
| IP | Negotiate bespoke deliverable ownership |
| Liability | Push for 24-month cap with data breach carve-out |

### Tier 3: Complex ($1M - $3M)

| Parameter | Guideline |
|-----------|-----------|
| Timeline | 6-10 weeks |
| Rounds | 3-5 |
| Focus | Full liability framework, IP ownership, custom SLAs, regulatory compliance, indemnification |
| Approach | Use client template or heavily marked-up provider template; full legal review |
| Approval | SVP or General Counsel |
| IP | Full foreground IP ownership with license-back |
| Liability | Super-cap structure with extensive carve-outs |

### Tier 4: Strategic ($3M - $10M)

| Parameter | Guideline |
|-----------|-----------|
| Timeline | 10-16 weeks |
| Rounds | 5-8 |
| Focus | Enterprise liability, complex IP, multi-year SLAs, full regulatory suite, governance |
| Approach | Client template; dedicated deal team; external counsel review |
| Approval | C-Suite or Board committee |
| IP | Joint development framework with clear allocation |
| Liability | Uncapped for specified claims; insurance requirements |

### Tier 5: Transformational ($10M+)

| Parameter | Guideline |
|-----------|-----------|
| Timeline | 16-26 weeks |
| Rounds | 8-12 |
| Focus | Bespoke everything; joint governance; exit planning; audit rights |
| Approach | Fully bespoke agreement; multiple workstreams; executive sponsorship |
| Approval | Board approval required |
| IP | Co-development IP framework with reversion rights |
| Liability | Bespoke structure with insurance backstop |
receiving-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when receiving code review feedback, before implementing suggestions, especially if feedback seems unclear or technically questionable - requires technical rigor and verification, not performative agreement or blind implementationStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
requesting-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when completing tasks, implementing major features, or before merging to verify work meets requirementsStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
using-git-worktreesobra/superpowersUse when starting feature work that needs isolation from current workspace or before executing implementation plans - ensures an isolated workspace exists via native tools or git worktree fallbackStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
verification-before-completionobra/superpowersUse when about to claim work is complete, fixed, or passing, before committing or creating PRs - requires running verification commands and confirming output before making any success claims; evidence before assertions alwaysStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall