Agent-Engineer-Master/skill-engineer / strategy/industry-analysis/map-value-chain-profit-pools
map-value-chain-profit-pools
UnverifiedProduces a paired Porter value-chain decomposition + Bain/Gadiesh-Gilbert profit-pool overlay for a defined industry. Output: value-chain-profit-pools.md with value-chain stages (inbound logistics through service + support activities), absolute EBIT/economic profit (not revenue margin) per stage, horizontal-bar profit-pool visualization in markdown, identification of which stage has structural profit concentration and why, plus V/C/A/I provenance tagging. The pairing is deliberate — value chain alone is incomplete; profit pool alone lacks structural context. Sub-skill of analyze-industry but invocable standalone. Triggers on 'value chain analysis for [industry]', 'profit pool analysis for [industry]', 'where does the money sit in [industry]', 'where do profits concentrate in [industry]', 'value chain and profit pools'. Do NOT activate for single-company P&L decomposition (use build-company-model), customer-level economics (use analyze-demand), or competitive share analysis (use map-competitive-arena).
| File | Kind | Size |
|---|---|---|
| SKILL.md | skill md | 9.6 KB |
| assets/profit-pool-template.md | markdown | 5.2 KB |
| evals/evals.json | config | 5.9 KB |
| references/economic-profit.md | markdown | 5.0 KB |
| references/edge-cases.md | markdown | 136 B |
| references/learnings.md | markdown | 252 B |
| references/listed-comparable-triangulation.md | markdown | 5.4 KB |
| references/profit-pool-methodology.md | markdown | 8.3 KB |
| references/structural-protections.md | markdown | 6.0 KB |
| references/value-chain-templates.md | markdown | 6.0 KB |
| scripts/validate_profit_pools.pyexecutable | script | 15.7 KB |
references/profit-pool-methodology.md
View on GitHub# Profit Pool Methodology
Source: Orit Gadiesh & James Gilbert, *Profit Pools: A Fresh Look at Strategy* (Bain / HBR, 1998). Now standard senior MBB / PE-CDD practice.
The discipline: map ABSOLUTE economic profit (not revenue, not margin %) by value-chain stage. Profit concentrates in structurally protected niches — often inverted from where revenue is highest.
## Why absolute $ matters
Two stages with the same 12% EBIT margin can represent radically different profit pools if their revenue scales differ. Final assembly might be 60% of industry revenue at 8% margin ($4.8B EBIT on $60B revenue); integration might be 15% of revenue at 25% margin ($3.75B EBIT on $15B revenue). The integration stage is nearly as large a profit pool despite being 1/4 the revenue — and it's structurally more attractive.
**Always express profit pool in absolute $ EBIT or economic profit. Never as margin % or revenue share.**
## Estimating EBIT per stage
**Method 1 — Listed comparable triangulation (most common):**
For each value-chain stage:
1. Identify 3-5 listed pure-play companies operating primarily in that stage
2. Pull their EBIT margins (consistent definition — typically EBIT/revenue from continuing operations)
3. Compute median EBIT margin for the stage
4. Multiply by estimated total industry revenue at that stage
5. Result: estimated absolute EBIT for the stage
Tag the median margin as `[I: derived from N listed comparables — list names]`.
**Method 2 — Reported segment data:**
For stages dominated by diversified players (e.g., an OEM that also runs integration services), use the players' segment-level reporting where available. Most public companies report segment EBIT in 10-K / 20-F filings.
**Method 3 — Sector analyst notes:**
Bernstein, Morgan Stanley, JPM, and Jefferies sector teams sometimes publish profit-pool maps for major industries. Use as triangulation, not primary source.
## Economic profit (preferred over EBIT for capital-intensive stages)
Economic profit = EBIT − (capital employed × cost of capital).
Use economic profit when stages differ materially in capital intensity. A pure-software integration stage and a capital-intensive component manufacturing stage with identical EBIT will have very different economic profit. For most consultative purposes, EBIT is sufficient; for PE due diligence on capital-intensive sectors, use economic profit.
## Profit-pool visualization
Use a horizontal-bar markdown table where bar width is proportional to absolute EBIT:
```
| Stage | EBIT ($B) | Margin (%) | Profit-pool bar |
|-------|-----------|-----------|------------------|
| Components | 2.1 | 11 | ███ |
| Manufacturing | 0.8 | 4 | █ |
| Integration | 4.3 | 25 | ██████ |
| Distribution | 1.2 | 8 | ██ |
| Service | 0.5 | 22 | ▌ |
```
Bar width scaling: pick a unit (e.g., 1 char = $0.7B) and apply consistently. Round to nearest character.
## Identifying structural profit concentration
Name the stage with highest absolute EBIT. Then answer the WHY question with a **named structural protection** from Helmer's 7 Powers:
- **Scale economies** — fixed costs amortised over large volume; minimum efficient scale unattainable for entrants
- **Network economies** — value increases with participants (two-sided marketplaces, payments, social)
- **Counter-positioning** — new entrant's business model is one the incumbent cannot copy without damaging existing economics
- **Switching costs** — customer's all-in switching cost (financial + procedural + relational) materially exceeds any price differential
- **Branding** — durable customer ascription of higher value to objectively-identical offering (trust, safety, status)
- **Cornered resource** — preferential access at attractive terms to a coveted asset (patent, licence, deposit, talent, dataset). **Regulatory barriers** sit inside this category.
- **Process power** — organisational capability evolved over years that competitors cannot replicate in reasonable time (Toyota, ASML, Amazon logistics)
These names map 1:1 to Helmer's 7 Powers (2016), which is how `assess-moat-sources` (Phase 2) will assess durability. See `references/structural-protections.md` for diagnostic questions per power and the list of non-structural anti-patterns the validator rejects.
**If you cannot name a structural protection, profit concentration is unstable** — and that itself is a finding. Document it explicitly.
## Cross-reference with Five Forces
If `working/five-forces.md` exists, reconcile:
- The named governing force should explain WHY profit concentrates where it does
- "Buyer power high" should NOT coexist with "customer-facing stage captures most profit"
- "Switching costs high" SHOULD coexist with "stage with switching cost lock-in captures most profit"
Document contradictions in the output and flag for orchestrator's Gate 2.
## Normalisation — 3-5 year average, not single year
Single-year EBIT prints are noisy. Cyclical industries (auto, semis, commodity chemicals, freight) can swing margins 1000+ bps year-to-year. Normalise:
- **Default:** 3-year trailing average margin per stage
- **Cyclical industries:** 5-year average to span at least one full cycle
- **Disruption phase:** explicitly flag and use most-recent-12-months, with rationale
The validator looks for a normalisation disclosure in the output footnotes. A profit pool built on a single-year print without justification is a failure mode.
## Ranges, not point estimates
Every stage EBIT estimate carries irreducible uncertainty. Express as:
```
Stage EBIT: $1.7-2.2B (base $1.9B)
```
Not:
```
Stage EBIT: $1.94B ← false precision
```
Three-decimal precision implies sourcing rigor that does not exist in triangulated estimates. The validator warns on EBIT figures quoted to ≥2 decimals without an accompanying range.
## Shared cost allocation — ABC-lite
When stages share back-office, IT, or corporate overhead (common with vertically-integrated players in the comp set), allocate using activity-based costing drivers:
- Revenue share (simplest, weakest)
- Headcount share (better for support overhead)
- Direct cost share (better for shared procurement / IT)
- Transaction count / SKU count (for distribution and operations)
Disclose the driver used and the % of total EBIT that came from allocated (vs. directly observed) figures. >30% allocated = flag as low-confidence.
## Alternative visualisation — Bain "river" chart
The horizontal-bar table is the default deliverable. For executive presentation, the original Bain visualisation is a **two-axis river chart**:
- X-axis: cumulative revenue share across value chain (0% to 100%)
- Y-axis: EBIT margin %
- Area under curve = absolute profit pool
The river makes the **revenue-vs-profit inversion** visceral — a stage with 5% of revenue and 35% margin shows as a tall thin block; a stage with 40% of revenue and 4% margin shows as a wide flat block. Useful in the orchestrator's executive summary, optional for the working file.
See `assets/profit-pool-template.md` for both formats.
## Common failure modes
1. **Revenue-margin pool** — using % margin where absolute $ is required. Always fails validation.
2. **Flat profit pool** — every stage shows similar EBIT. Rare in real industries; usually an estimation error.
3. **Non-structural protection** — "stage X captures most profit because it adds the most value." Tautological. Must name a specific Helmer power.
4. **Missing cross-reference** — pool location contradicts Five Forces governing force without flagging.
5. **Single-year anomaly** — built on a one-off margin print. Always normalise to 3-5 year average.
6. **False precision** — point estimates without ranges. Triangulated estimates carry ±20-30% irreducible error; disclose.
7. **Ignoring capital intensity** — comparing EBIT across stages with materially different capital bases. Upgrade to economic profit (see `references/economic-profit.md`).
8. **Pure-play comparable inflation** — counting diversified players as pure-plays. Tighten to ≥70% revenue concentration.
9. **Mixing GAAP and adjusted EBIT** — non-GAAP "adjusted EBIT" inflates margins 200-500 bps from SBC and acquisition add-backs. Standardise on GAAP including SBC.
10. **Static-pool fallacy** — treating the profit pool as a fixed map. Pools migrate (Christensen) — always note 3-year direction of travel.
Related skills
| Skill | Stars | Updated | Works with | Status | Install |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| reverse-engineer-anythingmorluto/reaReverse engineer native, managed, Electron/JavaScript, packaged, firmware, and browser targets with REA, and build agent environments (AgentEnv bundles) of web applications from a live instance or a capture, and of Linux desktop apps with a task from a request. Use shipped-artifact or requested runtime evidence to explain features, compare versions, decompile code, or guide a reconstruction. Skip REA for ordinary source-repository architecture analysis. | Stars: 471k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| diagnosing-superpowersobra/superpowersUse when a superpowers session went wrong and your human partner wants to know why — repeated work, ignored plans, stumbles, poor results, a skill that didn't fire, "it took too long", "why is it so expensive", "what is it doing" — or wants to build a bug report for the superpowers maintainers, for the current session or a past one identified by id or path, on any harness. | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| dispatching-parallel-agentsobra/superpowersUse when facing 2+ independent tasks that can be worked on without shared state or sequential dependencies | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |
| executing-plansobra/superpowersUse when executing an implementation plan in the current session as the implementer yourself — your human partner chose inline execution, or no subagent tool is available | Stars: 322k | Updated | Claude CodeCodex | Verified | Install |