borghei/Claude-Skills / legal/legal-risk-assessment
legal-risk-assessment
VerifiedStructured legal risk assessment with 5x5 Severity x Likelihood matrix. Use for risk scoring, risk registers, escalation decisions, and risk memos.
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 11.2 KB |
| references/escalation_guide.md | markdown | 17.3 KB |
| references/risk_framework.md | markdown | 13.5 KB |
| scripts/risk_report_generator.py | script | 11.7 KB |
| scripts/risk_scorer.py | script | 10.1 KB |
references/escalation_guide.md
View on GitHub# Outside Counsel Escalation Guide
Guidance for when and how to engage outside counsel based on risk assessment results, matter type, and organizational capability.
---
## Table of Contents
- [Escalation Decision Framework](#escalation-decision-framework)
- [Mandatory Engagement](#mandatory-engagement)
- [Strongly Recommended Engagement](#strongly-recommended-engagement)
- [Consider Engagement](#consider-engagement)
- [Selecting Outside Counsel](#selecting-outside-counsel)
- [Risk Category Definitions](#risk-category-definitions)
- [Contributing Factors Framework](#contributing-factors-framework)
- [Mitigating Factors Framework](#mitigating-factors-framework)
- [Engagement Models](#engagement-models)
- [Cost Management](#cost-management)
---
## Escalation Decision Framework
Use this decision tree when determining whether to engage outside counsel:
```
Is this an active litigation, government investigation,
or matter with criminal exposure?
→ YES → MANDATORY engagement (see Mandatory section)
Is this a novel legal issue, multi-jurisdictional matter,
or exposure exceeding 5% of revenue?
→ YES → STRONGLY RECOMMENDED (see Strongly Recommended section)
Is this a complex dispute, sensitive employment matter,
or data incident affecting >1,000 individuals?
→ YES → CONSIDER engagement (see Consider section)
Does the matter involve specialized expertise not
available in-house?
→ YES → CONSIDER engagement for that specific expertise
None of the above?
→ Handle in-house. Document rationale for not engaging outside counsel.
```
---
## Mandatory Engagement
Outside counsel must be engaged in the following situations. Do not attempt to handle these matters solely with in-house resources.
| Trigger | Rationale | Urgency |
|---------|-----------|---------|
| **Active litigation filed** | Court-imposed deadlines, procedural requirements, potential sanctions for missteps | Engage within 48 hours of service |
| **Government investigation** | Subpoena response, document preservation, Fifth Amendment considerations, regulatory expertise | Engage immediately upon notice |
| **Criminal exposure** | Constitutional protections, sentencing implications, parallel proceedings management | Engage immediately; separate counsel for entity vs. individuals |
| **Securities enforcement** | SEC/DOJ coordination, insider trading, disclosure obligations, director liability | Engage immediately; consider specialized securities defense counsel |
| **Board-level matters** | Special committee investigations, shareholder derivative suits, fiduciary duty claims | Engage before first board discussion of matter |
| **Existential threats** | Matters threatening company viability, license revocation, debarment | Engage immediately with crisis management capability |
### Mandatory Engagement Checklist
When mandatory engagement is triggered:
- [ ] Identify matter type and immediate deadlines
- [ ] Issue litigation hold / document preservation notice
- [ ] Brief General Counsel and CEO/executive sponsor
- [ ] Select outside counsel with relevant specialization
- [ ] Execute engagement letter with scope and budget
- [ ] Establish privilege protocols (joint defense or common interest if applicable)
- [ ] Create dedicated matter folder with access controls
- [ ] Schedule initial strategy session within 72 hours
---
## Strongly Recommended Engagement
Outside counsel should be engaged in these situations unless compelling reasons exist to handle in-house. Document rationale if not engaging.
| Trigger | Rationale | Considerations |
|---------|-----------|----------------|
| **Novel legal issues** | Untested legal theories, first-impression questions, rapidly evolving law | In-house team may lack depth in emerging areas; outside counsel brings broader case law awareness |
| **Jurisdictional complexity** | Multi-state or international matters, forum selection, choice of law disputes | Local counsel needed for jurisdictional requirements; coordination across jurisdictions |
| **Material financial exposure** | Exposure exceeding 5% of annual revenue or $5M (whichever is lower) | Financial risk warrants best available expertise; insurance carrier may require approved counsel |
| **Specialized expertise** | Antitrust, patent prosecution/litigation, international trade, tax controversy | In-house team unlikely to have depth in all specializations |
| **Regulatory changes** | New regulations with material compliance obligations, enforcement transitions | Outside counsel track regulatory developments and enforcement trends full-time |
| **M&A transactions** | Due diligence, deal structuring, regulatory approvals, post-closing integration | Transaction-specific expertise, volume of documentation, deadline pressure |
| **Class action risk** | Potential for class certification, multi-district litigation, mass arbitration | Class defense requires specialized strategy and experience |
### Strongly Recommended Engagement Checklist
- [ ] Assess whether in-house capabilities are sufficient (document assessment)
- [ ] Identify specific expertise needed
- [ ] Determine budget and engagement scope
- [ ] Evaluate 2-3 outside counsel options
- [ ] Brief senior leadership on recommendation
- [ ] Execute engagement letter with clear scope boundaries
---
## Consider Engagement
Outside counsel may be beneficial but is not strictly necessary. Evaluate based on in-house capacity, matter complexity, and available resources.
| Trigger | When to Engage | When to Handle In-House |
|---------|---------------|------------------------|
| **Complex commercial disputes** | Multiple parties, complex fact patterns, arbitration with significant exposure | Clear liability, small exposure, cooperative counterparty |
| **Employment matters** | Discrimination claims, wage/hour class potential, executive terminations, whistleblower retaliation | Routine discipline, straightforward terminations, standard HR issues |
| **Data incidents** | >1,000 affected individuals, sensitive data categories, multi-jurisdictional notification | <1,000 affected, standard notification, no regulatory inquiry |
| **IP disputes** | Infringement claims with injunction risk, trade secret litigation, patent portfolio strategy | Routine trademark monitoring, standard licensing, DMCA notices |
| **Insurance coverage** | Complex coverage disputes, D&O claims, cyber insurance claims, coverage litigation | Straightforward claims with clear coverage |
| **Real estate** | Complex leases, environmental issues, condemnation, development disputes | Standard lease renewals, routine landlord-tenant matters |
| **International matters** | Foreign law applies, cross-border enforcement, international arbitration | Domestic matters with incidental international elements |
---
## Selecting Outside Counsel
### Selection Criteria
| Criterion | Weight | Assessment Method |
|-----------|--------|-------------------|
| **Relevant expertise** | 30% | Track record in specific practice area; published authority; peer recognition |
| **Industry knowledge** | 20% | Prior work in same industry; understanding of business context and regulatory landscape |
| **Responsiveness** | 15% | Response time to inquiries; availability for urgent matters; partner accessibility |
| **Cost structure** | 15% | Hourly rates; willingness to offer alternative fee arrangements; budget predictability |
| **Conflicts clearance** | 10% | Clean conflict check; no representation of adverse parties or competitors |
| **Cultural fit** | 10% | Communication style; willingness to work with in-house team; diversity commitment |
### Alternative Fee Arrangements
| Arrangement | Best For | Risk Allocation |
|-------------|----------|-----------------|
| **Fixed fee** | Predictable matters with defined scope (transactions, regulatory filings) | Risk on outside counsel |
| **Capped fee** | Matters with variable scope but a known ceiling | Shared risk |
| **Success fee / contingency** | Litigation with clear upside; affirmative claims | Risk on outside counsel |
| **Blended rate** | Multiple attorneys at different levels | Balanced |
| **Phased budget** | Complex matters with distinct phases (investigation → litigation → trial) | Phase-by-phase assessment |
| **Secondment** | Extended need for specific expertise; surge capacity | Predictable cost |
---
## Risk Category Definitions
Detailed definitions for each risk category to ensure consistent categorization.
### Contract Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| Breach of contract | Failure to perform material obligations | 2-4 |
| Indemnification exposure | Claims under indemnification clauses | 3-5 |
| SLA violations | Service level failures triggering penalties or termination | 1-3 |
| Force majeure disputes | Disagreements over force majeure applicability | 2-4 |
| Termination disputes | Contested contract terminations | 2-4 |
| Warranty claims | Product or service warranty breach allegations | 2-4 |
### Regulatory Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| Enforcement action | Regulatory investigation or enforcement proceeding | 3-5 |
| Compliance gap | Identified non-compliance with applicable regulation | 2-4 |
| License/permit risk | Threat to required licenses or permits | 3-5 |
| Reporting failure | Missed or inaccurate regulatory reporting | 2-4 |
| Regulatory change | New regulation requiring material compliance effort | 2-3 |
### Litigation Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| Active lawsuit | Filed complaint or arbitration demand | 3-5 |
| Threatened litigation | Demand letter or pre-suit notice | 2-4 |
| Class action exposure | Potential class certification | 4-5 |
| Appellate risk | Adverse ruling subject to appeal | 2-4 |
| Judgment enforcement | Risk of adverse judgment enforcement | 3-5 |
### IP Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| Patent infringement | Infringement claim or assertion | 3-5 |
| Trade secret misappropriation | Theft or unauthorized disclosure of trade secrets | 3-5 |
| Trademark dispute | Trademark infringement or dilution claim | 2-4 |
| Copyright infringement | Unauthorized use of copyrighted material | 2-4 |
| Open-source compliance | License violation in open-source software | 2-4 |
### Data Privacy Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| Data breach | Unauthorized access to personal data | 3-5 |
| Regulatory non-compliance | GDPR, CCPA, or other privacy law violations | 3-5 |
| Cross-border transfer | Unlawful international data transfers | 2-4 |
| Consent management | Inadequate consent mechanisms | 2-3 |
| Vendor data handling | Third-party processor non-compliance | 2-4 |
### Employment Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| Discrimination claim | Protected class discrimination allegation | 3-5 |
| Wrongful termination | Unlawful termination claim | 2-4 |
| Wage and hour | Misclassification, overtime, or wage disputes | 2-5 |
| Harassment | Workplace harassment allegation | 3-5 |
| Non-compete enforcement | Non-compete or non-solicitation disputes | 2-4 |
| Whistleblower retaliation | Retaliation claim after protected activity | 3-5 |
### Corporate Risk
| Sub-Category | Description | Typical Severity Range |
|--------------|-------------|----------------------|
| M&A liability | Post-closing claims, earnout disputes, rep & warranty claims | 3-5 |
| Governance failure | Board fiduciary duty breach, conflicts of interest | 3-5 |
| Shareholder dispute | Minority shareholder claims, derivative suits | 3-5 |
| Securities compliance | Disclosure violations, insider trading | 4-5 |
| Corporate restructuring | Insolvency, reorganization, wind-down complications | 3-5 |
---
## Contributing Factors Framework
Factors that increase overall risk profile. Consider these when scoring severity and likelihood.
| Factor | Impact | Assessment Questions |
|--------|--------|---------------------|
| **No compliance program** | +1 likelihood | Is there a documented compliance program covering this risk area? |
| **Prior incidents** | +1 likelihood | Has the organization experienced similar issues before? |
| **Aggressive counterparty** | +1 likelihood | Is the opposing party known for aggressive litigation or enforcement? |
| **Public visibility** | +1 severity | Will this matter attract media attention or public scrutiny? |
| **Precedential risk** | +1 severity | Could an adverse outcome create harmful precedent for future matters? |
| **Multi-jurisdictional** | +1 to both | Does this matter span multiple jurisdictions with different legal requirements? |
| **Criminal exposure** | Sets severity to 5 | Is there any potential for criminal charges against the entity or individuals? |
| **Class action potential** | +2 severity | Could this matter become or contribute to a class action? |
| **Regulatory trend** | +1 likelihood | Is there an active enforcement trend in this area? |
| **Internal control weakness** | +1 likelihood | Have audits or assessments identified relevant control gaps? |
---
## Mitigating Factors Framework
Factors that reduce overall risk profile. Consider these when evaluating residual risk after controls.
| Factor | Impact | Assessment Questions |
|--------|--------|---------------------|
| **Strong compliance program** | -1 likelihood | Is there a robust, documented, and regularly tested compliance program? |
| **Insurance coverage** | -1 severity | Is there applicable insurance coverage with adequate limits? |
| **Favorable precedent** | -1 likelihood | Is there favorable case law or regulatory guidance supporting our position? |
| **Cooperative counterparty** | -1 likelihood | Is the opposing party willing to negotiate or mediate? |
| **Contractual protections** | -1 severity | Are there indemnification, limitation of liability, or insurance requirements? |
| **Early detection** | -1 both | Was the risk identified early, allowing proactive response? |
| **Experienced counsel** | -1 severity | Is experienced counsel (internal or external) already engaged? |
| **Regulatory safe harbor** | -1 likelihood | Does a safe harbor or exemption apply to the conduct at issue? |
| **Document retention** | -1 likelihood | Are relevant documents preserved and organized for potential litigation? |
| **Self-reporting** | -1 severity | Has the organization self-reported to regulators (where applicable)? |
---
## Engagement Models
### Full Representation
Outside counsel manages all aspects of the matter with in-house oversight.
| Aspect | Detail |
|--------|--------|
| **When to use** | Complex litigation, government investigations, M&A transactions |
| **In-house role** | Strategic oversight, business context, budget management |
| **Outside counsel role** | Legal strategy, court appearances, document review, depositions, negotiations |
| **Budget approach** | Phased budgets with quarterly true-ups |
### Co-Counsel / Supervision
Outside counsel handles specific aspects while in-house manages the rest.
| Aspect | Detail |
|--------|--------|
| **When to use** | Matters requiring specific expertise but manageable in-house overall |
| **In-house role** | Day-to-day management, routine filings, witness preparation |
| **Outside counsel role** | Specialized analysis, expert witness, specific motions or hearings |
| **Budget approach** | Task-based fees for specific deliverables |
### Advisory Only
Outside counsel provides advice and guidance while in-house handles execution.
| Aspect | Detail |
|--------|--------|
| **When to use** | Novel legal questions, regulatory interpretation, risk assessment validation |
| **In-house role** | All execution, document preparation, counterparty communication |
| **Outside counsel role** | Legal research, opinion letters, strategy review, risk assessment |
| **Budget approach** | Hourly or fixed fee for defined advisory scope |
---
## Cost Management
### Budget Controls
| Control | Description |
|---------|-------------|
| **Engagement letter scope** | Define scope precisely; require written approval for out-of-scope work |
| **Staffing guidelines** | Specify acceptable staffing levels; limit partner hours to strategy and court |
| **Invoice review** | Review invoices against budget; challenge block billing and excessive charges |
| **Phase gates** | Require budget re-approval at each phase transition |
| **Status reporting** | Monthly matter status and budget reports from outside counsel |
| **Early case assessment** | Require early case assessment with budget estimate within 30 days |
### Cost Benchmarks
| Matter Type | Typical Range | Key Cost Drivers |
|-------------|---------------|-----------------|
| Single-plaintiff employment | $50K - $300K | Discovery scope, depositions, trial vs. settlement |
| Commercial litigation (mid-size) | $200K - $1M | Complexity, document volume, expert witnesses |
| Patent litigation | $500K - $5M+ | Claim construction, technical experts, trial |
| Regulatory investigation | $300K - $3M+ | Document production, witness preparation, negotiation duration |
| M&A transaction | $200K - $2M+ | Deal size, regulatory approvals, diligence scope |
| Class action defense | $1M - $10M+ | Class size, discovery, certification fight, settlement negotiations |
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| slack-gif-creatoranthropics/skillsKnowledge and utilities for creating animated GIFs optimized for Slack. Provides constraints, validation tools, and animation concepts. Use when users request animated GIFs for Slack like "make me a GIF of X doing Y for Slack." | Stars: 198k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytailDietrichGebert/ponytailLazy senior dev mode for any coding task: the smallest change that fully solves it, and a reply a busy human understands in one read. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailHarvest every shortcut: comment into one debt ledger, so deferrals get tracked instead of forgotten. One-shot report. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-debtDietrichGebert/ponytailList every `shortcut:` comment (and older `ponytail:` ones) as a debt ledger. One-shot report, changes nothing. Use for "ponytail debt", "what did ponytail defer", "list the shortcuts", /ponytail-debt. | Stars: 196k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |