AgriciDaniel/claude-youtube / skills/claude-youtube
youtube
VerifiedThe ultimate YouTube creator skill. Covers channel audits, video SEO, retention-engineered scripts, hook writing, thumbnail briefs, content strategy, content calendars, Shorts optimisation, analytics interpretation, monetisation planning, competitor research, cross-platform repurposing, upload metadata packages, and data-driven video idea generation. Triggers on: "youtube", "channel", "video", "views", "subscribers", "watch time", "shorts", "thumbnail", "CTR", "retention", "monetize", "script", "hook", "upload", "youtube audit", "video ideas", "content calendar", "competitor analysis", "repurpose video", "youtube seo", "youtube strategy", "youtube analytics".
templates/commentary-channel.md
View on GitHub# Commentary Channel Template
> News commentary, opinion pieces, cultural essays, reaction/analysis content.
> Traffic mix: Browse Features (~45%) + Suggested (~30%) + Search (~15%) + Shorts (~10%).
---
## 1. Channel DNA
Commentary channels are **personality-driven opinion machines**. The algorithm rewards them for high CTR (pattern-interrupt thumbnails + polarising titles), strong early retention (hot-take hooks), and session-starting Browse traffic. The format is algorithmically distinct because it rides trending topics (high impression volume) while injecting a unique angle (differentiator). Entertainment/Education RPM sits at $2-8 depending on whether the niche leans cultural ($2-5) or news/politics ($5-8). Content has a short shelf life — 70% of lifetime views land in the first 7 days. Success hinges on speed-to-publish and strength of opinion.
## 2. Optimal Content Mix
| Type | % | Description |
|------|---|-------------|
| **Hero** | 25-30% | Trending/timely takes on breaking news or viral moments. Highest impressions, shortest lifespan. |
| **Hub** | 45-50% | Recurring series (weekly roundups, ranking videos, "worst takes" compilations). Builds subscriber habit. |
| **Help** | 20-25% | Evergreen explainers, "why X happened" deep dives. Compounds via Search over months. |
Trending content ratio should sit at 25-30% — high enough to capture spikes, low enough to avoid full dependence on the news cycle.
## 3. Upload Cadence
| Setup | Cadence | Notes |
|-------|---------|-------|
| **Solo creator** | 2-3 long-form + 3-4 Shorts/week | 12+/month target for 8x faster view growth. Batch record 2-3 evergreen videos, fill gaps with timely takes. |
| **Small team (2-3)** | 3-4 long-form + 5-7 Shorts/week | One person on trending radar, one on editing. Publish timely takes within 24h of event. |
Long-form target: 8-15 minutes (unlocks mid-roll ads at 8 min for ~50% revenue boost). Shorts repurpose best clips from long-form commentary.
## 4. Title Pattern Library
1. "I Need To Talk About [TRENDING TOPIC]"
2. "The [INDUSTRY/COMMUNITY] Has A [PROBLEM] Problem"
3. "[PERSON/BRAND] Just Made A Huge Mistake"
4. "Why Everyone Is Wrong About [TOPIC]"
5. "The Real Reason [EVENT] Happened"
6. "[NUMBER] Things Nobody Is Saying About [TOPIC]"
7. "This Changes Everything For [GROUP/COMMUNITY]"
8. "[TOPIC] Is Worse Than You Think (Here's Why)"
9. "I Was Wrong About [PREVIOUS TAKE] — Here's What Changed"
10. "The [TOPIC] Debate Is Missing The Point"
Front-load the opinion/tension word within the first 40 characters. Entertainment CTR benchmark: 6.0%. Strong commentary channels hit 8-12% by leveraging curiosity + controversy.
## 5. Thumbnail Formula
- **Face with exaggerated expression** (shock, disgust, disbelief) — close-cropped, filling 40-60% of frame
- **Bold 3-4 word text overlay** in contrasting colour (red/yellow on dark backgrounds)
- **Reference image** of the subject/topic in remaining space (screenshot, logo, person discussed)
- **High contrast + saturation** — commentary thumbnails compete in Browse where everything is small
- Avoid: cluttered backgrounds, more than 2 faces, small text, neutral expressions
- A/B test expression intensity — "concerned" often outperforms "screaming"
## 6. Hook Style
**Primary: Shock/Contradiction** — Open with a bold, counter-consensus statement that forces the viewer to stay and hear the reasoning. "Everyone is celebrating [X], but nobody is talking about the part that should terrify you."
**Secondary: Curiosity-gap** — Tease the conclusion without revealing it. "What [PERSON] just did isn't just bad — it's the beginning of something much bigger."
Deliver the hook in 0-5 seconds. Cut to a brief context-set (5-15 seconds), then promise the payoff structure: "Let me explain why in 3 parts." Retention benchmark: aim for 55-65% at 30 seconds (above the 42.1% educational average).
## 7. Monetisation Priority Stack
| Rank | Stream | Why This Position |
|------|--------|-------------------|
| 1 | **AdSense** | Primary driver. $2-8 RPM. 8-min+ videos unlock mid-rolls. Volume strategy — more uploads = more revenue. |
| 2 | **Brand Deals** | At 5K-15K avg views: $1K-1.5K/video. Commentary audiences are engaged and trust the creator's opinion. |
| 3 | **Memberships** | Loyal audiences pay for early access, behind-the-scenes, extended cuts. $4.99/month sweet spot. YouTube takes 30%. |
| 4 | **External Funnels** | Newsletter, podcast, Patreon. Own the audience off-platform. Email list is insurance against algorithm shifts. |
| 5 | **Super Chat/Thanks** | Works if you do occasional livestream commentary on breaking events. Spiky but real revenue. |
| 6 | **Shorts Ad Share** | Repurposed clips generate incremental revenue. RPM is low ($0.01-$0.07) but drives long-form discovery. |
| 7 | **Shopping Affiliate** | Lowest priority — commentary rarely has natural product tie-ins unless reviewing physical products. |
## 8. Growth Trajectory
| Milestone | Timeline | Key Metrics |
|-----------|----------|-------------|
| 0-500 subs | Months 1-3 | 20-30 videos published. Find your angle. 1-2 videos catch trending waves. |
| 500-1K subs (YPP Expanded) | Months 3-5 | 3K watch hours. Enable memberships/Super Chat. Consistent upload habit locked in. |
| 1K-5K subs (Full YPP) | Months 5-10 | 4K watch hours. AdSense active. 1-2 videos per month hit 5K+ views. Recognisable style established. |
| 5K-25K subs | Months 10-18 | Brand deal inquiries begin. 5K-15K avg views. Community tab active. First viral hit (50K+ views). |
| 25K-100K subs | Months 18-30 | Consistent Browse traffic. $2K-5K/month total revenue. Audience expects your take on every major event. |
Using both long-form + Shorts accelerates these timelines by 40-60%.
## 9. Common Failure Modes
**1. Trending-only trap** — Chasing every news cycle with no evergreen content. Views spike and crash. No compounding growth. **Fix**: Maintain 20-25% evergreen "Help" content. Create a signature series that runs regardless of news.
**2. Personality fade** — Copying other commentators' styles instead of developing a distinct voice. Audience has no reason to choose you over established creators. **Fix**: Define 3 opinion pillars (topics where you always have a take). Develop a catchphrase or recurring segment. Let your background/expertise differentiate you.
**3. Burnout from speed pressure** — Commentary rewards fast publishing, which leads to 7-day-a-week production and creative exhaustion. **Fix**: Batch-record 2-3 evergreen videos during slow news weeks. Use Shorts for quick takes instead of full productions. Build a 3-video buffer of non-timely content.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| rea-analysis-optimizationmorluto/reaOptimize REA providers and shared analysis workflows for agent context, latency, CPU, and memory while preserving correctness and Evidence. Use for analysis bottlenecks and cache or query design; CI/test-suite optimization belongs to rea-ci-tests-audit. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| rea-ci-tests-auditmorluto/reaAudit REA CI and test suites for correctness, fixture drift, false passes, and measured performance; use for suite or workflow investigations and efficiency changes, rather than ordinary feature testing or a single test failure. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| rea-tool-designmorluto/reaAudit, investigate, design, or change REA investigation tools, CLI/MCP contracts, provider capabilities, and Evidence semantics. | Stars: 472k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| ponytail-auditDietrichGebert/ponytailQuality audit of the whole repo: bugs, security, real load, missing tests, speed, and what to delete. Most important first. | Stars: 194k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |