Skip to content

borghei/Claude-Skills / legal/nda-review

nda-review

Verified

Deep clause-by-clause NDA review from Recipient or Discloser perspective. Produces issue log with redlines, fallbacks, rationales, owners, deadlines. Use when reviewing NDAs for negotiation or approval.

references/nda_clause_reference.md

View on GitHub
# NDA Clause Reference

Deep reference for clause-by-clause NDA analysis. Organized into five modules covering duration and scope, key clauses, party obligations, remedies and liability, and standard exceptions.

---

## Table of Contents

- [Module 1: Duration and Scope](#module-1-duration-and-scope)
- [Module 2: Key Clauses](#module-2-key-clauses)
- [Module 3: Party Obligations](#module-3-party-obligations)
- [Module 4: Remedies and Liability](#module-4-remedies-and-liability)
- [Module 5: Standard Exceptions](#module-5-standard-exceptions)
- [Cross-Module Analysis Framework](#cross-module-analysis-framework)

---

## Module 1: Duration and Scope

### Term of Agreement

| Element | Description | Analysis Points |
|---------|-------------|-----------------|
| Initial Term | Duration of the NDA from effective date | Standard: 2-5 years; flag if >7 years or perpetual |
| Renewal | Whether and how the NDA renews | Auto-renewal acceptable with opt-out; mutual written renewal preferred |
| Effective Date | When obligations begin | Should be clearly stated; "date of last signature" is common |
| Termination Right | How parties can end the agreement | Convenience termination with 30-60 day notice is standard |

### Survival Period

The survival period determines how long confidentiality obligations continue after the NDA terminates or expires.

| Survival Duration | Appropriateness | Context |
|-------------------|-----------------|---------|
| 1 year | Minimum acceptable | Low-sensitivity, short-term projects |
| 2-3 years | Market standard | Most commercial relationships |
| 3-5 years | Strong protection | Sensitive technology, strategic plans |
| 5+ years | Unusual | Trade secrets, national security |
| Perpetual | RED flag unless limited to trade secrets | Only acceptable with trade secret carveout |

### Scope Limitations

| Scope Element | What to Check | Red Flag |
|---------------|---------------|----------|
| Subject Matter | Is the NDA limited to a specific purpose or project? | "Any and all business purposes" -- no limitation |
| Geographic | Any geographic limitations on obligations? | Unusual in NDAs; flag if present |
| Information Types | Are specific categories of information identified? | No categories listed -- everything is confidential |
| Temporal | Does the NDA apply to past disclosures? | Retroactive application without clear boundary |

### Analysis Framework for Duration

1. **Is the term proportionate to the relationship?** A 5-year NDA for a 2-week evaluation is excessive.
2. **Does the survival period match the sensitivity?** Trade secrets may warrant longer survival; general business information does not.
3. **Is there a termination right?** Either party should be able to terminate with notice.
4. **What happens on termination?** Return/destruction obligations should trigger on termination.

---

## Module 2: Key Clauses

### Definition of Confidential Information

This is the most critical clause in any NDA. It determines what is protected and what is not.

| Element | Standard Position | Red Flag |
|---------|-------------------|----------|
| Scope | Information relating to the stated purpose | "All information of any kind" |
| Form | Written, oral, visual, electronic | Limited to written only (excludes oral discussions) |
| Marking | Must be marked "Confidential" or confirmed in writing | No marking requirement |
| Oral Confirmation | 10-30 day window to confirm oral disclosures | No window or unreasonably short (24 hours) |
| Negative Definition | What is NOT confidential (carveouts) | No exclusions from definition |

**Quality Indicators:**

| Quality Level | Characteristics |
|---------------|-----------------|
| Strong | Specific categories listed; marking required; oral confirmation window; tied to purpose |
| Standard | Broad but reasonable scope; some marking requirement; carveouts present |
| Weak | Overly broad; no marking; no oral confirmation; missing carveouts |
| Deficient | "All information" with no limits; no carveouts; no marking |

### Purpose Clause

| Element | Standard Position | Red Flag |
|---------|-------------------|----------|
| Specificity | Named project, evaluation, or business opportunity | "Any purpose" or no purpose stated |
| Limitation | Use restricted to stated purpose | No use restriction |
| Expansion | How purpose can be expanded | Unilateral expansion by one party |

### Permitted Use

| Element | Standard Position | Red Flag |
|---------|-------------------|----------|
| Use Restriction | Solely for the stated purpose | No use restriction |
| Internal Use | Sharing within organization on need-to-know basis | Unrestricted internal use |
| Derivative Works | Cannot create derivative works from confidential info | Right to create derivatives |
| Competitive Use | Cannot use for competitive purposes | Residuals clause allowing competitive use |

### Marking Requirements

| Marking Type | Standard Approach | Notes |
|-------------|-------------------|-------|
| Written Documents | Marked "Confidential" or similar designation | Most common requirement |
| Oral Disclosures | Identified as confidential at time of disclosure; confirmed in writing within 10-30 days | Important for meetings and calls |
| Visual/Demonstrations | Identified as confidential prior to disclosure | Often overlooked |
| Electronic Data | Marked in metadata or transmission notice | Increasingly important |

---

## Module 3: Party Obligations

### Standard of Care

| Standard | Meaning | Recipient Risk | Discloser Preference |
|----------|---------|---------------|---------------------|
| Reasonable care | What a reasonable organization would do | Moderate | Minimum acceptable |
| Same degree as own | Same care as for party's own confidential info | Moderate | Preferred |
| Industry standard | Consistent with industry practices | Moderate | Good for regulated industries |
| Best efforts | Highest possible standard | High | Aggressive; may be unenforceable |
| Absolute | Guarantees no unauthorized disclosure | Very High | Unreasonable; resist |

### Use Restrictions

| Restriction | Standard Language | Analysis Point |
|-------------|-------------------|----------------|
| Purpose limitation | "Use solely for the Purpose" | Must match the defined purpose |
| No reverse engineering | "Shall not reverse engineer, decompile, or disassemble" | Standard for technology disclosures |
| No copying | "Shall not copy except as reasonably necessary" | Allow copies needed for the purpose |
| No modification | "Shall not modify or create derivative works" | Standard restriction |

### Disclosure Limits

| Permitted Recipient | Standard Requirement | Red Flag |
|--------------------|---------------------|----------|
| Employees | Need-to-know basis; bound by written agreement | No need-to-know requirement |
| Officers/Directors | Need-to-know; inherently bound by fiduciary duty | Excluded from permitted recipients |
| Legal Counsel | Need-to-know; bound by professional obligation | Excluded (creates compliance impossibility) |
| Accountants/Auditors | Need-to-know; bound by professional obligation | Excluded |
| Affiliates | Need-to-know; bound by written agreement | Unrestricted affiliate sharing |
| Consultants | Need-to-know; bound by written agreement at least as protective | No downstream binding requirement |

### Notification Obligations

| Event | Standard Obligation | Red Flag |
|-------|---------------------|----------|
| Unauthorized disclosure | Prompt written notice | No notification requirement |
| Legal compulsion | Notice before disclosure (if permitted) | No notice of compelled disclosure |
| Breach by representative | Prompt notice; receiving party responsible | No responsibility for representative breach |

---

## Module 4: Remedies and Liability

### Injunctive Relief

| Element | Standard Position | Analysis Point |
|---------|-------------------|----------------|
| Availability | Injunctive relief available for breach | Should be explicit |
| Bond | Without requirement of bond or security | Bond requirement may delay enforcement |
| Irreparable Harm | Acknowledgment that breach causes irreparable harm | Standard; strengthens injunctive relief argument |
| Cumulative Remedies | Injunctive relief in addition to other remedies | Should not be sole remedy |

### Damages Framework

| Damages Type | Standard in NDAs? | Notes |
|-------------|-------------------|-------|
| Actual damages | Yes | Standard breach-of-contract remedy |
| Consequential damages | Usually excluded | May be included for willful breach |
| Liquidated damages | No -- RED flag | Transforms NDA into penalty contract |
| Punitive damages | No | Rarely available for contract breach |
| Lost profits | Fact-dependent | Difficult to prove in NDA context |

### Indemnification in NDAs

| Aspect | Standard Position | Red Flag |
|--------|-------------------|----------|
| Presence | Not standard in NDAs | One-way indemnification |
| Scope | If present, limited to third-party claims from breach | Broad indemnification for any damages |
| Mutuality | If present, should be mutual | One-sided obligation |
| Cap | If present, should be capped | Uncapped indemnification |
| Procedure | Notice, control, cooperation | No procedure specified |

### Red Flags in Remedies

| Provision | Severity | Impact | Action |
|-----------|----------|--------|--------|
| Liquidated damages | H | Creates predetermined penalty; may be unenforceable | Delete; use standard remedies |
| Unlimited liability | M | No cap on breach damages | Add reasonable liability cap |
| One-way indemnification | M | Shifts all risk to one party | Make mutual or delete |
| Mandatory arbitration (no injunctive carveout) | M | May delay emergency relief | Add carveout for injunctive relief in courts |
| Prevailing party attorney fees | L | May deter smaller party from enforcing | Acceptable either way |

---

## Module 5: Standard Exceptions

### Exception 1: Public Knowledge

**Standard Language:** "Information that is or becomes generally available to the public through no fault of, or breach of this Agreement by, the receiving party."

| Analysis Point | What to Check |
|----------------|---------------|
| Causation | "Through no fault of the receiving party" -- receiving party's breach should not activate this carveout |
| Partial Publication | Does public availability of part of the information make the whole non-confidential? Should specify it does not |
| Timing | "At the time of disclosure or thereafter" -- covers both pre-existing and subsequent public availability |

**Red Flags:**
- Missing "through no fault" qualifier (allows receiving party to leak then claim public knowledge)
- Limited to "at the time of disclosure" only (does not cover subsequent publication)

### Exception 2: Prior Possession

**Standard Language:** "Information that was already in the receiving party's possession prior to disclosure by the disclosing party, as demonstrated by the receiving party's written records."

| Analysis Point | What to Check |
|----------------|---------------|
| Documentary Evidence | "As demonstrated by written records" -- protects discloser from unfounded claims |
| Timing | "Prior to disclosure" -- clear temporal boundary |
| Source | Should not have been obtained from the disclosing party or under other confidentiality obligations |

**Red Flags:**
- No documentary evidence requirement (allows unsubstantiated claims)
- No temporal boundary (ambiguous when possession occurred)

### Exception 3: Independent Development

**Standard Language:** "Information independently developed by the receiving party without use of or reference to the disclosing party's Confidential Information, as demonstrated by the receiving party's written records."

| Analysis Point | What to Check |
|----------------|---------------|
| Clean Room | Implies clean-room development process | 
| Documentary Evidence | "As demonstrated by written records" -- essential for enforcement |
| Scope | "Without use of or reference to" -- both direct use and reference prohibited |

**Red Flags:**
- Missing from carveouts entirely (HIGH risk for recipients; blocks R&D)
- No documentary evidence requirement
- Weakened language: "without direct use" (allows indirect reference)

**Practical Impact:** Missing independent development carveout can contaminate entire engineering teams. If a developer sees confidential information and later works on a similar product, the discloser can claim derivation. This carveout is the most important for technology companies.

### Exception 4: Third-Party Receipt

**Standard Language:** "Information received by the receiving party from a third party who, to the receiving party's knowledge, is not under any obligation of confidentiality to the disclosing party with respect to such information."

| Analysis Point | What to Check |
|----------------|---------------|
| Knowledge Qualifier | "To the receiving party's knowledge" -- receiving party not required to investigate |
| Third-Party Obligation | Third party must not be bound by confidentiality to discloser |
| Lawful Receipt | Information must be lawfully obtained |

**Red Flags:**
- Requires receiving party to investigate third party's obligations (impractical)
- Missing "to the receiving party's knowledge" qualifier (strict liability standard)

### Exception 5: Legal Compulsion

**Standard Language:** "Information required to be disclosed by applicable law, regulation, court order, or governmental authority, provided that the receiving party gives prompt written notice to the disclosing party (to the extent legally permitted) and cooperates with the disclosing party's efforts to obtain a protective order."

| Analysis Point | What to Check |
|----------------|---------------|
| Notice Requirement | Prompt notice before disclosure (if not prohibited by law) |
| Cooperation | Cooperation with protective order efforts |
| Minimization | Disclose only the minimum required |
| Waiver for Legal Prohibition | Notice waived if law prohibits it |

**Red Flags:**
- No notice requirement (discloser cannot seek protective order)
- No minimization requirement (entire file may be disclosed when only a portion is required)
- No waiver for situations where notice is prohibited by law (creates impossible obligation)

---

## Cross-Module Analysis Framework

Use this framework to systematically review an NDA across all five modules.

### Step 1: Duration and Scope Assessment

| Question | GREEN | YELLOW | RED |
|----------|-------|--------|-----|
| Is the term reasonable (2-5 years)? | Yes | 5-7 years | Perpetual or >7 years |
| Is there a termination right? | Yes, either party | Yes, but conditional | No termination right |
| Does survival match sensitivity? | 2-3 years | 5+ years | Perpetual survival |
| Is purpose clearly stated? | Specific project/purpose | General business purpose | No purpose or "any purpose" |

### Step 2: Definition Quality Assessment

| Question | GREEN | YELLOW | RED |
|----------|-------|--------|-----|
| Is scope bounded? | Tied to purpose with categories | Broad but reasonable | "All information of any kind" |
| Is marking required? | Yes, with oral confirmation window | Partial (written only) | No marking requirement |
| Are carveouts present? | All 5 standard carveouts | 3-4 carveouts | 0-2 carveouts |

### Step 3: Obligation Balance Assessment

| Question | GREEN | YELLOW | RED |
|----------|-------|--------|-----|
| Are obligations mutual? | Yes (if mutual NDA) | Mostly balanced | One-sided in mutual NDA |
| Is standard of care reasonable? | Reasonable care | Same degree as own | Best efforts or absolute |
| Are permitted disclosures adequate? | Representatives + advisors + affiliates | Representatives only | No permitted disclosures |

### Step 4: Remedy Proportionality Assessment

| Question | GREEN | YELLOW | RED |
|----------|-------|--------|-----|
| Is injunctive relief available? | Yes, without bond | Yes, with bond | Not mentioned |
| Are damages appropriate? | Actual damages | Includes consequential | Liquidated damages |
| Is indemnification absent or mutual? | Absent | Mutual with cap | One-sided, uncapped |

### Step 5: Exception Completeness Assessment

| Question | GREEN | YELLOW | RED |
|----------|-------|--------|-----|
| Public knowledge carveout? | Present with "no fault" qualifier | Present without qualifier | Missing |
| Prior possession carveout? | Present with evidence requirement | Present without evidence req. | Missing |
| Independent development carveout? | Present with evidence requirement | Present without evidence req. | Missing |
| Third-party receipt carveout? | Present with knowledge qualifier | Present without qualifier | Missing |
| Legal compulsion carveout? | Present with notice + cooperation | Present with notice only | Missing |
receiving-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when receiving code review feedback, before implementing suggestions, especially if feedback seems unclear or technically questionable - requires technical rigor and verification, not performative agreement or blind implementationStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
requesting-code-reviewobra/superpowersUse when completing tasks, implementing major features, or before merging to verify work meets requirementsStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
using-git-worktreesobra/superpowersUse when starting feature work that needs isolation from current workspace or before executing implementation plans - ensures an isolated workspace exists via native tools or git worktree fallbackStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall
verification-before-completionobra/superpowersUse when about to claim work is complete, fixed, or passing, before committing or creating PRs - requires running verification commands and confirming output before making any success claims; evidence before assertions alwaysStars: 322kUpdated Claude CodeCodexVerifiedInstall