Skip to content

borghei/Claude-Skills / legal/privacy-compliance

privacy-compliance

Verified

Multi-regulation privacy compliance navigator. Use for GDPR, CCPA, LGPD, POPIA, PIPEDA, PDPA, Privacy Act, PIPL, UK GDPR compliance assessments, DPA reviews, and data subject request management.

references/global_privacy_regulations.md

View on GitHub
# Global Privacy Regulations Comparison

Comprehensive comparison of 9 major privacy regulations for multi-jurisdictional compliance planning.

---

## Table of Contents

- [Regulation Overview](#regulation-overview)
- [Territorial Scope](#territorial-scope)
- [Legal Bases for Processing](#legal-bases-for-processing)
- [Data Subject Rights Comparison](#data-subject-rights-comparison)
- [Breach Notification Requirements](#breach-notification-requirements)
- [Cross-Border Transfer Mechanisms](#cross-border-transfer-mechanisms)
- [DPO Requirements](#dpo-requirements)
- [Penalty Structures](#penalty-structures)
- [Cross-Regulation Comparison Matrix](#cross-regulation-comparison-matrix)
- [Enforcement Trends](#enforcement-trends)

---

## Regulation Overview

| Regulation | Jurisdiction | Effective Date | Supervising Authority | Key Legislation |
|-----------|-------------|---------------|----------------------|-----------------|
| GDPR | EU/EEA | 25 May 2018 | National DPAs (lead SA mechanism) | Regulation (EU) 2016/679 |
| CCPA/CPRA | California, USA | 1 Jan 2020 / 1 Jan 2023 | CPPA (California Privacy Protection Agency) | Cal. Civ. Code §1798.100-199.100 |
| LGPD | Brazil | 18 Sep 2020 | ANPD (Autoridade Nacional de Proteção de Dados) | Law 13,709/2018 |
| POPIA | South Africa | 1 Jul 2021 | Information Regulator | Act 4 of 2013 |
| PIPEDA | Canada (federal) | 1 Jan 2001 | OPC (Office of the Privacy Commissioner) | S.C. 2000, c. 5 |
| PDPA | Singapore | 2 Jul 2014 | PDPC (Personal Data Protection Commission) | Act 26 of 2012 |
| Privacy Act | Australia | 12 Mar 1988 (amended 2024) | OAIC (Office of the Australian Information Commissioner) | Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) |
| PIPL | China | 1 Nov 2021 | CAC (Cyberspace Administration of China) | Personal Information Protection Law |
| UK GDPR | United Kingdom | 1 Jan 2021 | ICO (Information Commissioner's Office) | UK GDPR + Data Protection Act 2018 |

---

## Territorial Scope

| Regulation | Applies To | Extraterritorial Reach | Representative Required |
|-----------|-----------|----------------------|------------------------|
| GDPR | Controllers/processors established in EU; or offering goods/services to EU residents; or monitoring EU resident behavior | Yes — applies regardless of establishment location if targeting EU residents | Art. 27 representative if no EU establishment |
| CCPA/CPRA | For-profit businesses meeting thresholds: >$25M revenue, >100K consumers/households, or >50% revenue from selling PI | Yes — any business meeting thresholds with CA consumers | No representative requirement |
| LGPD | Any processing of data collected in Brazil, of individuals in Brazil, or for offering goods/services in Brazil | Yes — broad extraterritorial scope similar to GDPR | Legal representative required if no BR establishment |
| POPIA | Processing of PI of data subjects in South Africa by responsible parties (controllers) | Limited — focuses on processing within SA | Information officer must be registered |
| PIPEDA | Commercial activities in Canada; federal works/undertakings; personal information crossing provincial borders | Limited extraterritorial — primarily territorial | Privacy officer designation required |
| PDPA | Organizations collecting, using, or disclosing personal data in Singapore | Yes — for organizations not in SG if they process SG residents' data | DPO designation required |
| Privacy Act | Organizations with >AUD 3M turnover; health service providers; some government agencies | Yes — for acts/practices with Australian link | No representative requirement |
| PIPL | Processing PI of individuals within China; or processing PI outside China for providing products/services to, or analyzing behavior of, individuals in China | Yes — broad extraterritorial scope | Designated representative or local entity required |
| UK GDPR | Controllers/processors established in UK; or offering goods/services to UK residents; or monitoring UK resident behavior | Yes — mirrors GDPR extraterritorial reach | UK representative required if no UK establishment |

---

## Legal Bases for Processing

| Regulation | Consent | Contract | Legal Obligation | Legitimate Interests | Other Bases |
|-----------|---------|----------|-----------------|---------------------|-------------|
| GDPR | Art. 6(1)(a) — freely given, specific, informed, unambiguous | Art. 6(1)(b) — necessary for contract performance | Art. 6(1)(c) — compliance with legal obligation | Art. 6(1)(f) — subject to balancing test | Vital interests Art. 6(1)(d); Public task Art. 6(1)(e) |
| CCPA/CPRA | Not a legal basis model — opt-out regime | N/A | N/A | N/A | Notice at collection; opt-out of sale/sharing |
| LGPD | Art. 7(I) — specific, informed consent | Art. 7(V) — contract execution | Art. 7(II) — legal or regulatory obligation | Art. 7(IX) — legitimate interests with balancing | 10 legal bases total including credit protection, research, health |
| POPIA | §11 — voluntary, specific, informed consent | §11(1)(b) — contractual necessity | §11(1)(c) — legal obligation | §11(1)(f) — legitimate interests | Public law duty §11(1)(d); Vital interests §11(1)(e) |
| PIPEDA | Principle 3 — meaningful consent (express or implied) | Implied consent for reasonable commercial activity | N/A — uses consent framework | Legitimate business interests (limited) | Publicly available information exemption |
| PDPA | §13-17 — consent required unless exception applies | Contractual necessity | Legal obligation exception | §25A — legitimate interests (since 2021 amendment) | Business improvement, research, publicly available |
| Privacy Act | APP 3 — consent for collection of sensitive information | Reasonable expectation in context | Required or authorized by law | N/A — no explicit legitimate interests basis | Direct marketing subject to opt-out (APP 7) |
| PIPL | Art. 13(1) — separate consent for sensitive data and cross-border | Art. 13(2) — contract necessity | Art. 13(3) — legal duties/obligations | N/A — no legitimate interests basis | Statutory duties, public health, public interest, news reporting |
| UK GDPR | Art. 6(1)(a) — same as EU GDPR | Art. 6(1)(b) | Art. 6(1)(c) — UK law | Art. 6(1)(f) — subject to balancing test | Same as EU GDPR |

---

## Data Subject Rights Comparison

| Right | GDPR | CCPA/CPRA | LGPD | POPIA | PIPEDA | PDPA | Privacy Act (AU) | PIPL | UK GDPR |
|-------|------|-----------|------|-------|--------|------|-----------------|------|---------|
| Access | Art. 15 | §1798.100 | Art. 18(II) | §23 | Principle 9 | §21 | APP 12 | Art. 44 | Art. 15 |
| Deletion/Erasure | Art. 17 | §1798.105 | Art. 18(VI) | §24 | Limited | §26H | 2024 amendment | Art. 47 | Art. 17 |
| Correction | Art. 16 | §1798.106 | Art. 18(III) | §24 | Principle 9.5 | §22 | APP 13 | Art. 46 | Art. 16 |
| Portability | Art. 20 | §1798.130 | Art. 18(V) | No | No | §26F | No | Art. 45 | Art. 20 |
| Restriction | Art. 18 | No | Art. 18(IV) | No | No | No | No | Art. 44 | Art. 18 |
| Objection | Art. 21 | §1798.120 (opt-out) | Art. 18(IV) | §11(3) | Consent withdrawal | §16 (withdrawal) | No | No | Art. 21 |
| Automated decisions | Art. 22 | §1798.185 | Art. 20 | §71 | Limited | No | No | Art. 24 | Art. 22 |
| Withdraw consent | Art. 7(3) | N/A | Art. 18(IX) | §11(2)(b) | Principle 3 | §16 | N/A | Art. 15 | Art. 7(3) |
| Opt-out of sale | N/A | §1798.120 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Limit sensitive use | N/A | §1798.121 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Non-discrimination | Implicit | §1798.125 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | Implicit |

---

## Breach Notification Requirements

| Regulation | Notify Authority | Timeline (Authority) | Notify Individuals | Timeline (Individuals) | Content Requirements |
|-----------|-----------------|---------------------|-------------------|----------------------|---------------------|
| GDPR | Yes — lead supervisory authority | 72 hours | Yes — if high risk to rights | Without undue delay | Nature, DPO contact, consequences, measures |
| CCPA/CPRA | California AG (>500 residents) | Most expedient time possible | Yes | Most expedient time possible | Description, types of PI, remediation steps |
| LGPD | Yes — ANPD | Reasonable timeframe (ANPD guidance says 2 business days) | Yes — if significant risk | Reasonable timeframe | Description, data types, risks, measures, recommendations |
| POPIA | Yes — Information Regulator | As soon as reasonably possible | Yes — if reasonable grounds | As soon as reasonably possible | Description, PI involved, identity of unauthorized person (if known) |
| PIPEDA | Yes — OPC | As soon as feasible | Yes — if real risk of significant harm | As soon as feasible | Description, date, PI involved, measures, complaint contact |
| PDPA | Yes — PDPC | 3 calendar days | Yes — if significant harm likely | As soon as practicable | Facts, PI affected, what organization is doing |
| Privacy Act (AU) | Yes — OAIC | Within 30 days of awareness (eligible breach) | Yes — if eligible data breach | As soon as practicable after assessment | Description, kind of information, recommendations |
| PIPL | Yes — CAC/relevant department | Promptly (no specific hour count) | Yes | Promptly | Causes, PI types, remedial measures, individual mitigation steps |
| UK GDPR | Yes — ICO | 72 hours | Yes — if high risk | Without undue delay | Same as GDPR |

---

## Cross-Border Transfer Mechanisms

| Regulation | Adequacy Decisions | Standard Contractual Clauses | Binding Corporate Rules | Other Mechanisms |
|-----------|-------------------|------------------------------|------------------------|-----------------|
| GDPR | EU Commission adequacy (14 countries + US via DPF) | EU SCCs (June 2021) — 4 modules | BCRs approved by lead SA | Derogations Art. 49 (limited), codes of conduct, certification |
| CCPA/CPRA | N/A — no transfer restriction model | Service provider agreements required | N/A | Due diligence on service providers |
| LGPD | ANPD adequacy decisions (limited) | ANPD-approved SCCs | BCRs | Specific consent, international cooperation, ANPD authorization |
| POPIA | Not yet issued | Binding agreements required | BCRs | SA Information Regulator approval, consent |
| PIPEDA | No formal adequacy | Contractual protections with comparable safeguards | N/A | Accountability model — transferor remains responsible |
| PDPA | No formal adequacy | Contractual obligations to equivalent standard | BCRs | Consent, necessity, publicly available |
| Privacy Act (AU) | No formal adequacy | APP 8 — reasonable steps for compliance | N/A | Binding contract, consent, required by law |
| PIPL | CAC security assessment (mandatory for CII and >1M records) | Standard contract filed with CAC | Certification by accredited institution | Security assessment, separate consent |
| UK GDPR | UK adequacy regulations (limited list) | EU SCCs + UK Addendum OR UK IDTA | UK BCRs | Derogations, codes of conduct |

---

## DPO Requirements

| Regulation | DPO Required | When Required | Qualifications | Registration |
|-----------|-------------|--------------|----------------|-------------|
| GDPR | Yes (Art. 37) | Public authority; core activities require monitoring; large-scale special category processing | Expert knowledge of data protection law and practices | Communicated to supervisory authority |
| CCPA/CPRA | No | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| LGPD | Yes (Art. 41) | All controllers — called "Encarregado" | No formal qualification requirement (ANPD guidance) | Published on website |
| POPIA | Yes | All responsible parties — called "Information Officer" | No formal requirement | Registered with Information Regulator |
| PIPEDA | Yes | All organizations — called "Privacy Officer" | Designated individual | N/A |
| PDPA | Yes | All organizations | No formal requirement | N/A |
| Privacy Act (AU) | No (recommended) | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| PIPL | Yes (Art. 52) | Processing above threshold (>1M individuals) | No formal requirement | Published and filed with CAC |
| UK GDPR | Yes (mirrors GDPR Art. 37) | Same triggers as GDPR | Expert knowledge | Communicated to ICO |

---

## Penalty Structures

| Regulation | Maximum Fine | Calculation Method | Notable Fines (2024-2026) |
|-----------|-------------|-------------------|--------------------------|
| GDPR | EUR 20M or 4% global annual turnover (whichever greater) | Severity, duration, negligence, cooperation, categories of data | Meta EUR 1.2B (2023 transfers); Amazon EUR 746M (targeting); TikTok EUR 345M (children) |
| CCPA/CPRA | $2,500 per unintentional / $7,500 per intentional violation | Per-violation basis; private right of action for breaches ($100-$750 per consumer per incident) | Sephora $1.2M (2022); ongoing enforcement actions |
| LGPD | 2% of revenue in Brazil, max BRL 50M per violation | Severity, good faith, cooperation, economic condition | Active enforcement since 2023 |
| POPIA | ZAR 10M fine or imprisonment up to 10 years | Severity and nature of infringement | Enforcement ramping up since 2022 |
| PIPEDA | CAD 100,000 per violation (PIPEDA); up to CAD 25M under Bill C-27 if enacted | Findings model; penalties under newer amendments | Recommendations model transitioning to penalties |
| PDPA | SGD 1M or 10% annual turnover (whichever greater) — since 2022 amendment | Severity, turnover, cooperation | SingHealth SGD 250,000 (2019); Grab SGD 10,000 (2021) |
| Privacy Act (AU) | AUD 50M, 30% adjusted turnover, or 3x benefit (whichever greatest) — since 2022 amendment | Severity, previous conduct, turnover | Medibank (pending); Optus (pending) |
| PIPL | CNY 50M or 5% annual revenue; personal liability for responsible persons | Severity, duration, illegal gains | Didi Global (2022 — combined cyber/data violation); ride-hailing apps |
| UK GDPR | GBP 17.5M or 4% global annual turnover | Mirrors GDPR methodology | Clearview AI GBP 7.5M (2022); TikTok GBP 12.7M (2023 children) |

---

## Cross-Regulation Comparison Matrix

| Dimension | GDPR | CCPA/CPRA | LGPD | POPIA | PIPEDA | PDPA | Privacy Act | PIPL | UK GDPR |
|-----------|------|-----------|------|-------|--------|------|-------------|------|---------|
| **Model** | Rights-based | Consumer protection | Rights-based | Rights-based | Fair info principles | Consent-based | Principles-based | State control | Rights-based |
| **Default consent** | Opt-in | Opt-out | Opt-in | Opt-in | Opt-in | Opt-in | Opt-in (sensitive) | Opt-in | Opt-in |
| **Sensitive data extra protection** | Art. 9 | §1798.121 | Art. 11 | §26-33 | Principle 4.3.4 | Limited | APP 3.3 | Art. 28-32 | Art. 9 |
| **Data localization** | No (transfer controls) | No | No (transfer controls) | No (transfer controls) | No (accountability) | No | No | Yes (CII) | No (transfer controls) |
| **Private right of action** | Varies by member state | Yes (data breaches) | Yes (Art. 42) | No | No (complaint to OPC) | No | No | Yes (Art. 69-70) | Yes (limited) |
| **Maturity** | High | Medium-high | Medium | Medium-low | High | Medium | Medium-high | Medium | High |

---

## Enforcement Trends

### 2024-2026 Key Trends

| Trend | Affected Regulations | Impact |
|-------|---------------------|--------|
| AI and automated processing scrutiny | GDPR, PIPL, CCPA/CPRA, UK GDPR | Increased enforcement of Art. 22 equivalent; DPIA requirements for AI; transparency obligations |
| Children's data enforcement | GDPR, CCPA/CPRA, UK GDPR, PIPL | Age verification mandates; design codes; higher penalties |
| Cross-border transfer enforcement | GDPR, PIPL, UK GDPR | Post-Schrems II TIA requirements; PIPL security assessments; UK IDTA adoption |
| Cookie and tracking enforcement | GDPR, CCPA/CPRA | Cookie banner enforcement; GPC signal requirements; ePrivacy convergence |
| Employee monitoring | GDPR, LGPD, POPIA | Remote work surveillance limits; proportionality requirements; works council notification |
| Dark patterns crackdown | GDPR, CCPA/CPRA | Deceptive consent interfaces; manipulative design; hidden opt-outs |
| Data broker regulation | CCPA/CPRA, GDPR | Delete Act (CA); registration requirements; enhanced opt-out |

### Upcoming Regulatory Changes

| Change | Jurisdiction | Expected Timeline | Impact |
|--------|-------------|-------------------|--------|
| ePrivacy Regulation | EU | Ongoing negotiations | Cookie consent harmonization; electronic communications |
| Bill C-27 (CPPA) | Canada | Under consideration | Replaces PIPEDA; higher penalties; new rights |
| Privacy Act reform | Australia | 2025-2026 | Right to erasure; children's code; direct right of action |
| ADPPA (federal privacy) | USA | Uncertain | Would preempt state laws; national baseline |
| UK Data Protection Bill | UK | 2025-2026 | Reforms to UK GDPR; legitimate interests expansion |

---

## Practical Compliance Strategy

### Unified Program Approach

Build compliance to the strictest standard (typically GDPR) as baseline, then layer jurisdiction-specific requirements:

| Baseline (GDPR) | Layer for CCPA/CPRA | Layer for PIPL | Layer for LGPD |
|-----------------|--------------------|--------------------|----------------|
| Lawful basis documented | Add "Do Not Sell/Share" link | Add data localization assessment | Appoint Encarregado |
| Privacy notice Art. 13/14 | Add annual metrics disclosure | Add CAC security assessment for cross-border | Add 10 legal bases mapping |
| DSR process (30 days) | Add 10-business-day acknowledgment | Adjust to 15-day timeline | Adjust to 15-day timeline |
| Breach process (72 hours) | Add CA AG notification for >500 | Add CAC notification | Add ANPD 2-business-day notification |
| DPO appointed | N/A (not required) | File with CAC if >1M records | Publish on website |
| DPIA for high risk | Add CPRA risk assessments | Add PI impact assessment (Art. 55) | Add privacy impact assessment (Art. 38) |
| SCCs for transfers | Service provider agreements | CAC security assessment or standard contract | ANPD-approved mechanisms |
receiving-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when receiving code review feedback, before implementing suggestions, especially if feedback seems unclear or technically questionable - requires technical rigor and verification, not performative agreement or blind implementationStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
requesting-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when completing tasks, implementing major features, or before merging to verify work meets requirementsStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
using-git-worktreesobra/superpowersUse when starting feature work that needs isolation from current workspace or before executing implementation plans - ensures an isolated workspace exists via native tools or git worktree fallbackStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
verification-before-completionobra/superpowersUse when about to claim work is complete, fixed, or passing, before committing or creating PRs - requires running verification commands and confirming output before making any success claims; evidence before assertions alwaysStars: 323kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall